Should America Have Dropped The Bomb

1174 words - 5 pages

Chris HardyMarch 23, 2010History CPThe ceremonies marking the 40th anniversary of Hiroshima's obliteration are over, and the ghostly figures of vaporized corpses that were stenciled on the sidewalks of scores of American cities have already begun to fade. What remains is a question, the same one that has gnawed at us from the first: Did the U.S. really have to drop the atomic bomb? Harry Truman, the man who gave the order, explained often and emphatically that he did so for the simplest yet most compelling of reasons: to end the war. Such surety seems comforting. Yet one thing last week's observances showed is that such a simple explanation remains unsettling. We continue to poke through the rubble of history, compelled to search for clues about why something so incomprehensible can seem so explainable. Nevertheless the United States elected to drop the atomic bomb to save American lives and to prevent Stalin from gaining potential territory in Japan.There were without doubt persuasive military reasons for using the new weapon in the summer of 1945. The first day of fighting on Iwo Jima had cost more American casualties than D-day; on Okinawa, 79,000 U.S. soldiers were killed or wounded. As the U.S. readied plans to invade the main islands, Japan was deploying up to 2 million soldiers and additional millions of "auxiliaries" who were clearly prepared to defend their homeland to the death. It was easy to believe estimates that an invasion would result in as many as a million American casualties, plus many more Japanese. The Bomb offered the chance of ending the war and saving lives. In addition, the Bomb, like any new weapon, had developed a constituency and a momentum of its own. J. Robert Oppenheimer, the charismatic master of Los Alamos, gave short shrift to those scientists working under him who urged that their creation not be used (Document A). Congressional committees, the first of them led by a Missouri Senator named Truman, had long been grumbling about the huge secret appropriations poured into the Manhattan Project and warning that "the results (of the Manhattan Project) had better be worth the $2 billion investment"( The Manhattan Project: An Interactive History.). When the scientists succeeded, it became all but impossible to argue that their weapon - one that could prevent a bloody invasion - should be shelved.There was, however, another factor, one still enmeshed in historical controversy. By the end of July, Japan was reeling (Document B). It was likely that a Soviet declaration of war would be the coup de grace. Gar Alperovitz, a historical revisionist whose newly updated Atomic Diplomacy is a harsh critique of American policy, argues that Truman was well aware of this. One of his principle goals during the Big Three meeting in the Berlin suburb of Potsdam in July 1945 was to secure Stalin's pledge to enter the war within a few weeks (Joseph Stalin). When the Soviet dictator agreed, Truman jotted in his diary: "Fini Japs when that...

Find Another Essay On Should America Have Dropped the Bomb

Should the new America have a strong national government with a centralized authority and commercial economy, or a modest centralized government that should remain on the side of the minority?

521 words - 2 pages Should the new America have a strong national government with a centralized authority and commercial economy, or a modest centralized government that should remain on the side of the minority? The minority was rural and agrarian. An issue such as this led Thomas Jefferson and James Madison to the forefront of the Republican Party whole Alexander Hamilton lead the opposing party. The rise of political parties began.Hamilton, despite his own

The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms.

1464 words - 6 pages Untitled The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The debates of whether use

"The Shift in Atomic Bomb Attitude" assignment: Why did attitudes change after the atomic bomb had been dropped?

2410 words - 10 pages press release on August 6 only sixteen hours after the atomic bomb had been dropped on Hiroshima, Japan. The document explained to the world and Americans alike, the technicality of the atomic bomb, the United States' position on the atomic bomb, and justified the validity of our use of the atomic bomb. He was sure to include details about the sheer, brute power of the bomb, which was unheard of in the present times. For an example of its

Why did America drop the Atomic bomb?

927 words - 4 pages bomb? Personally I think that America shouldn't have dropped the bomb because they already were on the verge of winning the war. The Japanese's air force had been completely destroyed and they had lost all their Islands. America would of won in due time. The bomb was supposed to save more lives but instead it killed more. Altogether 200,000 were killed with another further 100,000 from the effects of the bomb. In the world people are still

In 1989, a bomb was dropped on the Boston banking industry when a FED study of neighborhood lending patterns provided evidence of discrimination.

