Should A Deep Ecologist Be A Vegetarian?

2018 words - 8 pages

Deep ecology is essentially the belief that we should learn to live in harmony with nature and connect with the earth, and the idea that all life forms, including humans, deserve equal rights, thus embracing a rejection of anthropocentricism. Nowhere in the philosophy of deep ecology does it say, or is implied, that a deep ecologist should be a vegetarian. To be both a vegetarian and a deep ecologist would actually be to find oneself in a contradictory position, as there are several opposing ideas within the two ideologies.Generally, one chooses to be a vegetarian for ethical, ascetic or nutritional reasons (Britannica 2001 CD-Rom). There is no reason why a deep ecologist should have any ascetic or nutritional motivations for becoming a vegetarian, unless it is a personal choice with no relation to deep ecology. Deep ecology does not encourage a healthy, nutritional lifestyle as a central belief, and certainly doesn't demand asceticism of its followers. As for ethical motivations, there is no reason why a deep ecologist cannot also be an omnivore. Deep ecology does not promote vegetarianism as an important tenet but rather leaves it to personal choice.While many deep ecology supporters are also vegetarians or vegans, they do not accept that deep ecology requires this as a mandatory belief. Some deep ecology supporters are omnivores (Orton 2000:online).As an important element of deep ecology, biocentrism is the belief that every living organism is of great value (Maunter 2000:70). Orton comments on a biocentrist group discussion on vegetarianism;Perhaps the sharpest discussions on secondary contradictions within left bio arose around the issue of vegetarianism. Participants in this discussion eventually came to accept that if the discussion group was to continue, then the position had to be lived with that a supporter of deep ecology could be either an omnivore or a vegetarian (Orton 2000:online).Deep ecologists fight to preserve endangered species and oppose the domestication of wild animals for human consumption (Orton 2000:online), but do not oppose the killing of domestic animals. In fact, deep ecology states that eating meat is acceptable and sometimes even necessary. Deep ecologists suggest it may be vital for survival, as 'mutual predation' is a natural part of life (Harris 2004:online). Arne Naess, founder of deep ecology, states that human existence 'necessitates some killing, exploitation and oppression' (Harris 2004:online). Deep ecologists even support hunting as a way of connecting with the natural world, as long as it is not for sport but as a means of subsistence, which is 'ecologically acceptable' (Orton 2000:online). Hunting as a valid form of subsistence implies the consumption of meat. Surely one who is a vegetarian cannot also partake in hunting - this would be a serious paradox of morals, demonstrating that deep ecology is not meant to be read as an advocate of vegetarianism.Some deep ecologists even accept inevitable wildlife...

Find Another Essay On Should a Deep Ecologist be a Vegetarian?

The Benefits of a Vegetarian Diet

946 words - 4 pages The Advantages of a Vegetarian Diet Having a healthy dietary method can reduce the chances of receiving many health diseases. These health diseases include obesity, heart disease, and cancer. By consuming certain foods and nutrients in one’s diet the risk factors for these health diseases can be reduced. A healthy dietary method that is beneficial to reducing and/or improving these health diseases is the vegetarian diet. The vegetarian

The Benefits of a Vegetarian Diet

1625 words - 7 pages The Benefits of a Vegetarian Diet There is more to vegetarianism than not eating meat. A vegetarian generally pays attention to their health, makes choices about their diet, and respects animals. There are no rules to being vegetarian; a vegetarian sets his or her own guidelines and restrictions. One chooses not to eat meat for many reasons; it may be because of religion, respect for animals, health, or sometimes a person simply does not like

The Benefits of Being a Vegetarian

1152 words - 5 pages this Earth ate a plant-based diet, that is virtually everyone working together to save the lives of innocent animals. Most people are afraid to become vegetarians because of the supposed lack of protein (Graham). But because virtually all foods have protein in them, vegetarian diets should be consumed instead of meat to help save the lives of billions of animals. Offering more vegetarian food will eventually lead to more health in humans

Should Cyberbullying Be A Crime?

