Should Wild Animals Be Kept In Captivity?

1143 words - 5 pages

On February 24, 2010, Trainer Dawn Brancheau was killed by a captive killer whale which dragged her into its tank (McCarthy). This is not the only case where a trainer of ordinary person has been put in harm’s way because what is supposed to be a wild animal is being held in captivity. Wild animals should not be kept in captivity because it can lead to mental illness and abnormal behavior.
Capturing wild animals for entertainment is not a new practice; it has been going on for years. In fact, “136 killer whales were captured in the wild and held in captivity since the first on in 1961” (McCarthy). This number, 136, only represents killer whales; there are plenty of other species being captured. To imagine the magnitude of captured animals just multiply 136 by 6,000, the number of species currently in captivity. Additionally, since the 1970s, twenty-four people have been attacked by a whale in captivity (McCarthy). Therefore, not only is there a history of animal captivity, but since 1961 when the first whale was captured, there has also been a history of whale attacks. Similarly, “in 25 year period at the Houston Zoo, 14 out of 14 elephant calves have died [due to artificial breeding]” (O’Connor). For twenty-five years, the zoo has continually put the elephants through a treatment that has only failed; therefore, putting the animal at risk. However, amidst the amplifying number of whale attacks, the “justification of aquariums has grown weaker and weaker” (“The Great Whale”). Aquariums are being held more accountable for their actions, so that we can prevent tragedies. The captivity debate has been going on for a long time and it is time to start making changes to try and prevent abnormal behavior and mental illness in animals.
Likewise, zoos and aquariums are appealing on the surface, but behind closed doors animals are treated as property instead of living beings leading to abnormal behavior. In a Danish Zoo a young giraffe was killed along with being “publicly butchered and fed to a lion” (“Zoos Should Save Not Kill”). The giraffe is being treated as food that has been purchased for the lion instead of being treated as an animal that needs protection. Alternatively, zoo’s claim that they only kill their animals because of the animal’s poor health, but “only a fraction of 1% killings [in zoos] are for [poor health] reasons” (Rising). However, what if the whale isn’t being killed intentionally by its caretakers, what if it dies because its environment in the aquarium is unsafe. For example, there was a young whale that died because of items being thrown into pods lodged in her blow whole; her captors did not deliberately kill her but the placement of her tank and probably the tank itself put her in danger. On a slightly similar hand, mother whales are torn apart from their children which can send the young moms into extreme sadness (“The Great Whale”). The environment zoos provide for the animals can put them under extreme distress as shown...

Find Another Essay On Should Wild Animals Be Kept In Captivity?

Should animals be used in research

2056 words - 8 pages Should animals be PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 8 Running head: SHOULD ANIMALS BE USED IN RESEARCH?Should animals be used in research?There have been many different kinds of cruel animal testing performed over the years. The most unnecessary types of animal testing are using animals for testing cosmetics and different products. Although it is very possible to produce cosmetics without testing on animals, some companies continue to do so. Animal rights

Issues for Having Animals in Captivity

1338 words - 5 pages At the San Francisco zoo in California a young girl was killed by a tiger who had escaped his low-quality enclosure; the tiger was shot dead on the spot. If wild animals were kept in the wild, deaths and injuries of people from zoo animals would never happen. Animals are taken out of their natural habitats to live unhappy lives in zoos. As a result of having animals in captivity, animals suffer from health problems, insufficient

Being Careful about Putting Animals in Captivity

1022 words - 4 pages horse property. At my grandma’s we have three Arabian horses. The thing is that they are wild animals, and need to do what they do best, RUN. We have three acres of pasture they can run around and play and be horses. Now let me tell you, they love their treats. Animals love to learn. I see it in our horses every day. They are happy. They get kept clean, fed, ridden, and get treats. Wild horses live on hundred of thousands of acres. If you take

Dolphins in Captivity vs. Dolphins in the Wild

2139 words - 9 pages echolocation for navigating the vast expanses of the ocean. Dolphins in captivity perform all of these same activities, although their echolocation can not be used to its full potential in a tank or aquarium, as it is in the ocean. There are basically no obstacles, plants or objects to dodge in a captive setting. Next, the nature of a dolphin in the wild is playful, adventurous, and entertaining. This part of their nature bears no change in

Should animals be used for research in cosmetic industry?

