Should Congress Ban Embryonic Cloning? August 2002

1100 words - 5 pages

Scientist are now able to clone human embryos. There are basically two ways to look at this issue: as a medical procedure with the potential to save and create lives or as medical experiments on developing human beings that may harm or end their lives. Cloning, whether for therapeutic or reproductive reasons is a very controversial and complex issue.Scientist in favor of allowing the cloning of human embryos argue that is a new source of stem cells that could be used to treat previously untreatable diseases. Stem cells are master cells that have the potential to turn into any type of cell in the body. Theoretically, if the persons own DNA was used to make an embryo, stem cells could be ...view middle of the document...

Private industry that does not use federal funding is immune to the presidents ruling. The ruling will make the federal government fall far behind the private sector in stem cell research.Another issue brought about by the ability to clone human embryos is: Should cloned embryos be used for reproduction? Does Congress have the right to restrict reproductive rights? Creating a clone people argue is reproduction and if someone wants to reproduce, the federal government has no rights to stop him. At a hearing before a subcommittee of the U.S. House Energy and Commerce Committee in March 2001, Mark Eibert, a California attorney argued that a Supreme Court decision banning the forced sterilization of prison inmates (Skinner vs. Oklahoma (1942) asserts a constitutional right to "have offspring." The case he says "means that anyone who attempts to ban cloning will have to explain to the courts why infertile people should have less of a right to have children and families than criminals do. For infertile people who cant have children any other way, anti-cloning laws are the practical equivalent of forced sterilization." Those against embryonic cloning argue that in the case of Cary vs. Population Services International (1977) the Supreme Court ruled that reproductive activities may be limited by the government if there is a compelling state interest for doing so.The destruction of embryos in the cloning process is inevitable. A pro-life argument against cloning is that a cloned embryo is a reproduced human and has protection under Fifth Amendment. Pro-choice groups are arguing that if embryonic cloning is banned it is like saying to sick or injured people that a clump of cells is more important than a human being.Cloned animals have a high incidence of disabilities. Dr. Lanza, a scientist working for ACT, who has been using therapeutic cloning in experiments to give cows brand new immune systems, has cloned 50 cows states that "4 or 5 cows are absolutely normal." Those against the use of cloning for reproductive purposes bring up the issue of potential public responsibility for the upbringing and...


Stem Cell Research Essay

1337 words - 5 pages fertilization procedures. However, some embryos used have been fertilized especially to produce stem cells, which brings up the issue of cloning. In 1994 a National Institutes of Health panel argued that creating embryos for the sole purpose of extracting stem cells was justified; but Congress subsequently enacted a ban on federal financing for research involving human embryos. A few years later, the Department of Health and Human Services ruled in 1999 that

Cloning Human Beings Essay

834 words - 3 pages cloning is deeply troubling, and I strongly support efforts by Congress to ban all human cloning. We must advance the promise and cause of medical science, including through ethical stem cell research, yet we must do so in ways that respect human dignity and help build a culture of life." 7)Referencies1) Edward Epstein, "Bush tries to sway senators against cloning", San Francisco Chronicle, April 11, 2002(

Human Cloning Should be Condemned

614 words - 2 pages Human Cloning Should be Condemned   On November 25, 2001, the news that a firm called Advanced Cell Technology had created human embryos by cloning added new urgency to Congress's and the nation's deliberations on this issue.   This past summer, by a 265-to-162 margin, the House of Representatives passed a carefully worded ban on human cloning (H.R. 2505) which President Bush has said he will sign into law. The leadership

Should Human Cloning be Permitted?

2064 words - 9 pages asexual production of a human being from an ancestor to which it would be genetically identical. Scientists started their research on cloning animals in 18th century. August Weismann, In 1880s, proposed that the genetic information of a cell would diminish with every cell division. Hans Spemann challenged his idea and in his book entitled “Embryonic Development and Induction” talked about a fantastical cloning experiment which later became a basis

The Controversies Around Human Cloning

2288 words - 9 pages equally strong ban, however, is stalled in Congress. Christianity Today, 49(5), 18. Retrieved from Human cloning and stem cell research: engaging in the political process. (legislation review: prohibition of human cloning act 2002 and the research involving human embryos act). (2008, November). Life Extension. Retrieved from

