This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Sovereignty: Does It Exist? Essay

1562 words - 6 pages

Prior to World War I, it has been said that sovereignty was central, irreducible concept, signifying the states virtually absolute right to control its territory and population and repel those who interfere in its internal affairs. In recent years, however, sovereignty has become more problematic with the rise of social economical and cultural rights. Some question whether sovereignty remains a viable concept. In current international law, as in classical international law, a state's sovereignty is not absolute. A state has never been able to do as it wishes; not even within its own border. Before any domestic or foreign action was taken, considerations of what others may do were always taken into account. The only difference is that now, because of globalization and the expansion of International Governmental Organizations, a state's actions may have adverse results on many other states causing them or an international organization to take retaliatory or responsive action. The viability of sovereignty is almost nonexistent; especially with the expansion of International Law. International relations are dynamic and not static. The will and ideals of the strongest nation, at the time, will dictate largely what economically and military inferior countries are able or allowed to do. This has been the practice since recognized states or principalities began to interact with one another. If sovereignty was in fact absolute as proposed by many, how is it that Iraq is presently under the political, military and economical control of the United States? After all, before the March 2003 invasion of Iraq, no one can question that Iraq met the international criteria to be recognized as a state. Secondly, the trend towards the creation of large International Governmental Organizations is further diminishing the sovereignty of states. With the creation of such International Governmental Organizations, how much latitude should they be given to intervening in the domestic affairs of nations?Sovereignty as defined by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary is: 1: supremacy in rule or power 2: power to govern without external control and 3: supreme political control within a state (1997). Of the three definitions listed only one can be completely achieved by a state. Within most modern and ancient states, there has usually been a supreme political control measure. In the United States, that supreme political authority is the constitution of the United States. It clearly delineates how laws are made, enforced and reviewed. It also authorizes the creation of certain organizations to implement its intent. Ideally, states believe that they are able to achieve all three definitions of sovereignty. Within any given state, during a given time, a states ability to act is based on consequences of its actions. "In the international system of states, as in domestic counterparts, politics will turn to law to achieve desired ends and to promote the values of its members (Damrosch, et...

Find Another Essay On Sovereignty: Does it Exist?

Sovereignty is of declining significance in international relations

1921 words - 8 pages pilfering other states’ natural resources. Certainly, it has been challenged but so has all other ideologies of International Relations e.g.: Realism has been challenged by Liberalism but this does not mean that Realism today is of less significance than it was centuries ago. The environment is constantly evolving, new ideas arise, technology advances, and moral perspectives keep changing. Sovereignty has changed however it is still valid. As Emerich de Vattel (1883) asserted, ‘Of all the rights that can belong to a nation, sovereignty is doubtless the most precious’

Economic effects on soveriegnt Essay

1034 words - 4 pages Economic Effects on Sovereignty Some commentators claim that in the modern world, medium-sized economies do not have economic sovereignty any more. Thus it is necessary to form large economic and trading blocks such as the EU in order to recover some economic sovereignty. There is some truth in the idea that modern medium-sized governments have less control than they did in the past. "From about 1930 to about 1970 governments had a historically

Native Sovereignty

1313 words - 5 pages Native Sovereignty In the following assignment, I will discuss the issue of native sovereignty in Canada, and address the question; "Can native sovereignty coexist with Canadian sovereignty?" To answer this question I will summarize two articles that discuss the issue. The first by John A. Olthius and Roger Townshend entitled "The Case for Native Sovereignty", and the second, by Thomas Flanagan, entitled "Native Sovereignty: Does Anyone

Is there evidence to suggest that sovereignty as a corner stone of modern politics crumbling?

