This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legal For Terminally Ill Patients To Engage In?

1396 words - 6 pages

Should Physician-Assisted Suicide Be Legal For Terminally Ill Patients to Engage In?Critical Analysis EssayThe use of physician-assisted suicide in order to relieve dire pain and suffering has been a highly controversial practice that comes with a long history. In his award-winning documentary film, How to Die in Oregon, Peter D. Richardson examines the issue first handily, targeting the "Death with Dignity Act" which had been passed in the State of Oregon during 1994. The Act specifically permits terminally ill patients to end their own life with medication prescribed by their physician. Although Richardson may be correct in that physician-assisted suicide should be legal for terminally ill patients to engage in, his dependency on anecdotal knowledge inevitably evokes illogical argumentation, leading to a severely weak claim. Due to both social and Illegitimate biases as well as being guilty of committing both the "Fallacy of Semantic Ambiguity" and "Fallacious Appeal to Pity", I show how the involvement of Dr. Katherine Morris, Nancy Niedzielski, and Derek Humphry, within the documentary film, How to Die in Oregon, ultimately reduce the overall effectiveness of Richardson's main argument.This section contains a "Multi-Modal Argumentation" analysis of the award-winning documentary film, How to Die in Oregon. It is evident that both, "The Emotional Mode" and "The Logical Mode" are utilized within the documentary film. Concentrating on "The Emotional Mode", when assessing the effectiveness of Richardson's supporting arguments, it is evident that they are significantly effective. By focusing heavily on the personal experiences and observations of individuals specifically impacted by Oregon's "Death with Dignity Act", Richardson is successfully able to capture the raw emotion required to deliver a strong and persuasive main argument. Moreover, concentrating on "The Logical Mode", when analyzing the acceptability, relevancy, and sufficiency of Richardson's supporting arguments it is evident that large fragments are both unacceptable and irrelevant. Rather than focusing on the opinions of certain medical professionals, Richardson relies heavily on the personal experiences and observations of various "Lay Persons". In choosing to develop an argument in this fashion, the effectiveness of Richardson's main argument is insignificant as the creditability and emotional stability of his sources is dubious.A definite flaw that reduces the effectiveness of Richardson's main argument pertains to the involvement of Dr. Katherine Morris within his documentary film. Dr. Morris is a surgical oncologist situated in the State of Oregon and a clear proponent of the "Death with Dignity Act". When disclosing reasons for supporting such a controversial Act, it is recognizable that Dr. Morris's claims are neither acceptable nor relevant owing to fallacious reasoning. The precise fallacy's that Dr. Morris is guilty of committing are both the, "Fallacy of Semantic...

Find Another Essay On Should Physician-Assisted Suicide Be Legal For Terminally Ill Patients to Engage In?

Whether euthanasia should be legalized for terminally ill patients in China

1140 words - 5 pages ]. This essay examines reasons why euthanasia should not become a legitimate practice for terminally ill patients in Chinese context. Firstly, it seems to be difficult to draw a line whether a patient contracting with a certain disease can be regarded as terminally ill. China is a country where the distribution of medical resources is rather unbalanced [4,5]. According to a report published by Cheng and Zhu [6], the medical resource of urban area

Assisted Suicide Should be Legal Essay

2376 words - 10 pages Assisted Suicide should be legal for terminally ill patients. It is unethical that it is illegal in forty six states for a physician to humanely assist a terminally ill patient who had the mental capacity to sign a directive stating that they wished to end their life on their own terms. Assisted suicide is by no means a new concept; in fact, it has been debated throughout the history of the world (procon.org, 2013). According to Murphy (2011

Assisted Suicide Should Be Legal

712 words - 3 pages only have about two months to live; it is just a matter of when. You have said your last goodbyes and are ready to move on. Now, if you had the chance to choose how your life ended, would you take advantage of it? I believe it is important for assisted suicide to be legalized in the United States in order to assist the terminally ill and severely disabled patients who are not capable to take care of themselves because there already is a movement in

The Case for Euthanasia, Should Physician-Assisted Suicide be Legalized?

1534 words - 6 pages not the patient has the freedom to choose whether or not to prolong their life even though it may consist of pain and suffering. In answer to this question, proponents of physician-assisted suicide, most notably, Dr. Jack Kevorkian, are of the opinion that not only should patients be able to abstain from treatment, but if they have a terminal and/or extremely painful condition, they should be able to seek out the assistance of a doctor in order

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legalized?