Cloning Regulations Needed

1177 words - 5 pages religious issues. On March 4, 1997, President Clinton temporarily banned federally funded research for human cloning in the U.S., and gave the National Bioethics Advisory Commission 90 days to report on whether human cloning should be banned or regulated ("Clinton Bans. . ."). In June, the Advisory Commission recommended that Congress impose a five year ban on human cloning (Rosenblatt). President Clinton endorsed the ban, stating that, "Each

The Debate of Human Cloning

4520 words - 18 pages as ethical by the general public as a result of loopholes in current legislation. It is recommended that the current policy in place be revised to eliminate these loopholes and rewritten to permit human cloning to take place to generate the tissue and cells needed for therapeutic development and research to take place. The ban on human cloning should only apply when the procedure is used for reproductive purposes because current research has

Human Cloning Goes Global

874 words - 3 pages cloning. The House has already passed a strong total ban on human cloning (H.2505) The Brownback bill is nearly identical to the House bill sponsored by Rep Dave Weldon (R-FL). The Senate must pass a cloning bill before the close of the 2002 legislative session to avoid the legislative process again next year with a new Congress.   Senator Brownback contends that cloning raises serious questions. "Does the cloned human embryo have any moral

Cloning: Science to Sci-Fi

1526 words - 7 pages cloning. It is brought to the attention of cloning opponents that they should watch for false bans that appear to outlaw cloning but are actually legalizing SCNT using human DNA. In 2007, for example, Senators Diane Feinstein (D-Calif.) and Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) coauthored the Human Cloning Ban and Stem Cell Protection Bill, which would’ve banned cloning. However, it would’ve also legalized it by arranging an inaccurate definition. The term

Cloning: A Reproduction Replacement and Cure for the Ill, or Ethical Adversity?

1960 words - 8 pages , to help keep the moral and ethical standards of humankind in tact.As for future advances in cloning, the world continues to regulate it in its own separate ways. Different countries still have a ban on researching and practicing cloning and others only have regulations to make sure it only goes as far as its morals will allow it. As of March 2002 approximately 33 countries have formally banned human cloning. While encouraging, this represents

Stem Cell Research

1712 words - 7 pages to close infertility programs (Langwith 132). Later on judges stopped the funding for human embryonic stem cell research that Bush started in 2001 (Zigmond 1 of 3). People started joining groups against stem cell research because they think that the scientist are killing embryos (Langwith 31). These groups started forming when Obama lifted the ban for funding stem cell research and many groups opposed him for this (Stop-and-go scenario

Similar Essays

Embryonic Stem Cells Should Not Be Used For Cloning

1511 words - 6 pages associated with it. It is widely agreed that reproductive cloning should be banned internationally. This form of cloning bypasses the usual movement and combining of genes that produces a unique individual, having predictable negative effects on the human gene pool. Dolly the sheep, who was cloned from the DNA of another sheep, suffered from lung cancer and a crippling case of arthritis before she was put to sleep. Similar effects have been seen in

National Academy Of Sciences: Human Cloning

954 words - 4 pages The National Academy of Sciences (NAS) made headlines when it issued a broadside that would, if followed by Congress, grant an open-ended license for biotech researchers to clone human life. True, the NAS recommended that Congress ban "reproductive" cloning, that is, the use of a cloned embryo to produce a born baby. But it also urged that human cloning for purposes of experimentation--often called "therapeutic" or "research" cloning--remain

Cloning, Pros And Cons Essay

3749 words - 15 pages situation of not being able to reproduce sexually (Dream Technologies International, 2002). There is almost a universal agreement that cloning human beings is so unsafe and, to some, morally repugnant that it should be banned, but it would be unfortunate if the ban was extended to experimental cloning (Tilghman & Baltimore, 2003). Experimental cloning, or rather therapeutic cloning, refers to nucleus transportation to produce stem cells. This

The Effects Of Human Cloning On Medicine

2312 words - 9 pages involving cloning was made again in 2002 when a company called Clonaid announced that they cloned a human called “Eve” (ProQuest Staff, Human Cloning Timeline). In 2004, scientists in South Korea began creating embryonic stem cells from cloned embryos (ProQuest Staff). After a baby boy died in an operation, the hospital offered to have the baby cloned for the parents to replace the child (Talbot). The advancements in cloning over the years have led