Should We Believe Beyond Evide Essay

1692 words - 7 pages

This section provides us with two selections from the essays of William K. Clifford (1845-1879) and William James (1842-1910). Clifford's essay, The Ethics of Belief, is based on the concept of evidentialism. This concept "holds that we should not accept any statement as true unless we have good evidence to support its truth" (Voices of Wisdom, 346). James wrote his essay, The Will to Believe, as a response to Clifford's essay where he endorsed a philosophy called pragmatism.Pragmatism is described in the book as a method for settling philosophical disputes. It is based on the pragmatic theory of truth. This theory says that a "proposition p is true if and only if the belief that 'p is true' works" (Voices of Wisdom, 346). In order to get a better understanding of the pragmatic theory of truth, the theory is contrasted against two other theories, the correspondence theory of truth and the coherence theory of truth. James disagreed with these theories because "they present truth as a static property existing prior to and independent of human experience and investigation". James viewed truth as a constant movement of ideas, which guide human beings into more and more satisfying experiences every time.Clifford holds that you should not believe any proposition just because it will give you eternal happiness when in fact there is a lack of evidence which should lead you to doubt the proposition. James, on the other hand, gives us three conditions to believe beyond evidence. "First, when you are confronted with what he calls a 'genuine option' that cannot be decided on evidential grounds, you have a right to decide the issue according to your 'passional nature'. Second, when faced with a situation when belief in a fact is necessary for the existence of that fact, you have the right to believe beyond evidence. And finally, in a situation when belief in a true proposition is necessary for getting at the evidence in support of its truth, you are entitled to believe" (Voices of Wisdom, 347). In that last quote James tells us that we are entitled to use our feelings and/or our faith in order to resolve a matter.First we take a look at an extract of William K. Clifford's essay where he presents us a few situations in order to clarify his point. He starts by telling us a story of a ship-owner that was providing transportation for a group of emigrants. He knew the ship was old, worn out, and didn't have the best craftsmanship. To get rid of his worries he did a complete overhaul to the boat and sent her of to sea. The boat sank and he collected the insurance money without ever telling anyone about his suspicions of the boat not being in the best of shapes. He thought he had gotten rid of any doubts by overhauling the vessel. "He had acquired his belief not by honestly earning it in patient investigation, but by stifling his doubts" (Voices of Wisdom, 348). On the last quote, what Clifford means by "his (the shipowner) belief" is his thoughts of his ship being...

Find Another Essay On Should we believe beyond evide

Divorce Essay

616 words - 2 pages Rating: 3 Where I agree with you that marriage is a commitment/choice that should be embarked upon with much thought, dedication, and loyalty I do however think there are several reasons beyond physical abuse and adultery for people to rightfully file for divorce. I also think it is wrong to assume all marriage therapists and counselors are concerned with “fixing” couples who are not getting along or arguing. I think marriage counseling has

A Socratic Worldview Essay

1567 words - 6 pages to be. Although there are some distinct differences in what I believe to be the ultimate meaning behind life, which I will later address, I believe his thoughts on how one should live their life to be the wisest of any philosopher we have studied. First, let me relate what I understand Socrates philosophy to be. Socrates believed that we all have a soul. He believed that we are to live our life by principles, and that these principles should be

Solving the Foreclosure Crisis

1098 words - 4 pages believe this is an identity crisis and a problem of people not being comfortable with who they are and their financial worth. There must be a line drawn between our financial means and our inner struggles to “fit in“with what we believe society should be like. There are several people and organizations out there that are more than willing to help people adjust to the new lifestyles that will need to be pursued in order to restore stability. The

Freedom of Choice

617 words - 2 pages today is free to feel emotions, such as love, hate, joy, sadness, pleasure and pain all within themselves.Also, freedom of speech, or the freedom to vocally express ourselves in most cases should be a right and not a privilege. As long as we are not forcing our views onto others we should each have the right to stand up for what we believe in.Thirdly, Today in Australia we should not conform to the choices made by any one group. For example, some

How I Would Undertake a Good Existence!

