Should Intelligent Design Be Taught In Public Schools?

1629 words - 7 pages

In 1859, Charles Darwin published his groundbreaking Origin of Species, which would introduce the seminal theory of evolution to the scientific community. Over 150 years later, the majority of scientists have come to a consensus in agreement with this theory, citing evidence in newer scientific research. In an average high school biology classroom, one may imagine an instructor that has devoted much of his life to science and a predominantly Christian class of about twenty-five students. On the topic of evolution, one of the students might ask, “Why would God have taken the long route by creating us through billion years of evolution?” while another student may claim “The Book of Genesis clearly says that the earth along with all living creatures was created in just six days, and Biblical dating has proven that the earth is only 6000 years old.” Finally a third student interjects with the remark “maybe the Bible really is just a book, and besides, science has basically already proven that evolution happened, and is continuing to happen as we speak.” A secular country like our own does and should treat each argument as valid. However, only the third student’s argument cites scientific backing. Is it fair that we are denying that intelligent design be taught as an alternative to evolution in our science classes? When a belief has no legitimate scientific backing, it is not science, but rather a philosophy, whereas biology is in fact science, which is why intelligent design does not belong in science classes in public schools.
Since the time that teaching evolution in public schools was banned as heresy and taboo for contradicting the Bible, most public school systems today take an opposite approach in which creationism is seldom taught – the controversy, however, never diminished. In the last decade, many states are trying to reinstate the teaching of creationism in public schools under the more academic title of “intelligent design.” Funded heavily by the Discovery Institute, a conservative think-tank, intelligent design is an attempt to produce scientific backing for the idea that an intelligent being (the Abrahamic God) has designed all life on earth. The theory is made in assumption that pure creationism, for obvious reasons, can never pass as unaffiliated with religion, and thus can never be taught in government-funded public schools. As of now, its proponents’ claims for the earth’s age vary between 6000 and 4.5 billion years ago, as long as God did it (Branch). Rather than relying on scientific evidence, intelligent design thrives on the most miniscule of holes in evolutionary fossil records and the unfathomability of a living cell being created from inorganic matter. These holes are then complemented with ignorance of viable proof of evolution; proponents of the field have managed to turn these two elements in a supposed science. However, the yet infantile theory has still made its way to public schools in five states, with as many as...

Find Another Essay On Should Intelligent Design be Taught in Public Schools?

Should Birth Control Be Taught in Public Schools?

1245 words - 5 pages indepth class for those who would want to learn more, or even the methods of birth control, or the flip side to this, the reasons why people do not want this taught in public schools. Teens are going to have sex there is no doubt about it, the only way that they might not is going back to the chastity belt era but even then there is no for sure way to make them stop. In my opinion, I think they should teach information about how to be more safe

Arts Education Should Be Taught in Public Schools

1353 words - 6 pages student in America deserves a complete and competitive education that includes the arts. Therefore, art education should be taught in public schools, perhaps now more than ever. As the country becomes increasingly diverse and the workplace more oriented around creativity, arts education is the pivotal key to a successful public school system to ensuring students’ academic achievement, and enriching the positive social development of students

Evolution vs. Intelligent Design in Public Schools

1520 words - 6 pages religion (Lac, Hemovich, Himelfarb 2009). Intelligent design is the theory that life, or the universe could not have arisen by chance and was designed and created by some intelligent entity. Intelligent design should be allowed to be taught as an alternative theory in science classes in public schools. Evolution is a Religion In the Websters dictionary the definition of religion is, "something someone believes in and follows devotedly." Another

Intelligent Design: Reasons it shouldn't be taught

786 words - 3 pages CONThe origin of life, its an unknown that has been discussed, researched, and pondered for an unknown length of time. But is the theory of Intelligent Design, or ID, a theory that should be taught in the science department of the United States educational system? Unfortunately no, its not. The theory should not be added to the science curriculum because it is not science. It better fits in another curriculum. Says Presidential Science Advisory

Evolution: It Should Be Taught In Schools

1470 words - 6 pages creationism which believes the Earth to be ~10,000 years old). Further evidence for Intelligent Design is the complexity of nature (e.g. Human Anatomy), something so complex that a foreign agent could have created it (Stafford) Astounding, only 15% of all Americans believe in the evolution of humans taught in schools, with 46% believing in traditional Creationism (Templeton). Such a staggering number means that the populaces will embrace a new

Evolution Should be Taught in Schools

722 words - 3 pages opposed to those with only high school diplomas. The polls found that 74% Americans with post-graduate degrees believe in evolution theory compared to 21% of Americans with only high school diplomas. The Gallup polls suggest that the belief in the theory of evolution is associated with education. Evolution should be taught in schools because it has more scientific evidence to support it than creationism does. Also, public schools should not teach

Should Evolution be Taught in Schools?

