Soul, Body, And Augustine's And Machiavelli's Views On Human Nature

2412 words - 10 pages

Soul, Body, and Augustine's and Machiavelli's Views on Human NatureMachiavelli insists that he sees men as they really are rather than we might wish men to be (XV, p. 62). Augustine also depicts how men actually live in the City of God. How are Augustine's and Machiavelli's understandings of human nature similar to and different from each other? How does these differences affect their political philosophy? Augustine and Machiavelli are similar in their pessimistic views toward human nature, looking at human self-love and self-interested, full of evil, cruelty, betrayal, violence and war. Yet the two views are different fundamentally. Augustine thinks that men are not evil by nature but by their choice of disobedience to God, but Machiavelli believes that men are naturally sinful. For Augustine, love of self rather than God is driven by soul, by placing self ahead of God. By contrast, Machiavelli thinks that evil is maintained by self-interest, which is due to the insatiable lust of body. However, They both acknowledge that moral obligations do exist in human beings. Because of their different views of the cause of evil, Augustine and Machiavelli achieve their peace in different ways.In order to compare the philosophy of the two thinkers, we need to examine their views. Augustine claims that "no one is evil by nature" (p. 590) because all people are created by God in His own image, and God is by no means evil, nor will He make anything evil. One is evil because of some fault, namely, living according to man instead of God. Moreover, contrary to many classical philosophical thoughts, Augustine thinks that of the two parts of self, soul and body (p. 206), soul is the cause of evil. It is not the flesh of body that makes people sin, but soul's placing of the flesh over the divine God. In the Garden of Eden, Adam and Eve live in abundance but still betray God. When they place their wish above God's command, they live according to themselves and thus become evil. Fully aware of God's ban of eating the forbidden fruit, Adam and Eve sin consciously; they choose to be evil out of free will. (p. 608) However, Augustine also sees that all men are "necessarily evil and fleshly" when born, because they are the offspring of Adam, whose fault changed human nature for the worse. Only by being reborn and living according to God can men be good and spiritual again and attain true happiness. (p. 635) Therefore, according to Augustine, humans are not evil by nature, but they are sinful and driven by self-love as the offspring of Adam. It is not body but soul that makes human beings evil.While Augustine argues that humans are not evil by nature, on the contrast, Machiavelli is more inclined to the opinion that men are by nature readier to evil than to good. He ascribes human evil to the lust of body, while silently denies soul as the cause of evil by not even mentioning it in the Prince. Machiavelli thinks that men are wicked and self-interested due to insatiable...

Find Another Essay On Soul, Body, and Augustine's and Machiavelli's Views on Human Nature

This is a critical lens response to the quote literature opens a dark window on the soul, revealing more about what is bad in human nature than what is good

563 words - 2 pages "Literature opens a dark window on the soul, revealing more about what is bad in human nature than what is good." This quote means that literature will show all sides to a person not just their good side. It will show how evil a person maybe even though they may seem nice. I would have to agree with this quote because in the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare. Macbeth was once a noble man but the powers of greed made his true side come out. In

Comparing St. Augustine's and Jonathan Edwards' Views on the Origin of Sin

1313 words - 6 pages into sin were also looming, and Adam had a choice to obey God only if he could not bow to temptation. Augustine says that God breathed his soul into man giving him his own soul. The making of a woman from man confirms the social nature of human beings. Obedience of man would have earned him immortality and bliss without the imagination of death. Augustine believed that the entire human race was involved in the original sin. Augustine, therefore

Ethics According to Natural Law - Aquinas's and Augustine's Views.

1139 words - 5 pages Natural law would view abortion as wrong because it interferes with the fetus's "quest" toward its divine destiny of completed potentiality as a human being. "Thomas Aquinas, On the Truth of the Catholic Faith, book II, ch. 89, reflected the influence of Aristotle's views on human development: "The vegetative soul, which comes first, when the embryo lives the life of a plant, is corrupted, and is succeeded by a more perfect soul, which is both

On Evil and Human Nature

858 words - 3 pages epistemology wich is “a study of knowledge and justified belief” (Steup). And ontology wich is a study focusing on the question being. Both of these branches of philosophy have influential figures in the questions of evil and human nature such as Kant, St. Augustine, Saint Thomas Aquinas, Socrates, Aristotle, Leibniz, Thomas,S. Kubarych and Spinoza among other great minds. The first and perhaps most important question to be answered is whether Evil

Your Body, Your Mind, and Your Soul

701 words - 3 pages . That is what must get you up in the morning.      There are three main things that make up who you are, Caleb. Those three things are your body, your mind, and your soul. Your body is what other people can see and touch. It can be bent or broken, or bruised and abused. You must train your body to do what you want it to do. When you want to study, your body is not going to want to so it may become restless. You must control

