Significance Of Section 3 And 4 Of The Human Rights Act 1998

1738 words - 7 pages

The power to strike down Acts of Parliament is defined as the power to declare legislation invalid because it is unconstitutional. This paper will critically assess sections 3 and 4 of the HRA 1998 by defining them, reviewing case law surrounding their use, and by evaluating the powers that they give to the judiciary. By doing so, it will demonstrate that section 3 gives judges powers that are not significantly different from the power to strike down Acts of Parliament, whereas section 4 does not.
Definitions
Section 3 of the Human Rights Act (HRA) 1998 provides that primary and subordinate legislation “must be read and given effect in a way which is compatible with Convention rights”. This provides judges the power to interpret and amend legislation so far as it is possible so that it is in accordance with Convention rights. There is no need for ambiguity in wording of the act to use section 3 and it does not affect the validity of the Act notwithstanding the Act being incompatible with Convention rights. There are limits on judges’ ability to use section 3 which restrict cases in which it can be used. First, section 3 cannot go against the grain of the fundamental purpose of the legislation in question. Second, judges can only go “so far as possible” when interpreting legislation. The means that judges are restrained by the plain words of the provision and cannot stray from it’s meaning so far as to completely amend it.
Next, section 4 of the HRA 1998 provides that if the court is satisfied that the provision is incompatible with convention rights, a higher court may issue a ‘declaration of incompatibility’ (DOI). A DOI does not strike down legislation or remove it from the statute book. It defers the issue of incompatibility to the government and Parliament, giving it the option to take remedial action. Parliament and the government have three options after a DOI has been issued. First, they can use the fast-track remedial procedure under section 10 of the HRA 1998. This allows ministers, where there is ‘compelling reasons’, to amend legislation without having to go through the lengthy parliamentary process. Second, Parliament can take remedial action by using the ordinary legislative process. This method is the most frequently used of the three, seeing that the first options requires ‘compelling reasons’ in order to use it. Finally, they can decide to take no action because Parliament is not bound by a DOI to amend legislation. According to Lord Irvine, “the [DOI] is very likely to prompt the government and Parliament to respond”. Also, complainants can take their case the ECHR after they exhaust domestic remedies; therefore providing an incentive to act once a DOI has been issued.
Section 3 Case Law
In R v A, section 41 of the Youth Justice & Criminal Evidence Act 1999 was found to violate Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) because it denied the Defendant’s right to a fair trial. Section 41 prohibited...

Find Another Essay On Significance of Section 3 and 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998

Analysing the Dramatic Significance of Act 3 Scene 5 of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

2698 words - 11 pages Analysing the Dramatic Significance of Act 3 Scene 5 of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet The timeless tragedy of William Shakespeare's Romeo & Juliet is based upon two "star cross'd lovers", who are caught up in an ongoing feud between their two families. These are the houses of Capulet, where Juliet descends from, and the house of Montague, which Romeo belongs to. At the beginning of Act 3 Scene 5, Romeo and

The Dramatic Effectiveness and Significance of Act 3, Scene 1 in Romeo and Juliet

1416 words - 6 pages The Dramatic Effectiveness and Significance of Act 3, Scene 1 in Romeo and Juliet Shakespeare’s second tragedy ‘Romeo and Juliet’ was written between 1594 and 1596. The play is set in Verona a city in the north of Italy. In the play it is portrayed as a small independent country. The prince of Verona rules the city like a king and everyone obeys him. It is set over a period of four day. Shakespeare got the idea from a poem

The Significance of Act 3 Scene 3 of William Shakespeare's Othello

2506 words - 10 pages The Significance of Act 3 Scene 3 of William Shakespeare's Othello Othello was written by Shakespeare around 1602 and was set 35 years previously to that time (around 1571) during the Elizabethan era. Shakespeare got the idea for the play from the Italian Novella 'Gli Hecatommithi' and only changed minor details slightly. He kept the same plot but some of the characters and themes in the play were very different

As a Director if 'Twelfth Night,' explain how you would Exploit the Comic Potential of Act 3 Scene 4 and Act 4 Scene 2. GCSE A grade

2442 words - 10 pages clothes in a simple colour. This would make it easier for him to put on a gown over the top. In his disguise as Master Topas, Feste also wears a beard, not because he needs it as Malvolio can't see it but because it helps him feel more in character and is also more appealing to an audience.In Act 3 scene 4 and in Act 4 scene 2, the humour is a mixture of ironic humour, visual humour and erudite humour. An example of ironic humour is in Act 3

Have the courts struck a balance between the protection of individual rights under The Human Rights Act and Parliamentary sovereignty?

