Should Nature Have Constitutionally Protected Rights Equal To Human Rights? Environmental And Social Justice Research Paper

5310 words - 22 pages

Should Nature have constitutionally protected rights equal to Human rights and can these rights be enforced effectively?
Alessandra Taco
Environmental and Social Justice
Despite economic, political, or social differences, most people recognize that nature is a valuable “collective good.” Yet, this recognition does not mean that everybody agrees that nature should be granted rights. Even those who think that nature has inherent rights do not readily agree on who must decide how nature’s resources are distributed nor do they agree in what amount or to what extent the division is fair. These disagreements, in turn, have led to legal agreements, the establishment of regulations and allegations of rights violations. The rights discourse has also gone through many changes from seeing the environment as an “object” to be used and disposed of for human benefit, seeing the environment as an intrinsic part of human rights, to ultimately granting rights to the environment as an entity without any connection to human activities. The clear majority of environmental rights are based on a perceived relationship between human rights and the environment. Both at a national and at an international level, environmental rights are plentiful, varied, and complex and subject to many levels of governance. Thus, the arguments that environmental rights are not sufficient is not accurate. In this paper, I will argue that expanding or even amending environmental rights is not necessary to solve environmental legal problems. Instead, the perceived inadequacy of existing environmental laws can be remedied by establishing more streamlined processes and procedures, by, when possible, making the observation of environmental laws mandatory not just based on voluntary membership to environmental organizations. Current environmental procedures “have grown up haphazardly with no apparent underlying principle, and we consider they fail to provide a system appropriate for contemporary needs”
The protection of the environment is a global concern that requires the establishment of an agency or tribunal that oversees compliance with existing laws and regulations. If environmental rights are given the same value as human rights, then perhaps it is time to establish Environmental Tribunals to handle environmental legislation. A Report of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights recognizes the need for an organization such as the one described above, “We recommend the establishment of Environmental Tribunals to handle appeals under environmental legislation other than the town and country planning system.”
More than new environmental laws what is needed is modernization in the way environmental regulation is handled, applied and enforced. The existing system is complex, difficult to understand for the general public, and it does not reflect consistent application of the law.
Law follows public recognition of significant threat that is a surprise in a...

Find Another Essay On Should Nature have constitutionally protected rights equal to Human rights? - Environmental and social justice - Research Paper

Should Animals Have Rights? Essay

733 words - 3 pages This very moment an animal somewhere is being mistreated. Animals have been living with humans for thousands of years, during that time they have been typically viewed as soulless creatures. Animals are living creatures and should not be tested on, abused, or used for entertainment (“The Issues”). Animal testing’s main goal is to experiment with new medicines, vaccines, cosmetic products, and house hold cleaners. Every year all throughout the

the ‘rights’ a person should have to education, work, and health/well-being - Aspen University Social work - Essay

1162 words - 5 pages international security and peace. Civil rights and liberties are the protection against unfair treatment and discrimination. Everyone should have equal access to education and housing. All people are constitutionally guaranteed to certain freedoms including the right s to participate in activities that lead to social change. Social welfare impacts family life, economic conditions, and health and well-being. These human rights are outlines in the

Illegal Immigration and Equal Rights

1657 words - 7 pages Illegal Immigration and Equal Rights Should immigrants receive the same tolerances that other minority groups have received in the past decades? Should their struggle for equal rights over- shadow the fact that immigration laws are ignored? Pro Amnesty and Anti-Immigration groups have different opinions about these issues The immigration laws that exist in the U.S are not the problem, the problem exist with the people who refuse to enforce

Human Rights and Human Rights Organisations

2596 words - 10 pages other Islamic countries, and have not taken into account the nature of their dominant religion and culture's values and attitudes in terms of what is perceived to be human rights.Also many Human Rights agreements are simply ignored by many countries, and not given proper attention. The UN, although technically can address these issues, in reality can hardly ever do much about these sort of situations, which is a major limitation on its powers.4

