Should Animals Be Used For Research?

1141 words - 5 pages

We have all heard statements and read labels saying “against animal testing”, “animal cruelty-free product” and “no animals were harmed in the making of this movie…” Yet still to this day many companies continue to use animals for product and drug testing. Evidently, animal testing is a very controversial issue in the science and animal advocacy communities; as it serves as a safer and cost- efficient way to test new medicines and product lines. However, many will argue it is an unethical and inhumane way to treat animals, as science has made tremendous strides in evolution and can change their methods. With that being said, which argument holds more weight, cost and safety, over animal protection? Neither. The correct answer should be results. Is animal testing giving us the accuracy in results that we need? In my research paper, I will argue that animal testing should not be used for scientific research, as it is an inaccurate method of research in today’s society.
First and foremost, there is an anatomical & physiological difference between humans and animals. “Animals may be complete organisms, but they are the wrong ones.” Gericke, Corina. “Why animal experiments are not necessary.” According to Dr. Med. Vet. Gericke, Corina, “It is difficult to predict whether a human will react identically or differently based on the results of experiments conducted on animals. The diseases animals contract are much different from ours. And since most human diseases do not occur in animals, their symptoms are simulated using model organisms and have nothing in common with the human disorder they are supposed to simulate.” Seeing as how they are animals and we are humans, important factors such as “lifestyle, genetics, drug consumption, stress, diet and environmental influences are not taken into consideration and therefore, proving the results misleading and irrelevant.” Gericke, Corina. “Why animal experiments are not necessary.”
Secondly, not all medical research has been proven successful for humans through animal testing. As already stated in the previous paragraph, the diseases humans and animals develop are vastly different and are artificially induced in animals. Studies documented that these simulated diseases prove not to be effective on humans as they are on animals. Either they are temporary solutions or they have severe side effects which could lead to more discomfort and problems or even death. Due to the fact that modern drugs are “more complex and specific to humans, using animals to see if they work safely is even less useful, and may be dangerous.” (BUAV.org the campaign to end animal experiments)
“Over 1,000 potential treatments for stroke have been tested in animal models, only approximately 100 of these have been tested to human trials, and all of them failed. A review by the drug industry of animal experiments found that tests on rats and mice only predicted 43% of human side effects. And over 85 HIV/AIDS vaccines have been...

Find Another Essay On Should Animals be Used for Research?

Why animals should be used in biomedical research.

559 words - 2 pages techniques, and many more contributions to the society of man. Animal research has also helped animals. There are vaccinations against distemper and rabies, treatment for parasites, surgery for hip dysplasia in dogs, arthritis in dogs and the protection of endangered species. The majority of animals used in biomedical research are involved in similar techniques used on humans, and involve little or no pain to the animals.A myth of animal research is

Should Animals be used in invasive Laboratory techniques in psychological research

1525 words - 6 pages ensure the proper treatment of the animals used in laboratory research (Baldwin, 1993). Animal welfare should be of high priority within laboratories not only for the sake of the animals but also for the best interest of the scientists (Baldwin, 1993).In response however, the laws and guidelines in place may fail to adequately ensure humane treatment for animals (Bowd & Shapiro, 1993). In this instance there may be a breakdown from the laws

Federal Funds Should Be Used for Embryonic Stem Cell Research

1600 words - 6 pages .   The superb chance to further the overall health and wellbeing of the human race should not be squandered because of legal quarrels.   Works Cited Bothwell, Laura. “Federal Funds Should Be Used for Embryonic Stem Cell Research.” Stem Cells. Jacqueline Langwith. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2012. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt. from “Judge Lamberth’s Unspoken Morality.” The Hastings Center. 2010. Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 15 Apr. 2013

Animals for biomedical research

793 words - 3 pages )___ supporting details (FEE) in each body paragraph support the topic sentence___ transitional expressions are used between idea shifts in paragraphs (p. 81 BH)___ concluding paragraph sums up main ideas or makes an observationPick one of the following approved topics to write on:1. Should animals be used for biomedical research?2. Do the benefits of hydraulic fracturing ("fracking") of natural gas deposits outweigh the dangers?3. Should assisted

