Social Promotion Or Retention: The Only Choices For Failing Students?

1285 words - 5 pages

Social Promotion or Retention: The Only choices for failing students?

How to help students who fail, or students who do not achieve up to a certain academic standard, is an issue that probably goes back to the beginning of levels of school for students to progress through. In the U.S. it goes back to the 1840’s where age-graded schools began. In those times children who did not meet a certain standard were retained, or they repeated that grade. Rates of grade retention are difficult to trace in the past as well as currently. In some of these illustrative examples, a state could reduce retention by half in thirty years. However, different states had different retention rates. In 1909 one Massachusetts school district had a 7.5% retention rate while a Tennessee had a 75.8%. “In the 1930’s educators recognized that grade repetition might endanger student’s social and emotional development, which gave rise to the practice of social promotion. As a result of this policy, students were passed on to the next grade even if they were not ready for the work.” (Alkin, 1114) Both social promotion and retention intend to rectify the problem of failing students. However, does either of these two methods succeed? If they do not then what does?

Retention is the process of keeping students at the grade they fail. However, according to Donald R. Moore, the executive director of Designs for Change, a Chicago non-profit group that strives to improve schools, “It’s a politically popular initiative, but it harms kids in the long term.” (Gewertz, 1, 13 2002) talking about repeating the same grade. Holding students back a grade without changing the instructional strategies is ineffective. Much evidence suggests that the achievement of retained students still lags behind that of their peers after repeating a grade, making it an ineffective strategy for enabling students to catch up.” (Riley, 1999) Also it increases the likelihood of dropping out of school. So much so that if a person is held back twice it is almost certain they will drop out. A University of Georgia study helps prove this point. It involved over 11,000 students and concluded that repeating a year has a negative effect on a student’s performance. It also showed that the students tend to fall farther behind during the second year which could explain why they rarely graduate. “Retained children are 20 to 30 percent more likely to drop out of school when compared to low achieves who are allowed to move to the next grade.” (McBrien) states Lynn McBrien a former editor-in-chief of Education Today and a vice-president of corporate development for the National Reading Styles Institute. There are other studies that state the similar things.

Due to these and possible more reasons the idea of social promotion was implemented in some areas. Social promotion is the passing of students who fail to meet the criteria for passing. It’s called “social” because it is often used with the student’s social and...

Find Another Essay On Social Promotion or Retention: The Only choices for failing students?

Perception of 4th Year ECE Students to the Implications of the Proposed Abolishment of the Retention Grade

1687 words - 7 pages pressured to implement policies designed to “end social promotion,” students are threatened with retention if they do not meet academic standards or perform above specified percentiles on standardized tests.” Retention grade gives an effect to the mental health of students which can give students more pressure regarding their educational achievement. This study covers only the opinion of the 4th year ECE students in the capabilities of the future

Discuss whether Facebook is an effective medium for product promotion or not.

1131 words - 5 pages With the increasing universality of social network, it is not only a new medium to make friends, but also a way for business entities to promote their commodities.  More customers can recognize the brand as well as the latest products.  People, however, are riddled with overmuch advertisement which becomes disturbance and even computer virus.  Therefore, both for’s and against of social networking advertisement should be considered so as to

The Effects of Social Media on Students

997 words - 4 pages them to view the relationships they share with others differently. Not only does social media affect relationships, it also distracts others from what they are doing.Many people can say that social media is one of the most common ways of a distraction for students. It has an effect that is both harmful to the productivity of students and has been proven to decrease the student's grades academically. Networks such as Instagram, Twitter, or

Heterogeneous or Ability Grouping: What is Best for ALL Students

1930 words - 8 pages achievements gap. (Gamoran, A. 2009) Another issue that can be found in the tracking of students is the reinforcement of social inequality. Test scores of minority students that qualify for a higher track are just as likely to be placed in the high track as any student. However, minority students also tend to enter high school with lower test scores. The lower test scores then place these students in the lower-track, which will lead into a setting for

Online Degree Programs: The Only Option for Busy Adult Learners

2633 words - 11 pages than ten years, but for life experience such as training at work, occupational skills, and having had a career. By rewarding the students for their natural abilities and by adapting the curriculum to their needs, CPU remains successful in retaining such students. Motivations for learning in adult learners may also contribute to retention. Cantor (1992) stated that, adult learners want "to make or maintain social relationships, meet external

On the Roman Baths:Did the Romans only use the baths to get clean or were there political and social motivations behind the number of romans regularly going to the baths?"

