Should The Reader Forgive Humbert? Essay

2453 words - 10 pages

Should the Reader Forgive Humbert?

Lolita, by Vladamir Nabokov is a controversial book that elaborately represents and forces the reader to deal with a pedophiles obsession with his 12-year-old stepdaughter. As the reader finishes reading Lolita, he must establish a meaning for the novel which hinges heavily upon whether or not he should forgive Humbert for his rape of Lolita and for stealing her childhood away from her. This rape is legally referred to as a statutory rape because Humbert is having sex with Lolita who is under the age of consent. Humbert also figuratively rapes Lolita of her childhood and a normal teenage life. This decision to forgive Humbert will rely upon Humbert's words as he realizes what he has done to Lolita. In order for the reader to be able to forgive Humbert he must determine if Humbert is truly sorry for his actions.

One must overlook the fact that Vladimir Nabokov has written, Lolita has no moral in tow. (314). Nabokov has obviously anticipated the reader's response to his novel and so he discloses that he sees no moral value in the book. This is obviously a false statement that is used to complicate the book and make the reader think. Lolita is full of moral choices and situations that learned readers will recognize and make judgments on. Most readers have a conscience and thus look for the moral contained in the story. This argument thoughtfully represents Nabokov's Lolita with real world morals.

An ethical or moral reading of Lolita would lead the reader to the question of forgiveness of Humbert for his actions toward Lolita. To fully understand all that is involved in this question it is necessary to examine the word forgiveness. The word "forgiveness" has been used extensively throughout history to mean a pardon given to a wrongdoer for something he has done that has hurt another individual. In Lolita, Humbert is the wrongdoer and society is the judge of this crime. Though Lolita is a fictitious novel, let us presume for the sake of this argument that the novel can be represented by real world situations and morals.

In this world there are two kinds of forgiveness: forgiveness that comes from man, and divine forgiveness that comes from God. A definition from the Ungers Bible Dictionary gives this distinction: It (scriptural forgiveness) is not to be confused with human forgiveness which merely remits a penalty or charge. Divine forgiveness on the other hand, is one of the most complicated and costly undertakings, demanding complete satisfaction to meet the demands of Gods outraged holiness. (377). This definition gives a clear difference between how the world views forgiveness and how a Christian views forgiveness. This essay will primarily address forgiveness from a human perspective.

Another definition that will clarify the meaning of the word "forgiveness" comes from the Oxford English Dictionary. It describes forgiveness as the action of forgiving; pardon of a fault, remission of a debt, etc....

Find Another Essay On Should the Reader Forgive Humbert?

Power of Diction: Vladimir Nabokov Essay

1475 words - 6 pages tempted to sympathize with Humbert’s story. Another example takes place in their first "make out" scene; Humbert uses several forms of diction to influence the reader, two of which in particular stand out to this reader. The first is his poor speech patterns while talking to Lolita. Claiming his "word-control [was] gone" (Nabokov 120), Humbert childishly mixed up the first letter of pairs of words, allowing him to sound innocent and Lolita as the

Is Vladamir Nabokov's "Lolita" the most convincing love story of our time?

1435 words - 6 pages the connection Humbert feels with Lolita is his doomed childhood relationship with Annabel, whom he refers to once as his "dead bride" (Nabokov 39). He seems to be telling the reader that because he could not consummate their bond, he is fated to fall for Lolita. Humbert says "there may have been no Lolita at all had I not loved, one summer, a certain initial girl-child." (Nabokov 9). It's a mathematical equation: If Humbert's love for Annabel is

Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov

1522 words - 6 pages students may not have developed yet. Furthermore, parents may find the piece objectionable due to religious or cultural beliefs and does not want their child open to such crudeness. In accordance to these reasons, I don’t believe Lolita should be taught in regular High School classrooms, and should only be offered to AP students and as pleasure reading. Before forming an appropriate opinion on Lolita’s banning, basic knowledge of the text is

Use of Language the Sexual and Textual

1088 words - 5 pages jury, that the object of his devotion, love of his life, maliciously deceived him, then he succeeds in casting himself as the true victim in this situation, instead of the young girl he has manipulated. It’s up to the reader, as Humbert’s jury, to decide whether this devotion constitutes a genuinely selfless love and, if so, whether that excuses Humbert’s crimes. Humbert is just as guilty of artistically manipulating the situation. After all