2377 words - 10 pages organizations may choose to ignore them. When globalization as a whole is seen, it does not infringe much on the sovereignty of the states as it is mainly an economic phenomenon, which does not violate the three principles, of self governance, equality and definite borders of sovereignty. The United Nations is a peacekeeping organisation that was set up in 1945 after the end of World War two and has a vital role in modern politics. Its aims are to

Theory Complex Interdependence Analysis

974 words - 4 pages sovereignty does not really exist because there are too many global problems that arise that cannot be solved with military force. Political scientist Stanley Hoffman, says that realism “depend for their survival and success above all on military might and the economic underpinning of it” (31). With a great dependence on the use of military force, a security dilemma is created. As soon as nation decides to arm itself, its opposing nation gains a

Humans Rights Act

1031 words - 5 pages benefits for the United Kingdom, as it focuses on the institutions of the states to separate the scrutiny, which can be seen as an important fact when there is powerful doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty. The Human Rights Act does not allow the courts to make primary legislation which violates the Convention. It is not seen to affect parliamentary sovereignty as the parliament is still able to pass laws in the UK courts, although they may be

On whether America still exists

1139 words - 5 pages , I will delve deeper into Rousseau’s arguments to decipher what he is driving at when he writes, “ soon as a nation appoints representatives, it is no longer free; it no longer exists.”(101) Hopefully America will still exist in the end. The key to Rousseau’s argument on representation is his notions of the general will, sovereignty, and on the role of the government. I will first go through these ideas, then I will demonstrate their

Discussing the claim that in today's world the idea of a soveriegn nation is no longer relevant, due to globalisation and long range weapons etc

778 words - 3 pages difficult - the United States is governed ultimately by its constitution, but is interpreted by the supreme court and can be amended by the legislatures - where does the sovereign lie?Even in Britain - with a parliament that enjoys status as the single legislature, with power to create, change and repeal any laws due to an unwritten constitution - it can still be argued that sovereignty does not lie within a single body or institution. As a European

How International Organizations Exercise Sovereign Powers Within States

746 words - 3 pages organization should seek to achieve and use when they exercise sovereign powers. (p.2) From the theoretical premise, the author has adopted a theoretical model that is multilateral i.e. it has many actor including values. There is a wide range of sovereign values that exist within a state, however its only specific sovereign values that will help international organization to exercise sovereign powers. Hence the dilemma that the author seeks to clear

Theory of Modernity

1053 words - 4 pages Theory of modernity is based on the notion of social progress, it implies that all of society, in whatever era they exist and in what region or were located, are involved in a single, all-consuming, the universal process of the ascent of human society from savagery to civilization. Culture of modernity is defining the development of European civilization for four centuries. It based on the idea of progress and human values, which are

State sovereignty

2098 words - 8 pages , and freedom from any external interference in the above matters". What is the point of having state sovereignty if the basic idea to it is taken away from the country/state. Yes, I agree that it does not mean complete failure of state sovereignty, but a part of it is definitely taken away and I feel that is more than enough to say that the political aspect of globalisation has a direct threat to state sovereignty. I also strongly agree with

Similar Essays

Addiction Does It Exist Or Is It A State Of The Mind? By Saaim Khan

448 words - 2 pages addiction does not exist. Furthermore, it would seem implausible to think that they are addicts; they seem to have overcome their subconscious decisions. Their acumen takes control over their desire.I would like to conclude that addiction is perhaps an illusion we pull on ourselves. And it is not only to the smoking class that I point this article at, but also towards those who feel, or rather fear that they are addicted to a particular object or activity.

Real Estate Bubble? Does It Exist And What Does It Mean?

1767 words - 7 pages these peaks a number of areas experienced a bust with a loss of 40 percent in value almost overnight. Another disparaging fact comes to light when looking at rental rates and prices. With the discrepancies suggesting that more houses are being bought for investment (flipping it) rather than for shelter or for rental income that they can provide ( One of the most significant valuation ratios measures the total value of real estate owned

Argument Against Native Sovereignty In Canda

2131 words - 9 pages Flanagan clearly shows that Native sovereignty can not exist in Canada. Flanagan's analysis of Native sovereignty internationally is effectively argued. International organizations such as the World Trade Organization and United Nations would be hesitant to accept sovereignty of Aboriginal people. Although it is commonly known that many bands within Canada have access to significant natural resources the majority do not. Flanagan is very direct in

Globalization And State Sovereignty Essay

2105 words - 8 pages STILL EXIST? With all the debates and papers that have been done on sovereignty as well as globalization, one might ask, should sovereignty exist? Is it possible for a state to hold on to its sovereignty? Is it better to have sovereign state or live in a state in which, the major source of power does not lie in the hand of the state? On one side of the argument, it would be playing with fire, to tip the power in favour of multinational