3287 words - 13 pages allow to bathe together (2) but these were avoidable for any Roman who knew his city well.One source (3) says,'Socially the Baths were an important meeting and mixing place. Everyone had his favourite Baths just as every Englishman has his favourite public house'.This comparison of the Baths and a modern pub leads to the question my coursework examines:'Did the Romans only use the Baths to get clean or were there political and social motivations

"The most powerful characters in The Odyssey are women." Argue for or against this proposition using examples from the text; please limit evidence to two or three episodes only.

1179 words - 5 pages "The most powerful characters in The Odyssey are women." Argue for or against this proposition using examples from the text; please limit evidence to two or three episodes only.The word powerful can be looked at in several ways; it can be regarded as strength, knowledge, control, and beauty. All these forms of power are repeatedly illustrated within The Odyssey. A key observation with respect to power is that women are undoubtedly the most

Cosmetic Surgery - No Longer Only For the Rich and Famous

1431 words - 6 pages stretching (Cosemetic Proceedures: Scars, 2010). Although many people are concerned with even the tiniest flaw to mar their appearance, there are some children and even adults who retreat from social contact because of facial deformities and/or other forms of deformities that can only be changed through surgery (Magee, 2010). In 1981, Operation Smile was formed when Kathleen Magee and her husband, Dr. William Magee visited the Philippines

The SAT Test for College Students

2608 words - 11 pages to just simply the SAT in most recent years (Gilroy). Though the SAT went through an identity crisis, the SAT was originally formed to give students that were not of the elite private high schools an opportunity to show their skills and attend selective colleges. In recent years the SAT seems to be exclusively filtering only socially and financially elite students into elite schools, failing at its original purpose. The test in general has had

Homeschooling is the choice for students.

1304 words - 5 pages The alarm clock rings at eight in the morning for Michael to wake up to start his day. Yet, he turns and twists around, ended up pressing the snooze button about five or six more times. Now, you might assume that Michael will be late for school and miss the bus. Thankfully, his mother calmly wakes him up in time to have breakfast, the most important meal of the day. Then after breakfast his school day will begins. Nevertheless, the only

The Benefits of Aromatherapy for Students

1943 words - 8 pages and antimicrobial purposes rather than for aromatherapy (Gülçin et al., 2004). Limitations There were several limitations to this study. The first was the small sample size that was limited to a specific population of participants, which decreased the study’s validity related to the overall population. By only sampling a small group of nursing students the research cannot be generalized. Another limitation was the time given to participants

Similar Essays

Social Promotion Vs. Retention Essay

2016 words - 8 pages specialist to help students with reading and create flexible scheduling more students should succeed. Although we can only help students who want to learn perhaps these efforts early on will encourage students to want to learn. The earlier we start the better chance we have. In conclusion I am still faced with decision of social promotion or retention. I have always been a firm believer in grade retention but I never knew the affects of it

Social Promotion: A Dead End On The Road To Success

2220 words - 9 pages retention and social promotion create long term problems in which the students left behind must fight against for the rest of their lives. Several districts and states have ended the practice of social promotion. New York and Chicago both took steps to end social promotion. A study by the RAND Corporation found that no negative effects of retention on students’ sense of school belonging or confidence in mathematics and reading over time (McCombs

The Internet: Helpful Or Harmful For Social Interaction?

2086 words - 8 pages relationships in real life by allowing one to communicate with others more easily and readily. The use of the internet can expand ones social range. However, if relied on too heavily, it can lead to dependence on the social website as one of the only means of communication a person has and can lead to social isolation. Feelings of like and/or dislike can be determined over the internet towards a person and a small connection can be made, however

The Internet: Helpful Or Harmful For Social Interaction?

1076 words - 4 pages Introduction The Internet: Helpful or Harmful for Social Interaction? Tonight our main topic is interaction through Social Media websites via the Internet. People can become instantly connected with other individuals through texting, messaging, and on social networking websites on the Internet. The question is, however, whether these instant connections are helpful or harmful to social interaction? Some say yes and some say no. These