South African Power Groups Essay

1079 words - 4 pages

Efforts to Address the Problem
South Africa’s revolution was unique because it was neither an elite-imposed transition nor a classical revolution. Many analysts were surprised that a classical revolution hadn’t occurred sometime in the 1980s (Marx, 1997, 476-479). It is likely that there wasn’t a classical revolution because the military was still loyal to the dominant white group. Furthermore, whites controlled nearly all of the economic power, and as a result, blacks needed the white structure to stay in place to continue lest the economy crumble (p. 478). But, mounting pressure from citizens, a steadily weakening economy, and the international community caused the Afrikaners to reevaluate their position. An elite-imposed transition didn’t occur because the citizens of South Africa had mobilized to too great of an extent. The Afrikaners realized that a negotiated settlement was the only option if they didn’t want to face a thorough-going revolution (p. 478).
This negotiation process wasn’t particularly effective though. It was initially assumed that such a tactic would result in peaceful negotiations similar to those of Brazil (p. 479-480). The ANC promised to end the guerrilla violence that was causing thousands of people to die each year once the negotiations started (p. 481-482). Unfortunately, the perception that violence could enhance negotiating positions quickly grew, and by 1992 South Africa had become, “one of the most violent countries in the world” (p. 483). This violence lead to a situation in which ‘winner take all’ amendments to the constitution were rejected as being too inflammatory (p. 483). Clearly, this slowed down the process of integration. There are simply some parts of Apartheid that needed to be eliminated, but couldn’t be because of a fear of violence. In addition, the ANC gave up complete power in exchange for more immediate power (p. 482). One could make the argument that blacks negotiating away some of their power would be worth it to ensure a peaceful revolution. Unfortunately, that power was given up and South Africa still became a very violent place. This negotiated revolution simply wasn’t the most effective means of change.
The mobilization of disadvantaged groups in South Africa showed a desire to have their voice heard, but as Goetz stated, an amplified voice does not necessarily equal a change in policies or in the behavior of bureaucrats (2003). What is needed is change in the accountability institutions, i.e. police and judges (p. 34). The laws can be in place, and those advocating a position of equality can be very vocal, but those efforts don’t exceed anything other than an ideological function without some sort of enforcement. South Africa attempted to address this issue.
In 1995, South Africa passed the South African Police Service Act. It consolidated the previously separate police forces of each of its states and territories. This new force became known as the South African Police Service. It...

Find Another Essay On South African Power Groups

The Evolution of African-Americans in Film: Essay Test #5

1385 words - 6 pages in society were shown through the divided political approach that major parties like the Republicans took in order to gain control of key states. The Republican Party put into place a plan of attack to gain the South by implementing the Southern Strategy. The Southern Strategy was a power move to gain control of the South from the Democratic Party through the exploitation of African-Americans. The strategy played to the strong background of

The Effects of Injustice, Corruption, and Crime Rates on South African People

2249 words - 9 pages distributed to every South African that put them into the categories based on skin color, ancestral history, hair texture, and nose width (Overview of Apartheid). By separating the majority in to several small groups, they could no longer unite and pose a threat politically. This allowed the legislation to empower the white Afrikaner population by reserving job openings in the public service (Henrard). In addition to the separation of people, public

FORWARD ( 6th Jan – 8th Feb 2014)

1313 words - 6 pages even cut aid money to any African country that would support an anti gay law? That makes the situation in South Sudan more difficult, using the Britons or their past as the only excuse. How can President Kiir and other Dinka brothers possibly give a deaf ear to the agitations of the other ethnic groups to share the political bed with them, using homophobia as an excuse? Oh yes, President Kiir has suddenly found solace in South Sudan’s political

Jazz Music of the 1920-1950’s in South Africa

1524 words - 7 pages culture that was not recorded. Both the white authorities and middle-class black listeners frowned upon it, much as jazz was depreciated because it was seen as a temptation to vice in its early years throughout the United States. The lure towards illegal activities wasn’t the only comparison between South African and American music, though. South African music also portrayed American swing groups that were popping up in the south. As oppression


833 words - 4 pages 2. Introduction Has the post 1994 South African government succeeded in improving the economic status of previously disadvantage groups? In the following essay I will be discussing the co dependence of the economy and politics in South Africa. 3. Shift in political power After 27 April 1994 South Africa was challenged with enormous economic and political transformation. The power of political dominance now lied with the previously

