This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Sir Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella

1395 words - 6 pages

Sir Philip Sidney's Astrophil and Stella

The literary fortunes of Sir Philip Sidney illustrate nicely the contrast between the Elizabethan and twentieth century views on imitation and originality in literature. Sidney's sequence of 108 sonnets entitled Astrophil and Stella which appeared at the end of the sixteenth century drew immediate praise from English readers who appreciated his "blend of wit and sensibility, of intellectual brilliance and temperamental ardour" (Lever 53); they liked especially the "directness and spontaneity" (53) of the poems. Sidney himself contributed to his reputation for sincerity with the immortal lines of first sonnet: "Biting my truant pen, beating my self for spite, / Fool, said my Muse to me, look in thy heart and write." Teachers repeat this good advice endlessly. I tell my College Writing students to use personal experience; one can hardly go wrong with early childhood memories because the material is pure--not yet contaminated with the clichÈs of what we are supposed to believe and feel. Astrophil and Stella inspired literally thousands of sonnets and Sidney's admirers thought that he was greater than Spenser or Shakespeare.

The idea that Sidney, himself happily married to Frances Walsingham, could be passionately in love with Penelope Rich and jealous of her husband bothered Victorian critics. How can one justify Astrophil's pursuit of adultery? Various excuses were made for Sidney: Elizabethan morals tended to be lax, it was Astrophil and not Sidney who was at fault, the marriage of the Riches was not what it should have been, etc.

But the story of a passionate Astrophil who pursues the chaste Stella lost much of its appeal for another reason with the advent of historical criticism. Critics discovered that the real Astrophil had a "placid married life" (54) and that Stella was twice married--had tarnished her reputation because of divorce. Furthermore, Sidney had made good use of Petrarchan images, even specific details; there were other borrowings from French and Italian love-poems. For example, Astrophil envied his mistress's lap-dog just as had Serafino a century earlier. In other words, a poet who advises us to find the material for our art in personal experience does not necessarily follow his own advice as J.C. Nichols suggests in The Poetry of Sir Philip Sidney: "Sidney's 'sincerity', at least in the 'better' ones, has often been stressed. But to say that poems succeed because Sidney is deeply moved and sincere . . is really to tell us nothing more than that Sidney has succeeded in giving that impression" (53). Not only does Sidney claim to find the material in his heart (which indirectly emphasizes biography), but he also pretends to have no great skill, suggesting that sincerity counts for more than literary talent. The quality of his writing disproves that assertion! His very skill and the use of literary conventions contradict his references to sincerity and lack of talent in his...

Find Another Essay On Sir Philip Sidney's Astrophil and Stella

Compare and contrast Sir Phillip Sidney's Astrophil and Stella (sonnet # 47) and William Shakespeare's sonnet # 1

2457 words - 10 pages reminds the young man that the only way to counter this peril is through the replication of a parent's beauty within his offspring and therefore continuation of the family line. And according to Kenneth Muir, "to refrain from procreating is to be guilty of narcissism, and of cruelty to future generations" (45).Phillip Sidney's series of sonnets, Astrophil and Stella, are similar to that of Shakespeare's as they incorporate strong imagery and are full

A Brief Analysis Of Sir Philip Sidney's Sonnet 7

609 words - 3 pages Sir Philip Sidney’s Sonnet 7 is from the sonnet sequence Astophel and Stella dating from the sixteenth century. It is a lament by one of the central figures, Astophel, a man who is in love with the other central figure, Stella, who is ultimately unattainable because she is married to another man.In the first few lines of the poem, Astrophil talks about Stella’s black eyes and how they “beam so bright” (ll. 2) and how in “

An Analysis of Sir Philip Sidney's "Sonnet 31"

860 words - 4 pages genuineness has failed him, the quality might ironically—but nevertheless literally—be defined as a virtue in that it possesses the ability to bring about a desired result. Sir Philip Sidney’s “Sonnet 31” might, at first glance, appear to be a man asking a series of questions to no real end. Closer examination, however, reveals that this is a work that delves deeply into its speaker’s—and perhaps the author’s—psyche, offering its readers as much insight

Reader Response to Sydney's Sonnets, Astrophil and Stella

1421 words - 6 pages Reader Response to Sydney's Sonnets, Astrophil and Stella As we discussed Astrophil and Stella in class, I felt a familiar knot in my stomach. At first I could not pin-point the reasons for my aversion to these sonnets. However, as we discussed it in class, it became clear to me. I could identify with Penelope Devereux Rich. Although Astrophil and Stella could be interpreted as an innocent set of love sonnets to an ideal woman and not a

Love Sonnets by Sir Thomas Wyatt and Sir Philip Sidney

1742 words - 7 pages poets have chosen to work within such a strict form, that form and its structures make up part of what they want to say. In other words, the poet is using the structure of the poem as part of the language act: we will find the "meaning" not only in the words, but partly in their pattern as well. Both Sir Thomas Wyatt the Elder and Sir Philip Sidney were English poets of the renaissance. They were both courtier poets who wrote many sonnets