2052 words - 8 pages reinforced the rights of the individual against the state. However, the courts have not always been so zealous in defending rights and liberties, as cases such as Malone indicate. Nevertheless, when the Human Rights Act 1998 was passed, the courts were again given a special role with regard to protecting human rights.According to section 2 (1) (a) of the Human Rights Act, when determining a question relating to a Convention right, a national court must

Act 3 Scene 4 of William Shakespeare's Hamlet

1780 words - 7 pages Act 3 Scene 4 of William Shakespeare's Hamlet It is tempting to condemn Gertrude as evil, but it is probably more sensible to consider her as weak and inconstant. But when have tragedy plays ever been sensible? Like many of Shakespeare's women it is argued that their characters are somewhat "sketched in" rather than drawn in with detail like for example, Hamlet's. The way Shakespeare has "sketched in" Gertrude's

With detailed reference to the text (Act 1 scenes 1-3) analyse the dramatic significance and the effect of the opening of the play'

1518 words - 6 pages 'With detailed reference to the text (Act 1 scenes 1-3) analyse the dramatic significance and the effect of the opening of the play'Macbeth was written in the 1600s by William Shakespeare. It was one of his tragedies. A tragedy is a play that ends in death and the hero or main character gets killed. I am going to be analysing the dramatic significance and the effect of the opening of the play with detailed reference to the text. Macbeth is about

"How Would You Direct The Actors In Act 3, Scene 4 of Shakespeare's Macbeth?"

2351 words - 9 pages not allowed to do anything. If there was a woman's part to be hand, it would usually be taken by a young boy who would dress in a woman's costume.all of this into account, I will explain how, if given the choice, I would direct Act 3, Scene 4.I was to direct it, I would choose to direct the play in modern times, for a modern audience. this is because it will give me much more choices when directing the play, and I will be directing it to attract a

What does the juxtaposition of act 4 with 3 in Bernard Shaw's Pygmalion highlight about change?

839 words - 3 pages . Higgins is so involved with his studies that he denies the existence of human emotion.Throughout the acts III and IV, one can see the obvious changes in Eliza's persona and demeanor. From an obedient lady at the establishment of act III, Eliza becomes gradually less of a lady towards Higgins and towards everyone else, because of the lack of recognition of her feelings and emotions. Towards the end of act IV, Eliza seems to have gained the ability

Discuss the different attitudes towards Love and Marriage presented in Act 3 scenes 4 and 5 of Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet"

1694 words - 7 pages Act 1, Capulet arranges a ball to which Paris is invited. Capulet told Paris, at the ball, that he would agree to their marriage only if Juliet agreed, 'And she agreed, within her scope of choice lies my consent and fair according voice' this means; 'if she agrees, I will give my consent to her marrying the man she chooses'. However in Act 3 Scene 4 his assurances to Paris that Juliet will be dutiful are dramatically ironic, because Juliet has

Comparing Act 3 Scene 5 and Act 4 Scene 5 in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

2574 words - 10 pages Romeo and Juliet essay The Act 3 Scene 5 and Act 4 Scene 5 are set in Juliet’s bedroom in Capulet’s mansion ‘Verona’. To begin with, the atmosphere in Act 3 Scene 5 is very romantic, kind, loving and is running at a slow pace but when Romeo leaves and lady Capulet enters, the atmosphere turns aggressive, insulting and upsetting and gets into a faster pace. This is unusual seeing the start of the scene where the language

Similar Essays

The Human Rights Act 1998 Essay

2485 words - 10 pages Administrative Law, Routledge Cavendish (10th Edition, 2013) Chapter 18 (3) Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza (2004) [2004] UKHL 30 (4) Fitzpatrick v Sterling Housing Association [1999] 4 All ER (5) See Mello and others, 'The Human Rights Act 1998: a practical guide', Jordans (2000) (6) Flores, Imer, "Proportionality in Constitutional and Human Rights Interpretation" (2013). Georgetown Law Faculty Publications and Other Works. Paper 1168.

Human Rights Act 1998 Essay

816 words - 4 pages number of infringements were identified and this eventually led to the start of the legislative process which resulted in the Human Rights Act 1998. Arguments that were put forward for the incorporation of The European Convention on Human Rights into UK law were partly based on the costs and time considerations involved in taking cases before the European Court in Strasbourg. The Human Rights Act 1998 gave the citizens of the United Kingdom the

The Extent To Which The Human Rights Act Of 1998 Strengthened The Rule Of Law In The U.K. Constitution

3695 words - 15 pages The Extent to Which the Human Rights Act of 1998 Strengthened the Rule of Law in the U.K. Constitution The Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA), an Act introduced to give effect to rights from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in domestic legislation. Its introduction has affected many legal areas; especially the conceptions of the rule of law and their place in the UK constitution. To understand the effect of the HRA

The Origin, Development And Significance Of Human Rights

9689 words - 39 pages nongovernmental human rights organizations such as Amnesty International, Interights, and Human Rights Watch, the International Commission of Jurists, and diverse faith-based and professional groups,(3) A worldwide profusion of teaching and research devoted to the study of human rights in both formal and informal settings,(4) The proliferation of large UN conferences in areas such as children's rights, population, social development, women's rights, human