This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Socrates' Fight For Justice Essay

1233 words - 5 pages

In Plato’s works Apology and Crito there is an attempt by Socrates to defend himself in court and defend his choice to receive the death penalty when found guilty. Although he makes very valid and strong arguments throughout one can only wonder why such a wise person would choose death over life. The following essay will analyze three quotes from Apology and Crito, find the correlation between them, and reveal any flaws that may exsist inside these arguments made by Socrates.
In Plato’s Apology Socrates explains to the jury the reasons he should be found not guilty against his accused crimes. Although none of the accusations have any true merit Socrates is forced into the courtroom. During his defense Socrates states, “A man who really fights for justice must lead a private, not a public, life if he is to survive even a short time (Cahn pg. 36 Apology 32a1).” Socrates is arguing that anybody that wants to truly fight for justice must stay out of the public eye, and out of politics due to its corrupt nature. To back this claim Socrates follows with two examples of his past, one being, “I served as a member of our tribe, and our council was trying the ten generals who failed to pick up the survivors of a naval battle. This was illegal, as you all recognized later. I was the only member to oppose and I voted against it. The orators were ready to prosecute me and take me away (Cahn pg. 37 Apology 32b1-9).” Socrates gave the readers explicit examples of members of a political committee acting unjustly and attempting to punch those who do not follow along with their agenda. Anybody that has ever been a part of a social group that makes decisions, whether it is political or not, has most likely ran into this issue. As acknowledged by Dougal Blyth, “the Apology shows that, despite his intentions, Socrates ultimately could not avoid public political activity (Blyth).” People of power tend to follow their own agendas and are willing to punish anyone that gets in their way. Socrates would rather be punished or die before he breaks the laws that were set forth by his state, and this he says later in the same passage, “I should run any risk on the side of law and justice rather than join you. (Cahn pg. 38 Apology b10-c2).”
Socrates is eventually found guilty and is to fight no longer for his innocence, but against a penalty of death. As Socrates speaks to the jury he begins to speak more of the meanings of life opposed to the need for life. He claims, “it is the greatest good for a man to discuss virtue every day and those other things about which you hear me conversing and testing myself and others, for the unexamined life is not worth living for men.. (Cahn pg. Apology39 38a1-4).” Although Socrates never explicitly states why he feels this way, but upon reading this statement and analyzing its context one can grasp a sense of this argument. Socrates is arguing that life is unlived if it is not questioned and our thoughts are not examined. He understands...

Find Another Essay On Socrates' Fight for Justice


778 words - 3 pages 1CompeanKrystyne CompeanPhilosophy 1301July 13, 2014ESSAY ONEIn the beginning of Euthyphro, Socrates does not present his own account of piety. I He is asking for Euthyphro's definition of the word to help him understand so that he can use it for his own benefit in trial. "Tell me then, what is pious, and what the impious, do you say" (Plato, Euthyphro, Grube)? Euthyphro says, "I say that the pious is to do what I am doing now, to prosecute the

Writing Assignment 2

2041 words - 9 pages agree that the education of the philosopher’s make better rulers than any other individual./ Before looking at the role of education in a just society, justice must first be defined. Socrates argues to Glaucon that “Justice will be admitted to be the having and doing what is a man’s own and belongs to him.” Socrates believes that being just means, in short, minding one’s own business and not getting involved in another’s work. For example, Socrates

Socrates's Philosophizing

658 words - 3 pages Socrates" have taught those whom choose to seek wisdom.Socrates was a sophist for his time. The "The trail and death of Socrates" starts outside the king's court. Euthyphro, a professional priest, initiates a conversation with Socrates. Euthypro is going to the court to place charges upon his own father. Socrates in great shock, after hearing the plan of Euthyphro, attempts to enlighten him explaining righteous philosophy. In accent Greek society

Aristophanes’ Clouds a Satyr Play Written in 419 BCE

1337 words - 5 pages be read as a warning to Socrates. Aristophanes is a “friendly critic” of Socrates and warns Socrates to change his ways for Athens and for the good of himself (Whidden). Plato’s Symposium and especially his Apology of Socrates does not discount the claims made in Clouds about the dangers of philosophy and Socrates to the public, even if Plato’s Socrates is less exaggeratedly flawed than the Socrates in Clouds. In Apology, Socrates takes