1588 words - 7 pages grounds” (WNYC). States are honing in on the fact that cyberbullying is becoming a growing issue and that harsher consequences are needed to be put into play. Cyberbullying laws need to be put into place nationwide so that bullies realize that consequences will be given for their actions. Through recent tragedies worldwide due to cyberbullying, it has also been a contributing factor for lawmakers to propose new laws. An individual should not have

Should Palestine be a State

2263 words - 9 pages their own state alongside the state of Israel. I will also discuss why Palestine should not have their own state, as well as why the one-state solution would be the right way to solve the solution. Reason for an Independent Palestinian State Shearer 2 The first argument I am going to present is that under International law, Palestine is considered a state. Under the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States, it states that a state

manager should be a leader

2191 words - 9 pages manager should be a leader What is leadership? How is it different from being a manager? How can leaders keep their finger on the pulse of what's happening, inspire others to high achievement, guide their team members through difficult decisions, and still have time to actually finish a cup of coffee while it's still warm? The solution is disarmingly simple: Ask questions. Listen to the answers. Ask some more questions. Give good answers to

the importance of a vegetarian diet

5719 words - 23 pages flesh--tigers, sharks, hawks, wolves and the like. Similarly, no one fears a gentle vegetarian, but all have reason to fear the unpredictable meat-eater. Scriptures admonish that it is wise to fear what should be feared. Food and Consciousness Food is the source of the body's chemistry, and what we ingest affects our consciousness, emotions and experiential patterns. If one wants to live in higher consciousness, in peace and happiness and love for

A Slaves Soul Runs Deep

1070 words - 4 pages . Abe Lincoln was one of the first people to get the ball rolling and speak against slavery. The river turning muddy to golden could theoretically be the start of hope and realization that a better tomorrow is possible. In his last line the speaker says, ‘My soul has grown deep like the rivers’. I am convinced that anyone having seen and witnessed all that has been described would have had to develop a very deep soul. The issue of slavery

Digging Deep Within A Matchmaker

1906 words - 8 pages careless when it comes to finding love. She is more concerned with matching up people who she believes should be together. Emma hurts many people when she plays the role of a matchmaker. In Tave’s article he compares Emma to a lonely astronomer who thought he controlled the weather. (Tave 11) Emma does not think she controls the weather, but she does believe that she controls the people of Highbury. She does not only believe she controls the

Beauty is not Skin Deep: Genes Should not be Chosen

1265 words - 5 pages Even if modern medicine advances to the point where parents can pick out exact physical traits for their children, it should not be legal because it promotes the idea that beauty is skin deep. It seems inevitable that eventually virtually anything will be possible in the genetic world. Today geneticists have discovered ways to test for certain pre- natal diseases, identify the sex of a fetus, and take ultrasounds of the fetus still inside the

Waist Deep: A Fictional Narrative

1096 words - 5 pages getting that. I don't always get what I want.. But something about him made me want to be his friend. Who knows. "Well, um.. I'm Zayn. Zayn Malik." I mumbled. Curse my shyness. He grinned even wider and rushed up to me to give me a hug. I tensed up but then quickly relaxed. I'm not used to all of this. This is too much, I need to go sit down. I maneuvered my way to my slightly wrinkled bed, that had a slight visible shape of two butt cheeks on

Similar Essays

Should Committed Environmentalists Choose To Adopt A Vegan/Vegetarian Diet?

2213 words - 9 pages impacts, one solution would be to transfer to a vegetarian or even vegan diet. It is not necessarily ethical to prescribe one way of being for environmentalists all over the world, especially without thinking about differences in cultures. However, most committed environmentalists should adopt a vegetarian or vegan diet, with a few caveats. This is because (1) animal products are an inefficient source of protein in terms of environmental impact, (2

Being A Vegetarian Essay

539 words - 2 pages fraction of the energy found in the plants used to feed the animals. If more people turned to a vegetarian diet, a lot more food would be available for the world's population. In fact, if we all adopted a vegetarian diet, there would be no hunger in the world. Most importantly, we should be vegetarian for ethical reasons. Many people have ethical problems with the killing of animals for food, especially because this killing is not absolutely

Benefits Of A Vegetarian Diet Essay

1178 words - 5 pages such as calcium, found in milk, omega 3 found in eggs are important and should be eaten regularly. Omega-3 fatty acids are one of the most common nutrients lacking in a vegetarians diet. However, most omega-3 supplements and additives are derived from fish oils which go against the vegetarian diet. Luckily, there is vegetarian omega-3 vegetarian supplements which provide equal nutrients to omega-3 with fish oil. With this in mind, supplements

A Deep, Musical Connection Essay

1721 words - 7 pages were basically isolated by the industry over advertising schemes. The rules don’t lone brand a declaration around the "influence of discrimination on the commercial area in the world,"(Wilson 50) somehow similarly make a deep declaration about relationships in the world. Advertising of "racial songs" is understood to be one of the “undercover rises to prevalent folk music”. Upon learning, around 1920, that there was revenue in the advertising of