Skepticism And The Philosophy Of Language In Early Modern Thought

3259 words - 13 pages

Skepticism and the Philosophy of Language in Early Modern Thought

ABSTRACT: This paper discusses the importance of skeptical arguments for the philosophy of language in early modern thought. It contrasts the rationalist conception of language and knowledge with that of philosophers who adopt some sort of skeptical position, maintaining that these philosophers end up by giving language a greater importance than rationalists. The criticism of the rationalists' appeal to natural light is examined, as well as skeptical arguments limiting knowledge such as the so-called 'maker's knowledge' argument. This argument is then seen as capital for favoring a positive interpretation of the importance of language for knowledge.

The revival of ancient skepticism in early XVIth century has been considered one of the major forces in the development of modern thought, especially as regards the discussion about the nature of knowledge and the sciences. Richard Popkin in his History of Skepticism from Erasmus to Spinoza (1979) has shown that skeptical arguments were influential in the attack against traditional scholastic conceptions of science, opening the way to the development of the new scientific method. The dispute between those who embraced skepticism and those who tried to refute or surpass it was central to the philosophical scene well into the XVIIIth century.

However, the importance of the discussion of the nature and role of language in this process and its relation to skeptical arguments has scarcely been examined. My objective in this paper is to extend Popkin's analysis of the role of skepticism in the formation of modern thought to the consideration, in general lines, of some of the main features of early modern theories about the nature and function of language.

The skeptical arguments against the possibility of certain knowledge of reality were dealt with by rationalists, such as Descartes and his followers, by appealing to natural light or divine illumination as a characteristic of man's mind capable of guaranteeing this privileged access into nature's essence. According to this view it is this kind of intuitive knowledge that grounds the possibility of certain knowledge. Skeptics, on the other hand, attacked the very notion of intuitive knowledge, either rejecting it, or, such as the more moderate ones, restricting its application to specific domains, e.g., mathematics.

My main contention is that skeptical arguments, which were mainly arguments purporting to establish limits to knowledge, opened the way to the consideration of language as an alternative to mind's intuitive powers in man's access to reality. Linguistic representation became important as a way of avoiding some of the main problems affecting mental representation. I intend to concentrate here on one specific septic argument known as "the maker's knowledge argument," stating that we can only know what we create. My hypothesis is that the philosophical interest in...

Find Another Essay On Skepticism and the Philosophy of Language in Early Modern Thought

The Complexity of Language in Modern Society

1013 words - 4 pages of the level of language from earlier eras as well. The level of complexity in language in the modern era is also much deeper than it was in earlier eras before. For example, in the Stone Age, people had cave paintings. In the Modern Age, people have books. What does this imply? Cave paintings, in the opinions of our era’s people anyway, are vague and hardly understandable. Images of two stick-drawing people with spears pointing at each other

Security of the Political and Social Position of the Nobility in Early Modern Europe

1908 words - 8 pages Security of the Political and Social Position of the Nobility in Early Modern Europe The nobility of early modern Europe were descended on the whole from the mounted knights of medieval armies who had been granted land along with social and political privileges and had subsequently formed a higher social class. Between 1500-1789 the status of the aristocracy came under threat both politically and socially. The rise of

Dueling in Early Modern England History of Early Modern England

3570 words - 14 pages PAGE Dueling in Early Modern EnglandHistory of Early Modern EnglandIf I could summarize the time period between 1485 to 1714 I would choose the word turmoil. During this time period the concepts of honor and the duel would enter into the English culture. The first and most obvious question is; what is a duel and how is it different than a fight. Well I believe Barbara Holland does a pretty good job of explaining the concept in modern terms in

Evolution of the Haunted House in Early and Modern Gothic Novels

959 words - 4 pages Evolution of a Haunted House: The use of setting in early and modern gothic novels The setting for a novel plays a big part in how the story and its characters relate to the reader. This paper will examine how setting in gothic literature, plays an important role in the telling of a story by using Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto and Shirley Jackson’s The House on Haunted Hill as examples. During the eighteenth century, the Romantic

Superstition and the Witch-hunts in Early Modern Britain

1856 words - 7 pages Superstition and the Witch-hunts in Early Modern Britain The people of Early Modern Britain were deeply superstitious and this aspect to their character had a major bearing on the course that the events of the witch-hunts took. The belief in witches was as illogical as many of the other beliefs that were popularly held in Early Modern Britain. The populous held many beliefs that were not based on fact. These beliefs

