This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should Scotland Become Independent From Britain?

1012 words - 5 pages


Since the SNP came to power, there has been a lot of nationalism scattering across the country. On Thursday, the 18th of September, 2014 there will be a referendum. Independence for Scotland is on the top of the nationalist’s ‘to do’ list. But why exactly should we be independent? Would our small, financially challenged country really be able to stand on its own feet against the bigger countries in the global market? For over 300 years we have been part of Great Britain’s success but now in a time of economic meltdown, people have a growing want for independence.
To start, let’s take a look at why our country can’t afford (and will never be able to afford) independence. The credit crunch occurred when our banks were forced to cancel debts after them carelessly giving money to people who could not repay their loans. This forced the government to use public money, to keep the banks afloat and resulted in decreasing our budget by billions of pounds (also causing inflation levels to rise). So what is our tax money going towards now? Instead of paying for the much demanded and quite frankly desperately needed improvements in healthcare, housing and education we are now investing in unstable banks, with the hope that everything will soon be fixed, which, to be honest, sounds good, but it’s going to take a long time, longer than anyone thinks. If we were to become independent, we would be in huge debt, and, owing 3.6 billion is a lot when there is only a population of about 5.4 million in Scotland. If we weren’t to become independent, our debts would get paid more quickly.
It is not only the recession but also our decreasing oil which we must be worried about. Our country heavily relies on oil to make most of its money but when that’s gone independence won’t be easy. How will we pay for our enlarging costs? For the last forty years the oil industry has made up a large portion of our income but with supplies decreasing what will we do then? In 2007 our oil industry had an estimated worth of £250 billion but with this income depleting we could not possibly look at independence as a serious issue. People may say the oil will provide us with enough income in the in the short-run but the reality is in the long-run our oil is going to run out, and we will be left with no sustainable source of income. So what will we do when our twenty years or so of oil has been used? With depleting oil supplies and an economic position like ours independence cannot be an option.
Through being a part of Great Britain we have managed to become one of the top financial powers in the world but some are still trying to improve Scotland when in fact it isn’t as messed up as people seem to think. People think we should have even more control over our own country...

Find Another Essay On Should Scotland Become Independent from Britain?

Scotland's Future Finally in the Hands of the Scottish

1838 words - 7 pages Together’ and ‘Yes Scotland’, are unfortunately both biased as they are bombarding the British people with distorted facts, statistics and predictions in hope to gain more support. The public should therefore view both sides claims, expert opinions and keep an open mind to make the right decision on this very important matter on whether it is in Scotlands best interest to become independent or remain part of Britain. Scotland has used the same

UK Political Devolution and Scottish Independence

2267 words - 9 pages the debate is separatism, this is the thought that Scotland should become independent and leave the UK. The idea of this has caused a few concerns as the vote for independence approaches, reasons for concern is the thought that Scotland will not be allowed to keep the pound as its currency and also the view that Scotland will find it difficult or impossible to remain part of the EU. The other main issues to consider is the oil business and

Scottish delusions of grandeur or the death of Britain

1907 words - 8 pages for Scotland remaining a part of Britain. Last but not least, I will give my personal opinion on whether Scotland should become independent or not. 1.1. Problem formulation First of all, in order to formulate the answer for my main problem, I asked a few questions that will help me stay on the course: - What are the characteristics of Scottish culture? - What are the main reasons for Scottish independence? - What are the advantages of Scotland

Scotland's Referendum 2014

2918 words - 12 pages the well-being of human kind. Scotland will flourish again, without the watchful eye of England. The referendum becomes as simple as this: If you believe that Scotland still is, or can become again the country you have read about, than the answer to the referendum is Yes. Works Cited 101 inventions Caledonia gave the world. (2012, January 15). The Independent. Retrieved December 19, 2013, from http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain

To What Extent is the Proposed Scottish Split from British Rule Beneficial for Either Country?

