Similarities In The Criticisms Of Industrial Agriculture Made By Michael Pollan, Wendell Berry, And Vandana Shiva And Their Visions Of Better Farming

1134 words - 5 pages

    With the continuous evolution of global industrialization and mechanization of agriculture since early 20th century, traditional farming that relied heavily on the labor of humans and animals has been gradually replaced by a modern form of capital intensive farming, considered more “efficient” through the application of science and engineering. Despite the fact that industrial agriculture has brought a rapid increase in world food production, it has also attracted criticisms and demands for a better form of agriculture. Michael Pollan, Wendell Berry, and Vandana Shiva, the three environmental activists, have all claimed in their essays and speech that, industrialized agriculture has negative impacts on our environment, farming economy, and the survival of traditional farmers. They all call for a better kind of agriculture that is more sustainable, resilient with natural biodiversity.
    Michael Pollan, Wendell Berry, and Vandana Shiva have all claimed that the massive use of chemical herbicide and fertilizer in industrial agriculture has contributed to the environmental degradation such as soil erosion and water pollution, as well as the adverse effects on agriculture. Pollan concludes, in “Mass Nature”, that the “cheap” industrial food does not count “costs charged to the environment, in the form of soil depletion and water pollution”. Similarly, Wendell Berry, in his “The Agrarian Standard”, said “the continuing unsustainably high soil erosion rates” has uncovered the fact “We continue to pollute our soils and streams agricultural poisons”. What’s worse, the rise of “super-pests” as the resistance to pesticides, has forced the farmers to use ever-stronger pesticides which have put the already vulnerable environment into an infinite loop. Vandana Shiva, argued in the video “Seeds of Freedom”, that “Instead of controlling pests, and controlling weeds, you are getting super pests, and super weeds. So even in the narrow domain of weed control and pest control, the technology is failing.”.
    Not only does the industrial farming harms our environment, but also it hurts our farming economy according to Pollan’s, Berry’s, and Shiva’s criticisms. Pollan, in“Mass Nature”, reveals the invisible cost of “cheap” industrial food such as the cost to the public purse, “in the form of subsidies to conventional commodity farms”, and the economic cost of more than $100 billion per year on the epidemic of diabetes and obesity caused by the industrial corn sweeteners in soft drinks. Berry, in “The Agrarian Standard”, also indicates the disadvantages that industrial agriculture has put on the local economy. “Industrialism prescribes an economy that is placeless and displacing. It is about the gathering of an exploitive economic power into the hands of a few people who are alien to the places and the people they exploit. Such an economy is bound to destroy locally adapted agrarian economies everywhere it goes, simply because it is too ignorant not to do so.”...

Find Another Essay On Similarities In the Criticisms of Industrial Agriculture Made by Michael Pollan, Wendell Berry, and Vandana Shiva and Their Visions of Better Farming

The Omnivore’s Dilemma by Michael Pollan

2165 words - 9 pages restaurants like McDonalds can be possible to combine because there are restaurants that use organic products. Fast food restaurants like Chipotle come in mind where it uses organic products. Chipotle used to be owned by McDonalds, and it made them a lot of money because of the fresh products they use on their food. This makes me wonder why can’t McDonalds do the same thing if they owned Chipotle in the past. Michael Pollan mentions that “this

The Man in the High Castle: Criticisms of Reality and Dictatorship by Philip K. Dick

1342 words - 5 pages The Man in the High Castle: Criticisms of Reality and Dictatorship by Philip K. Dick “Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.” -Philip K. Dick Botwinick writes in A History of the Holocaust, “The principle that resistance to evil was a moral duty did not exist for the vast majority of Germans. Not until the end of the war did men like Martin Niemoeller and Elie Wiesel arouse the world’s conscience to the

Orwell's and Huxley's Visions of the Future

739 words - 3 pages and is no longer held as a significant importance as it had in the past. In the novel, technology is related with every aspect of their community in one way or another, and it is the ultimate source of their stability and happiness. Similarly, intelligence and knowlege are being less appreciated and acknowledged by the contemporary community. Beauty and convenience has become the main focal point, and meaningless products have become the best

Impacts of Organic Farming on the Efficiency of Energy Use in Agriculture

1176 words - 5 pages annually than the total amount of solar energy captured yearly by all U.S. plant biomass (Pfeiffer Farms that operate on an organic structure depletes the use of fossil fuel energy usage. Compared to conventional farming, organic farming improves several conditions of the agriculture’s environmental energy output. Corn and soybean farming systems are the two main grains grown in the U.S. According to USCB, “they are high