966 words - 4 pages person whose morals and standers are beyond the average, a person who gets the meaning of life and who is in peace with himself. Furthermore, the spiritual life plays a vital role for developing this side of our personality. When we believe in a power beyond our strength, recklessly and intensely, we fill in one side of our brain which was full of qualms and reluctance. For instance, religious people believe that life is sort of a test where

Blaise Pascal's essay "The Wager" and three well-known objections to it

1077 words - 4 pages we are supposed to believe in. Once we get past the point of actually believing in God, be it at all possible, there is the dilemma of choosing which God to believe in. Pascal makes the assumption that the all-powerful God of the universe is the Christian God. Fundamentalist Christians would say that according to the Bible one should accept Jesus Christ as their lord and savior. If you applied Pascal's Wager to Islam Fundamentalist Muslims would

Accounts of Miracles and Their Support of Belief in God

841 words - 3 pages than that of established laws; he suggests we should always look at things in a naturalistic way and should favour the naturalistic explanations as opposed to supernatural explanations. Hume believes that a wise person will always look at the available evidence then proportion their belief according to this, so therefore accepting a miracle would be ridiculous due to the amount of sufficient evidence compared to the

Is it Rational to Believe in God?

1208 words - 5 pages -powerful evil should not exist. However, as we all know it does. He doesn’t state that just because god is all of these things evil shouldn’t exist, though. He does believe small amounts of pain and suffering builds character and can do some good, but with the vast amounts of pain and suffering going on, on a large scale that there must be no god. Another argument is the argument from change, which states that Everything in motion is moved by

The Power Of The Internet

862 words - 3 pages souls, murder, terrorist attacks; as a result of bomb making, involvement in drugs, and many more. I do strongly believe that we should be safe in all environments we experience, even in technological places such as the net. 3) Whilst I believe that some inappropriate information should not be shown on the net, I do not believe this should prevent us to get vital and correct information needed to make decisions, such as

How Can I Be Happy?: The Different School of Thoughts of Stoicism and Epicureanism

1146 words - 5 pages hunger. When we go above and beyond the removal of pain, the level of pleasure is not increased; it is only varied (Sharples 85). When we pursue desires that relieve the body and mind from pain, the Epicureans conclude that we are happy. Stoicism prevails in the pursuit of happiness because it is guided by our natural reason and desire to attain wisdom. If we do not secede to our natural inclinations toward virtue, how could we ever be happy

The Power of You

736 words - 3 pages said. Motivation is the difference between someone who wants to be successful and someone who goes through the motions. With no desire or passion to become greater, there is no reason to think of other critical skills to become successful as there should be a purpose behind achieving success. Once a purpose or motivation for success in college and beyond is established, it takes a great amount of responsibility to stay on the best path toward

Similar Essays

Should We Believe In Conspiracy Theories?

883 words - 4 pages There are a great number of conspiracy theories in the world and their popularity is higher than ever. For example, there are many conspiracy theories around the bombings of the world trade center; one of these theories proposes that the world trade center bombings were executed so that the United States could invade the Middle East. An important question that arises, when considering conspiracy theories, is should we believe them? Brain Keeley

The Chicago Black Sox Essay

2350 words - 9 pages and told him to rest for the upcoming pennant. Cicotte requested $10,000 for e fix so he could have the money that was promised to him(Black Sox). Gandil then went after Charles " Swede" Risberg, and while talking to him Fred McMullen approached them and wanted in on the fix. "Chick" wanted another pitcher, and so he went to aude "Lefty" Williams. "Lefty" did not believe the Series could actually be fixed, and wanted some

Thomas Nagel Essay

662 words - 3 pages responsibility. Although Thomas Nagel’s argument was well structured, I found it to be inconsistent. A second objection is that most things happen for a reason and I believe that people do have control over most things in your life. For example, if one eat’s unhealthy food then that leads to numerous health problems and issues. Resulting from the choice the individual took to eat unhealthy cause them to have a fatal heart attack, therefore I believe that final results are controlled by the agent. For these two reasons we should be hesitant to accept Nagel’s views.

If The Sceptic Is Right, The I Do Not Know I Have Hands. I Know I Have Hands Therefore, The Sceptic Is Wrong

993 words - 4 pages argument is subtle here in that, he is trying to show that it is less questionable to believe that we have hands, than it is to believe that we don't, and therefore we should accept the former over the latter. The idea, I think, is that not only does moore think it is a better explanation, it also does not bring in superfluous information that no one can demonstrate, and the fact that he can demonstrate his argument at any time, means that it