3522 words - 15 pages openly hostile towards the Scottish Referendum. Those in the EU are particularly dismissive. EU rules state that those who wish to join must adopt the Euro. Britain and Denmark have exclusive permission from Brussels, which is considered to be the de facto capital of the European Union, to use independent currency. The fact that Scottish National Party (current government in power) wishes to keep the pound and simultaneously join the EU has

Scottish Independence Essay- Argumentative

2283 words - 9 pages referred to them for a direct decision.") will be held on Thursday, 18 September, 2014 to decide whether Scotland should become an independent country. I am for Scotland being an independent country primarily because of, but not limited to, the points listed below.Scotland will be more prosperous and economically better off as an independent country. In any society, one of the main questions asked before any sort of political decision, whether it be

Scottish Independence

3028 words - 12 pages Scottish Independence and theReferendumA general overview of the upcoming referendum on Scottish Independence.IntroductionDescribed as Scotland's "biggest choice since 1707" (McLean et al, 2013, p. ix), the upcoming referendum on Scottish independence will provide a pivotal event for the current and future populations of Scotland as voters get the opportunity to decide whether or not they are to remain a part of Great Britain or become an

scottish independence

3028 words - 12 pages Scottish Independence and theReferendumA general overview of the upcoming referendum on Scottish Independence.IntroductionDescribed as Scotland's "biggest choice since 1707" (McLean et al, 2013, p. ix), the upcoming referendum on Scottish independence will provide a pivotal event for the current and future populations of Scotland as voters get the opportunity to decide whether or not they are to remain a part of Great Britain or become an

Ebola essay

547 words - 2 pages the main one is America becoming its own independent country from Great Britain. Then the case was different because the people in Scotland are ot being oppressed or being ruled by a monarch. The main reason for wanting to leave the UK is because some people wanted to not pay the UK taxes and they wanted to make all of their own decisions without having to meet with the rest of the nation and debate. This can also be a connection to my life as I

Examine from an economic perspective ‘poverty in Scotland’ in relation to the forthcoming Scottish independence referendum. Based upon your analy

948 words - 4 pages minimum wage will increase from £6.31 per hour to £6.50 for adult workers. (Milliken, Maclellan, 2014). Since 2009 wages in Scotland have fallen by 8.1 percent resulting in a real median household income of only £436 per week as of 2011/12. An independent Scotland want to set a Scottish minimum wage that at the very least will rise in line with inflation which if achievable will help to relieve the weight of poverty on 250,000 Scots who are currently

Great britian

1778 words - 7 pages "Good Luck"Great Britain is made up of three countries, England, Scotland and Wales. It is an island off the coast of north­west of Europe. Britain is part of the United Kingdom of Britain and Northern Ireland. The capital is London.ReliefThere are many different landscapes in Britain, from high mountains to rolling hill sand valleys. Places like Wales, the Lake District and northwest Scotland have high mountains and steep slopes made out of

Similar Essays

Should Britain Become Involved In Foreign Conflict?

886 words - 4 pages differing opinions and disagreements over religion, political viewpoints and social norms? It seems clear to me that alternative solutions to warfare must be found and so I firmly believe that Britain should not become involved in foreign conflict. First and foremost, Britain is simply not a major world power. Not only are we an island, and therefore by definition able to be attacked from literally any angle, but we are a small island, and there

Quebec Nationalism The Question Of Whether Quebec Will Secede From Canada To Become An Independent Nation Has Been A Hot Topic In The Country For Several Years Now

1646 words - 7 pages The question of whether Quebec will secede from Canada to become an independent nation has been a hot topic in the country for several years now. It dates back to the abortive rebellions of 1837-38. In 1980, a referendum to secede was rejected by a 60-40 margin. Since then though, the numbers of Quebeckers that want to become sovereign has significantly increased. There is so many questions of what will happen if this does happen. In this paper

The European Union From A British Perspective: What Is It And Should We [Britain] Deepen Our Intergration?

1156 words - 5 pages Of course there are the many arguments regarding European integration and the part that the UK should play in Europe. The deepening of European integration could result in some benefits for companies. It would allow many companies to expand into Europe more easily as they would have a pan-European perspective as opposed to a simply national one. This would be especially true if the Euro was introduced into Britain, it would make transferring

A Historic Referendum Essay

868 words - 4 pages What is a referendum? According to the Oxford Dictionary, a referendum is “a direct vote by the electorate of a country on a single political issue.”(Soanes, 2001) This is now the word used by the Government in Great Britain that describes the question, ‘Should Scotland be an independent country? Yes/No.’(The Scottish Government, 2013) This referendum was agreed to on the 15th of October in 2012 by SNP’s (Scottish National Party) leader, Alex