Hinduism and the God Shiva

1310 words - 5 pages . Shiva was extremely pained by Sati's death and can be seen dancing on his ex-father in law who is responsible for the death of his beloved Sati. The Devine Mother Kali goddess of time and death was Shiva's second wife. They have two sons together, Ganesha, the elephant headed deity of all existing beings, and son Kartikeya the scientist of gods. There is the tale that Ganesha was challenged to race around the universe, so he simply walked

Criticisms of Consumerism and Materialism in Fight Club

1422 words - 6 pages range of identities through products and labels” (Lockwood, 2008, p. 329.). Explicit examples of society’s dependency on consumerism is constantly portrayed through makeovers, where an individual gains a plethora of confidence and social acceptance through the modification of their sense of dress. Thus, we live in a world defined almost entirely by what we own hence the propensity for people to change their identity from time to time. The film

Criticisms of Consumerism and Materialism in Fight Club (1999)

1198 words - 5 pages caused by a “consumer’s ability to choose from a vast range of identities through products and labels” (Davis, 2002), the support groups are an attempt at belonging somewhere. “His portrayal as an exhausted and numb narcoleptic insomniac is a vivid depiction of a man suffering from the failed promise of self-fulfillment in a brand name, corporate-driven consumer society” (Davis, 2002). Though the groups generally provide him relief, he is never

Visions of a Perfect Society Illustrated in Machiavelli's The Prince and Thomas More's Utopia

518 words - 2 pages prince.The Utopians have a seemingly democratic form of government as educated people elect their leaders and then those leaders elect the prince. To conclude, the visions of a perfect society vary from person to person. Machiavelli wrote of a society where a prince is in charge. ‘The Prince’ is a book of guidelines, if you will. More wrote of a so called perfect society. He describes the government of Utopia, policies, people, etc… Utopia is

The Hitler Youth and Boy scouts - an investigation of the differences and similarities, and their origin

4104 words - 16 pages The Hitler Youth and Boy scouts- an investigation of the differences and similarities,and their originIntroductionIn 1939 Hitler said "Look at these young men and boys! What material! With them I can make a new world!" This gives an idea of what Hitler thought of the youth and what an important role the youth played in his politics. Hitler had wisely observed that the youth is the key to the future. Since they are so important, the youth

The Use of Fertilisers and Pesticides in Agriculture

3405 words - 14 pages back into the soil[2]. However, in a farm, the plants (i.e. crops) are harvested and the nutrients are removed with them. If a high yield is to be maintained for a number of years the nutrients must be replaced. Therefore in order to maintain productivity in agriculture farmers need to use fertilisers containing these nutrients. There are two types of fertilisers used by farmers in agriculture: inorganic fertilisers

Pollan´s Theories and the Potato

746 words - 3 pages Pollan has a few positions regarding the nature that the potato satisfies and its connection to politics, production, and his own personal life. His view regarding the desire that the potato satisfies is compared with the idea of the sublime. Pollan states that the sublime is “mostly a kind of vacation in both a literal and moral sense” (184) and that nature itself is a counter to that. Agriculture can be described as a method of control of

Similar Essays

The Botany Of Desire, By Michael Pollan

1110 words - 4 pages Every garden has their own purposes that make gardeners devote a great amount of time to take care of them. Gardeners are coming up with their own unique ways of taking care of their gardens, especially when they make profits out of it. In his book, The Botany of Desire, Michael Pollan claims the best gardeners of his generation have devoted themselves to growing cannabis, popularly known as marijuana. Intrigued with Pollan’s argument, I

Explain What Is Meant By Verification And Falsification, In The Context Of Religious Language? Evaluate Their Criticisms Of Religious Language.

1844 words - 7 pages not everyone has the same “blik”. Religious beliefs are “bliks” because of the impact they have on the way in which people look at the world and live their lives. Further criticisms were added by Karl Popper who argued that it was not only the fact that a statement was verifiable which gave it meaning, it was also whether it was falsifiable. Popper is not here proposing an alternative theory of meaning, but simply pointing out

The Agriculture And Industrial Revolutions Of The Eighteenth Century

791 words - 3 pages Question: Identify changes the occured during the Industrial and Agricultural revolutions of the eighteenth centuries.In Europe during the time prior to the Industrial and Agricultural revolutions, people had a specific way of life that had been functional for many years. People had a strictly production and consumption way of life. This is also known as subsistence farming, in this, the families would grow just enough food for their families

The Social And Economical Impacts Of Organic Farming On Agriculture And The Environment

1199 words - 5 pages economic and ecological benefits from it. This study will also help the farmers in creating awareness about the organic farming for its social and economical impacts on agriculture and environment. The social benefits will include employment opportunities as entrepreneurs, eco friendly environment and better opportunities. The organic products can gain more economic benefits in the global market. It can improve the life and health of farmers