Title: South African support on Humanitarian Intervention in the 1653

1149 words - 5 pages Advantages for Support and Intervention of the UN Resolution of 1653: If South Africa was to support intervention into Assadistan and the UN Resolution 1653. It would base this decision on the fact that as a state that upholds Human Rights as an inherent and innate part of its citizens. It cannot allow for human rights abuse to occur on the African continent. This stands in line with the values of organizations that South Africa is a part of

Castell's Postion Regarding African Americans and the Identity Crisis They are Facing

2379 words - 10 pages within South Africa has been described followed by comparing and contrasting Castells’ position regarding the identity crises between African-American and the state of ethnicity in South Africa. Through the application of Marcia’s theory an argument that a similar situation to the African-American situation will arise in South Africa has been made. Reference list: Castells, Manuel. 1997. The Power of Identity. Cambridge, MA.: Blackwell, 52

Twenty Years of Democracy and Challenges

870 words - 4 pages The I994 elections implemented democracy into South Africa’s government. This allowed for many parties including the African National Congress (ANC), the Pan-Africanist Congress (PAC), the South African Communist Party (SACP), and other parties to run for office (Southall 1994). With these elections, the ANC was able to convert “itself from a movement of liberation into the predominant party of power” (Southall 1994: 643). Over the past twenty

Nelson Mandela

1141 words - 5 pages Congress in 1944, at a time when the abolishment of the Apartheid was just talk. Also in 1944, in hopes to pull younger people into the African National Congress the ANC youth league was formed. de Klerk unbanned a number of organisations including the ANC and the South Africa Communist Party in February of that year. Nelson Mandela was released, and soon elected president of the ANC who four years later swept to power with a 63

Discussion of the Importance of Multilingualism Among Yout South Africans

997 words - 4 pages strengths that can be found within each language. Just one of the many important characteristics that must be embraced by the youth. Unfortunately, language has the power to destroy unity within a community as seen during the Apartheid Era. The white population was a minority of the South African population while the remaining seventy-five percent was black. There was only one way to prevent cohesion within this ethnic group and this was to

The Xhosa People of South Africa

1710 words - 7 pages Xhosa were created. “For unknown reasons, certain southern Nguni groups began to expand their power some time before 1600. Tshawe founded the Xhosa kingdom by defeating the Cirha and Jwarha groups”(Xhosa South 2). With the takeover of these two groups, Xhosa was created by Tshawe, who is a powerful ancestor the Xhosa worship. After this initial takeover of Cirha and Jwarha, the Xhosa kingdom had spread, including more South African clans as time

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Reconstruction Period

1192 words - 5 pages that the group they felt were inferior to them were now citizens and were granted with most of the rights the Whites withheld. Southern whites, infuriated with the new political power African Americans withheld, tried to diminish the African-Americans’ new political power by inciting hateful groups of people with the same mindset. These nativist groups include the infamous Ku Klux Klan. The Ku Klux Klan gained popularity with the poor whites

South Africa Essay

972 words - 4 pages South Africa is a nation with a wonderful and varied culture. This country has been called “The Rainbow Nation”, a name that reflects the diversity of such amazing place. The different ethnic and cultural groups of the South Africa do, however, appreciate their own beliefs and customs. Many of these traditions, besides African culture, are influenced by European and Western heritage. The complex and diverse population of the country has made

The Importance Of African American Studies Essay

1854 words - 7 pages capacity 5) community organization 6) possession of critical knowledge 7) coalition and alliance and 8) coercive capacity. In order to attain these, African-Americans must unite, for unity strengthens weak groups (African-Americans) and increases the power of others (Caucasians) (Karenga, 363). Over time, African-Americans have made substantial strides in politics. Civil rights leader Jesse Jackson, who ran for the Democratic Party's presidential

The Apartheid Essay

684 words - 3 pages Justice and humans rights have changed over the years in South Africa. Many human rights violations occurred during South Africa’s Apartheid Period. (1948-1994) Actions and efforts were made by groups and individuals that helped bring an end to the South African Apartheid Era. Dating back to 1948 the Apartheid movement was a formal social system that consisted of racial segregation and discrimination. The foremost problem with the Apartheid