Major Faults Of The Sociological Approach To Religion

2527 words - 10 pages

The scope and methods of sociology have been constituted such as to include everything within the close area of human society,that is everything that is relevant for the study of social phenomena,social structures and interractions.Sociology is an entirely modern science and therefore it has been constituted to meet the requirements of the modern man,whose need for religion and sacralization is much diminished.This has led to the strange and,as I shall try to prove in this essay,totally unjustified claim that there is nothing sociology cannot judge and even condemn according to its own narrow principles.But that doesn't mean that religion ceased to follow its legitimate course or that any authentic doctrine has lost anything of its inner value even if purely religious points of view have come to be included in sociological or philosophical discourses.Let us start from one of the classical definitions of religion offered by sociology.It belongs to Durkheim and claims that religion is "a unitary system of creeds and practices relative to sacred things,that is separate,forbidden,creeds and practices that bring together in a single moral community,called Church,all those who adhere to it" .This definition reduces the entire complexity of religious beliefs and practices,as well as the Church,to a strictly moral convention.This great confusion between morality and spirituality,which probably arised from the gradual departure of man from his spiritual roots,has an obvious consequence:everything that is beyond one's limited power of understanding is rejected out of hand as confused,unscientific or archaic and a "sociological" or "philosophical"explanation is offered instead of true knowledge.Let me explain in detail what the confusion consists of.First,there has to be understood that there is a major distinction to be made in order to approach this issue with any amount of intelligence.Religion and sociology represent two opposed realms:that of the sacred and that of the profane.The order I put them is the actual chronological order in which they arose and developed but unfortunately I could not leave enough free space to illustrate the exact distance between them in point of time and authority.While the religious tradition spans the entire history of mankind and constitutes indeed a tradition ,sociology as a science is no older than a century,which renders its claim to explain religion through the eyes of modern mentality if not unlegitimate at least unappropriate.That is not to say though that sociology is somehow inferior to religion (if this comparison can be accepted) because it obviously appeals much more easily to the modern mentality than religion does and has proved more compatible with the profane character of the modern society.Still,a profane approach to religion is not legitimate.The only thing that would make it legitimate is the claim that the modern manifestations of progress are enough to dismiss any traditional view as obsolete and that...

Find Another Essay On Major Faults Of The Sociological Approach To Religion

Religion as a Major Organizing Ideology to the Social and Political Reality of the Nineteenth-Century

3995 words - 16 pages Religious scholar, Stephen Prothero, sees religion as a major organizing ideology to the social and political reality of the nineteenth-century. For Prothero, there is a close and intimate ideological relation between theological beliefs and a culture; therefore, they are not separable from characterizing the religious mood of the nineteenth-century. Prothero argues that many Americans were, “inspired by [the] republican rhetoric of liberty

The Faults of the Age of Jackson

911 words - 4 pages ). Americans resented these immigrants for their Roman Catholic religion, and believed foreigners were to blame for the unfavorable job market. Occupations requiring little skill went to the dirt-poor Irish, who would work for far less than anyone else. Persecution from the Jacksonian Democrats of the age was fairly indiscriminate, and targeted blacks, immigrants, and Native Americans. The Age of Jackson furthered class segregation by empowering the poor

Discuss two sociological theories of poverty and why it is important for social workers to develop a sociological approach to practice.

2128 words - 9 pages SociologyPoverty is an issue that many social workers are likely to address and tackle throughout practice. Cunningham & Cunningham, (2008) state that 'Social work service users are amongst the most impoverished people in Britain and for many, poverty defines their lives'. (p32) Poverty can result from a number of factors that include political, social and economic dynamics. This assignment shall be based on two sociological theories of

In "The Adventures of Huckleberry" by Finn, Mark Twain uses satire to reveal faults in society.

