Should The Unthinkable Happen: Are You Prepared?

1384 words - 6 pages

Utilitarian Approach
As we continue to dissect the actions on the part of JPS, could we argue that perhaps the deontological approach was possibly not the best guide to use in deciding the actions to be taken under the given circumstances? We will present the possible outcomes using the Utilitarian theory to provide a contrasting viewpoint. The deontological approach relies on duty and law as a guide to determine moral rules and principles; the utilitarianism approach relies on benefit and overall good to determine if a decision is moral or ethical. We begin by identifying the stakeholders involved in the case. For the sake of focusing on the actual participants in the case we have identified the group as the family, the hospital, and the community. The community is not mentioned in the case, but it will be directly affected by the final judgment on the case. The possible benefits to each group are as follows:
1. The family’s wishes would have been honored and life support would have been withdrawn thus allowing them to begin their grieving process and ultimately moving past the ordeal.
2. Although uncertain at the time, sparing the family the prolonged pain and emotional distress in seeing their daughter in a brain dead state and on life support.
3. The hospital would benefit by avoiding the filing of legal action, the negative publicity, and media attention.
4. Avoid public criticism that questions JPS willingness to adhere to the law when it conflicts with the organizations value system.
5. Eliminate the burden of the incurred cost on the community. The cost of sustaining life support for the prolonged period is estimated at $310,000. Due to the fact that John Peter Smith hospital is a publicly funded, county owned hospital, the bill may be passed on to the citizens of Tarrant County.(Panifer, 2014)
Would using the utilitarian approach lead to a better outcome for everyone involved? Unfortunately the previously mention benefits are unpredictable and contain an element of uncertainty and would not guaranty avoidance of legal liability. In complying with the wishes of the family, John Peter Smith hospital could have definitely avoided the drawn out emotional distress on the family. The national attention around the case, even at its initial stages could have still created enough negative public reaction and enough controversy to pressure authorities to consider legal action. The Attorney General could pursue criminal prosecution if it deemed the actions taken by John Peter Smith hospital as unlawful. Regardless of the actions taken by John Peter Smith hospital the case had gained enough national attention which has focused on the series of events that followed despite the decision made by the hospital. Discontinuing of the life support at the time it was requested by the family would have significantly reduced the financial cost of care. The cost would have been marginal in comparison to the current estimated cost and possibly...

Find Another Essay On Should the Unthinkable Happen: Are you prepared?

Are You Prepared? Essay

943 words - 4 pages . I've used some of this stuff and it really does work. Whenever my wife and I travel now, I'll sweep the hotel room for hazardous items, move all electronics out of baby's reach, and close the bathroom door. These are only "some" of the ideas on baby-proofing the hotel room quickly. Some other ideas involved tape, lots and lots of tape. You should tape an "X" on the glass doors to show baby he can't climb straight through. I don't know about that

Creative Expression Cannot Happen When You Are Dead

2570 words - 10 pages News polls from 2005 shows that of the people who watch FOX News, 46% are in favor of legalizing physician assisted suicide for patients who are terminally ill, while only 39% are opposed (, 3). The poll also asks if people believe that states should be able to allow doctors to prescribe medications that would assist terminally ill patients to die (, 3). The results are 52% in favor and 37% opposed. In both cases more are in

Are you convinced by Plato's claim that philosophers should rule

1626 words - 7 pages The title of this paper was "Society originates because the individual is not self sufficient and no two of us are born exactly alike." How does Plato get from that claim to the view that philosophers should rule? Are you convinced by his claim that philosophers should rule."The two concepts stated above are the fundamental ideas that Plato establishes as a starting point to argue for what is in essence a totalitarian society that is ruled by

Drugs are bad for people and you should spread the word - Midddlsex Community College & English 096 - Essay

1035 words - 5 pages , methamphetamine, and many others. Peer pressure and loneliness or other factors may lead college students to the substance, although some students had previously abused alcohol or drugs in high school. This should be one of the main focuses in todays world because our children are the future and also play a big part in how the culture shapes. From what I am beginning to understand young American adults 18 to 25 years of age report the highest prevalence of

Lower the Legal Drinking age because If you are recognized as an adult at 18, then you should be granted all rights

1193 words - 5 pages Drinking Age Act. Along with setting the legal drinking age to 21, an extreme consequence if the state chose not abide was a reduction in federal highway funding by 10%. (APIS) Naturally the states were in a hurry to enact this legislation or suffer a financial hit to their highway budgets. In society today children are taught that alcohol is a drug, categorized with the likes of cocaine, crack, marijuana, and any amount of intake is considered

"The Second Amendment" i knoe there are some spelling that need to be fix so if you change those and look up a lil more it should work

