Slavery And Freedom In William Shakespeare’s The Tempest

2034 words - 8 pages

Slavery and Freedom in William Shakespeare’s “The Tempest”

The subtly comedic interactions and juxtapositions between masters and slaves in William Shakespeare’s “The Tempest” generate a question which has been the source of much controversy throughout history: are the hierarchical classifications “slave” and “free” reflections of a person’s fundamental nature, or are they social constructions based on bias and self-interest which have nothing to do with absolute truth? This question is crucial because the way that we answer it has the potential to either justify or condemn the widespread practice of enslaving certain individuals. A close look at Shakespeare’s portrayal of masters and slaves in this play suggests that although those who enslave others would like to believe that slave and free are natural categories, they seem to be socially constructed.

In his essay “The Ancient Comic Tradition”, Bernard Knox states that “Slave and free were not so much separate classes as separate worlds: Aristotle could go so far as to claim that they were separate natures” (131). While the concept that slave and free are separate worlds is defensible given the vast differences in lifestyle between the two, the idea that they are separate natures is not a logical extension of this fact, but rather a separate idea altogether. Fundamental nature has nothing to do with one’s political or social situation, but rather one’s innate capabilities, motivations, and morality. Our task, then, is to determine the degree of similarity (or lack thereof) in the innate capabilities, motivations, and morality of the masters and slaves in this play.

Through close examination of Prospero and Caliban, it becomes apparent that although Caliban is a slave and Prospero is his free master, their innate capabilities are nearly identical. One place where similarity is shown is when Caliban, Stephano, and Trinculo are plotting to overthrow Prospero. In the course of their scheming, Caliban advises Stephano and Trinculo to “Remember/ First to possess his books; for without them/ He’s but a sot, as I am; nor Hath one spirit to command: They all do hate him/ As rootedly as I” (3.2: 95-99). Caliban is claiming that Prospero’s power over him is not due to fundamentally superior intellectual capacity, but rather to privileged circumstances which have allowed him to acquire his books on sorcery. The fact that Caliban is under Prospero’s powers would logically give him first-hand information regarding these powers, and because honesty about this information could potentially further his goal of overthrowing Prospero while dishonesty could undermine it, he has no motivation to lie in this instance. For these reasons it seems logical to trust Caliban’s evaluation of Prospero here. This evaluation supports the argument that “slave” and “free” are separate social classifications rather than separate natures, since one’s circumstances are a product of chance and the framework...

Find Another Essay On Slavery and Freedom in William Shakespeare’s The Tempest

Black Magic vs. White Magic in Shakespeare’s The Tempest

585 words - 2 pages Black Magic vs. White Magic in Shakespeare’s The Tempest “A man who governs his passions is “truly wise”…. The heavens have not seen nor has the earth borne a more glorious person than the man who always obeys reason. Not all the crowns of the world can adorn his head fittingly; only eternity can recompense one of such high virtue. To have a quiet soul is the only pleasure of the world” (Anderson 173-4). Where is the line drawn

The Relationship between Slavery and Freedom in Provincial Chesapeake

1256 words - 5 pages The Relationship between Slavery and Freedom in Provincial Chesapeake Edmund S. Morgan has presented an interesting question regarding the question of the colonists' treatment of slavery as a special circumstance, one that is separate from freedom. The promotion of freedom by the Virginia settlers to their own kind, but not to those whose skin was a darker shade, exhibits the tough judgment calls that had to be made to help the colony

Mothers in William Shakespeare's The Tempest

2268 words - 9 pages Mothers in William Shakespeare's The Tempest Although Miranda’s mother and Sycorax never actually appear in The Tempest, their memories occupy a precarious position in Prospero’s will to power. Prospero invokes the memory of Miranda’s mother to legitimize his lineage, yet feels threatened by the control she exerts over it. His narration deftly erases his wife’s presence from Miranda’s memory, rendering him the sole purveyor of his

The Relationship Between Slavery and Freedom

891 words - 4 pages The Relationship Between Slavery and Freedom For Edmund S. Morgan American slavery and American freedom go together hand in hand. Morgan argues that many historians seem to ignore writing about the early development of American freedom simply because it was shaped by the rise of slavery. It seems ironic that while one group of people is trying to break the mold and become liberated, that same group is making others confined and shattering

Post Colonial Interpretations of Shakespeare’s The Tempest

1945 words - 8 pages Americas, was now being explored for its commentary about the inherent dominance and oppression of the natives of the Barbadian islands (the geographical setting of the play), and further as a commentary on slavery and oppression as a whole. The plays main characters, Prospero and Caliban, have come to personify the thrust of the oppressors vs. oppressed debate. In the introduction to Critical Essays on Shakespeare’s ‘The Tempest’, editor Alden T