Plato and Sir Philip Sydney's Views on Poetry

1061 words - 4 pages It seems that Plato and Sir Philip Sidney are somewhat different and alike but Sidney is more relative. He makes it acceptable for poetry to experiment in different things instead of being so serious all the time. Comparing the two essays, Sidney is more realistic and practical about poetry and its meaning than Plato. Plato wants to create something that does not exist in the world-The Perfect Ideal State. There is nothing wrong with wanting to

In Pamphilia to Amphilanthus

672 words - 3 pages . Women were supposed to be cold and aloof never letting their lovers succumb to their desires. The image of Cupid placing "one heart flaming more than all the rest" shows that Pamphilia now has a burning desire for her beloved and can no longer be cool and aloof. This difference can be expressly witnessed when comparing Wroth's Pamphilia to Sidney's Stella in Astrophil and Stella.Unlike her uncle, Philip Sidney, Wroth does not convey the paradox of a

Early English Lyric poetry as a medium of the poet expressing himself

1883 words - 8 pages Poets have used their gifts to many ends. To explore emotions, to celebrate nature, to praise God, to celebrate in rhyme, to argue and judge, to seduce, to attack, and as a means of self-presentation in the hierarchical structure of the court in sixteenth century England, by the use of witty lyrics and twofold meanings. Sir Thomas Wyatt and Sir Philip Sidney were two poets who spanned the Henry VIII and Elizabethan era. They used their poetry

Chivalry in Elizabethan Poetry

2801 words - 11 pages bids his lover “farewell”. In Odabashian’s words, “there is no reason for the speaker to go on suffering and composing traditional love complaints if his lady refuses to play by the rules of courtly love”. This indicates that the speaker has given up on his lover and has decided to move on. “Astrophil and Stella”, Sonnet I by Sir Philip Sydney Another illustration of the combination of courtly love and chivalry is Sir Philip Sydney's sonnet I in

Lady Mary Wroth as Proto-Feminist

3176 words - 13 pages . One in particular was Sir Philip Sidney who, consequently, was her uncle. In Sidney's Sonnet #41 from his collection, Astrophil and Stella, Sidney uses "his hand" and "lance" to battle the enemy, France. Because of his heroism in battle, Sidney says: "I obtained the prize (Stella)" (Adam, Logan 489). With his phallic lance, Sidney has conquered the heart of his beloved Stella. Germaine Greer in her book The Female Eunuch analyzes the use of

All for Show – The Post-Petrarchan Poetry of Wyatt, Sidney, and Spenser

2217 words - 9 pages The difficulty of discussing the representation of women in the work of sixteenth century English poets like Sir Thomas Wyatt, Sir Philip Sidney, and Edmund Spenser is the need to address authorial intent in its historical context. As a critic, one cannot attribute to words what the author did not intend; however, one can attribute intentions that the author did not word. For example, it is easy to justify the objectification and subordination

Similar Essays

Sir Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella Sonnet 20 Versus Shakespeare's Sonnet 130

1792 words - 7 pages In Sir Philip Sidney’s Astrophil and Stella Sonnet 20 and William Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130, both are talking about love. Love in a romantic relationship, yet they seem very different from each other. Sir Philip Sidney’s is the traditional Petrarchan sonnet and Shakespeare’s have his own style of sonnet. Take a side on the type of sonnets, the two sonnets shares some more differences. The love object in Astrophil and Stella Sonnet 20 and

Desire In Chaucers "The Wife Of Bath" And Sir Philip Sidney's "Astrophil And Stella"

1040 words - 4 pages When a person is infatuated with something, they can become single-minded and ignorant to reality. If they cannot have the object of their desire, they may be plunged into a state of despair and frustration. Sir Philip Sidney explores the affects of desire in his sonnets, Astrophil and Stella. Geoffrey Chaucer also delves into the topic in “The Wife of Bath’s Prologue and Tale”. These two works present the idea that desire is

William Shakespeare’s Sonnets And Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella

2635 words - 11 pages Anglicized the sonnet, and essentially did for the sonnet, what establishing grammar did for English—they gave English a pedestal among the greatest poets of all time. Although neither sonneteer was completely on their own in assimilating Italian conventions into English culture, both certainly added unique flavor into the mix. Works Cited Cain, Jeffrey P. "Sidney's Astrophil And Stella, Sonnet 108." Explicator 52.1 (1993): 12. MasterFILE Elite

Compare/Contrast The Ways Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella And Milton's Comus Explore Gender And Sexuality

1185 words - 5 pages the society. Both Sidney's and Milton's heroines are no longer passive feminine receivers of affections. They determine what happens to them by using reason rather than emotions. Hence, Sidney and Milton exemplify progressive views of their periods, attempting to see gender and sexuality in a new light. Sexuality and desire Philip Sidney: Astrophil and Stella (c. 1591) Sidney's Astrophil and Stella, a compilation of 108 sonnets and 11 songs