Should Canada Ratify The Npt? Essay

1452 words - 6 pages

Despite recent criticism and calls for the termination of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), Canada has a domestic and international responsibility to support efforts towards a strengthening of the NPT. The main difficulty in arguing otherwise, is that one is then left with the formidable task of suggesting a more effective alternative. It cannot be denied that the NPT is flawed. The regime is not as effective as it needs to be, and it is inherently unfair. It is this second weakness that appears to cause the most tension among non-nuclear weapons states (NNWS) and nuclear weapons states (NWS). If a NWS is entitled to possession, why not any state? This is an especially strong argument when NWS fail to uphold their end of the agreement that entitled them to possession in the first place. However, as flawed as the NPT might be, a viable alternative has yet to be suggested to the international community. Some critics, such as Michael Wesley, claim that an acceptance of "managed limited proliferation" is the necessary road to travel. The immediate problem with this ideology is that it is impossible to guarantee limited proliferation. If such a thing could exist, what would the limits be, and who would enforce them? Certainly it would appear logical that the more NWS that exist, the greater the chances of proliferation beyond such limits, resulting in the increased likelihood of nuclear activity. Marianne Hanson's suggestion of an NPT with necessary adjustments, has more merit than Wesley's suggestion of the formation of a whole new regime. Non-proliferation must be pursued above "managed proliferation", and an international system of trust must be the goal if the threat of nuclear disaster is to be quelled.Critics hold a valid assertion that the NPT is flawed. It has not been as effective as it originally planned, and it operates on a principle that is unfair. With respect to the contention that the regime is ineffective, it is important to discuss the main points of evidence of this. As Wesley notes, military and peaceful nuclear programs are nearly identical.# Under the basic principles of the NPT, a NWS could bring a NNWS to the brink of possessing nuclear weapons under the commitment to aid in peaceful nuclear activities. That NNWS can then withdraw from the NPT, and conceivably become a NWS. This lends to the possibility of proliferation, which is exactly what the NPT was designed to prevent.Another way that the NPT is inefficient lies in the verification processes over possession and development of the nuclear fuel cycle. Without stringent enough measures to verify the purposes behind possessing nuclear materials and processes, a state can work towards the covert development of nuclear weapons.# A related weakness is that even if such covert nuclear development was uncovered, the ramifications are mixed and perceived as inconsequential by many critics.The second flaw mentioned above, the unfairness of the NPT, creates high levels of...

Find Another Essay On Should Canada ratify the NPT?

The Non-Proliferation Treaty: Reasons For Its Failiures And Suggestions For Its Improvement And Strenghtening

3997 words - 16 pages have been to develop new weapons..." (sanity 6) Therefore, it is assumed that the desire to reduce this test readiness time stems from the wish to test new nuclear weapons devices, which clearly goes against the commitment the United States made in Article VI of the NPT. This also puts into question the future of the United States moratorium on nuclear testing.Along with this, the United States government has also refused to ratify the

Mongolia and its Stand on The Atomic Bomb, Disarment and Outer Space

695 words - 3 pages mentions that Mongolia was one of the first to sign and ratify the NPT and the seventh country to ratify the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT). The main reason why Mongolia is supporting the disarmament is mostly due to the tension that exists between China and Russia, two neighboring countries with nuclear weapons. By freeing its soil from nuclear armament, no countries should deploy nuclear weapons in its territories. By officially declaring

Nuclear Weapon Proliferation: South Africa

798 words - 4 pages president of South Africa, F.W. de Klerk, ended the program with the aim of joining the NPT as a state without a nuclear weapons capability. In 1991 they then joined the NPT and came to a safeguards agreement with the IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency). This was an organization that promoted peace, which they also performed, safeguard inspections. South Africa thus submitted its declaration on facilities and nuclear material inventories, and

Problems with Health Information Technology Implementation

1050 words - 4 pages examine two articles one from the United States, the other from the United Kingdom describing different approaches to considering the human element. The process of sensemaking utilized in the U.S article and the Normalization Process Theory (NPT) used in the U.K. article will increase the understanding of how people can influence the success or failure of an implementation project. Currently, global efforts exist to incorporate HIT into

Chemical and Biological Weapons of Mass Destruction

1536 words - 7 pages /bacteria will infect and kill large populations, and the economic implications will be enormous. Anthrax can be produced easily using animal material from farms, and can be preserved for over 100 years. The use of anthrax can have a place an inhabitable, hectors of fertile land wasted and lives destroyed. In short, humanity regardless of political affiliation should consider BWs as lethal weapons that have no generational limits, and no boarders. Use

