This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should Virtual Child Pornography Be Banned?

1024 words - 4 pages

In today’s society, people are debating if “virtual” child pornography should be banned. Most people believe that it should, while others believe that it should not be banned at all. Since the Supreme Court decided that “virtual” child pornography is legal, most people have felt that they have made a horrible mistake. By check many articles on this topic, I have decided to use two fairly good articles, written by two well-known editors, Wendy Kaminer, editor at The Atlantic Monthly, and Paul Rodriguez, editor of Insight on the News. Even though I agree that “virtual” child pornography should be banned, Kaminer presented a stronger argument that “virtual” child pornography should not be banned.
The article, “Virtual Child Pornography Should Not Be Banned,” by Wendy Kaminer, argues that “virtual” child pornography should not be banned because no child is harm. Kaminer serves on the national board of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU). Kaminer claims since no “real” child is being harm in the production, it should not be banned.
Kaminer start her argument by saying that it is possible that “virtual” child pornography may encourage pedophiles to act on their impulses or may help them in seducing children, but there is no evidence proving that these images have that want effects. She relied her sources on stating what the Child Pornography Prevention Act (CPPA)prohibited and what she believe they fail to realize and considered when making the Act of 1996. She also made points on how movies and ads are involved in “virtual” child pornography.
Kaminer argument was good, it was not that strong for me to think on it but she did point out good examples such as: how forty-year old mistake fifteen years old for young adults, which is true because in most cases young girls look older than they seem to be in life. Another good point is how films have scenes when young adults are having sex with children, which a lot of films have sex scenes with children having sex with adults or children their own age. While this could have been her strongest argument, she made it until a weak one, but she did support her reason by bringing up a case from Oklahoma, where they judged a film obscene.
Kaminer believes virtual-porn prohibitions are easy to abuse, since evidence of social, scientific, or artistic value is irrelevant to charge of child pornography. She states how Senator Jesse Helms includes sex education materials in his definition of child porn. Another source she uses is from the case in 1985, American Bookseller v. Hudnut, the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals struck down a local antiphon ordinance that was based on the assumption that pornography leaded to the objectification of women and contributes to sexual violence and discrimination. Kaminer argument was basic on little evidence and also little emotions. She basically stated problem the CPPA fail to realize. She did a good job at stating her claim but a poor job at showing strong evidence.

Find Another Essay On Should Virtual Child Pornography Be Banned?

Youth access to Internet Pornography; should it be banned? Title: Trash Folder is full

1450 words - 6 pages information sites and blocked 5 percent of the sites at the intermediate level. However, at the most restrictive level filters blocked 24 percent of these 'good' in ten sites containing pornography were still accessible" (Filters Bring Problems, 12). This study proves that no matter what settings filters are set at they are ineffective--either the child can't reach information that they should be able to or they view information they

Pornography Should be Regulated Essay

2343 words - 9 pages pornography could be justifiably proscribed. Moreover, as previously stated, these feminists believe that pornography is incapable of constituting real expression, and so perhaps should be banned outright. On the other hand, Nadine Gourgey argues that anti-pornography feminists such as Dworkin and MacKinnon rely on a logical fallacy to get their message across. Gourgey highlights that their assertions that pornography is not speech is

Should abortion be banned?

2237 words - 9 pages check-ups to ensure that the child is being taken care of properly, if not the child is then taken away from the parents and placed immediately into a better home. Abortions can also be quite expensive leading women to search for someplace that would do it for an adequate price or a low-cost price, this is another reason abortion should be banned. Knowing that there are women that wouldn’t mind the sanitary complications or the

Should uniform be banned?

571 words - 2 pages Argument For School UniformSchool uniform is an integral part of school life. School uniform should not be banned, because of finances. Our financial circumstances can have great affect, and more often than not, those with less money and therefore less desirable clothes are frequently subjected to various forms of prejudice and discrimination, exclusion and even ostracism, especially in schools.Wearing less expensive less fashionable clothes

Should steroids be banned?

