Should Euthanasia Be Legalised? A Moral Perspective

2127 words - 9 pages

The purpose of this paper is to consider and critically analyse the arguments, both legal and moral, in regard to legalising euthanasia, engaging with the ethical theory of deontology. This paper will provide an outline of the definition of euthanasia and associated terms, such as passive and active, involuntary and voluntary, as well as define and demonstrate deontological theory with regard to the topic. It will be demonstrated that the consequences of proposed euthanasia laws, though they have not come to pass, have certainly caused the debate of ethical and legal issues and thus, it is proposed that euthanasia should not yet be legalised. This argument will be supported with examples from Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act, as well as incorporate statistics found in a study of end-of-life decisions in six European countries published in 2003. This supporting evidence will assist in demonstrating that if the practice becomes legal without control measures and adequate safeguards in place, it will become easy for accidental deaths to occur, thus making euthanasia a legally and morally wrong option.
Legalising Euthanasia
Ethical Concepts and Legal Definitions
Prior to outlining the right or wrong of legalising euthanasia, it is imperative to firstly discuss the concepts and definitions. Euthanasia is largely defined as the deliberate omission of treatment with the intention of hastening or ending a life, in order to relieve unmanageable pain and suffering (Sanders and Chaloner 2007, 42). There are subdivisions to this definition; passive and active. Active euthanasia is the deliberate intervention to end a person’s life through means such as a lethal drug, whereas passive is the notion that it is permissible to withhold treatment from a patient and allow the individual to die (Garrard and Wilkinson 2005, 64). Involuntary euthanasia is the termination of life made by another who is not the person in question, whereas voluntary is where the person requests to be euthanized.
Normative ethics is the study of ethical action that investigates moral obligations and actions, including consequentialism and utilitarianism. Of primary relevance to the question of legalising euthanasia is the ethical theory of deontology, a subset of normative ethics, Deontology is also known as duty-based ethics. and is concerned with the fact that acts are either right or wrong, and people have a duty to act accordingly, regardless of both negative and positive consequences (Quadrelli, 2014).
Arguments using Ethical Theory
Deontology is about the nature of duty without regard to the good that it might produce, as outlined by the Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy (2012). The majority of arguments with regard to euthanasia is against the its proposed legalisation. The fact that euthanasia has only been legalised in The Netherlands, Belgium and Oregon shows it is not widely accepted and there is much controversy (Chapple et al. 2003). In the review of the...

Find Another Essay On Should Euthanasia be Legalised? A moral Perspective

Same-sex marriage should be legalised. (A speech)

753 words - 3 pages from marrying?All that gay and lesbian people are asking for is, if not understanding, then at least tolerance. All they are asking for is the same basic civil equality that all Australians yearn for and should be entitled to.As I leave, I'd like you to think about the great moral changes that have occurred over the past 200 years. Ask yourself would you have felt safe to speak in favor of the separation of the colonies from Great Britain? Would you

Why Marijuana Should Be Legalised Essay

1183 words - 5 pages Why Marijuana Should Be Legalised There is no denying that the drug problem in our country today has reached epidemic proportions. The problem has gotten so out of hand that many options are being considered to control and/or solve it. Ending the drug war may not seem to be the best answer at first, but the so-called "war on drugs" has actually accomplished very little. Different options need to be considered

That marijuana should not be legalised.

659 words - 3 pages The issue to be discussed in this essay is that marijuana should not be legalised. The contention of this persuasive piece is that the legalization of marijuana should not be allowed. The arguments to be presented are that marijuana has a complete detrimental effect on the human anatomy and that its legalization would create a greater amount of new drug users. The opposing arguments relative to this topic will also be explored.Marijuana puts a

Euthanasia Should Be A Legal Option

3434 words - 14 pages States enable thousands of people to receive excellent home care during their last months? (McCuen 161). Should a patient have the right to end his or her life? ?Every patient has the right to judge his suffering as unbearable and the right to ask his/her doctor for euthanasia?, said Dr. Peter Admiraal at the eighth Biennial World Conference or right to die societies. ?Our laws must be changed so that any patient in consultation with

Should euthanasia be decriminalised?

1013 words - 4 pages circumstances voluntary euthanasia is the morally right course. People should have the right to choose a painless and dignified end. To postpone the inevitable is of no benefit to patient or family. Individuals should be allowed to decide on such personal matters for themselves. So humanists generally support voluntary euthanasia but they recognise the need for safeguards to prevent involuntary euthanasia. ( Recently a Human rights

Should Euthanasia be Prohibited?