626 words - 3 pages Satire censures things, people, activities, or ideas, and makes people see things that they normally wouldn't permit to exist. Often times, satire is used to relay a message between an author and his reader. In The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Mark Twain uses satire to reveal faults in society. The humor he includes leaves his reader laughing at him or herself, and often times responding with a "That's me" statement. By the end of the novel

The Role of Religion and Major Deities in Ancient Egypt

693 words - 3 pages Prior to Egypt becoming unified under the rules of pharaohs each community of people in the Nile Valley and along the Nile River developed its own god or gods, many connected or replicating animals. Religion played a central role in the daily lives of ancient Egyptians and inspired the extraordinary temples, pyramids and other associated magnificent structures. The unique spiritual world was complex with the fascination of afterlife and the

An Analytical Approach to Truth and Religion

6399 words - 26 pages An Analytical Approach to Truth and Religion ABSTRACT: I discuss some of the problems of the application of the notion of truth to religion. After introductory remarks on the problem called truth and religion to show the peculiarity and the actuality of the problem discussed, I examine the different meanings of the notions of truth and religion, in order to formulate some comments on the different concepts of the truth of religion. I name

Religion and Science: A Metaphysical Approach to Evolution

1487 words - 6 pages with this scientific statement? Children learn about the laws of gravity and matter, and there is no debate over that topic but, when considering what our children learn about the origins of life there is major disagreement. Whether biologists in schools are teaching children this as fact or theory can be an issue within itself, so, we must direct our attention to the idea if children are learning this as a basic scientific fundamental then

The Value of the Afrocentric Approach to Education

911 words - 4 pages –Wilborn,et al 1999] Conclusion The Afro centric approach to education emerged as a reactive stance to address racial inequalities identified by black parents and teachers as a major factor in the under achievement and disaffection of black pupils. A further refinement of the integrationist model emerged as cultural pluralism - an essential part of a pluralistic model of society. The key feature of pluralism is that groups are not ranked

The Approach of Nonviolence

976 words - 4 pages within him. This will not only attain justice, but also helps him to recognize his faults and to rectify them. As a result we will be creating a beloved community. Works Cited Gerber Hansuli John, “The Road to Nonviolence”. October 18, 2010. Web December 26, 2010. Gandhi M.K. “Peace, Nonviolence And Conflict Resolution”. N.p. Web. December 26, 2010. Gandhi M.K. “The Gospel of Non-Violence

The Sociological Aspect of Obesity

7097 words - 28 pages ). In my research, I approach obesity as a discursive category that is created, produced and reproduced through various social practices, such as: medicine and health care system, school, religion, and the media (e.g. Foucault, 1979). I claim that in American culture, a thin body is held as the "original", normal body; whereas obesity is viewed as a `temporary disruption' to the balance of the body. According to our cultural understanding, an

The Approach to Nature of Descartes and White

1269 words - 5 pages The Approach to Nature of Descartes and White The approach to nature which René Descartes takes is distinct from that of Gilbert White. Descartes and White have similar key methods of examining nature. It is mainly in Descartes’ deductive

Similar Essays

The Main Function Of Religion According To Sociological Arguments

961 words - 4 pages The Main Function of Religion According to Sociological Arguments Many sociologists believe that the main function of religion is to provide people with a code of conduct, which regulates personal and social life. There are two main theories to what role religion plays within society. One of these theories is the Marxist theory. Marxism sees society as superstructure. They believe that society isn’t peaceful and

Comparison Of The Three Major Sociological Theories

1817 words - 7 pages positivistic and interpretive sociologists to make determinations aboutsocial change. If indeed critical theorist are to be involved in sociological study, full disclosure of prejudicesand objectives would be needed for any inquiry to be beneficial and trustworthy.Postpositivism remains the best approach for observing the exteriors of society. Coupled with theinterpretivist's view of the interior culture, the two theories working hand in hand would be

Sociological Perspective Of Religion Essay

1040 words - 4 pages , Functionalism, Feminism, and lastly the Interactionist perspective.God is seen as the ruler and creator of the world. People must be dedicated and behave in a particular manor in order to be rewarded. Religion gives an explanation for everything in life, influencing people to follow a specific path in order to reap the benefits in life. When following a religion they teach ideas, such as sacrificing and facing adversities in life to receive benefits in

I Vow Not To Talk About The Faults Of Others.

2188 words - 9 pages happiness to ourselves and others; it enables us to feel and to extend love. Leaving aside the mental habit that finds faults prevents suffering for ourselves and others. This should be the heart of our spiritual practice. For this reason, His Holiness the Dalai Lama said, "My religion is kindness."We may still see our own and others' imperfections, but our mind is gentler, more accepting and spacious. People don't care so much if we see their faults