Sir Thomas More’s Utopia: An Alternative To European Life

1790 words - 7 pages

Presented as a conversation between friends, Sir Thomas More’s Utopia offers an alternative to European life that is hopelessly unobtainable, but undeniably superior. Utopia is absolutely fiction, and yet it is written in a style that makes its content remarkably believable. More’s conversational attitude towards a serious and scholarly piece of thought makes his thesis at once obscure and obvious. He spends a majority of the narrative describing small, unconnected details of the lives of the Utopians, ignoring the lengthy scholastic explanations which are to be expected of a man of his education, and yet through the detail he reveals an expansive and original hypothesis. More sees the value of the European lifestyle and yet, through his fictional acquaintance Raphael Hythlodaeus, makes a convincing argument for the practices of the Utopians. The dichotomy between the virtues of one culture and the failures of another highlight More’s most central point: perfection would be obtainable in real life only if the world could be destroyed and created again. Pride and human ambition will forever limit the people of the real world from seeing the success of the people on More’s fictitious island.
Raphael Hythlodaeus is a well traveled, well educated, and well opinionated man. He has seen enough of the world to know the world, and is articulate enough to share his opinions of it. Hythlodaeus’s discovery of Utopia and his persuasive account of the society he finds there create the narrative through which More discusses his ideas on perfection. More cleverly creates an incarnation of himself to hear about and question Hythlodaeus’s findings, effectively discussing weighty ideas in a causal and approachable manner. Utopia seems real because it is discussed as if it is real and because the man who finds it seems just as real as the man who invents him.
Established as a credible source, Hythlodaeus describes a lifestyle that shocks Europeans, both real and fictitious. Utopia is perfect, and yet almost everything about it is alien. Values held sacred in Europe are denounced and rejected in Utopia. Slaves are dressed in gold, and houses are redistributed and traded every ten years. Women are contributing members of society, existing even in the priesthood. Cities are well planned and ruled by a government that is always stable, the crowded streets of Europe’s cities and the turbulant thrones of its palaces. Utopians live without the faintest hint of proper European society, and yet, they are entirely content. Europeans, including More’s incarnation, are flabbergasted at how such a happiness could be possible in a world so different from their own. More uses the difference between the structure of Utopia and the established custom of Europe, and the skepticism of Europeans upon hearing of it, to discuss his views on the limitation and impossibility of perfection in Europe.
The most striking difference between Utopia and the nations of Europe is a...

Find Another Essay On Sir Thomas More’s Utopia: An Alternative to European Life

An Approach To Alternative Fuel Vehicle Rentals

1674 words - 7 pages An Approach to Alternative Fuel Vehicle Rentals As one of the leading car rental companies, Lotus car rental is in a position to take advantage of a great opportunity. This is an opportunity to be one of the first car rental companies to provide our consumers with alternative options to fuel-powered vehicles, and to rise above the competition. Adding alternative fuel vehicles to our car rental fleet will increase our car rental turnover and

Home Confinement: An Alternative to Incarceration

978 words - 4 pages Home Confinement: An Alternative to Incarceration      West Virginia state prisons have a maximum capacity of 2,154 inmates; currently they house 2,363 inmates, and more remain in City and County lockups to manage the overflow (West Virginia Blue Book). Home Confinement solves this problem. Reduction of the prison population should be reason enough to institute home confinement, but other reasons do exist. Would you like lower taxes? Home

An Alternative to Traditional Elderly Care

1481 words - 6 pages chance to meet new vacationers, as they come and go from each cruise destination. We hope to provide travel, socialization, fun and adventure for those requiring assistance with their specific healthcare needs. It is an alternative for a quality of life that may add years to a person's life and life to that person's years.To live on a traditional cruise ship, for an entire year, would cost about $33,000 a year. An assisted living facility costs

Wind-Power: An Alternative to Hydroelectricity

670 words - 3 pages The supply of fossil fuels is drastically depleting, and the consumption of energy causes multiple problems which include: global warming, pollution and geopolitical conflicts according to Dan Hogan, editor of One respective alternative would be wind-power. Wind-power can be used as both electrical power and mechanical power. Electrical power refers to fuel that has been converted to electricity. Mechanical power is fuel used

Nurse to Patient Ratios: An Alternative Approach

1479 words - 6 pages and nurse retention rates saving on the cost of hiring and training new staff. Mandating staffing ratios is not the answer because the health care industry is already burdened with an overwhelming number of regulations. The aforementioned issues necessitates further research on how to implement a cost effective, safe, and quality method of maintaining nurse to patient ratios. This research paper will prove the considerable evidence of the

Sir Thomas Moore, Richard III, in comparison to Guy montag, "Farenhiet 451."

