Shifting Perceptions In Dances With Wolves

1805 words - 7 pages

Shifting Perceptions in Dances With Wolves

In Kevin Costner's motion picture Dances With Wolves, a white veteran of the Civil War, John Dunbar, ventures to the American frontier, where he encounters a tribe of Sioux Indians. At first, both parties are quite wary and almost hostile to each other, but after some time, Dunbar realizes that they have both grown to love and value each other as friends. As the movie critic Robert Ebert comments, "Dunbar possesses the one quality he needs to cut through the entrenched racism of his time: He is able to look another man in the eye, and see the man, rather than his attitudes about the man. As Dunbar discovers the culture of the Sioux, so do we. " As the viewpoint of the hero gradually shifts throughout the film, it is also paralleled by the similarly shifting perception of the audience- from one of initial, stereotypical fear to a much more positive one, of respect and sympathy. This overall effect on the viewer is accomplished through the skillful use of several techniques in the film, as well as through the use of some memorable scenes, as portrayed through Dunbar's eyes.

In the first several scenes of the movie, the audience is introduced to the hero, John Dunbar, and is instantly able to sympathize with him. Firstly, he is a war hero, and thus, brave and respected. Then, when he chooses to move to the frontier, he reveals his adventurous spirit, and when he toils tirelessly each day to build the post, he also shows his hardworking and disciplined personality. Furthermore, Dunbar is a well-educated man, for he eloquently records his experiences in his journal each day, and his thoughts and insights reveal a man of noble and upright character. Thus, these qualities constitute the foundation of a hero with whom the audience can better sympathize, and through whose view the audience can more readily perceive others throughout the remainder of the film.

When the Native Americans are, therefore, initially portrayed in the film in stark contrast with Dunbar, the audience is, not at all surprisingly, immediately biased against them. While Dunbar is noble and upright, the Indians are wild and brutal; for example, they murder Dunbar's wagon driver Timmons in a most violent and cruel way, by hacking him with knives and tomahawks. Their actions confirm traditional views of Indians as bloodthirsty savages who kill for no better reason than the fact that Timmons was ignorantly tending an open fire on their territory. Another case in point is when Dunbar finds Stands With a Fist by the river, cutting herself with a knife. He immediately tries to help her and gently returns her to the Sioux Indians. The Sioux, however, respond in a quite different manner; instead of being grateful towards Dunbar, Wind in His Hair screams at him and fiercely snatches the woman away from him by her hair. As a result, the audience feels indignation and anger at the Indians, especially for treating its esteemed hero in such...

Find Another Essay On Shifting Perceptions in Dances With Wolves

Comparing Dances with Wolves with The Searchers

780 words - 4 pages Comparing Dances with Wolves with The Searchers The Native American culture is something that is cherished by their people. “Perhaps no other group of people has quite the rich and storied culture as those of the Native Americans. They have a history rich in struggle, strife, and triumph (Native American Culture).” Dances with Wolves, directed by Kevin Costner in 1990, is about a white man who becomes interested in the Native American culture

Commentary and analysis of "Dances with Wolves".

781 words - 3 pages Dances With WolvesThroughout Dances With Wolves, several of the film's characters develop both spiritually and emotionally. In particular, the main character John Dunbar, develops a great deal spiritually. His growth can be tracked from the beginning to the end of the movie, with a few scenes in between that accentuate his rapid progression. At the beginning of Dances With Wolves, John Dunbar can be considered an undeveloped spiritual person

Dances With Wolves by Michael Blake

1792 words - 7 pages Dances With Wolves by Michael Blake is a novel that covers the topics of cross-culture, equality and respect. It also shows me the history of modern America. Reading this novel is a great adventure to me. Through years of getting ready, Michael Blake spent nine months on writing the book and got it done in 1981. The story happens in 1863, when US civil war was in ongoing. Knowing the potential amputation of his wounded leg, Union Army Officer

A Glimpse into the Past with "Dances With Wolves"

695 words - 3 pages Dances with Wolves is an epic film made in the year nineteen ninety shot in South Dakota and Wyoming. The film tells the story of a Civil War-era and a United States Army officer, Lieutenant Dunbar who travels to the American frontier to find a military post and befriends a local Sioux tribe. It shows how life was in times of the Civil War. The movie also shows how Indians lived and how they respected everything except the

Historical Evaluatino of "Dances With Wolves" by Michael Blake

1369 words - 5 pages Dances With Wolves, by Michael Blake, creates a remarkable story of a soldier named Lieutenant Dunbar. This story is written in third person, and has diary entries of lieutenant Dunbar in them. The story tells off buffalo, Comanche enemies, Comanche leisure, society, homes, religion, and clothing. In the novel, Dunbar meets Comanche Indians, and learns their ways of life. The story takes place during the civil war era. Eighteen excerpts from the

"Dances With Wolves" Analysis - Illustrate how Native-Americans & Native-American culture is represented in this film differently than in usual media presentations.

