This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Social Desirability And The Manipulation Of Self Concepts. How The Pressures Of Others Can Contribute To A Shift In Self Image.

1743 words - 7 pages

People crave success. Kunda and Sanitioso (1989) stated that our self-concept is malleable, that the desire to be more like others is enough for us to make subtle changes to our self-concept. 102 university students were each assigned to one of two groups. Each group was informed that either extraversion or introversion was responsible for academic success by way of fictitious study. They were then asked to rate the strength of characteristics in themselves. It was found that the extraversion success group rated themselves more highly on a majority of the tests given to them. As Kunda and Sanitioso (1989) found, the extraverted success groups differed in their self-ratings and a majority of the ratings. The extraversion success group rated the extraversion characteristics more highly than did the introverted success group. The extension of this study lead to a significant difference between the two groups rating themselves as more or less similar to another individual. This result suggested that people tend to prefer the company of people like themselves.Introduction:Are self-concepts malleable? Or do people have set views, opinions and desires that we can not change? Kunda and Sanitioso (1989) studied the working self-concept and found it to be relatively malleable (Kunda, Sanitioso and Fong 1990). The example used in their study involved university students and their desire for success. Subjects were told that either introversion or extraversion was responsible for academic success. Subjects were then asked to rate themselves on a scale of one - six on a number of related characteristics. It was hypothesized that extraversion success subjects would rate themselves more highly than introversion success subjects. This was exactly what they found.This study is a replica of the one performed by Kunda and Sanitioso (1989) although it does go one step further. It is hypothesized here that the extraverted success subjects will rate themselves as more similar to the extroverted individuals. It is also hypothesized that the introverted success group would be more likely to rate themselves as less extraverted when compared with the extraversion success groups' ratings.This is a test of the similarity concept in which we desire to be around those who are more like ourselves (Sanitioso, 1998). It has previously been hypothesized that people change their own self-concepts to ensure that they relate well with those around them. There is also pressure to see oneself in a desirable light (Kunda, Sanitioso and Fong, 1990). We know that the self guides behavior. This study focuses on motivated self-concept changes leading to predictable outcomes. In this case the focus is on the shift in ones' self-concept.Method:Subjects:102 students, both male and female, from the University of Melbourne participated in this study. 49 were placed into the introversion success group and 53 were placed into the extraversion success group.Materials:Fictitious report - An article...

Find Another Essay On Social desirability and the manipulation of self-concepts. How the pressures of others can contribute to a shift in self image.

The Self Vs. Others Essay

850 words - 4 pages Henri Frederic Amiel who was a professor of Moral philosophy in Geneva said: “There is no respect for others without humility in one’s self”. American culture has been a significant influence for American literature since it not only has served writers to convey the lives of Americans ancestors, but also to express their thoughts and feelings. Furthermore, American literature shows the “self” with the power exerted by many European Americans

The Effects of Advertising on Self Image

2077 words - 8 pages resonance. According to Jaehee Jung, assistant professor at the University of Delaware, the term self-schema is defined as the beliefs and ideas that people have about themselves. They are said to guide the way a person processes information, especially if the idea or belief is very important to them. A person can either be schematic or aschematic in a certain area. Those who are schematic in an area are greatly concerned with the particular idea

Importance of Self-Image in the Loman Family

1473 words - 6 pages financial difficulties seem insurmountable. The play depicts America as the land of opportunity as well as a place where the society has acquired a new set of values that threatens to destroy those who cannot abide by new changes. This paper discusses the importance of self-image in the Loman family and how the conceptions of self-image fuel the destruction of the characters. To begin with, the plot structure of the play does not follow a

Philosophy Essay On Self: What Role, If Any Do Others Play In The Formation Of Self?