Carl Rogers and George Kelly's Views on Nature and Development

3665 words - 15 pages Carl Rogers and George Kelly's Views on Nature and Development Many consider the science of psychology an attempt to create a comprehensive theory of personality and therefore be able to explain why people are alike in some ways and different in others (Jourard, 1974). In so doing, varying schools of thought have evolved. Carl Rogers and George Kelly

The title of the paper is Human Nature: Comparing Christianity to Islam. The question was aimed at comparing the work of a prevalent figure from each religion in regard to understanding the varying...

1750 words - 7 pages foundation using two different approaches. In order to better interpret the meanings within the texts, a few things must be taken into consideration like the genres in which they were written, the purpose for which they were written and to whom they were written. Having mentioned that, we can extract from both texts their unique views on what it means to be human. Even though, the means by which each writer attempts to explain human nature is

Comparing Coleridge and Wordsworth's Views on People's Relationship to Nature

2817 words - 11 pages Comparing Coleridge and Wordsworth's Views on People's Relationship to Nature Although Wordsworth and Coleridge are both romantic poets, they describe nature in different ways. Coleridge underlines the tragic, supernatural and sublime aspect of nature, while Wordsworth uses anecdotes of everyday life and underlines the serene aspect of nature. In order to imply a connection between nature and the human mind, Wordsworth uses the

Henry D. Thoreau's views on nature, society, and man.

1520 words - 6 pages Thoreau Views on Nature, Society, and ManHenry David Thoreau's life began on July 12, 1817 in Concord, Massachusetts. At a young age he began to show an interest in writing. In 1833, at the age of sixteen, Thoreau was accepted to Harvard University. Although his parents could not afford the cost of tuition, his family offered to help with the funds, and in August he entered Harvard. In 1837 he graduated and applied for a teaching position at a

My Views on God and the Nature of the Universe

1337 words - 6 pages written in the Bible give reasons why we should follow them. The earliest law was not to eat of the tree of knowledge of good and evil and Genesis 2:17 states, “but you must not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, for when you eat from it you will certainly die” (NIV). The Bible and Holy Spirit are the reasons human beings can discern between right and wrong. How do we know who God is and the nature of the universe, what is our

Personal Identity, refers to the mind, body, and soul; comments on the author John Perry

568 words - 2 pages Personal Identity can be broken down into three areas: 1.) Body 2.) Memory and 3.) Soul. In John Perry's 'A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality' these composing aspects of personal identity are discussed at length. In the reading and class discussions the body was defined clearly as a part of one's person, even alluded to at times as a 'prison' in which one cannot escape until one dies. Memory and one's Soul seemed to be lumped

Similar Essays

Machiavelli's View Of Human Nature Essay

760 words - 3 pages [...] when danger is far away, but when it comes nearer to you they turn away" (Machiavelli 44). He characterizes men as being self centered and not willing to act for the better of anyone other than themselves. He expresses that it is not in human nature to do anything out of their will unless it is forced. Human beings are power hungry, conceited, and selfish, motivated by self interest and fear. Although Machiavelli's view of human nature is very

Examining Contending Views On Human Nature: Mancius Vs. Xunzi

2039 words - 8 pages of a concise linear argument on the positioning of Mencius and Xunzi’s views on human nature in relation to modern society and common contemporary notions of human morality. The first section will deal with the similarities between the two philosophers beliefs and methodologies, and their interpretations in the modern day. Then, the essay will individually analyze first Mencius, then Xunzi’s fundamental stance on human nature using the primary

Machiavelli's View Of Human Nature. Speaks Of "The Prince"

1066 words - 4 pages to the well being of the state, Machiavelli was quick to mock human nature. Humanists believed that 'An individual only 'grows to maturity- both intellectually and morally- through participation' in the life of the state.'4 Machiavelli generally distrusted citizens, stating that ' time of adversity, when the state is in need of it's citizens there are few to be found.'5 Machiavelli further goes on to question the loyalty of the citizens and

"Literature Opens A Dark Window On The Soul, Revealing More About What Is Bad In Human Nature Then What Is Good."

734 words - 3 pages A person once said, "Literature opens a dark window on the soul, revealing more about what is bad in human nature then what is good." In other words, authors unlock an evil portal on the spirit and display more about what is regretful in the human race then what is good. This true is because the writer is free to opinionate and write about their intimate emotions that for the most part are unpleasant. John Steinbeck, author of Mice and Men, said