Sociological Analysis Of The Media

2149 words - 9 pages

Sociological Analysis of the Media

In our society today, control is maintained by the authorities through regulation. In North America, major regulatory systems comprise two main systems of expertise. One is the criminal justice system, which is concerned with what will we do about crime and deviance. The other is the academic system of expertise, which is concerned with why crime and deviance exists. Academic expertise is the type of discourse deployed in the article by Michael Conlon to show, with ostensible authority, that maternal smoking during pregnancy is “linked” to adult criminal behaviour.
By using a recently published study, the article sets up the system of expertise to lend credibility to its headline and make a very persuasive (at first glance) claim. Scientists have high credibility and prestige in our society, and the article plays greatly on this assumption.
The key idea of the article is that criminal males are the product of mothers who smoked during pregnancy. The fallacy of affirming the consequent is evidenced in this statement when a closer look at the clarification of the meaning of the premise, and its significance, is made. To seriously answer questions of cause and consequent, the reader must assemble (“accurately”) measured covariables and variables and draw reliable conclusions from them. While the researchers of this data present certain conclusions, these conclusions may not necessarily be reflected in the media report. The media is capable of manipulating the information from the research report in order to support their own biases or beliefs.
In the year 2000, smoking has fallen out of public favour and is seen as an undesirable social and physical health habit; many cities across Canada have banned smoking in all indoor, and in some cases in certain outdoor, areas. This article accurately reflects the general public opinion that smoking is “bad”, but it does not necessarily accurately reflect the results of the main study it is citing, but rather could be using only parts of the study to support the evil-causes-evil fallacy, i.e., smoking causes criminal behaviour.
There are also some reporting problems in the article regarding the applicability of the the study’s findings. The sample of the study was taken from several small, affluent Western European countries, where poverty is low, compared to many larger industrialised nations such as Canada, and where minorities make up a very small part of the population (i.e., it is mainly a white society) . Another incongruity is evident in the reporter’s assembling of data; the reporter cites a study done in Western Europe, based on western European data, but also quotes North American researchers, who confirm that the link between the independent variable (smoking) and the dependent variable (adult male deviance) exists. Thus the validity of the conclusion the article puts forth is questionable, as it may not be generalizable...

Find Another Essay On Sociological Analysis of the Media

Sociological Analysis of Scientology

8080 words - 32 pages often held in a negative light. Unlike those movements, Scientology thoroughly embraces these aspects of the modern world. Rather than rejecting the norms of society, Scientology provides its followers with knowledge and techniques that ensure success within modern society. Bryan Wilson deems such religious movements as manipulationist in his sociological analysis of religious sects. He also describes these movements as often bureaucratic

Deviance and the Sociological Analysis of The Godfather Part I

2415 words - 10 pages Fejzoski 1 Sabrije Fejzoski Mrs. Rath Sociology 15 October 2013 Deviance and the Sociological Analysis of The Godfather Part I In Mario Puzo's The Godfather Part I, the Corleone family demonstrates deviance when one compares it to the society that contains no organized crime influence. Deviance is also shown through different members of the family as well as other characters introduced throughout the course of the movie. By watching the

Film: "The Color Purple" - Sociological Analysis.

702 words - 3 pages she had not learned these skills, she would not have been succesful as an indepented woman.The system theory, symbolic interactionism, and the social exchange theory explain the actions of the characters in the story very well, within a sociological perspective. Celies's family was a system with many subgroups and she was probably the most important member of the family. Her perceptions of life, which where imprinted on her from a young age, shaped

The Sociological Aspect of Obesity

7097 words - 28 pages The Sociological Aspect of Obesity ABSTRACT Much has been written to explain the medical aspect of obesity but little attention has been paid to understanding the sociological aspect of the epidemic. This research attempts to understand the sociological aspect of obesity by examining the socio-cultural, gender, and psycho-social effects and includes the different perceptions of the epidemic as well as what is deemed acceptable in the

Media analysis of propaganda

2647 words - 11 pages of the effects of propaganda administered on such a massive scale. The public was never peppered with all these different forms of mass media, all promoting the same message, all the time about the enemy.Because this war was the first war waged with the use of technology, such as radio, cinema, newspapers and others the public was not aware to effects that these all play in coherence with the same message. When the public hears lies that all

