Should Human Reproductive Cloning Be Legal

1004 words - 5 pages

The matter of human reproductive cloning is a complex topic, in which there are many issues that must be addressed before any actions take place. Any decision based on reproductive cloning will not be clear-cut, and instead will host a multitude of ideas. In this paper, I will determine, through philosophical thinking, if human reproductive cloning is morally appropriate.
First and foremost, it is important to discuss what human cloning is. It is the conception of in vitro embryos that produces “individuals that are exact genetic copies of the donor from whom the DNA was obtained” (Munson 366). In Laymen’s terms, cells are inserted from the donor host into an unfertilized egg from another host (meaning it is asexual) and the new egg is transferred into the surrogate mother where it will foster into an embryo, if effective.
There are some rewards and disadvantages to utilizing human reproductive cloning. One advantage would be giving a woman who was not able to find the right person to have a child with, the child she had wanted. In “Mothers by Choice” there are many professional women, who before, would have to settle with ”Mr. Okay” to have a child (Munson 335). Now, marriage is not necessary to allow working women a child and they would not have to settle or put their ambitions to the wayside.
One disadvantage would certainly be like the Calvert Case. A couple was determined to have a child, however, the mother had a hysterectomy removing her uterus and therefore was not able to carry a child to term. Instead, the couple turned to a surrogate who would carry the child. Unfortunately, the surrogate felt that she should be a mother to the child as well, and took the case to court (Munson 348). The courts decided that since the child was not hers genetically speaking, she should not be part of the child’s life. This sort of repeal of parenthood for the surrogate mother would be devastating. We would create a great amount of turmoil for this woman and we completely disregard that she has rights as well as a human being.
I decided upon using Kant’s ethical theory, also known as Kantianism to discuss the topic of human reproductive cloning. This theory is applicable to the topic because it is based on doing our moral duty, no matter what our own desires entail. Our tools in determining the correct action to do are universality and respect for others. Therefore, any solution of our problems must stem from these necessities. We are hence in search of the “maxims that satisfy the categorical imperative”, or the “motive force behind our actions …that determines [our] moral character” (Munson 872).
Initially, we must consider the major possible courses of action. The first possibility is that human cloning is allowed. Scientists test experiments freely without constraints from the government. To analyze this in the views of Kantianism, we must apply “universalizability” or the idea that we must act consistently and apply a moral...

Find Another Essay On Should Human Reproductive Cloning Be Legal

Human Cloning Should be Condemned Essay

614 words - 2 pages Human Cloning Should be Condemned   On November 25, 2001, the news that a firm called Advanced Cell Technology had created human embryos by cloning added new urgency to Congress's and the nation's deliberations on this issue.   This past summer, by a 265-to-162 margin, the House of Representatives passed a carefully worded ban on human cloning (H.R. 2505) which President Bush has said he will sign into law. The leadership

Should Human Cloning Be Banned? Essay

937 words - 4 pages definition of a clone is an individual grown from a single body cell of its parent and having the same gene as its parent (Berube 282). ? Human cloning should be banned whether it is reproductive cloning or therapeutic cloning According to the Economist, attempting to clone a human would certainly end in disaster. The clones would be at high risk for stillbirths or sudden deaths. In animal cloning, for example, every one hundred eggs are used

Human Cloning Should be Permitted

1435 words - 6 pages conservatives. This scenario is true and is taking place with human cloning at this very moment. If you don't act fast this crowning achievement of medical science could be lost forever. "This procedure will be both a contribution to science and a betterment of the human race." Human cloning will provide unlimited benefits to our species and should be legal. This paper is intended to educate you to the many benefits of human cloning before it

Should Human Cloning Be Banned?

783 words - 4 pages . Although some scientists and ethicists agree with human cloning, there are more evidence that human cloning yields negative results. Opponents of banned human cloning claim that human have the right to clone themselves. They insist that human cloning is problem of individual choice and individual choice should be guaranteed if individual choice do not damage to other people. (Kerry, 2006) Also, they claim that human have right to choose the

Reproductive Human Stem Cell Cloning

1353 words - 6 pages The argument on whether human cloning/stem cell research should be deemed acceptable still exists. Those that are in favor of artificial reproduction claim that the benefits of human cloning far outweigh the negatives. Those opposed of accepting stem cell research lift up the argument that it is unnatural and cruel. This particular procedure is a technological process that involves “copying” a human’s nuclear DNA, this type of cloning is known