The Ethical Egoist: What's the problem

1033 words - 5 pages . Whereas Socrates, or Plato, argues that being just and good is essential to eudaimonia. This counters with the ethical egoist who believes that being just is not in the business of self-interest and therefore not good for eudaimonia. Socrates states, "Justice, although it resembles a mirage, is really concerned with internal rather than external activity - with the true self and its business” (Plato, 443C). This is important in understanding

The Overlooked Gift of Knowledge

1019 words - 5 pages , and other strategic ways to win difficult arguments. This also included coming up with facts, rather than relying on opinions to win arguments. Socrates also encouraged his students to think independently and for themselves. This is something that was lacking in Athenian youth before Socrates. Socrates felt that you can spark a change in people if you think about ethics, justice, politics, morals, and how to better the world around you. These

Orwell and Plato: Comparison of the Hero Figure

660 words - 3 pages Socrates and Winston both have similarities in their pursuit for the truth and response to their treatment of death but have different views on ethics in society. In 1984, Winston pursued truth and justice because he wanted freedom from the Party. In The Apology, Socrates seek justice or sense of truth so that the people of Athens have the freedom to expand their knowledge and produce their own truth. The similarities between Winston and

Plato's The Crito

1200 words - 5 pages escape his death sentence, he chose not to do so because he had a moral obligation to commit a sacrifice. Socrates was being guided by his moral beliefs when he decided not to escape from prison. Socrates informs us of his principle when he says, “[…] my first principle, that neither injury nor retaliation not warding off evil by evil is ever right.”(1). Retaliation and injuring other people is what Socrates did not lived by. For this

Plato's Republic Justified

1423 words - 6 pages rulers, Socrates hypothesizes that they "must be the best of the guardians" (412c) and hence "the ones who are best at guarding the city" (412c). The rulers need to be knowledgeable, not easily deceived, care for the city greatly, and pursue what is most advantageous to the city. The producers of the city are not discussed as in depth as the other two classes. Socrates wants to wait until justice has been isolated before delving into the

The Death Of Socrates

515 words - 2 pages The Death of Socrates By viewing the painting The Death of Socrates by Jacques-Louis David, Socrates? loyalty to the Athenian government was far more important to him than his own death or friendship. He was more interested in teaching his students about his belief in reason and the law of justice before he died. Still, the students and friends were arguing with him and trying to convince him to renounce his teachings. Socrates was strong in

The Death Of Socrates

556 words - 2 pages in justice and loyalty to the government. This was very devastating to his friends. Indeed, this painting was, and still is so dramatic! To think that one's beliefs can be so concrete that they would pay the price with their life shows complete integrity. Socrates was tremendously brave to drink the poison and die instead of fleeing with his friends. The respect he must have had for his government is beyond belief. By drinking the hemlock

Similar Essays

Nelson Mandela’s Fight For South African’s Justice

1939 words - 8 pages that Black people would have to work as sharecroppers and live separately from the White people.4 The ANC hoped to help Black people unite and gain power against these white men’s torture. The Congress also conducted protests to fight for participation in the government, and to reduce taxes for Black workers. Many men and women joined happily, but their protests didn’t last long. 5 White men created apartheid after WWII, giving the African people

The Dilemma In Defining Good Judgement, And Justice, In Socrates' Definition For Justice

701 words - 3 pages how a just person would act in different situations. Socrates' definition fails to give a clear description of justice that is practically applicable to all moral situations. 'Each part doing its job and only its job' does not show us what justice is because it cannot predict a person's behaviour. We are unable to predict a person's behaviour with this definition until we know how reason makes judgements. Sometimes It is reasonable for us to act

This Short Story Is Called "Fight For Justice". It Is A Story About War And The Horror Of Battle

1117 words - 4 pages The Fight for JusticeAs if in a dream, bullets were flying past me in fast, swift motions trying to hunt me down. "Ahhh...." "Helppppp!!" The desperate screams of dying soldiers were heard as they were being shot down into the blood-stained dirt. I, Ryan Baker had joined the state guard to avenge the death of my family members and of my best friend, John who have been murdered by the national army. It is year 2100 and the United States

Socrates Sides With Creon Or A

1487 words - 6 pages not she will go against the state and do what she feels is right.The question at hand is on what side would Socrates stand on, Creon's or Antigone's. I feel that Socrates has great respect for the state but is definitely not afraid to question officials to try and find Justice. He shows this attribute when he fights for his life in the Apology of Socrates. Prove of this is shown in the Apology when the Athenians other a deal to Socrates. They say