This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should Welfare Recipients Be Drug Tested?

830 words - 4 pages

There is an ongoing debate over whether or not Welfare recipients should be drug tested to receive the benefits. The lines of reasoning from both sides of this argument have unambiguous points. Those who oppose the idea of drug testing say that it is unconstitutional, and violates the Fourth Amendment. Furthermore, they claim that this law stereotypes and discriminates against the poor , implying that because they are poor, they must be drug addicts. However, individuals that support the law, express that the plan being put in effect is to ensure that tax payer’s money isn’t being thrown away on people who only plan to abuse this assistance. Out of the fifty states, only nine have ...view middle of the document...

While some of the states’ test recipients based on suspicion of drug use, others choose to test all applicants.
Those who are against the drug testing of recipients claim that this law is in violation of the Fourth Amendment which states: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
To keep this movement in place, advocates of this law have proposed that the applicants for Welfare should pay for the drug testing themselves, and in the event the test is negative, the recipients will be fully reimbursed. The cost for drug testing ranges from $30 to $40 per person. They propose, likewise, that making the applicants pay for their testing will deter drug abusers from applying (Martin, 2012). To further keep the costs down, those in favor of the drug testing law believe that selecting only persons with “reasonable cause” to be tested can help keep government spending to a minimum (Martin, 2012).
Disputers of the law say that that drug testing is unlawful, and defies the Fourth Amendment which “states that searches and seizures are unlawful without probable cause” (Shaberg, 2012, p. 567). Furthermore, Florida’s federal trial judge recently halted its drug testing of Welfare recipients, ruling that it unconstitutionally mandated searches without suspicion (Martin, 2012). The recipients feel as if this is blatant...

Find Another Essay On Should Welfare Recipients Be Drug Tested?

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Essay

1112 words - 4 pages abused substance among welfare recipients (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2011). Cost effective? There are different types of testing that can be done, and they range in accuracy and cost. There are urinalysis tests, which range from $25 to $44 each as well as hair follicle test which cost from $75 to $150 per test. This does not include the additional staff, time, laboratory fees, and facilities to handle the procedures, not to

Drug Testing For Welfare Recipients Essay

761 words - 4 pages change. Works Cited "Preface to 'What Are Some Alternatives and Improvements to the Welfare System?'." Welfare. Ed. Margaret Haerens. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2012. Opposing Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 6 Feb. 2014. Vitter, David. "Should Welfare Recipients Be Tested For Drugs?." U.S. News Digital Weekly 3.46 (2011): 14. Business Source Premier. Web. 4 Feb. 2014. "Welfare Programs Should Include Mandatory Drug Testing." Welfare. Ed. Margaret Haerens. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2012. Opposing Viewpoints. Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Web. 6 Feb. 2014.

Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients

955 words - 4 pages this will not be a feasible solution to the perceived problem. Although many states are implementing programs for drug testing for welfare recipients, it is not a feasible idea for the immediate future because of the problems with achieving an accurate report on drug use with welfare recipients, issues with the drug testing system itself, the fact that there are bigger concerns regarding welfare dependency than drug abuse, and the evidence shown by

Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients

795 words - 4 pages have received government assistance in the past and knowing their background with drug use, I believe it would be good if the regulations were stricter about testing for drug use and taking corrective action. Drug testing should be required for welfare recipients to ensure help is being provided to those who truly need it, to be sure that tax dollars aren’t going to irresponsible drug users, and because the working class already has to, so they

Drug Testing on Welfare Recipients: Necessary or Costly?

2309 words - 10 pages A major issue in society today is welfare and its effect on everyday life for the country as a whole. There has always been a disagreement about whether tax money should be going to assist the needy and if social programs that bring government assistance are the best way that the tax money can be used. The taxpayers of America are concerned that welfare recipients are abusing the system and taking benefits where they aren’t needed or using the

Welfare Drug Testing in the U.S.-Should it be Required?