1570 words - 7 pages To many, it may seem others play an important role in the formation of self. When we interact with others, make comparisons with others and live out our social roles we seem to be affected – so we assume that so is the formation of our “self”. In reality, it isn’t affected. With an idealist view of a non-physical self, that also possesses continuity and unity it can be exposed how flawed this view of self is, and how others

The Influence of Self-Assessed Body Image on Confidence and Self-Esteem

2509 words - 10 pages through media influence but friends and family as well (Pavica, 2010). These pressures can affect many different aspects of a person’s life and significantly influence their actions. The aspects affected by body image can include popularity among peers, social comfort, and the attitudes an individual comes to commit to behavior (Lewis & Rosenblum, 1999). Studies of body image in the past have gained varying results as to the groups that are

A Bruised Self Image: An Analysis of Conflict in John Keats' "On Seeing the Elgin Marbles"

1519 words - 6 pages some sort of conflict, they are usually resolved by the volta. However in this sonnet, the arrival of the volta is premature, and its sense of relief is but fleeting: the relief does not continue through till the end. By way of the imagery in reference to mortality, and through the personification of the statues, it can be inferred that the speaker's self image, or as most often is the case with romantic poetry Keats' self image, has been sorely

The Construct of Self through the Influence of Others

2371 words - 9 pages we develop we also have the opportunity to move up or down on the social status ranking based on how supportive or unsupportive our parents were in raising us. Because Teresa had such a great support system from both of her families she was able to move up in social class and redefine her sets of moral, values, and norms. The social institution of family is the most important aspect in the success of an individual, which can be seen through the

The Interrelationship among Self, Others, and Environment

1171 words - 5 pages this form the foundation of social psychology, a field with the primary focus being the systematic study of human cognition, emotion, and actions. Social psychologists seek to understand the way human beings develop thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, as well as, the effect our environment, mainly our interactions with others, has on the formation of these very things. We can divide social psychology into three main categories: self, others, and

What role, if any, do others play in the formation of the self?

748 words - 3 pages identity; a) the self and b) our perception of this self. It is with the combination of the two influences that our behavior and such is determined.I argue that the self image is purely created by social forces - self image is the way in which I perceive myself, and how can we perceive unique aspects about us, without comparing us to others? It seems contradictory for us to be able to discover something unique about ourselves without involving

Liars and Self Image

1001 words - 5 pages admit I had a problem, let alone allow anyone to help.” (Hornbacher 4) Many children are like this. They try so hard to be flawless when no one can be perfect. A study showed that “Girls are more focused on their looks than what they eat or how much they exercise.” (McBride 2) People lie to themselves and others to preserve their self-image for reasons that are unknown to the outside world. All we can do is speculate. There are a few factors that we know. Their families, the media, the community, their emotional reactions all play a huge part in a child’s self-image.

Liars and Self-Image

988 words - 4 pages had a problem, let alone allow anyone to help.” (Hornbacher 4) Many children are like this. They try so hard to be perfect when no one can be perfect. A study showed that “Girls are more focused on their looks than what they eat or how much they exercise.” (McBride 2) People lie to themselves and others to preserve their self-image for reasons that are unknown to the outside world. All we can do is speculate. There are a few factors that we know for sure. Their families, the media, the community, their emotional reactions all play a huge part in a child’s self-image.

Similar Essays

The Principal Approach To Perception Of Self And Others & What Can Assist Someone To Be A Qualified Manager

1650 words - 7 pages The principal approach to Perception of self and others & what can assist someone to be a qualified managerEveryone has his own world, his unique way to understand and evaluate the environment and the people within it. 'The situation may be the same but the interpretation of that situation by two individuals may be vastly different.'(Mullins, 1999, P.377)No two individuals can perceive the same thing in the same way. For example, a new

Self Image And Judging Others Essay

954 words - 4 pages Self Image and Judging Others Would you rather be called good-looking or attractive? Is there a difference between a good looking and attractive person? To many probably not but I believe there's a thin line that separates those two words. A person might be very good-looking yet not attractive. How is that possible one might ask? Well the answer is very simple; it all depends on the attitude and personality. While working at

The Decline Of Self Image In Women

1217 words - 5 pages dissatisfaction with their internal body image. The decline of self-image in women can be directly linked to several contributing factors including: film and print advertising, social media, and the early exposure of adolescent girls to overly-sexualized products and media. “Sex sells” is an aphorism closely adhered to by both the film and print advertising industries. For over a century, magazines, newspapers, film, and other advertising mediums have

You Can Be Anything You Want To Be: How Self Image Effects Quality Of Life

947 words - 4 pages You Can Be Anything We Want You to Be It is a known fact that one’s physiology and sociology affects one’s psychology, but there are many different factors that lead to different outcomes. The way one appears to others and self-image has a major role in the way one behaves, as well as the greatest factor the quality of one’s life (e.g., Economic status, community, (slums or suburbs) and nationality). I believe that the stereotypes society