A Proposal for the International Elimination of Nuclear Weapons

1729 words - 7 pages . But, both disarmament and non-proliferation processes should be done together. There are variations that exist with regards to the negotiation of steps to be taken. However, there is no consistent policy that focuses on completely eliminating nuclear weapons. For instance, the 1995 NPT was expounded by several steps that were proposed in the 2000 NPT agreement (NPT/CONF., May 9, 1995). A limited number of such steps have been enforced. The CTBT

International Institutions and Nuclear Proliferation: The Dependence on Nations

2895 words - 12 pages The Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) that took effect in 1968 was the landmark of international cooperation during the Cold War. As of 2015, there are 190 nations as parties to the treaty with four abstentions and one withdrawal. While the cooperative importance of this treaty cannot be understated, it is not the only International Institution that has a prominent place in the non-proliferation, disarmament and


1794 words - 8 pages that can be affected is the North American Free Trade Agreement that bring together countries such as America, Canada, and Mexico. Among the three, America dominates the market with Canada feeling shortchanged by the agreement. Canada feels threatened by America in case America agrees to ratify Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement in the absence of CANADA JOINING TRANS-PACIFIC PARTNERSHIP 5 Canada. This would increase the market share and trading

Global Warming and the Kyoto Protocol

893 words - 4 pages Kyoto Protocol, the European Union is one of the strongest advocates of regulations. With this the European Union today is lower than what it was in the 1990’s. ( Rowntree) Of course, this is good for the environment, but there are many people out of jobs due to the moving of jobs to china and other countries and the lowering of emissions. That is a large factor in the process of ratification in many other countries. In Canada the loss of jobs will

Joining the Nuclear Family

894 words - 4 pages deployment and testing. The most well known of these, the 1970 Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), recognized five nuclear powers which were permitted to have nuclear arms contingent upon reduction of their arsenals. The nations specified included the United States, Britain, France, China & Russia. In March 1993, a panel testifying before the U.S. Foreign Affairs Committee concluded that India and Pakistan were now nuclear powers, and that the


2360 words - 9 pages . Canadian exports account for about 37 percent of its GDP, and 87 percent of this exports go to the United States. Consequently, Canada has to be responsive to the needs of its trading sectors due to the decision of the United States to not ratify the agreement (Canada 17). According to the Government of Canada, The AMG competitiveness review also examined the issue of investment “leakage” (the relocation of capital as a direct result of climate change

Similar Essays

Worcester Gazette “Usa” Constitution:Why Mass. Should Ratify? January 1788 Editorial Written By The Highly Respected Political Commentator:Quinn G

937 words - 4 pages Our state is on the verge of of making either a highly impetuous, or decidedly resolute decision.The resolve of which, ladies and gentlemen, shall have an imperative effect upon our fine state.Our state legislature has already sent delegates to what our youthful new government called the “Constitutional Convention”, and our states views have been well spoken for. However, our representatives have not decided upon what the official decision

Young Offenders Act In Canada. Speaks Of Why It Should Be Changed, And The The Reasons And Actions Taken

1424 words - 6 pages it clear thatthere are some serious problems with this system and that safe guardsmust be implemented to ensure that as few as possible cases of thistype slip through the system. This publication is an important piece asit shows clearly that improved systems are needed in dealing with theyoung offender, and that much of the process should be initiatedwithin the family and community.Toronto, Canada. Canadian Bar Association - Continuing

Today's Youth: Should The Government Of Canada Coordinate The Organization Of Youth Groups That Would Encourage Patriotism, Good Social Skills, And Good Work Habits?

1319 words - 5 pages The government should not coordinate the organization of youth groups to encourage patriotism, good social skills, and strong work habits. The government has enough to do regulating the economy, education, health care, law enforcement, international relations and many social services. While government officials, especially leaders, could model good ethics, teaching morality to the youth of the country is not their job. There are many people and

Controling The Spread Of Nuclear Weapons

919 words - 4 pages addition of new states to the nuclear club. The dynamic between these two groups is extremely complicated because each side has a completely different perspective on the situation. This makes non-proliferation difficult to achieve because neither side is willing to consider the perspective side of the other. A NPT Review Conference was held in 2000 to strengthen the provisions put in place by the NPT in 1968, and multiple proposals for further