The Sociological Complexities of the Taliban

542 words - 2 pages Due to the ethnocentrism of American culture and ideas, the tribal group known as the Taliban may seem like a sociological disgrace to law-abiding citizens of the United States. The Taliban is made up of Pakistanis and Afghans who are said to be the “Holy Warriors of Allah” and rigidly adhere to a set of standards set out by the prophet Mohammed himself. They are considered one of the most radical groups that exist in the world today and are

A Sociological Analysis of Ron Howards Apollo 13

1742 words - 7 pages rescue of the Apollo 13 crew really showed traits similar to those found in any three of the major sociological perspectives: functionalist, symbolic interactionism, and conflict. On one hand, it can be seen that NASA is a large structure formed of many smaller structures that keep is going. The government funds NASA, NASA hires crew to build and fly the ships and the different crews do their separate parts to come together as a whole and make it

Sociological Analysis of a Naturally Occuring Conversation Between Two People

3388 words - 14 pages In this assignment, I will be conducting a Sociological analysis of a piece of naturally occurring interaction between two people. I will complete this by doing a transcription the piece of interaction using the work of Harvey Sacks and his work on conversation analysis. For this the piece of interaction I have used is that off a radio station. This involves George Galloway hosting his programme on Talk Sport and having a debate with a male who

The Sociological Framework of Harriet Martineau

1113 words - 4 pages ," Pichanick observes (111). Martineau's technique--as Rizter'--results in an expression of interpretation that leaps over the obstacles of theoretical approach by intertwining sociological analysis theory into a forward-moving dynamic. Ritzer, in both The McDonaldization of Society and Expressing America: A Critique of the Global Credit Card Society, shows evidence of application of Max Weber's rationalization process, for example, as well as

Comparison of the Three Major Sociological Theories

1817 words - 7 pages canbe characterized as an external relationship, firstly because the object is controlledby the subject, and secondly becasue the knoweldge acquired by the subject inorder to explain the behavings of the object does not influence the behavings of theobject.While effective for the external analysis, positivism is lacking in explaining socialbehavior.Probably, the biggest problem in utilizing positivism in a sociological setting is thedifficulty

The Sociological Criticism of Alice Walker

1786 words - 7 pages . Furthermore, her stories mirror a lot of the social characteristic that were taking place in America, from the 1940’s on; thus, making Alice Walker the epitome of sociological criticisms. According to the bibliography portion of “The Color Purple” by Alice Walker, Alice was born in Georgia and attended Spellman College before transferring to Sarah Lawrence College in New York. Her first work was a book of poetry that was published while she

Similar Essays

The Sociological Impact Of Media Body Induced Image On Women

2132 words - 9 pages In recent years, sociologists, psychologists, and medical experts have gone to great lengths about the growing problem of body image. This literature review examines the sociological impact of media-induced body image on women, specifically women under the age of 18. Although most individuals make light of the ideal body image most will agree that today’s pop-culture is inherently hurting the youth by representing false images and unhealthy

Constructing Crime In The Media, By Way Of The Sociological Constructionist Perspective

2843 words - 11 pages CONSTRUCTING CRIME IN THE MEDIA: THE SOCIALOGICAL CONTRUCTIONIST PERSPECTIVE ON THE INFLUENCE OF MEDIA ON THE PERCEPTION OF CRIMEINTRODUCTION "Anti-Social Behaviour On the Rise. Can Anything Be Done?", "We're Still the Break in Capital of Canada", "Hail of Bullets Wounds Passenger", and "Gang Attacks Prompt Warnings" are just a few of the headlines we see plastered on newspapers and repeated relentlessly throughout the nightly news. The amount

Why Is The Study Of Consumption Central To How We Understand How The Media Works? Examining Sociological Issues Surrounding Media And Consumption.

948 words - 4 pages "Why is the study of consumption central to how we understandhow the media works?"The study of consumption is essential to understanding how the media works because all media are consumed in a particular way. Therefore, understanding how and why different media are consumed is essential in learning why different types of media are successful or not.In order to understand consumerism we first of all need to understand the consumer. Unlike the

'the Hypodermic Syringe Model Sees The Media Audience As Passive And Easily Influenced And Manipulated By The Mass Media.' Assess This,Referring To Sociological Evidence And Arguments.

1296 words - 5 pages it also agrees with the two step flow theory's focus on the importance of social relationships: messages are interpreted according to social grouping, for example gender, ethnicity or sexual orientation. Because of the variety of scope for individual analysis, measuring the effects on people using the Cultural Effects theory is difficult, especially since a range of other, more personal factors such as past experience can also affect media