This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should Holden Stay Or Go Essay

1003 words - 5 pages

Mentally and physically drained, Holden returns home, only to find he almost got tuberculosis. Holden, who is 16 years old, has trouble accepting that innocence is lost by everyone and one cannot preserve their innocence. During The Catcher in the Rye, Holden also does many concerning things that make people question whether he should stay in the mental institution. Although people argue that Holden needs to go home and get his life back, Holden really needs to stay in the mental facility because he continues to have suicidal thoughts, he needs people to help him get over him being lonely, and he also needs cope with his issue of growing up in order to become mentally stable again.
...view middle of the document...

One can also assume if Holden can stay at the mental facility, he will be able to realize how to talk to people much faster. If Holden can stay, he will be able to create new relationships and realize that not everyone is phony like he originally thought.
Being in the mental facility will also benefit Holden because he will be able to cope with his issues of people growing up. When Phoebe asks Holden what he wants to do, he replies saying, “…And I'm standing on the edge of some crazy cliff. What I have to do, I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff - I mean if they're running and they don't look where they're going I have to come out from somewhere and catch them…”(Salinger 173). This is one of the many examples where Holden wants to protect kids’ innocence and when innocence is taken away from someone he knows, he gets very angry and has trouble expressing his feelings. Holden not being able to express himself is another one of Holden’s issues because if he never lets things go, everything gets bottled up inside him and he eventually goes on total rampages and gets depressed. If Holden does end up staying in the mental hospital, he will learn from is physiologist how to express himself and deal with his issues regarding society and life in general.
One may be concerned if Holden does stay in the mental facility because he needs to be less independent, he needs to deal with his problems on his own and he needs to make realizations about himself. Since Holden has grown up going to boarding and prep schools and without his parents, he has an extreme independence from his parents and society. One will say that leaving the mental hospital will make Holden...

Find Another Essay On Should Holden Stay or Go

To Stay Or Go? Essay

893 words - 4 pages she makes the decision to leave with her lover Frank in secret, but over time reminisces on the past. This allows her to come to the conclusion that maybe her life at home isn’t the worst option. With the factors of her promise to her mother only makes her decision even harder. Stuck as if she was a deer in headlights she stays. Eveline goes through a series of processes in which she contemplates furiously whether she should stay or go

Sports: Stay or Go? Essay

652 words - 3 pages healthy. Therefore, sports helps children to stay fit whether it is running down the court, on the field, or around the bases. According to the CDC (Center for Disease Control and Prevention), children should keep their heart rate up for thirty minutes a day to maintain the weight that a child already has. However, many children do not run like they should which causes the rate of obesity to rise. According to the American Heart Association, about

Should Moms Work or Stay at Home?

1394 words - 6 pages some married women who are economically strong and their husbands work, these women must make a decision whether they should work or stay home. Family life would be better if mothers choose to stay at home.One of the toughest decisions of a woman's life comes with motherhood. The question is - stay at home or pursue a career? Both types of mothers deserve credit, but the question remains, "What is best for the children?" Many mothers have different

Should we go green or black?

898 words - 4 pages Should we go green or black? It is high times that we have to decide upon to which color we cling on to –green or black. Before that, we have to decide on about ourselves and our future generations. Are we expecting to see our sons and daughters to prosper or perish? I hope no parents will like to see their children perish, but to see them having more comfortable life than they had. So, we have to be green, not only for us, but also for our

Should Deaf Children go to Deaf School or Mainstream

894 words - 4 pages When the parents found out that those children become to losing hearing. This is an impact to the parent hard to decide, and which is those deaf children can go to school. Most of the parent did not know about how they can communicate with deaf children. The board school will give them to choose to institute for the deaf or mainstream in a hearing school. Which is deaf children should go to deaf school or mainstream. “The differences

Christians should be silent on social issues and stay out of people's lives because they have no right to judge or critique others