1212 words - 5 pages Should be legalized for physician to let assist terminally ill patients with suicide if he/she or family members request for it? In any case, either the patient or family members ask for it, we must look at many other reasons why legalizing assisted suicide is a wrong to the public. Therefore, it is extremely important to focus on the wrong doing that we are attempting to allow physicians commit. If physician assisted suicide legalized and made

Physician assisted suicide should be legalized

1847 words - 7 pages Angela Gao March, 2005physician assisted suicide should be legalizedPhysician assisted suicide (PAS) refers to a practice in which the physician assist a patient to end his or her own life, in a painless or minimally painful way, for merciful reasons (encyclopedia.laborlawtalk.com). Its main purpose is to end patients' suffering. PAS is an intentional termination of life to the terminally ill patients and carried out with physicians' help such

Assisted Suicide Should Not Be Legal

1462 words - 6 pages is a debate on whether it should be legal or not. Some of the positive issues on assisted suicide are it reliefs a person from the pain they are in. The person has the right to choose how they want to die because that falls under the equal protections clause. Oncology patients don’t necessary like the idea of physician assistant suicide. Some negative issues of assisted suicide are that it violates ethics that people may have. Also it is

Physician Assisted Suicide Should Or Should Not Be

745 words - 3 pages else taking action at the request of the patient who wants to die from an incurable disease. Helping someone to take his/her life has raised many questions and concerns of these procedures. One question is being asked, should physician assisted suicide be legalize? I believe that physician assisted suicide should not be legal. It raises too much moral and ethical concern in the society. Many believe that it is immoral, unethical, and just

Euthanasia/Physician Assisted Suicide Should Not be Legalized

1510 words - 6 pages single year (14,691 according to the Dutch government…) is cases of involuntary euthanasia.” (Koukl) Over time the guidelines to whether one should be aided in suicide for whatever motive would diminish and be redefined; sad, but evidently that is how it starts. Reason 2: Physician Assisted Suicide violates the Hippocratic Oath Physicians are taught to be responsible and loyal to their patients, which is why they swear on the Hippocratic Oath

Physician-Assisted Suicide Essay - Euthanasia Should Not be Legalized

846 words - 3 pages done anyway.  People HAD access to abortion, it was just being done terribly.  We're in exactly the same situation today:  People do have access to assisted suicide--it's just being done so badly.  (Shavelson, 39)"  Just because something is done does not mean that it should be legal. Many things that are illegal are done anyway.  Look at drugs, underage drinking, drunk driving, and speeding; these things are all illegal

Medical Decisions for Incapacitated or Terminally ill Patients

978 words - 4 pages state will make sure that all state-funded facilities abide by this statement. The topic of assisted suicide for terminally ill patients is one that the state is always changing views on. As renewed Surgeon General for the State, it is my job to use my knowledge and abilities to make the best decisions on this topic. I believe that assisted suicide should be allowed for terminally ill patients. It is their right to decide if they want to

Similar Essays

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legal For Terminally Ill Patients To Engage In?

1396 words - 6 pages Should Physician-Assisted Suicide Be Legal For Terminally Ill Patients to Engage In?Critical Analysis EssayThe use of physician-assisted suicide in order to relieve dire pain and suffering has been a highly controversial practice that comes with a long history. In his award-winning documentary film, How to Die in Oregon, Peter D. Richardson examines the issue first handily, targeting the "Death with Dignity Act" which had been passed in the

Terminally Ill Patients And Physician Assisted Suicide

697 words - 3 pages Terminally Ill Patients and Physician Assisted Suicide For hundreds of years a doctor was sworn into practice with the Oath of Hippocrates. Although in the present time parts of the oath have oath has come into question on how they should be interrupted. "To do no harm," the question is what does one consider harm? With our modern technology in medicine our medical community has the ability to prolong a person's life for quite awhile

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legal? Essay

1717 words - 7 pages Should physician-assisted suicide be legal? This debated subject has no right or wrong answer. Assisting someone in death has a felony murder conviction in some cases. There are a few different ways of being charged, but there are certain circumstances. There are many reasons why I am for it and of course, I have reasons against it. When you have a loved one in a vegetative state, does the family say yes or no to “pulling the plug

Should Physician Assisted Suicide Be Legal In America?

886 words - 4 pages In America today, there is a considerable amount of debate on whether or not physician-assisted suicide should be legal nationwide. However, I believe the question is not just should physician-assisted suicide be legal nationwide, but instead, do we as human beings have the right to determine when we die? Personally, I believe we do have the right to determine when we die, so I support physician-assisted suicide. However, I also believe