Should Same Sex Marriage Be Legalized? Essay

1549 words - 6 pages

Should same-sex marriage be legalized?
The same-sex marriage issue has ignited worldwide. Joseph Chamie- the previous director- and Barry Mirkin-the previous Population Policy Section Chief- of the UN’s Population Division aim to present up-to-date statistics and information on the same-sex marriage debate in “Same-Sex Marriage: A New Social Phenomenon.” They mention that same-sex marriage is a “recent phenomenon” that will possibly stick around for years in many countries because societal, religious, and legislative controversies continually revamp its debate (544). The issue is labeled “recent” because “…SSM [same-sex marriage] did not exist until the twenty-first century when an increasing number of countries began permitting same-sex couples to marry legally” (Chamie and Mirkin 529). The writers report that, as of mid-2011, 10 countries, Mexico City, seven states in the US, and Washington DC, have made same-sex marriage legal (531). “Thus, 319 million people, or 5 percent of world population, live in jurisdictions that recognize same-sex marriage” (Chamie and Mirkin 531). In the US, 40 states have rulings prohibiting same-sex marriage where, in 29, the prohibitions are voter-backed blocking judges from overturning the legislation (Chamie and Mirkin 537). The statistics confirm that “… in the United States, the country remains divided over same-sex marriage” (Chamie and Mirkin 537).
The division in opinions here, at home, is no clearer than when analyzing the polar perspectives of La Shawn Barber (a freelance writer that has appeared in many well known radio stations and newspapers such as the Washington Post), and Anna Quindlen (a nationally acclaimed writer and a contributing editor for Newsweek magazine). Barber posted an essay on Townhall.com in 2007 entitled: “Interracial Marriage: Slippery Slope?” where she expresses her opposition for same-sex marriage. By deconstructing the common comparison of same-sex marriage to interracial marriage, she intends to defend her view that interracial marriage is not a slippery slope decision that will roll down hill in an out of control manner and head for the worst like, she claims, same-sex marriage will. Opposing Barber’s views, Quindlen wrote an essay in 2008 entitled: “The Loving Decision” where she sets forth her support for same-sex marriage by constructing a comparison between interracial marriage and same-sex marriage. She uses this comparison to suggest that same-sex marriage will, too, be validated by the courts because “the world only spins forward” (258). Even though Barber and Quindlen stand on opposite sides of the debate with views clashing on fundamental concepts like the meaning of marriage, the nature of homosexuality, and the applicability of the Loving v. Virginia court case to the issue, in various areas the two authors have common ground.
Marriage is an abstract concept that may have different definitions for different people. For Barber, marriage is the legal union...

Find Another Essay On Should Same-Sex Marriage Be Legalized?

Should Same-Sex Marriage Be Legalized in All States?

1881 words - 8 pages not only denied their civil rights, but also their legal and economic benefits. No state should prohibit a person to show their love to another person because of gender because; it does not uphold the fundamental principles of the constitution. In the United States, over 17 states have legalized same sex marriage. In addition, around 16 countries have been able to legalize gay marriages too. This was an incredible breakthrough since same sex

Same-sex Marriage Should be Legal Essay

1089 words - 4 pages unrecognized by the United States government. Same-sex marriages deserve to be legalized in this country. Homosexual couples should be entitled to the same rights as heterosexual couples. To initially understand this issue, one must understand what a marriage is in the eyes of the law. A legal marriage is a "civil contract established through a license issued by state governments" ("About Marriage"). This type of marriage is often

Same Sex Marriage Should NOT Be Allowed

1202 words - 5 pages raise children. Children who are raised in a same sex environment are more inclined to pick up their parents sexuality and lifestyle. Children should be raised in a heterosexual environment, which is biologically correct. Children should not be brought up with a predisposition to be homosexuals or lesbians. The purpose of marriage is to protect our children not our sexual preferences. “With the legalization of homosexual marriage, every

Should Same Sex marriage be Allowed?