572 words - 2 pages Loyalty to one's own conscience and beliefs is key to maintain identity. Guy Montag the main character of "Fahrenheit 451", and Sir Thomas Moore the main character of the play "A Man for All Seasons" both play roles as the Hero's of their respective works of literary genius. Many hard decisions and challenges are put before them, but they both manage to succeed on their own terms, and by what they deem to be "the right thing to do."In the

Solution to an Energy Utopian Oriented Alternative Fuel

789 words - 4 pages focused, achievable solution. For example, ecological economics addresses the “limitations of ecology … and also the limitations of capitalism” and consolidated the two fields into an alternative acceptable to the public. 1 In creating this utopia, we managed to consolidate our varying views into one shared goal that we all believed in, demonstrating collective wish-fulfillment,1 which is a major goal of imagining a utopia, as Dr. Mikulak states

Green Politics as an Alternative to Capitalism (Final Paper)

694 words - 3 pages Aleksandersen, L.S. 698 Words The world today is a witness to the problems regarding the state of the environment, the degree of social inequality, and the continued rise of social injustice. Many claim that to address these, an alternative to the capitalist system needs to be found. Meadows et al. for example, argue that there are limits to growth, which means that, given the present context, society has surpassed its own limits. Green

Black Cumin Seeds as an Alternative to Chemotherapy

891 words - 4 pages Society of Hematology). It is one of the most common cancers in the world and can be treated by chemotherapy and bone marrow transplant. Statement of the problem Although chemotherapy is an effective treatment for cancer, patients still suffer from side effects such as hair loss. Thus, more studies need to be done to find alternative medications that do not have side effects. Folk medicine is one option used to treat many diseases such as hepatitis

An Alternative to Cable TV: Streaming Internet Video

1129 words - 5 pages , features and the availability of their desired content. Another reason that many consider streaming video services as an alternative to cable is convenience. The Digital Video Recorder used in modern entertainment systems can now be replaced with an easy to use streaming video devices. As the online video libraries grow to include more content, eventually streaming set top boxes will provide this functionality, without the need to schedule

Life in Latin America Prior to European Contact

1077 words - 5 pages religious and obeyed their gods at all times. Life in Latin America prior to European contact insinuated duality because they engineered buildings, had a strong understanding of astronomy, yet had limited technology, and practiced human sacrifice and blood-letting. They had a challenging life filled with violence but were advanced people at the same time. The indigenous people were very advanced in engineering and constructing buildings. According to

Similar Essays

Comparing Sir Thomas More's Utopia And Virgil's Aeneid

2376 words - 10 pages violent undercurrents of Pax Romana. In essence, More and Virgil speak to the dangers of imposing a normative national identity that actually becomes the flipside of a violent imperialist project. More importantly, they open up space for dissent by critiquing the seemingly impenetrable state system from the inside and thus exposing its inherent contradictions precariously built on a foundation of violence. Works Cited Virgil. The Aeneid of Virgil: A Verse Translation. Trans. Rolfe Humphries. Ed. Brian Wilkie. New York: Macmillan, 1987. More, Thomas, Sir. Utopia. Trans. Paul Turner. New York: Penguin, 1965.

Utopia By Sir Thomas More This Is Sort Of A Comparison Essay On More And Machiavelli But It Is Moer About More And His Book, Utopia

1061 words - 4 pages to cheat on one another. More brings out many issues that he resents in Europe but he does this safely by having a dissenting opinion of Europe and also has someone who is in compliance with the way Europe is run. More's Utopia, calls for a more perfect society. Therefore, I chose Sir Thomas More.

Sir Thomas More's Life Of Public Service

674 words - 3 pages Thomas becoming a monk. He qualified as a lawyer, because of his father’s disapproval. He was an affable man. His friend Erasmus wrote he was “born for friendship”. He wrote quite a bit of literature, the most famous being Utopia. Utopia was a controversial piece of literature comparing European politics at that time with a fictional, idealized Island republic where there was no class system and everybody is forced to work. Thomas More eventually

The Loves And Life Of Sir Thomas Wyatt

1870 words - 7 pages half of the 1520s” (Burrows). Thomas Wyatt and Elizabeth Brooke were separated in 1525 when Wyatt accused his wife of adultery. At this time Wyatt took an interest in Anne Boleyn, the future queen. Much of Sir Thomas Wyatt’s poetry is seen as being reflective of his love life. His personal relationships certainly served as inspiration for a notable amount of his work. In Sir Thomas Wyatt’s poem “Blame not my lute”, the speaker addresses the