Equal Rights Amendment

1012 words - 5 pages changes that would have been affected by the Equal Rights Amendment would deal with discriminatory laws, which helps women have an equal chance. It gives women equality in wages, health insurance, pension, social security, and more. This also helps redefine that women’s roles aren’t just within home taking care the family and having no say in such issues, but that women have much to contribute to society just as much as the men’s roles. This

Equal Rights of Woman

645 words - 3 pages by nature but by a poor system of education that prevents women from gaining the wisdom necessary to secure virtue and fulfillment. Wollstonecraft concludes from this vindication that women have been forced to learn, when permitted to learn, from men who considered women to be less fully human thereby rendering the assumption they lack reason and not at all human. This is a poor insight on these men and show that men are not willing to understand

The Equal Rights Amendment

1013 words - 4 pages The Equal Rights Amendment "Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex."      In 1923, this statement was admitted to Congress under the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). The ERA was a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution granting equality between men and women under the law. If the Era was passed, it would have made unconstitutional any laws

Equal Rights Amendment

1097 words - 4 pages 'Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex.'In 1923, this statement was admitted to Congress under the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). The ERA was a proposed amendment to the United States Constitution granting equality between men and women under the law. If the Era was passed, it would have made unconstitutional any laws that grant one sex different rights than the

Attaining Equal Rights

815 words - 4 pages Publishing her book Lean In, Sheryl Sanberg the vice president of Global sales and operation at Google referred to the great sexual discrimination. The majority of every filed are running by men, and they control everything by the majority. Women do not have equal status like men because women are not allowed to have equal political seats like men, be fully emancipated to get their basic human rights, and have equal right to

The 19th Amendment: Equal Rights to Vote

1692 words - 7 pages the 19th amendment was passed. The amendment let women into power giving them social justice and many political rights. Before 1920 women did not have the right to vote. They were known as “second class citizens”. Women were to stay home to help and organize the family’s necessities. Having any other higher power was said to be way out of their limitations. Mainly because women weren’t fully exposed to the happenings outside of the home, which

Equal Rights Amendment

975 words - 4 pages The Equal Rights Amendment, 1972-1872 Alice Paul and the National Woman's Party first introduced the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) to Congress in 1923. From its inception, the amendment had been meant to end "special privileges" that women were afforded by the law and to build equality between the sexes. In the 1950s, support for the amendment would grow with Presidents such as Eisenhower within their ranks. In 1963, President Kennedy's

Similar Essays

Do Animals Have Rights And, If So, Should They Be Protected?

696 words - 3 pages make it more important that man should draw out more rights for animals and then set about protecting them, since there is little that animals can do to protect their rights. My opinion is that animals definitely have rights and these rights must be protected.References:Feinberg, J. (1974) The rights of animals, in: W. T. Blackstone (Ed.) Philosophyand Environmental Crisis (Athens: University of Georgia Press).Godfrey-Smith, W. (1979) The value

Government, Justice, And Human Rights Essay

3098 words - 12 pages founded on our beliefs that all men and women have a "natural right" entitling them to equal concern and respect. They are due this right because they are human beings who have the abilities to "make plans and give justice" (1977, p. 182). H.L.A. Hart, Joel Feinberg, John Locke, Robert Nozick, among others, unite in advancing the thesis that there are at least some rights which precede those granted by citizenship and which remain when a government

Understanding Justice And Human Rights Essay

1537 words - 6 pages gender was not respected and had no say in the government. If the regime was still reigning then all leaders could be men. The educated people in the society could comprise of men only. Having one gender dominant in a society brings about gender disparity. According to the present human rights and justice all gender should have equal opportunities in the societal tasks. The regime did not allow servants to marry without seeking

Feminism And Equal Rights Essay

1426 words - 6 pages . Ladies like Taylor Swift, Beyoncé, Miley Cyrus, and Kelly Clarkson all support and advocate for women and equal rights. Others however claim that they are not feminist. Katy Perry for example, says that she is not a feminist due to the negative connotation associated with the word (Duca). The meaning of feminism has changed greatly over the century and has a more modern definition of “equality” and “justice”. Women should be more educated about