Should We Include Merit Pay As A Part Of Educational Reform?

1560 words - 7 pages

Should we include merit pay as a part of educational reform?
These days, merit pay for teachers becomes a very arguable topic. Merit pay, also known as pay by performance, is a payment schedule for teachers that design to motivate teachers and improve our education. However, although more and more schools and states begin to try this new payment schedule, only a few of them get some significant results. Because of that, more and more people begin to doubt the effectiveness of merit pay. Should merit pay become a part of our educational reform become a serious problem for everyone to think about. In my opinion, I think we shouldn’t include the merit pay that only uses standard tests to evaluate teachers, provides too little or too much bonus, and requires teachers to finish impossible missions in order to get this money in our educational reform.
The most important problem of todays’ merit pay is that most schools only use standard tests score to evaluate teachers. As Al Ramirez points out, “[tests] are typically designed to measure student learning—not instruction or teacher effectiveness,[...]” and “factors beyond teachers’ control”(56). For example, teachers cannot decide who is signed in the class, they cannot decide if the students would finish assignments, and they cannot decide if the students study hard. Standard tests is a really uncertain way to evaluate teachers, and if we only focus on the scores that students get to evaluate teachers, then that will incite teachers to manipulate, to cheat, and it has already happened -“[what] behind the rise of the 55,000-student Atlanta public school system in national prominence during the 2000s were teachers and principals in 44 schools erasing and changing test”(Jonsson 2). This is so disappointed because teachers who should be the models of our kids are cheating about students’ score in order to get more bonus. I am sure it is not the kind of educational reform that most people want. Even worse than that, in order to increase the performance of students in the standard tests, some schools in Texas seek for “bad students” who cannot pass the standard tests and “make those students ‘disappear’ so they would not be counted among the students who were tested”(Llorca). Mostly likely, principals and teachers will incite students that cannot pass the standard tests to drop out from high school, which will probably destroy the whole life of those high students. Based on those facts, the merit pay that uses the score of standard tests to evaluate teachers definitely cannot be a part of our educational reform because instead of any positive impact, it will cause a lot negative results.
Second problem of our ineffective merit pay is the amount of bonus for individuals because both too little amount of bonus and too much amount of bonus will cause some problems. If we only provide a little bit bonus for teachers, then they probably just do whatever they used to do because “the performance pay for...

Find Another Essay On Should We Include Merit Pay as a Part of Educational Reform?

Essay on Educational Reform Going into our twenty-first century, we

1587 words - 6 pages Essay on Educational Reform Going into our twenty-first century, we are finding more and more students graduating from high school not prepared to do college-level work or achieve sufficiently in entry-level jobs. The public business community is beginning to doubt whether or not public schools are capable of producing individuals who can become productive members of society. They ask the school systems how it is so many students can graduate

Should morality be included as an essential part of law? At what point to do we draw the line between what is legally morally acceptable and what is not?

724 words - 3 pages Should morality be included as an essential part of law? At what point to do we draw the line between what is legally morally acceptable and what is not? The moral views of a society should be incorporated into the laws of society to a degree that represents the best interest of the people. It is far fetched to say that we should remove entirely moral views from our legal system, while on the other side of the spectrum it wouldn't seem right to

Happily ever after as long as we are a part

923 words - 4 pages Why am I not able I find the perfect relationship? This is the question on many singles' minds. Relationships to some people come very easy. Now for the rest of us that do not fit into that category dating is like a big rulebook of do's and don'ts. This never ending list can be very overwhelming, but if a person will examine the top three scenarios on why relationships go wrong then the mistakes should become clear as crystal. Whether it is

Why should i deserve a Merit scholarsip

746 words - 3 pages by my self. Throughout high school, in many group projects students don’t finish their part, and therefore every gets a bad mark. In such situations I would finish the work that is not done so that no one would get a bar mark. This shows initiative because I am stepping in to do the work that is not done by another person. Therefore, as I show posses the skill of initiative, I believe I should earn the merit scholarship. To sum up, as I am a dedicated, responsible person and take initiative, I believe that I am a eligible and a reasonable student to earn the merit scholarship.

