This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Society Must Be Governed By Rules

1719 words - 7 pages

Society Must be Governed by Rules

According to Sober, "Utilitarianism is an ethical theory whose central idea is 'the greatest good for the greatest number'" (Sober 430). Utilitarianism rose in opposition to the idea that the upper crust of society had the right to arrange the rules of society as they saw fit. The concern of Utilitarianism is the most good for the most people, not the most good for the people that "matter." From this standpoint, Utilitarianism appears to be an attractive ethical theory. However, there are many philosophers who criticize Utilitarianism. They argue that the apparently simple premise of Utilitarianism has many complex problems behind it. For example, what is happiness? How can we ensure the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people? And what happens if acting for the greatest good for the greatest number leads to injustice? I believe that a specific variation of Utilitarianism -- Rule Utilitarianism -- can adequately address these problems, and it is therefore the most plausible ethical theory.
Rule Utilitarianism is derived from the basic Utilitarian principle of the greatest good for the greatest number. However, where Act Utilitarianism addresses each individual action or situation in reference to this principle, Rule Utilitarianism states that we must use the Utilitarian principle to define the rules that regulate society. Many of the rules of modern society have derived in this manner. For example, it would not benefit the most people if murder were allowed by society. No matter how beneficial a murder might be for one individual, society would not benefit from murder being allowed, and therefore Rule Utilitarianism supports the idea that murder is wrong. However, society does benefit from murdering people who are dangerous to society -- those who murder other people. Therefore, Rule Utilitarianism can also be used to support the idea of capital punishment, even as it opposes murder. Rule Utilitarianism is an offspring of Utilitarianism; however, instead of using the utilitarian principle to examine whether an action is ethical on an individual basis, Rule Utilitarianism uses this principle to formulate rules to govern society. Therefore, Rule Utilitarianism is a very realistic ethical theory. Modern society is not governed by one overriding principle, as Utilitarianism would suggest. Society is governed by rules, and Rule Utilitarianism would allow society to formulate rules with the greatest good for the greatest number in mind.
Elliot Sober presents one objection to Utilitarianism in what he calls, "The Case of the Lonely Stranger." Sober presents a situation in which a sheriff in a town where a murder has occurred knows that the murderer is dead, and knows the town will riot soon if a suspect is not arrested. The sheriff also knows that the town will not believe him if he tells them that the murderer is dead. The sheriff is then presented with a stranger with no...

Find Another Essay On Society Must be Governed by Rules

Rules of Society In the Lord of Flies by William Golding

818 words - 3 pages that they always had within them. Without any rules to hold a society together, it will soon be corrupted and fall apart, leaving the people to become less human, and resorting to savagery. Without any enforcement of the rules set by the boys on the island, they lose sight of the most important things, and prefer to spill the blood and guts of animals for meat. Rather than maintain a fire to be rescued by a ship, they chose the path of painted faces and bloodlust.

The Stolen Generation needs To be Recognised by Australian Society

751 words - 3 pages Hypothesis: We cannot say sorry for the stolen generation, but the damage that it has caused to the indigenous society must be recognized.Reconciliation, apologies and the stolen generation, all these words are past reminders of the serious wrongs that have been committed. Good morning/afternoon, today I will explore these wrongs and show how they should be solved.The term stolen generation is the name given to aboriginals, usually those with

"It might be thought that UK police discretion is tightly constrained by legal rules. At times it is but more frequently it is not" Discuss in the context of Stop and Search

3419 words - 14 pages expedient method of protecting society against the terrorist threat. The reasonable suspicion that someone is a terrorist must surely only come from intelligence as even the most inept terrorist would not walk around advertising that they were so. This would raise, therefore, the question, on what grounds an officer on the street would suspect, reasonably, that a person could be a terrorist for the purposes of S. 43(1). By the colour of their skin

Animal farm by george orwell. essay must be more than 750 words.explain and express values of the quotation "all animals are equal but some are more equal than others."

893 words - 4 pages . Weak or strong, clever or simple, we are all brothers. No animal must kill any other animal. All animals are equal" (pg 6). This is an example of irony because all these rules that Old Major has made; all of them are broken by Napoleon or any of the other pigs.An allegory is a story with two meanings; a true meaning and a symbolic meaning. The true meaning in 'Animal Farm' is that the animals are able to talk and have a mind of their own

"The Quiet American" by Graham Greene: "In order to understand events clearly we must observe them at close range." How far does the novel show this to be true?