615 words - 3 pages Should animals be used for research in cosmetic industry? Animal testing is widely used to develop new medicines and to test the safety of other products. These experiments can cause pain to the animals involved or reduce their quality of life in other ways. Animal experimenters are aware of this problem and agree that the testing should be made as humane as possible. While this practice has been followed for years now, some people still

Why animals should be used in biomedical research.

559 words - 2 pages systems. They can be easily compared to one another making it easy to practice crucial procedures and create vaccines on animals before it is practiced on human patients. Animals and humans are also both susceptible to the same diseases; the animal's shorter lifespan allows the researchers to study the animal throughout their entire lives.Most Americans today can live in good health for at least seventy years. Back in 1900 the average life

Performing Animals: The Ill Treatment of Performing Orca’s in Captivity

2070 words - 8 pages that their behaviors all indicate that something is not right with them, yet those who can do something to rectify the Orcas grievances choose not to. Tilikum, the Orca that claimed 6 lives, is still performing till this day. Orcas should not be kept in captivity for no other purpose than to be nursed back to health if they are found in distress in the wild and released soon after like many wildlife animals have had happened. They should not be

Abortion Should Be Kept Out of The Criminal Code

1340 words - 5 pages Abortion Should Be Kept Out of The Criminal CodeAbortion, termination of pregnancy before the fetus is capable ofindependent life. When the expulsion from the womb occurs after the fetusbecomes viable (capable of independent life), usually at the end of six monthsof pregnancy, it is technically a premature birth.The practice of abortion was widespread in ancient times as a method ofbirth control. Later it was restricted or forbidden by most

Abortion should be kept out of the Criminal Code

1346 words - 5 pages health was threatened by her pregnancy. Thebill died in the Senate in Jan 1991. 5In the case of Campbell v. Attorney-General of Ontario (1987) the allegations inthe statement of claim that the effect of the stay was to deny s.7 and s,15 rights to unbornchildren aborted or about to be aborted support a reasonable cause of action. The lawdoes not regard unborn children as independent legal entities prior to birth, so that it isonly at birth that

Profiting on Conservation: Animals in Captivity Abused for Human Entertainment

1179 words - 5 pages metal cage. Although marine animals who have been taken out of their natural environment can not return to the wild without extensive rehabilitation, the federal government should restrict the removal of wild animal from hereon out. All animal themed circuses should be banned and be replaced with ones with only human acts. All weapons known in the training of animals should be considered illegal. The government is the key component in the

Should Animals Be Used For Medical Research?

1441 words - 6 pages fight infections inside the body. Also asthma inhalers, smallpox has been eradicated completely, vaccines against polio, meningitis, TB, the human papillomavirus (HPV) linked to cervical cancer. Many people do not agree with the use of animals in research, some of them affirm that animals should not be used in drug development medical research because they are God’s creatures and should not be killed to save our lives. ( debate.org) But, in the

Similar Essays

Should Animals Be Kept In Captivity

2110 words - 8 pages Animals should not be kept in captivity for any reason unless they have been harmed and need to receive treatment but they should be released as soon as they are healthy and capable of taking care of themselves again. The use of a captive animal for research, education, or entertainment is just wrong no creature deserves to have their life taken away for our benefit. Would you want to be captured and put in a tiny box or a fake little ecosystem

Killer Whales Should Not Be Kept In Captivity

2647 words - 11 pages to have a bent dorsal fin as the tank does not allow them the space to grow correctly. The teeth of orcas are worn down, and if they were to be released in the wild, it would be difficult for them to hunt. Also whales do not get the proper nourishment they need because they only get fed after doing tricks. When they are in the wild they eat as they please. These are only a few physical affects captivity has on the whales. There are also

Animals In Captivity. Essay

532 words - 2 pages There is much conjecture over whether captivity is good or bad for wild animals. Many people consider it will bring negative impacts for wild animal to live in captivity. Others believe wild animals should be taken captive for both environmental and physical. I faced this controversial essay topic and fell into much contemplation.It's undeniable that most animal zoos or such organizations really have relevant knowledge, offer suitable

Fine Arts Programs Should Be Kept In Schools

1147 words - 5 pages cases the one class that helps them get through the day, and many teachers that truly care fir the students would lose their dream jobs. Fine arts should not be cut from schools; they build confidence, help with the application of other academic concepts, and even help to prepare students for their future work in the business world. Performing or public speaking of any kind is difficult, but that difficulty can help to build confidence. Fine