We have all heard statements and read labels saying “against animal testing”, “animal cruelty-free product” and “no animals were harmed in the making of this movie…” Yet still to this day many companies continue to use animals for product and drug testing. Evidently, animal testing is a very controversial issue in the science and animal advocacy communities; as it serves as a safer and cost- efficient way to test new medicines and product lines. However, many will argue it is an unethical and inhumane way to treat animals, as science has made tremendous strides in evolution and can change their methods. With that being said, which argument holds more weight, cost and safety, over animal protection? Neither. The correct answer should be results. Is animal testing giving us the accuracy in results that we need? In my research paper, I will argue that animal testing should not be used for scientific research, as it is an inaccurate method of research in today’s society.
First and foremost, there is an anatomical & physiological difference between humans and animals. “Animals may be complete organisms, but they are the wrong ones.” Gericke, Corina. “Why animal experiments are not necessary.” According to Dr. Med. Vet. Gericke, Corina, “It is difficult to predict whether a human will react identically or differently based on the results of experiments conducted on animals. The diseases animals contract are much different from ours. And since most human diseases do not occur in animals, their symptoms are simulated using model organisms and have nothing in common with the human disorder they are supposed to simulate.” Seeing as how they are animals and we are humans, important factors such as “lifestyle, genetics, drug consumption, stress, diet and environmental influences are not taken into consideration and therefore, proving the results misleading and irrelevant.” Gericke, Corina. “Why animal experiments are not necessary.”
Secondly, not all medical research has been proven successful for humans through animal testing. As already stated in the previous paragraph, the diseases humans and animals develop are vastly different and are artificially induced in animals. Studies documented that these simulated diseases prove not to be effective on humans as they are on animals. Either they are temporary solutions or they have severe side effects which could lead to more discomfort and problems or even death. Due to the fact that modern drugs are “more complex and specific to humans, using animals to see if they work safely is even less useful, and may be dangerous.” (BUAV.org the campaign to end animal experiments)
“Over 1,000 potential treatments for stroke have been tested in animal models, only approximately 100 of these have been tested to human trials, and all of them failed. A review by the drug industry of animal experiments found that tests on rats and mice only predicted 43% of human side effects. And over 85 HIV/AIDS vaccines have been...