563 words - 2 pages judge her because she was White. They accepted her as their own.Native Americans have been portrayed as lazy. They were in fact very hard-working. Their efficiency even impressed Lt. Dunbar who mentioned that even military authorities would be impressed. They lived a nomadic life, and they all worked together. Although they didn't have to look for Dances with Wolves, they worked hard to make sure they had correct timing on when to attack the

Close analysis of Text Dances with Wolves directed by Kevin Costner

831 words - 3 pages 'Dances with Wolves' is a movie of the journey of one man's life and dreams. In this movie the lead character ventures on an epic journey of the body and mind. He was a soldier sent to an abandoned post without any knowledge, on an intense spiritual journey. This spiritual journey did not start smoothly however; it began with a bit of friction and harsh words. But it gradually progressed, with basic communication and ceremonial dances. The movie

American and Japanese Perceptions Explored in Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea

950 words - 4 pages A ship's horn wails in the distance. The long kiss is broken. The sailor's palate is once again wet with longing for the infinite freedom of the sea. It is in this world, where layers of opposite meaning crash as waves to rocks do, that Mishima's The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea is set. This tale of tragedy is one of a man caught in a tempest of moral collision in the interstice which borders freedom and entanglement. Inevitably

Assessing and Comparing Perceptions of Distance Education in the U.S. and Britain with Kazakhstan

841 words - 4 pages learning experience are not well studied. Research papers assessing DE involve questioning students and comparison of their knowledge with students sitting in the classroom (Pardasani et al., 2012, pp. 414-416). However, after obtaining knowledge and statement of accomplishment, the perception of professors and employers are not assessed. Especially, this problematic in Kazakhstan where concept of distance education is not well understood. This

Native Americans and Their Intrinsic Relationship with Western Films

923 words - 4 pages Wolves presents a truly realistic representation of Native Americans. Both Dances With Wolves and The Searchers protagonists, Dunbar and Ethan, embark on a journey and evolve in different ways. The purpose of Dunbar’s journey is to find who he is. For Ethan, it is to rescue his nieces who he feels had been kidnapped and turned into something abnormal and inhuman by Native “savages." Unlike Ethan, Dunbar is always self-reflective; his engagement

Saving Wolves

900 words - 4 pages Sharolyn WinfreySpecies ProfileAugust 27, 2014A Look Into The Wolves LifeWolves depend on one another to survive. In 1630, settlers in Massachusetts Bay Colony pass rewarded money to any resident that killed a wolf. 100,000 wolves were killed every year between 1870 and 1877. Yellowstone National Park, a park created for endangered animals, was created in 1872. In 1930 the last wolf was killed, in Yellowstone National Park. Finally, in 1994

Similar Essays

Dances With Wolves Essay

623 words - 2 pages with another tribe. Dances with Wolves was assigned to watch the chief’s family. While the men were gone, the tribe was attacked me other Indian’s. Dances with wolves provided rifles to the Indians who were there and they defeated the other Indians. Dances with Wolves and the lady he found that one-day were becoming very close. When the men returned, the chief told the lady (his daughter) she would mourn no more. She was in mourning

Dances With Wolves Essay

1312 words - 5 pages Dances With Wolves Dances with Wolves offers a cinematic portrayal of Native Americans that is quite contrary to the stereotypical norm. In this film, John Dunbar, goes out to the west where he meets and becomes friends with the Sioux Indians. He is drawn more and more into their community and eventually chooses to side with the humane Indians over his fellow cruel white Americans. In an attempt to change stereotypical views, director Kevin

Dances With Wolves Essay

850 words - 3 pages few Sioux warriors go to save John Dunbar from the Union soldiers. In order to save their dear friend, they have to kill a regiment of white men. John Dunbar, or Dances With Wolves as he is known with the tribe, is a close friend who has helped the Sioux in many ways. The Sioux never went looking for white men to kill. They remained isolated until people found or threatened them. The Sioux are an unselfish, unified tribe. They support one

Undoing Stereotypes In The Movie, Dances With Wolves

1220 words - 5 pages Undoing Stereotypes in the Movie, Dances With Wolves Hollywood has helped create and perpetuate many different stereotypical images of the different races in the world. Those stereotypes still continue to affect the way we think about each other today and many of those stereotypes have been proven to be historically inaccurate. The movie Dances With Wolves, directed by actor Kevin Costner, does an excellent job in attempting to promote a