1431 words - 6 pages recognizing same-sex marriage. Same-sex marriages should be legalized and recognized because our government guarantees equal rights for all citizens.The government says that every citizen of the United States shall receive equal rights. But, why did they pass the Defense of Marriage Act? The Defense of Marriage Act prohibits the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages; in my opinion this act is immoral and unjust because it restricts the

Same-Sex Marriage Should be Legal

1640 words - 7 pages News revealed that 46% of Republican Mississippi voters believe that interracial marriage should be made illegal. In 2001, Molly McKay and Davina Kotulski began a ritual on Valentine’s Day that would continue for the next decade. Along with other same-sex marriage advocates, they would storm San Francisco City Hall and ask for a marriage license. McKay, adorned in a wedding gown, and Kotulski, wearing a man’s tuxedo, approached the clerk and made

Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legal

523 words - 2 pages Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legal Marriage has long been a traditional aspect of Western Society. It is widely recognized as a ritual between both man and woman. Marriage is deemed as a holy matrimony meant to publically announce a commitment between two heterosexual individuals. For many traditional reasons and religious beliefs the institution of marriage has been denied to homosexuals. Publically opposing the idea of marriage by

Should Same-Sex Marriage Be Legal?

756 words - 3 pages Should same-sex marriage be legal? It is already legal in some areas, but most of the world doesnot allow it. Also, in areas where it is legal, homosexual couples usually do not have the samerights or benefits as heterosexual couples. These people should not be discriminated against.They deserve the right to get married and do other things that heterosexual couples are so free todo like get insurance benefits and even adopt children.Many people

Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Legal

1641 words - 7 pages . Now, gay men and women fight for the right to be married. In Christianity, marriage is a life long commitment under god. It is well known to many Christians that practicing homosexuality is a major sin. How can a union, which is created for man and woman, under god, bond two partners of the same sex if it is stated in god's book that it is morally wrong? Homosexuals should be allowed to make a lifetime commitment to their partners, but it should

Same-Sex Marriage Should be Legal

1308 words - 5 pages marriage - bringing brute force logic and reason to this argument isn't enough. We need more flexibility. And once we see that a lot of these opinions are driven by the religion, we can find a resolution. My solution is for the government to get out of the marriage business completely. It should not be called marriage - civil unions for everyone. Let it be simply a legal contract that recognizes desire of two people to join their lives and

Same-sex marriage should be legalised. (A speech)

753 words - 3 pages from marrying?All that gay and lesbian people are asking for is, if not understanding, then at least tolerance. All they are asking for is the same basic civil equality that all Australians yearn for and should be entitled to.As I leave, I'd like you to think about the great moral changes that have occurred over the past 200 years. Ask yourself would you have felt safe to speak in favor of the separation of the colonies from Great Britain? Would you

Gay Marriage Should be Legalized

1700 words - 7 pages There are numerous opinions and standing views on gay marriage. The argument regarding gay marriage should be legalized or not is extremely controversial. According to an article from the Human Rights Campaign, there is nothing wrong with allowing homosexuals to have the same rights as those who are heterosexual. Every individual person should be granted equal rights, regardless of sexuality. Gay marriage should be legalized in all states and

Similar Essays

Should Same Sex Marriage Be Legalized? Essay

1685 words - 7 pages In the United States, the debate of legalization of same-sex marriage is very controversial. Same-sex marriage is a union between two people of the same gender identity. Only a few states have legalized gay marriage, but in all the other states there are many arguments over whether it should be legalized or not. The citizens of each state have many different opinions on the matter. Many citizens feel disgusted at the thought of it and there are

Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Legalized

1580 words - 6 pages legalized? No. Same-sex marriage should not be legalized due to its harmful effects on societal order, the Constitution, and traditional religious values. Many people think that variety is the spice of life, but that is not always necessarily true. Our society thrives on order, the reassurance that day after day, life will be fundamentally the same. Family life is a part of that. Every child feels a little safer if they know that both mommy and

Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legalized Essay

1167 words - 5 pages . Article 14.1 of the United States Constitution entitles all citizens equal protection under the law and forbids states from enacting laws which deny citizens’ rights. Denying same-sex couples the right to marry, denies them equal protection under the law. Therefore, same-sex marriage should be legalized. Denying people who are homosexuals, the opportunity to marry is a form of minority discrimination. Marriage, in itself, is the highest level

Same Sex Marriage Should Be Legalized Essay

1591 words - 6 pages centuries. The roots of this debate lie in the soil of discrimination. Gays have long been discriminated against, even though there is little difference between sexual orientation-based discrimination and that based upon race. Also, many states and the federal government still have laws that discriminate on gays. These laws must be struck down to pave the way for a new law. Same-sex marriage should be legalized on the basis that discrimination is