676 words - 3 pages The novel, “The Quiet American”, demonstrates that in order to understand events clearly, something more than just observation at “close range” is required. It shows that interpretation, wisdom and experience must be present to allow a clear view of such events as those occurring within the novel. This is shown in a comparison between Fowler and Pyle and how they react to various situations. The novel also demonstrates that

Thoughts and Notes on Dicken's portrait of Industrial Society in his novel "Hard Times" by Charles Dickens. Good starting point. Includes quotes + refs which may be helpful

1423 words - 6 pages would "carpet your room - or your husband's room, if you were a grown woman, and had a husband - with representations of flowers" (p. 13). Sissy does not waver and states that she would because she is fond of flowers. He then goes on to give a pompous speech about how all things need to be governed and regulated by fact, and the ills of fancy. A good quote to illustrate his smugness is "You don't find foreign birds and butterflies come and perch of

Describe how analogue to digital will affect the system from a technological point of view, and discuss more widely how society might be affected by these changes

829 words - 3 pages It has been claimed that 'television has altered our world. In the same way people often speak of a new world, a new society, a new phrase of history, being created- 'brought about'- by this new technology' . Television wowed society when it was originally created as for the first time we were able to enjoy visual entertainment in the confinements of our own homes. At that time television only displayed two channels and transmitted simply to

"Outsiders are victims of themselves and society" What is your view? use the texts you have studied ("The Floating World" by John Romeril and "Death Be Not Proud" by John Donne)and one other text

1365 words - 5 pages surrealcomic tragedy "The Floating World" he uses a narrator to relate his thoughts about thedegeneration of Australian society to the audience, using Les Harding's disintegratingsanity as a metaphor for this. Romeril portrays Les as a victim of society's materialismand of the effects of war. John Donne paints death as an outsider in his metaphysicalpoem "Death Be Not Proud" by rebelling against the traditional forms of a sonnet andusing three

[ENGLISH]A good man/woman does not need to be perfect to leave his/ her mark on society. Discuss in relation to at least two characters in The Crucible by Arthur Miller

687 words - 3 pages A good man/woman does not need to be perfect to leave his/ her mark on society. Discuss in relation to at least two characters in The Crucible by Arthur Miller.One of the main issues Miller introduces in The Crucible is that a man or woman does not have to be perfect to be recognized and leave their mark on society. In his play, Miller contrasts both negative and positive effects certain people have on their society. To display these things in

Chivalry, Politically Incorrect? <Tab/>Who would have thought that chivalry, a sense of justice, and honor above all else would be accosted by a modern society and the legal system?

782 words - 3 pages Chivalry, Politically Incorrect?Who would have thought that chivalry, the idealization of virtue, military courtesy, a sense of justice, unconditional devotion, and honor above all else would be accosted by a modern society and the legal system? Who would accuse the medieval King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table principles as unjust or thought of as an object of scorn? Present day American society, that's who would dare to attack such a

Types of Legitimacy and How Normative and Regulative Legitimacy Is Managed

1259 words - 5 pages should be exempt from some of the laws. In some cases “powerful organizations attempt to build their goals and procedures directly into society as institutional rules” (Meyer and Rowan 348). If an organization is forced to adopt rules that are in opposition to another rule, which they are required to follow, they overcome this by only loosely coupling “their formal structures and actual work activities” and by not checking up on or paying

Similar Essays

Title Ix Must Be Tailored For Today's Society

2093 words - 9 pages justifiable evidence, and passionate fervor, male athletes across America are declaring that Title IX is synonymous with injustice. Title IX was necessary in 1972, but it is now outdated and hindering male athletics. Two conflicting arguments, both with substantial claim, leave room for all but one solution. Title IX, although once successful, must be tailored for today’s society. Known as a “three-prong test” (Green, 2014) Title IX requires that a

The Idea That Each Person In Society Must Be Free And Able To Express His/Her Opinions Taken From "On Liberty" By John Stuart Mill

1153 words - 5 pages liberties and their rights are being violated by an overzealous government. Mill recognized this problem and published an essay titled "On Liberty", in 1859, which spoke of the idea that each person in society must be free and able to express his/her opinions. Contrary to Mill's beliefs, Edmund Burke, another political philosopher, stated that to have order and less chaos, a monarchial government is necessary. He argued that there would be less

To What Extent Could It Be Argued That An Individual’s Response To Ill Health Is Governed By His/Her Social Identity?

1670 words - 7 pages illness. This may be because in society from the time people are born they are taught a "normal" role in society, firstly by parents and then by schools, media etc, which gives them a stereotypical role that is expected of them, because of this it is much excepted in society that women can go to the doctors more because they are a weaker sex, where a man is expected to be masculine and accept illness. It could also be said that men mostly work in

Society And Culture Content Analysis Of "The Gods Must Be Crazy"

2183 words - 9 pages resulting in the involvement of an aspect of another concept (e.g. a confined environment), with this all happening over a period of time. The movie 'The Gods must be crazy' has thus raised a great number of points relating to the courses in Society and Culture as well as being an amusing and thought provoking piece of entertainment produced by Western society for their entertainment, with cinematography and its enjoyment being an aspect of Western culture.Bibliography:"The Gods Must Be Crazy" movie