1926 words - 8 pages diagnosed annually worldwide, it is not a surprise that doctors and families see euthanasia as a viable alternative for the terminally ill. Indeed, euthanasia has become a common practice in society and a number of people, doctors and families alike, believe that is it the right thing to do. However, euthanasia should be prohibited in all circumstances because it goes against the doctors’ Hippocratic Oath, violates patient rights, leads to a

Should Euthanasia be Allowed?

1861 words - 7 pages longer upholds the authority to sustain his profession's goals. Therefore, to keep the value and prestige a doctor claims to obtain, assisted suicide should not expand. Yet, one must not only look at assisted dying from a doctor’s perspective, but also look at euthanasia from a patient’s perspective. If doctors deliberately prescribe death to suffering patients, more patients will die since the only way to escape anguish seems by ceasing one’s life

Euthanasia Should Be Legal

2053 words - 8 pages Euthanasia has been an ongoing debate for many years. Everyone has an opinion on why euthanasia should or should not be allowed but, it is as simple as having the choice to die with dignity. If a patient wishes to end his or her life before a disease takes away their quality of life, then the patient should have the option of euthanasia. Although, American society considers euthanasia to be morally wrong euthanasia should be considered

Should gods be Moral?

890 words - 4 pages act like a human. He is superior to humans and has a perfect mind and heart. He sees and knows everything that had happened, has happened, and will happen. God in no way contradicts himself. With the question about whether or not gods should be moral, the answer is quite simple – yes. When people believe in something, they want to look up to it. A god is something or someone who guides people in the right direction they want to be

Euthanasia should be made legal.

1154 words - 5 pages (title)"If I could choose between a death of torture and one that is simple and easy, why should I not have the right to select the latter?" These are the lines of famous Euthanasia critic, Seneca.If you had to choose between a death of torture and one of peace and ease, wouldn't you rather select the more pleasant death? Shouldn't you be entitled to picking your own death? Shouldn't you be in control of yourself? Isn't that what living in a

Should Euthanasia Be Considered Ethical?

845 words - 3 pages Active euthanasia is one of today's most widely debated moral issues. Active euthanasia, by definition, is, "The act or practice of ending the life of an individual suffering from a terminal illness or an incurable condition, as by lethal injection or the suspension of extraordinary medical treatment." In my opinion, active euthanasia is an immoral process of ending someone's life. Active euthanasia is a sin and a crime, as it is no different

Similar Essays

Should Euthanasia Be Legalised Essay

959 words - 4 pages Should Euthanasia be Legalised This essay will explore several different and varied opinions about whether or not euthanasia should be legalised. Euthanasia is the Greek word for easy death, but is often referred to as mercy killing. There are two main forms of euthanasia. Voluntary euthanasia is when a terminally ill patient expresses the wish to be euthenised. Active euthanasia is when a Doctor decides that it is in

This Is A Retorical Persuasive Speech I Had To Do On Cloning Should It Be Banned? Should Legal Rights Over Turn Moral Rights? Please Note, This Was Not Designed To Show A 'christian' Perspective

1139 words - 5 pages know it in ourselves. And we should not begin to think that clones will be socially accepted into our world. We still discriminate against people who live in different countries, who are a different shape to us. We discriminate against gays and lesbians. Why should clones be any different? They can not help who they are, but in saying that cloning a human makes us responsible for the way that clone is. So we have no one to blame but ourselves. And

Should Cannabis Be Legalised? Essay

652 words - 3 pages A hot topic for debate at the moment is, Should cannabis be legalised? This issue has been discussed in parliament and public places, it seems everyone has a view on it. Although I think it should be legalised, I will discuss both sides of the argument. Cannabis is currently a class B, schedule 1 drug, which means it, has no recognised medical value. For possession, the maximum penalty is five years in prison, plus an unlimited fine - a hefty

Should Cannabis Be Legalised? Essay

901 words - 4 pages that cannabis use leads to the abuse of harder drugs which have much more serious effects, but no actual proof has supported this view.I believe people should be able to choose what they want to do, and what they want to get involved in. We should all have the freedom to express who we are; cannabis is not harmful and has never killed a single person. Therefore I believe that it should be legalised. This would keep people away from drug dealers