3055 words - 12 pages stem from discrimination - including unintentional, but real actions on the part of lenders.What is the case about?In 1989, a bomb was dropped on the Boston banking industry when a FED study of neighborhood lending patterns provided evidence of discrimination. Black and Hispanic applicants were failing to meet the credit criteria. A fact confirming this study is the following. The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act of 1974 (HMDA) required that banks

What was the reason the U.S Dropped the Atomic Bomb on Hiroshima And Nagasaki? Find out some of the reasons why this happen and how it got started. DBQ

563 words - 2 pages Why Did the U.S Dropped the Atomic Bomb in Hiroshima and Nagasaki?On August 6 and 9, 1945 the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were destroyed by the first atomic bombs used in warfare. The United States decision to drop an atomic bomb on Hiroshima was strictly military measure calculated to intimidate the Soviet Union in the post-Second-World-War era rather than a strictly diplomatic measure designed to force Japan's unconditional surrender. The

Cat's Cradle by Kurt Vonnegut A book report on the novel about the atomic bomb which was dropped on Hiroshima. Explains major themes, opinion on novel and why it is a classic.

528 words - 2 pages couldn't wait to find out what he would talk about next.5) I believe that this book should be considered a classic. I believe that it is dated because it deals with events which occurred in a certain time period (the dropping of the atomic bomb).It should be considered a classic because I could easily reread this book and still find interest in it. It asks many questions and is full of many interesting things which you would have to reread over and

The Mother Should Have the Choice

1114 words - 4 pages The Mother Should Have the Choice When abortion is being discussed in any case, there is one common question to be answered; does the mother or the fetus have the rights? Aborting pregnancies has been around for centuries, and so has all of the controversy around abortions, dealing with religious beliefs and morals. After all sides are looked at women, the mother should have the right to decide what she wants to be done with her unborn

Should Women Have the Right to Abortion?

1262 words - 5 pages limitations on abortion leading to limited amount of abortion clinics and providers. They claim abortion is the killing of babies and try to force their beliefs onto women by spreading false propaganda and pretending to care for the women. Even though these people believe abortion is unmoral and even consider it to be murder, women should have the right to end their pregnancy legally because this would reduce injuries caused by unsafe, illegal abortions

Should we have started the Iraq War?

907 words - 4 pages America put out the fires of September the 11th, and mourned our dead, and went to war, history has taken a different turn. We have carried the fight to the enemy. We are rolling back the terrorist threat to civilization, not on the fringes of its influence, but at the heart of its power.” He is saying that for years the terrorists attacked our country after they attacked and killed their own people. They believed that free nations like

Should The Police Have More Power?

959 words - 4 pages trouble.The biggest trouble a person can cause is by creating a car chase. The police must stop the suspect?s car without harming the public. When a car chase is at hand, everyone is in danger. Many times a chase will end in tragedy. This is one of the biggest reasons police must have more power. One way to give police more power is to give them the ability to shoot. Police should only shoot someone who puts others at risk or runs away from the

Similar Essays

America Should Never Have Entered The Vietnam War

1439 words - 6 pages American security is at stake….A war in Asia should be recognized as unthinkable….We cannot justify the shedding of American blood in that kind of war in Southeast Asia” (Handout 18). Therefore, these politicians were not wise in their position concerning the war. If America decided to let Vietnam be rather than intervening and going to war, Vietnamese men and women would not have experienced the tragedies that they experienced and America would

Should The United States Of America Have A Flat Tax?

1480 words - 6 pages $4,326. Under Herman Cain’s plan 84% of people would pay more taxes. As of December 3, 2011 Republican presidential candidate Herman Cain dropped out of the race. According to the LA times the reason Herman Cain dropped out of the race because he had been embroiled with allegations of having an affair with a woman for over a decade and sexual harassing women. Now because of this we may never know if Herman Cain’s plan would have worked. According

Why The United States Of America Should Have Attacked Hitler Earlier

1612 words - 6 pages large percentage. Any arguments against the thesis of this paper cannot refute the evidence presented throughout the paper. The United States should have clearly attacked sooner. The evidence presented shows the radical beliefs of Adolf Hitler, throughout a large portion of his life. Hitler was a major contributing factor to what was a horrific war. So the facts show that if the United States of America stepped in and attacked Adolf Hitler sooner

Was The Bomb Dropped On Japan Justified?

637 words - 3 pages , approximately 200,000 people died from injuries and radiation from the atomic explosions. Emperor Hirohito surrendered in September. The bomb never should have been dropped on Japan.There were alternatives to make Japan surrender other than the killing of innocent civilians. The US could have invited Japanese officials to view the testing of the bomb at Los Alamos, New Mexico. After seeing the destructive power of the bomb, the officials could make