The Unfair Prosecution of Women: Witchcraft in Early Modern Europe

2270 words - 9 pages and rural policy for the University of Wagenigen, provides socio-economic and rural views of the prosecution of witches in early modern Europe. He explains the evolution of witchcraft belief that coincided with agricultural and societal development. Brian Levack takes an in-depth look at all aspects of witchcraft in his Articles on Witchcraft, Magic, and Demonology: a Twelve Volume Anthology of Scholarly Articles, from which I chose to examine

'the Excellent Foppery of the World': Skepticism in King Lear

2424 words - 10 pages will argue that King Lear strongly advocates a skeptical worldview, not just in regards to belief in theism, but in all areas. A skeptical, humanistic philosophy pervades the entire text of Lear; I do not believe this is incidental. First, an important distinction must be made. Skepticism is not atheism, and it is not nihilism. By "skepticism" I simply mean the philosophical position whereby all claims and belief systems, particularly, although

The significance of the 'Cogito' for Cartesian and modern philosophy.

2186 words - 9 pages Descartes' 'Cogito' is regarded by many as the birth of modern philosophy. Descartes was born in on the cusp of 17th century in 1596 after the high renaissance had literally rebirth-ed the worlds of the arts, politics and science. Philosophy was largely untainted by this worldwide upheaval initially as medieval scholasticism was still the dominant system studied and taught. Philosophy's renaissance from scholasticism was to come with Descartes

Exploring the Concept of “Self” in Modern Philosophy

1302 words - 5 pages believe that humans are just animals caught in the mechanistic world. However, modern philosophy sheds a positive light and tries to prove the existence of a self. Modern philosophers, Descartes and Hume in particular, draw upon the notion of the transcendental self, thinking self, and the empirical self, self of public life. Hume’s bundle theory serves as a distinction between these two notions here and even when both of these conception in

9. What changes took place in the form, role, nature and availability of education in early-modern England?

2088 words - 8 pages Many changes took place in the Education system in Early-Modern Britain. This paper will firstly discuss the changes to the form of education, how education has moved away from the exclusive realm of private tutorage towards grammar schools and akin. This paper will delve into the role of education and the achievement of a more cultivated youth. The paper will discuss the nature of education and how it evolved into an education with a more

The Birth of Modern European Thought - Study Notes

1998 words - 8 pages journals catering to them often were mediocre.Science at Mid-CenturyIn about 1850 Voltaire would still have felt at home in a general discussion of scientific concepts. The basic Newtonian picture of physical nature that he had popularized still prevailed.Comte, Positivism, and the Prestige of ScienceThe French philosopher Auguste Comte (1798-1857), developed a philosophy of human intellectual development.Comte thought that positive lows of social

Similar Essays

Philosophy Of Knowledge; David Hume's "The Origin Of Our Ideas And Skepticism About Causal Reasoning" And "An Argument Against Skepticism," By John Hospers

529 words - 2 pages David Hume's "The Origin of Our Ideas and Skepticism about Causal Reasoning" states his beliefs about knowledge and his idea that we can only have relative certainty of truth. Skeptics concur that there is not enough evidence to predict the future or prove truth. In "An Argument Against Skepticism," John Hospers argues that we can have absolute certainty because there is enough evidence from the past and from our own experiences to prove an

The Role Of Science, Ethics, And Faith In Modern Philosophy

3577 words - 14 pages The Role of Science, Ethics, and Faith in Modern Philosophy ABSTRACT: Curiously, in the late twentieth century, even agnostic cosmologists like Stephen Hawking—who is often compared with Einstein—pose metascientific questions concerning a Creator and the cosmos, which science per se is unable to answer. Modern science of the brain, e.g. Roger Penrose's Shadows of the Mind (1994), is only beginning to explore the relationship between the

The Philosophy Of Language Essay

2361 words - 10 pages Over the course of the semester we have discussed several interesting philosophers and their theories on the philosophical issues such as, epistemological concerns, the meaning of life, and morality. One approach to the epistemological debate is the context of our language and the meaning of the words we use to claim one’s beliefs as true knowledge. In epistemology and the philosophy of language context seems to play a huge part in our

The Relationship Between Language And Thought, And Assess One Explanation Of The Relationship Between Language And Thought

610 words - 2 pages ?Condition 1: 'smashed' -32% said they saw broken glassCondition 2: 'bumped' - 14% said they saw broken glass.The addition of false details to a memory is called confabulation. The way information leads a person to say a certain bit of information is called a leading question.Sapir ideas helped develop the linguistic relativity hypothesis which states that the form of language influences or determines the structure of our thought processes and affects