Obsession in Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita

2471 words - 10 pages story. For instance, he constantly talks directly to the reader and tries to get him on his side: "Frigid gentlewomen of the jury!...I am going to tell you something very strange: it was she who seduced me" (132). In addition, Humbert controls the therapists: "I discovered there was an endless source of robust enjoyment in trifling with psychiatrists: cunningly leading them on; never letting them see that you know all the tricks of the trade

Humbert's obsession with Lolita, lust vs. love in "Lolita" by Nabakov

1035 words - 4 pages the sort in regard to Charlotte was unthinkable" (83) as a way of letting the reader understand his sense of fear, his lack of control, and his desperation to regain his feeling of control. In hopes of regaining his lost sense of control Humbert plots to kill Charlotte; with out her in his way Lolita would be his, and he would have full control over her. However, Humbert never went through with his scheme for the mere reason, "poets never kill

The Face of Evil

1599 words - 6 pages going on. Humbert tells his story as though nothing he did was wrong; as though killing Quilty and statutorily raping a minor were socially acceptable things to do. When reading this novel, the reader feels as though they have entered a microcosm where mainstream morals no longer exist. Author and critic James Tweedie said:Those inclined to skip prefatory remarks discover within three short paragraphs that the narrator's obsession is a diminutive

Dreaming with Lolita

1720 words - 7 pages power to enchant by her beauty all who behold her" (Jones 70). Just like Snow White does. Lolita is a person who possesses all of those qualities. She is beautiful, long limbed, and can charm anyone she wishes. Like Humbert puts it, "She was the loveliest nymphet....Priap himself could think up" (Jones 44). Lolita's depiction of this hot, seductive, gorgeous looking girl makes us, the reader, imagine how she would be in real life and what we

The Unreliable Narrator in Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita

2571 words - 10 pages the passionate admirer who is not in love, but "bewitched". Humbert can, and does, use this identity to justify his sexual urges toward Lolita. Recalling the restless hour spent wandering through the Enchanted Hunters hotel, waiting for Lolita to fall into a drugged, defenseless sleep, Humbert confesses that he was gravely mistaken in his assumption that Lolita was powerless and innocent:   I should have understood... that the

Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov

1502 words - 6 pages with it. Humbert’s genuineness contrasts with the overwhelming social criticism towards pedophilia. The contradistinction leaves the reader searching for Humbert’s moral resolve in the form of regret or a righteous conscience; however, the reader is only met with a vast ethical grey area as Humbert manipulates the reader’s understanding of the truth by embodying solipsism. Both Humbert and Nabokov challenge the early 20th century Freudian

Modernism and Postmodernism in Vladimir Nabokov's "Lolita"

650 words - 3 pages . Humbert is a typical modern character: sensitive, an artist.He tries to let the reader understand his mind, he is completely aware of his alienation with the world and he tries to separate and define the positive and the negative in him.The novel is an innovation, beginning with the theme, treating another kind of love, a hidden love and an outcast. Humbert is the outcast type in the view of the society."A common motif in modernism is that of an

Similar Essays

The Government Should Not Forgive Student Loan Debt

2196 words - 9 pages speeding up the frustratingly slow economic recovery? Opponents do not believe so for various reasons. First of all, many do not believe we should forgive student loan debt because most borrowers actually are able to afford paying off their debt. There are without question those who need relief, but how many are just pushing for this solution so they do not have to pay back a certain percentage of their income every month? The average debt total

Lolita Essay

4860 words - 19 pages topic of narrative unreliability. Initially this approach will spark anger because it will appear as if the reader should be sympathetic toward Humbert, and that idea is generally not a popular one. But by discussing the origins of Humbert’s addiction, one will be able to move smoothly beyond the socially constructed norms of right and wrong and into the concept of Lolita as a mythical representation rather than a reality. This mythical

Lolita Essay

3129 words - 13 pages pedophilia left to the side. Now that we’ve categorized Humbert as a pedophile without reasonable doubt, let’s move on to the reasons why this novel should and/or is a “Love Story.” My first example from the text that I thought I could use to relate this story to a “Love Story,” I happened to find within a critique article. Jennifer Green, author of Aesthetic Excuses and Moral Crimes: The Convergence of Morality and Aesthetics in Nabokov’s

Vladimir Nabokov's Lolita Essay

642 words - 3 pages with the wrong medium. He is convinced, and he obviously wants his reader to become so, that Lolita could be forever his, that his seduction would be a complete achievement. Recognizing that "Lolita will not forever be Lolita", Humbert uses film as a proleptic defense against losing her to those witnesses who would attempt to reformulate her. Since film works only as fantasy, however, Humbert risks losing control over the definition of his art