2135 words - 9 pages not individuals receiving welfare should be drug tested in order to receive benefits from welfare assistance programs. In 2014, this particular issue has taken more precedence over many other issues that are plaguing the United States. Many feel that drug testing recipients is unconstitutional while others feel that it is not any different than getting a job. As the state’s proposed legislation has shown, the majority of citizens feel they are

Welfare Drug Testing in the United States-Should it be Required?

2270 words - 9 pages not individuals receiving welfare should be drug tested in order to receive benefits from welfare assistance programs. In 2014, this particular issue has taken more precedence over many other issues that are disturbing the United States. Many feel that the drug testing of applicants is unconstitutional while others feel that it is not any different than getting a job. As the state’s proposed legislation has shown, the majority of citizens feel

Should people on welfare have to have drug testing?

1389 words - 6 pages Should people on welfare have to have drug testing?When accepting a job many employers require one to consent to and pass a drug test before being hired. If that individual rejects to consent or fails the drug test they are not hired for the position. Why should drug testing among welfare recipients be any different? Recipients of welfare do not currently have drug testing regulations on a federal level and that has a lot of people very upset

Students Shouldn't be Drug Tested

1087 words - 4 pages testing is that it is very expensive and that the results may come back as a false positive or a false negative. A comment is that all school faculty should be drug tested. There are many good and bad sides. I will show you some of both. In this essay, the topic that will be discussed is that students shouldn’t be drug tested. A “pro” to students being drug tested is that it might help students get away from drugs. “The benefits to drug

Welfare Should Be Temporary

875 words - 4 pages need to work together. This will help to eliminate the need for welfare fraud, and help the mother get to a position where assistance is no longer needed. Helping educate welfare recipients should be the biggest issue in welfare reform because it leads people to a better future and gets them off welfare. Jensen recalls, "My life on welfare was very hard--there were times when I didn't have enough food for the three of us. But I was able to get

Why Marijuana Should Be Tested for Medicinal Purposes

1391 words - 6 pages Many opposers believe various legal drugs make medicinal marijuana use unnecessary, but varied strains of marijuana should be tested for medicinal purposes because there are many patients who have medical issues without known treatments that could have relief from medicinal marijuana, it could be used as a natural alternative to chemically enhanced or harmful treatments, and it could lead to the discovery of uses of marijuana for reasons outside

Similar Essays

Should Welfare Recipients Be Drug Tested?

1286 words - 5 pages There is an ongoing debate over whether or not welfare recipients should be drug tested to receive the benefits. Both sides of the argument have merit. Those who oppose the idea of drug testing say that it is unconstitutional and violates the Fourth Amendment. Furthermore, they claim that this law stereotypes and discriminates against those from low socioeconomic demographics, implying that because they are poor, they must be drug addicts

Americans On Welfare Should Be Drug Tested

902 words - 4 pages used to help them to survive everyday but instead they are using it to get their fix on drugs. I think that we should drug test any american twice a month who chooses to receive welfare so we know they are not taking drugs. This will eliminate any problems with people using welfare money for things other than their necessities. The main reason why i think Americans that receive welfare should be drug tested is because taxpayers who have to work

Should People On Welfare Be Drug Tested?

826 words - 4 pages ground on the extension of unemployment benefits, drug testing the recipients of those benefits promises to be a topic ripe for compromise. So as it stands right now, Should Welfare recipients be drug tested? Works Cited www.debate.org www. usnews.com www.Huffingtonpost.com www.minnpost.com www.aclu.org www.ncsl.org

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Essay

1375 words - 6 pages a right without responsibilities…” (Anderson, 1997, p.83). With this quote, Anderson draws attention to the effects of excessive welfare assistance. There is an unsaid fairness that goes in concurrence with establishing a suspicion-based drug test for welfare recipients. If working American’s are required to be part of randomized or suspicion-based drug test at work, then welfare recipients should also be required participate in suspicion-based