825 words - 4 pages The third argument presented is that even if steroids are banned, they should not be banned from sports because there are a multitude of other risks already associated with sports, and steroids increase competition. Just last year, a media car ran Johnny Hoogerland off the road during the Tour de France, sending him headlong into barbed wire. Redskins quarterback Joe Theismann famously had his leg broken and career ended mid-game, and the

Abortion should be banned

695 words - 3 pages Abortion is killing a human, why is this okay but murder isn’t? An abortion is a procedure to end a pregnancy. It uses medicine or surgery to remove the embryo or fetus and placenta from the uterus. Abortion also hurts the mother emotionally and physically, it hurts her body and hurts her emotionally. The babies being killed deserve the right to live; they are innocent and haven't caused any harm. Abortion should be banned, because it's taking

Should Boxing Be Banned?

2165 words - 9 pages be a safe and fun sport as long as it is practiced and played properly. Boxing should not be banned because it can help relieve stress, and like running it is a good addition for getting in shape. It should also not be banned because boxers know the risks and they still choose to do it ; it is their choice not the community's. Another reason not to ban boxing would be because if boxing is banned it will be enforced by people who still like it

Deforestation should be banned

763 words - 3 pages Deforestation should be banned Deforestation is an issue all over the world. It harmfully affects everything in a way or other, including the ecosystem, human beings, and the animals that live in the forests. The outcomes of cutting down thousands of trees increases as human beings increase in their population, and the long-term results can be shocking as more and more species of animals become endangered. I have three reasons why deforestation

Smoking Should Be Banned

1012 words - 5 pages Agreement in 1998 the TV adds for cigarette companies were banned. Smoking is a detrimental practice, which even though is carried out by individuals of their own accord, affects the surroundings and thus should be banned. Ever since people started smoking researchers had been searching for its adverse effects to the human body. Fritz Lickint, in 1929 presented formal statistical evidence that cigarette smoking leads to lung cancer. This

Should MMA be banned?

1979 words - 8 pages themselves. MMA has a good reputation in general; however, there are a select few that would like to see MMA banned as they believe it is a form of "human cockfighting." MMA should not be banned because it provides four essential elements in life, which include discipline, physical fitness, self defense as well as boosting one's confidence.It is almost impossible to train in the field of Martial Arts without discipline. One needs discipline to continue


579 words - 2 pages ALCOHOL SHOULD BE BANNED Alcohol in the form of alcoholic beverages has been consumed by humans since pre-historic times, for a variety of hygienic, dietary, medicinal, religious, and recreational reasons. While infrequent consumption of alcohol in small quantities may be harmless or even beneficial, larger doses result in a state known as drunkenness or intoxication and, depending on the dose and regularity of use, can cause acute respiratory

Similar Essays

Child Labour Should Be Banned Essay

800 words - 3 pages wealthy country, but the fact is that there are many Third World countries out there where the economy and living conditions are so bad that children have to work in unsuitable and unsafe situations. There are certain charities that help, but that it is. Not enough is being done to stop child labour. It is very wrong and should be banned thought out the world and looked at as a disgrace.Figures from the International Labour Organisation (ILO) show

Why Child Beauty Pageants Should Be Banned

1831 words - 7 pages high prices in various aspects. Child beauty pageants should be banned not only because they sexualize girls and lead to mental problems but also they endanger toddler’s physical health. In the first place, since hypersexualization in pageants takes away the beauty of childhood,disrupts mental capacity and is linked to unhealthy sexuality, pageants should be banned. As Dr.Robyn Silverman says ‘’Pageants ask little

Should We Support Virtual Pornography? Essay

1707 words - 7 pages advanced a growing question began to be formed: should virtual pornography be constitutionally protected, under the argument that it is a form of personal expression and that it’s content has significant scientific, literary, artistic, or political value? Unlike actual child pornography, which has to include two innocent children partaking in sexual acts, virtual pornography consist of two computer generated children engaging in sexual acts. The

We Must Make Virtual Child Pornography Illegal

2782 words - 11 pages . Virtual child pornography also includes any images presenting people who appear to be minors or adult bodies superimposed with the faces of children, often making it difficult to tell if the material is of a real child or not. These new forms of child porn were becoming prevalent on the Internet at the time because it was easily accessible and not yet illegal. The act therefore prohibited the possession, transmission, or distribution of anything