Storytelling: A Part of Who We Are

1171 words - 5 pages interesting. As Andrew Stanton declared, “Storytelling is joke telling. Its knowing your punchline-your ending. Knowing that everything you’re saying from your first sentence to your last is leading to a singular goal and ideally conforming some truth that deepens our understanding of who we are as human beings. In simpler terms, a great story always has a strong running theme throughout it. Andrew Stanton goes on to say that,”Change is

Should Manganese Nodules Be Exploited As A Source Of Metal? Should We Continue Exploiting Manganese Nodules As A Source Of Metal, Taking Into Consideration All The Moral Aspects

1797 words - 8 pages the International Seabed Authority in Jamaica, any technological advances in sea mining is shared, thus providing countries such as Gabon, South Africa and India an opportunity to extract their vast undersea resources without the risk of technological failures.In general, I believe that the manganese nodules should be exploited as a source of metal. Unimaginable technologies and knowledge await us, and I believe that undersea mining will lead to a huge industrial development wherever manganese nodules are in possession, regardless of the country's economical status.

Dickens' Hard Times as a Critique of the Educational System

2270 words - 9 pages Dickens' Hard Times as a Critique of the Educational System            Industrialization made Victorian England a brave new world.  A world bereft of justice, humanity and emotion.  In Hard Times, Dickens critiques this world in several ways; it's pollution problems, factory accidents, divorce laws, utilitarian ideals, and educational system.  The goal of this essay is to focus strictly on Dickens critique of the educational system which

An Examination of Teach for America as a Reform Model

2312 words - 10 pages Two Years of Magical Thinking An Examination of Teach for America as a Reform Model EDUC 532 Antoinette Davis March 28, 2014 In the 1980s, Wendy Kopp wrote a thesis detailing a reform that could be replicated in public schools across America. Modeling her idea after the Peace Corps, she named it Teach for America. This reform effort is a top down approach, focusing on teacher training and teacher

The Stereotypes and Fight to Keep To Kill a Mockingbird a Part of Educational Learning

822 words - 4 pages We should keep to kill a mocking bird. It is a marvellous award winning book, although it is very racist and brings back memories of dark times. It is recommended for all senior and junior high schoolers to read. No cases of black people going to court in the years the book was writeen for reasons written and demanded to be kept out of school libraries. There are many lies about the character's and it is all just a made up story with an

Reform as a Sympothy Strategy

1855 words - 7 pages Sympathy as a Reform Strategy By writing personal accounts of their lives, many women of the nineteenth century used the emotion of sympathy to share their feelings. According to Rosemarie Garland Thompson, "Sympathy is an effective rhetorical strategy in women's writing because it combines and embodies the fundamental elements of the feminine script." (Thompson 131) By using sympathy in their writing, Harriet Jacobs and Elizabeth Barret

Race to the Top: A Nationwide Educational Reform Movement

1414 words - 6 pages . Instead, the most effective teacher should be dispersed among the lower income schools so that every student has equality of education. As a result, educational opportunity is then available to every student in America as the best teachers are spread out across schools of every rank. In the history of education, has reform demanded a redistribution of teachers as it does in Race to the Top? While earlier initiatives have attempted this

Similar Essays

We Must Reform America's Educational System

1671 words - 7 pages . Moreover, we should remember forgotten standards that still are part of our systems in theory, the concept of in loco parentis, that places the teacher and school system into a position were they are seen as a helpful substitute for the absent parent, which becomes even more important in our busy lives today. Parents need to realize that raising children takes time and work beyond just cooking and cleaning for them. Caregivers need to re

Discuss The Extent To Which International Assistance Can And Should Be Effectively Used To Achieve Security Sector Reform As Part Of Post Conflict Peace Building

3491 words - 14 pages this tradition with security sector assistance being dominated by the United States of America (USA) and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR). The unexpected failure to realize the much anticipated peace dividend in the post-Cold War era has led, not only to the broader redefinition of security, but also to the emergence of initiatives, such as security sector reform (SSR), designed to create a benign security apparatus. This was

Education Reform Deals With Raising Teacher Pay To Increase Educational Standards, Therefore Improving Education By Improving Quality Teaching

1210 words - 5 pages One of the top priorities on every U.S. president's agenda is education reform. This is the result of a continuing decrease in the quality of education in America. When compared to the rest of the world, the United States simply does not measure up to the educational standards of other countries. The comparison statistics may be inaccurate due to the methods in which other countries test. However, the endless resources that the U.S. has access

To Pay Or Not To Pay, That Is The Question Explaining If We Should Or Not Pay For Peoples Organs "Lets Pay For Organs" Time Article

722 words - 3 pages might donate, it kills the whole objective of the program: everyone can get an organ. Sure, the patients might have to pay hospital bills, but that's about it. None of this paying someone 50K just to get an organ. As soon as we start that, organs will be out of reach for the lower class quicker than they can get them out of their bodies!Therefore, I think that there should be a line drawn. And it should be drawn right where it was stated in the