737 words - 3 pages The Second Amendment" Our greatest strength lies in the fact that so many of our people not only posses weapons but also understand their use, and above all they are prepared to defend them selves against any sudden attack by an enemy, You will remember that we won are freedom because we were armed. We were not a simple peasantry unused to weapons. The men who wrote our constitution knew our people would be safe as long as they were armed

Using DNA as a starting point, do you believe there are limits to the knowledge people should acquire? Defend your answer

1215 words - 5 pages we do? For billions of people, there are no answers to these questions. They are beyond the limits of our knowledge.Because genetics is important to so many aspects of human behavior, defense attorneys might consider using a defendant's genetic constitution as a strategy to excuse criminal behavior. Take one of the two sides listed below:Present an argument about why a defendant's genes should be considered as a factor in the criminal

What should the government do about segregation in our public schools today? Does it matter to you, that students often attend public schools that are populated only by students of their own race?

665 words - 3 pages and should not be taken lightly. If we allow close-minded officials to segregate, we might as well pretend that the civil rights movement did not happen. So many people put their lives on the line to protect our future. Was Rosa Parks arrested so that in 2004 her great grandkids are still segregated? Was Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. shot because what he spoke about was lies? The answer to all of these is, no. By allowing segregation to continue, we are saying yes! We have come very far, yet it seems like we did not go anywhere at all.

"Do you think there are any authors or books not listed in the `Chicago Canon` that should definitely not have been omitted? Discuss" Socrates

562 words - 2 pages ”When I started thinking of which authors should I choose, few difficulties cropped up. After consideration, I decided to start from the very beginning and select the greatest philosopher of antiquity – Socrates, who is widely credited for laying the foundation for Western philosophy. Famous for his view of philosophy as a pursuit proper and necessary to all intelligent men, he is one of the great examples of a man who lived by his

Science Fiction Essay - "Planet of the Apes": There should scientific elements that are to be considered, use them in your essay if you can

944 words - 4 pages Science fiction text like the one studied "Planet of the Apes" has typical and common elements such as conventional characters, setting, themes and plots. These are explored in Planet of the Apes and in numerous different ways across a number of different texts which helps to classify science fiction genre.Conventional characters in Planet of the Apes would be that the good guys are not considered to be as powerful as the bad guys. The good

Love the way you are

792 words - 4 pages vehicles are the transportation this cow has become an issue of sanitation and legal problems. If a cow comes in front of your vehicle you are to immediately stop and wait till this cow moves and if it is harmed you are penalized. Hinduism wants peace to be in every corner of the country. This is not possible when a violation of the caste system arises. When you marry within caste systems a war breaks out in the families from both sides. This rage is

Similar Essays

Should The Unthinkable Happen: Are You Prepared?

1407 words - 6 pages MEDICAL FUTILITY JUDGMENTS. Health Matrix: Journal Of Law-Medicine, 18(2), 229-235.  Gold, R. B., & Nash, E., 2013, Abortion Rights Are Threatened. In T. L. Roleff (Ed.), Are Abortion Rights Threatened? Detroit: Green haven Press.  Gregorian Alexis, 2010, Post-Mortem Pregnancy: A proposed Methodology for the resolution of Conflicts over Whether a Brain Dead Pregnant Women Should Be Maintained on Life-Sustaining Treatment. Annals of health law. 19

Should The Unthinkable Happen: Are You Prepared?

1497 words - 6 pages behalf of a grantor under the FHCDA law are persons younger than 18 years of age (Tiernan, 2002, 43). For the grantor to designate an agent to make end-of life decisions for the grantor the following are required 1) the surrogate or agent should be a family member, 2) during the signing process - two witnesses must be present, 3) the advanced directive can be enacted upon as soon as the physician deems necessary and 4) the document must be notarized

Should The Unthinkable Happen: Are You Prepared?

1407 words - 6 pages underway (Hills, 2010, 34). If family members reject invasive ancillary tests, physicians must seek guidance from the hospital’s legal counsel and the ethics committee (Hills, 2010, 34). 3. Clinical assessment of brain stem reflexes. The following clinical indications and observations should only be complete if the possibility of recovery has been excluded (Hills, 2010, 34). The assessments are recommended for adults 18 years and older with a normal

Are You Prepared? Essay

1172 words - 5 pages Disasters are serious disruption of functioning society. It involves environmental resources, causing scarcity and mass destruction. Disaster can happen at any given time and place without warning. Being prepared is a key safeguard for people’s lives so that they’ll be able to take appropriate actions when facing imminent type of disaster. From the article “Mass casualty events Are you prepared?” by Janice S. Smith, she discussed disaster in