Animals for biomedical research

793 words - 3 pages )___ supporting details (FEE) in each body paragraph support the topic sentence___ transitional expressions are used between idea shifts in paragraphs (p. 81 BH)___ concluding paragraph sums up main ideas or makes an observationPick one of the following approved topics to write on:1. Should animals be used for biomedical research?2. Do the benefits of hydraulic fracturing ("fracking") of natural gas deposits outweigh the dangers?3. Should assisted

Embryonic Stem Cells Should NOT Be Used for Cloning

1511 words - 6 pages the cloning of mice and other cloned animals. In fact, it has been hard to get good data on the life span of clones because most of them die at such an early age. The same side effects would be prevalent in human clones. For this reason, many do not and should not condone human cloning. Also, the mental effects on the clone themselves would be significant. The mere way in which the clone is brought into existence would have effects on how he

Should Animals Be Kept in Captivity

2110 words - 8 pages Animals should not be kept in captivity for any reason unless they have been harmed and need to receive treatment but they should be released as soon as they are healthy and capable of taking care of themselves again. The use of a captive animal for research, education, or entertainment is just wrong no creature deserves to have their life taken away for our benefit. Would you want to be captured and put in a tiny box or a fake little ecosystem

Experiments on Animals Should Not be Banned

2962 words - 12 pages medical research, cosmetics, and finding vaccines. We will be debating whether or not animal testing should be banned, no matter what the animals are being tested for. Issues such as how animals are bred for testing, how many animals are used, what kind of animals are used, why they are used, and what effects could happen to the animals during and after the research has been conducted. II. Animal Testing is important for medical research A

Should Wild Animals Be Kept In Captivity?

1143 words - 5 pages On February 24, 2010, Trainer Dawn Brancheau was killed by a captive killer whale which dragged her into its tank (McCarthy). This is not the only case where a trainer of ordinary person has been put in harm’s way because what is supposed to be a wild animal is being held in captivity. Wild animals should not be kept in captivity because it can lead to mental illness and abnormal behavior. Capturing wild animals for entertainment is not a new

Stem Cells Should Not Be Used Therapeutically

818 words - 3 pages Stem Cells Should Not Be Used Therapeutically A stem cell is a cell in the body that can differentiate into almost any other type of cell in the body. Stem cells come from sites in the bone marrow, as well as the tissues of developing fetuses. The most controversial issue in stem cell therapy is the use of fetuses for their stem cells. Scientists want to clone human embryos, and use the stem cells long before the embryo matures (when it

Native American Mascots should not be used

564 words - 2 pages . Investigation also been done by the US department of education for this issue. (6) "Potentially harmful ethnic imagery is inappropriate in a learning environment." (Taylor, Kelley R. Sports Law & Legislation, Education Digest, Prakken publication, 2002) Many of the schools used to post the images of Native American and many of them are strongly ethnical. These images create a negative impact on young students mind. They should not be comfortable

Similar Essays

Should Animals Be Used For Medical Research?

1441 words - 6 pages fight infections inside the body. Also asthma inhalers, smallpox has been eradicated completely, vaccines against polio, meningitis, TB, the human papillomavirus (HPV) linked to cervical cancer. Many people do not agree with the use of animals in research, some of them affirm that animals should not be used in drug development medical research because they are God’s creatures and should not be killed to save our lives. ( debate.org) But, in the

Should Animals Be Used For Research In Cosmetic Industry?

615 words - 3 pages Should animals be used for research in cosmetic industry? Animal testing is widely used to develop new medicines and to test the safety of other products. These experiments can cause pain to the animals involved or reduce their quality of life in other ways. Animal experimenters are aware of this problem and agree that the testing should be made as humane as possible. While this practice has been followed for years now, some people still

Should Animals Be Used In Research

2056 words - 8 pages Should animals be PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 8 Running head: SHOULD ANIMALS BE USED IN RESEARCH?Should animals be used in research?There have been many different kinds of cruel animal testing performed over the years. The most unnecessary types of animal testing are using animals for testing cosmetics and different products. Although it is very possible to produce cosmetics without testing on animals, some companies continue to do so. Animal rights

Should Animals Be Used For Experiments?

544 words - 2 pages One of the most debated topics of our times is whether we should use animals for ex-periments or not. The interesting point that always comes up is what else is there instead of our dear friends. Without our lab creatures; our medicines, cosmetics and food would not be tested and might not be safe for our use and consumption.The process of using animals to test safety of food and medicines was practiced for many centuries. People watched