752 words - 3 pages Evolution has been taught in all public schools for as long as many can recall. Though the process of evolution is not the only theory, schools have been teaching it as if it is the complete truth, ignoring other aspects and only focusing and targeting on Darwin's theory of Evolution. However, there are still many other ideas that the students should be informed of as well because all are theories, all are hypothetic. Teaching of the evolution

Should sex education be taught in schools?

779 words - 3 pages completely clueless about what goes on in their bodies and what the other gender is capable of. Overall, my point of view is that sexual education should be taught in school. It's a subject that should not be looked over and should be taught before you go to high school when those things come into play.This is my point of view because boys and girls need to know about their bodies, know about STD's, and know the different types of methods to prevent pregnancy. Schools should allow sex education because there are a lot of diseases that are going around today that are deadly. Sexual education should be taught regardless.

Should manga be taught in schools?

1013 words - 5 pages (as these are the western norm), manga holds a much more complex, artistic background. More than most understand. However as globalisation continues on its crusade, bringing more imports from other countries the question rising to the surface is: should books such as manga be taught more widely in schools along side other texts? While manga may be viewed as children's books, this could not be further from the truth. Picture orientated books have

Birth Control Should Be Taught in Schools

1371 words - 5 pages large number of teen pregnancies in todays society. “Nearly one hundred years ago, when Planned Parenthood was founded, birth control was illegal” (Richards) We need to teens know how to be responsible about sex and be safe. Works Cited "Most in Poll Favor Public Schools Providing Birth Control." Beaumont Enterprise: 0. Nov 02 2007. ProQuest. Web. 19 Mar. 2014 . DeNARDO, CHRISTINA. "District Putting Limits on Sex Ed ; Sarasota

Should Creationism be Taught in Schools?

1003 words - 5 pages denominations. After bashing evolution left and right, creationists have conceded to allow it to be taught in the classroom, but they still want ID or creationism to be taught alongside it. The argument as claimed by creationists is “all alternatives should be taught in the classroom anyway. Everyone has a right to speak their mind. Let the kids decide for themselves. It’s only fair.” This argument is one of the most compelling arguments because it isn’t

Similar Essays

Position Paper: Should Intelligent Design And/Or Creationism Be Taught Alongside Evolution In Public Schools?

901 words - 4 pages There are many controversies in courtrooms about whether or not should intelligent design should be taught alongside evolution in public schools, which has been going on for a great amount of years. Intelligent design is the idea of nature's changes cannot be a random process, but a type of guidance must have lead to why nature is the way it is in today’s era. In most cases, that specific guidance is God. God has created the world for a purpose

Should Creationism Be Taught In Public Schools?

1186 words - 5 pages Teaching Creationism or Intelligent Design to our youth can be done in a way that is neither opinion based nor completely fact based, but may hold some risk of personal interpretation. The first thing needed to be considered is how can children of the middle school age range grasp such a deep subject and have the capacity to reach their own conclusion. Information found regarding the development of children in this developmental range was found

Religion Should Be Taught In Public Schools

3344 words - 13 pages North Carolina, believes that religion should be taught in schools as a matter of education, and education only. If students were more actively aware of other religions they could better understand each other. An unnamed political official believes that since religion plays such an important role in history, it would be improper to try and completely separate the religion and the government. Religion in school should be allowed in school as long as

Intelligent Design Should Be Taught In School As A Science

1587 words - 7 pages science. “ I was absolutely pleased with the recent revote, the loss hurt, but the vote showed a resurrection of intelligent design” (Dembiski 5). Intelligent design has been on a scientific roller coaster, with two very bias sides, nobody will ever be able to tell its future. When push comes to shove intelligent design entirely deserves to be taught in a science lab, at every public high school. Every thing needed for it to be taught is