Human Torture SHOULD Be Legal

1930 words - 8 pages others runs counter to how we define ourselves as a nation and as human beings. But allowing innocents to come to harm is as much a part of that same definition. Works Cited Dershowitz, Alan M. “Yes, It Should Be ‘On The Books.’” The Little, Brown Reader. Ed. Marcia Stubbs, Sylvan Barnet, and William E. Cain. Boston: Longman, 2009. 554. Heymann, Philip B. “Torture Should Not Be Authorized.” The Little, Brown Reader. Ed

Human Cloning Should Not Be Banned

2939 words - 12 pages Proposition: Human Cloning Should Not Be Banned.The news of the successful cloning of an adult sheep, in which the sheeps DNA was inserted into an unfertilized sheep egg to produce a lamb with identical DNA, has generated an outpour of ethical concerns. These concerns are not about Dolly, the now famous sheep, nor even about the considerable impact cloning may have on the animal breeding industry, but rather about the possibility of cloning

Human Cloning Should Not be Permitted

4387 words - 18 pages continuing cloning research and those who are staunchly opposed to it.  Meanwhile, despite public opinion, science trudges on behind closed doors working to clone the first human. This paper will first provide a thorough, but brief, introduction into the topic of cloning itself, including its history and its mechanisms; then, through a series of carefully thought out points, it will illustrate why human cloning should not be allowed to continue at

Human Cloning Should Not Be Regulated

1084 words - 4 pages these breakthroughs in their sights, would be forced to take their experiments underground to avoid political repercussions.           The opposition insists on the regulation of cloning and is suggesting a permanent ban, arguing that cloning in any way is unethical.  Some take the position that scientists can not be trusted, ethically, to know when the experiments should stop, therefore, the scientific community would be unable to effectively

Is Human Cloning Legal?

1287 words - 6 pages Human cloning has not been legally used in humans because many people and experts are still discussing its effectiveness, worthiness and effect on humanity. Human cloning, also known as human genetic engineering, can be divided into two main types, which are therapeutic cloning, growing cloned tissue from individual, and reproductive cloning, genetically identical copy of an individual. Human cloning have drawn people’s attention because people

Cloning: Right Or Wrong? Should cloning be legal? What are the pros and cons of cloning? What can cloning lead to? What should be done?

563 words - 2 pages products such as proteins for humans.Some people would suggest that cloning is unnatural and not ethically correct but so would be talking medicine when you fall sick. The whole of the modern medicine world in based on unnaturalness, so it seems cloning would be part of that modern medicine world. Some people also suggest that clones of human beings would behave in different ways than a normal human being would however this is also wrong as the

Similar Essays

Human Reproductive Cloning Should Be Banned

1053 words - 4 pages Human Reproductive Cloning Should be Banned The issues concerning human reproductive cloning are shrouded in controversy, perhaps overshadowing the true advantages of cloning technology. Therapeutic cloning, which is often misunderstood as reproductive cloning, is less controversial than the latter as it does not involve the creating of an individual being. Instead, vital stem cells are extracted from human embryos, in order to generate

Should Reproductive Cloning Be Allowed? Essay

710 words - 3 pages destroys and dehumanizes the child, the clone, and all humans at large. Humans will now become careless about the value of their life and the life of another, due to the fact that they could “simply” be replaced by cloning. Most supporters of human cloning don’t honestly asses the great disadvantages that it holds. The many downfalls and moral impediments in the allowance of reproductive cloning of humans should be in the

Should Human Cloning Be Permitted? Essay

2064 words - 9 pages approximately ten to fifteen percent of couples of reproductive age throughout the developing world (“The Ethics of Human Cloning”). Infertility, in its worst cases, can bring some degree of shame or incompleteness for both the sexes and may also develop into psychological problems in some couples. Therefore, reproductive cloning should be practiced for curing the infertility of couples and satisfying their emotional and psychological need for

Should Human Cloning Be Pursued? Essay

1209 words - 5 pages continue so that it can be used to save lives improve the practice of medicine. Reproductive cloning on the other hand is unethical and should never be allowed. Measures need to be taken to control research on therapeutic cloning, and cloning in general, so that the creation of a human clone never happens. Works Cited Bush, George W. "President Bush’s Speech on Cloning." White House. 10 Apr. 2002. PBS. Web. 28 Feb. 2014.