804 words - 4 pages . So Christians should utilise their numbers and partake in social issues that directly concern them or issues which create, ‘the stirring of the love of God which cannot be contained,’ within them. In Hebrews 5:11 it states, “for those who are mature, who through training have the skill to recognize the difference between right and wrong.” Christians are blessed with a moral compass. It is this compass that we should employ in our struggle to

This essay is about the book A Seperate Peace by John Knowles. Wasn't really sure what category this should go under; it's literature but i don't know what it means by North American or European, etc

811 words - 3 pages , Brinker, is revealed. If he had only left the past in the past Finny would have maintained a strong relationship with Gene and learned to live a good life even with his disabilities. To all who have read A Separate Peace, Gene seems to be this ruthless killer when he jounces the limb out of anger. It is only until later that the reader discovers that it is the emotional trauma brought upon him by Brinker that actually kills him. There were many factors involving the death of Phineas, but none of them were as significant as Brinker's interrogation. It is in cases like these where the best option is to let go of a troubling past and work on building a better future.

The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger - Symbolisim throughout the novel

809 words - 3 pages too peaceful and he did not want to disturb it. This symbolizes Holden having the power to change his view on life and his view of the people in his life. Holden does not use this power because he likes the way things are. He does not like change. The snow represents purity and innocence. To specify Jane Gallagher, in Holden's mind, is still innocent and pure. If Holden were to go and see her or call her, he would be disturbing his ultimate image

How Holden Deals with Grief in Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye

744 words - 3 pages of childhood he hates to see children lose. Holden Caulfield values his brother, Allie. When Allie died of Leukemia on July 19, 1946, Holden was left devastated. However, Holden always thought that Allie was the most interesting person that he has ever met. Allie was one person that Holden mentions that he loves in the novel. When Holden’s younger sister Phoebe asks Holden what he likes he says, “I like Allie” (171). Holden hides or

What challenges must Holden overcome in order to reconnect to the world?

813 words - 3 pages the world, Holden needs to learn how to move on from the past.Another challenge that Holden needs to overcome is growing up. Holden fears change, and says that "certain things they should stay the way they are." When Holden talks about sex and admits that "sex is something I just don't understand. I swear to God I don't". As the adult world scares him, Holden invents a fantasy that all adults are "phonies" while children are innocent and honest


1319 words - 6 pages J.D. Salinger’s “The Catcher in the Rye”, opens with the narration of a young boy named Holden Caulfield. He explained that he was kicked out of his third boarding school, Pencey Prep, and that he didn’t like the majority of the people that went to school with him because to him they are all phoney. After having a fight with his roommate, Stradlater, Holden decides to leave school two days early and stay in New York until he is supposed to go

Similar Essays

Should They Stay Or Should They Go?

850 words - 4 pages population such as trapping, euthanization, poison, and shooting them, but we should handle this problem humanely. One solution we should go to is Trap, Neuter, and Release, (TNR). We trap the ferals, without harming them, and take them to a nearby pet shelter where they can be neutered or spayed, and then released back into the wild away from the community. By neutering and releasing the ferals, they won't be able to reproduce but they can still go out

Should They Stay Or Should They Go...Now

3234 words - 13 pages the murals should be left up to serve as a learning opportunity. This is a concept that might be better served within an art gallery or museum where people choose to go for these learning opportunities and where these establishments do not necessarily strive to attain equal representation.A Province newspaper poll that asked "should the B.C. government remove some murals in the legislative building because some natives find them offensive

Should I Stay Or Go ?

776 words - 4 pages “Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It is not rude, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, and always perseveres.” But where do you draw the line? When does love become impatient, unkind and rude? When do you know that it is no longer love but

Confederate Flag, Should It Stay Or Go? American Government Essay

613 words - 3 pages to continue to do so. There may come a day when the blatantly racist meaning of the flag fades away along with the scars of integration. Until that day comes, the responsibility falls upon Confederate flag flyers to explain what it means to them. As for the rest of us, we should keep an open mind, about a symbol that has stood for so much to so many, be it right or wrong.