An Ecological Translation of Shakespeare’s The Tempest

1643 words - 7 pages failure of human innovations. It equally hints at civilization’s rejection of life enhancing qualitative values under the illusion of the advancement directed by sheer anthropocentric acquaintance and materialistic ambitions, which in turn have dehumanized man against Nature’s law. Human abuse and denial of natural freedom gets revealed in the repression and refutation of their instinctual life in quest for documentary rationality in The Tempest

William Shakespeare's The Tempest

2257 words - 9 pages . Mish, Fredrick C., ed. The Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Massachusetts: Merriam-Webster, Inc., 1994. Miller, Naomi J. ed., Reimagining Shakespeare for Children and Young Adults. New York: Routledge, 2003. New American Bible. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops. DC: Confraternity of Christian Doctrine, Inc., 1991. Slights, Jessica. “Rape and the Romanticization of Shakespeare’s Miranda.” SEL: Studies in English Literature (John Hopkins) 41.2 (2001): 357-380. EBSCOhost. UWSP Library. 05 Dec. 2005. Smith, Hallett, ed. Twentieth Century Interpretations of The Tempest. New Jersey: Prentice Hall, Inc, 1969.

William Shakespeare's The Tempest

1888 words - 8 pages William Shakespeare's The Tempest ‘The Tempest’ was Shakespeare’s last major play and is partly based on a true story about a ship called ‘The Seaventure’ which set sail for America in 1609. However, the ship was blown off course by a storm and ended up in Bermuda. This was the time when people were just beginning to explore the world and Bermuda was thought to be inhabited by spirits, demons and monsters. Shakespeare

William Shakespeare's The Tempest

3428 words - 14 pages William Shakespeare's The Tempest Generally acknowledged as one of Shakespeare's final plays, 'The Tempest' may be described as a romantic tragi-comedy - where love and contentment prosper despite the threatening presence of evil forces. However, beyond the almost 'fairy-tale' like exterior lies a seemingly direct approach to a greatly topical debate at the time. This was the supposed contrast between civilised and

A Compare and Contrast Between Characters From Shakespeare’s Macbeth & The Tempest

887 words - 4 pages If you have read through Shakespeare’s plays, you’ll come to realize that many of the characters have similar traits or situations. Although some can be compared to one another, they are also very different in their own ways. The play Macbeth is about a man whose attempts to seize power ruin his life. Tempest is about a man who uses magic to reconcile with his brother of past disagreements. The main characters Macbeth from Macbeth and Prospero

An Analysis between the Father and his Son in William Shakespeare’s Henry IV

1342 words - 5 pages ready for the black belt, then he will reject him. It takes a long time to gain the “sensei’s” trust and achieve his high expectations (“martial art.”) Just like the relationship of the sensei and trainee, in Shakespeare’s Henry IV, Part 1 Hal tries to gain his father’s trust so he can become prince once and for all. However, the king sees Hal as a dishonoured child that is misled by the darkness of the tavern. Of course, Hal shows his father how

Similar Essays

The Characters' Metamorphoses In Shakespeare’s Tempest Universe

4420 words - 18 pages The Characters' Metamorphoses In Shakespeare’s Tempest-Universe In the play The Tempest, Shakespeare provides a unique and alternate universe for his characters to function in on the magical island. In this universe there are both native characters: Prospero, Miranda, Ariel, and Caliban, who have lived on the island previously, and external world characters, namely: Alonso, Ferdinand, Antonio, Sebastian, Stephano, Trinculo, and

Comparing The Cultures Of The Tempest And Ours In The Tempest By William Shakespeare

1106 words - 4 pages Comparing The Cultures of The Tempest and Ours in The Tempest by William Shakespeare "All men are created equal" is one of the declarations that American culture is built on. This declaration means that all men no matter of race, religion, or creed are equals in the eyes of society, as well as the law. This was not always true in history, especially not in Shakespeare's day and age. During this time, society had levels of

The Character Of Caliban In Shakespeare’s The Tempest

850 words - 3 pages The Character of Caliban in Shakespeare’s The Tempest Caliban is one of the most interesting of Shakespeare’s characters. For centuries, scholars have puzzled over the meaning and importance of this central character. Who or what is this creature? Is he a man or a beast (Peterson, p.2)? Most of the people who have debated this question take the question itself at face value. Caliban is either a man or a beast. The other characters in

Shakespeare’s Powerful Use Of Characterization In The Tempest

2540 words - 10 pages Shakespeare’s Powerful use of Characterization in The Tempest In The Tempest, Shakespeare investigates the process of creativity as well as the idea that knowledge is equivalent to power. The Bard draws on both Christian and Aristotelian philosophy to support the premise that morality and creativity are made possible only through the acquisition of knowledge. The characters of Prospero, Ariel, Caliban, and Miranda each represent a