This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Spanking: Discipline Or Abuse – Who Decides?

1042 words - 4 pages

“Whoso shall offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea.”
-Jesus Christ (Scofield Reference Bible , Matthew 18:6)
A parent’s right to spank their child has been an issue of great debate for a long time. On one side of the debate are people who feel that to strike a child in any way automatically constitutes abuse. The opposing side believes that parents are within their legal and, more importantly, their moral rights to discipline their child as they see fit. As one can imagine, the former are routinely portrayed to be overly humanistic and ultra-liberal, while the latter are almost always smeared as right-wing bible thumpers and uneducated miscreants.
The main issue, as is so often the case with controversial subjects has been lost along the way. Everyone has become caught up in the right vs. left fight and ensuing name calling so few people are truly paying attention to the children themselves. America already has enough laws. What parents need most is education and support, not legislation. Also, those without children need to mind their own business and stick to subjects they have experience with, not just opinions. Having been a child does not give one insight into how to raise a child.
Proponents of spanking bans have a tendency to label spanking as corporal punishment. They then categorize it along with many abusive activities. Psychologist Kerby Alvy explains corporal punishment as, “pinching, pulling ears and hair, shaking, slapping, smacking, spanking, swatting, hitting, kicking, punching, paddling, using switches, hair brushes, belts and ironing cords, and having children kneel on gravel or a grate” (Spanking Should Be Illegal). To hear that definition one would have to be a very calloused and uncaring individual to raise any opposition to outlawing such activities. The catch is, in most cases they already are illegal. What these bans are in effect trying to accomplish is end the parents’ right to put their hand on their child in any way which would be considered physical discipline (Reading).
How exactly does spanking differ from abuse? According to Dr. Elizabeth Gershoff spanking is, “physical force used with the intention of causing pain, but not injury, in order to correct or control a child’s behavior” (Harvard Medical School). The National Clearinghouse on Child Abuse and Neglect defines physical abuse as, “the infliction of physical injury, intentionally or not, by punching, beating, kicking, biting, burning or shaking” (Harvard Medical School). The difference between the two is obvious but, the line between them is very fine.
A parent who reacts unpredictably or out of anger is much more likely to abuse or cause harm to their child than a parent who is acting as a disciplinarian with the child’s best interest in mind. Research shows that “the quality of family life and the motives of the parent...

Find Another Essay On Spanking: Discipline or Abuse – Who Decides?

Spanking? Never Heard of It Essay

1147 words - 5 pages Proverbs 32:24: “Those who spare the rod hates his son, but he who loves him is diligent to discipline him.” Ever since biblical times, spanking has been the most dominant, widespread discipline for children. Since many Americans claim Christianity, they follow the Holy Bible. Although spanking is a ritual type of discipline that has been among humans since biblical times and even before Christ, the world has grown and evolved to find other ways

Children Should Not Be Spanked Essay

521 words - 2 pages . Spanking results in poor self-esteem and depression. After being spanked, most of the children say that they hate their parents and feel unloved. Most parents probably agree that hitting a small child is unfair because the child is defenseless. Moreover, when a child is hit, it even makes the child feel as though he does not deserve any respect or appreciation.Lastly, spanking could cross over to child abuse. Supporters of spanking say that it is ok to

stop spanking: save the children

1237 words - 5 pages , the people who are not wanted on society’s streets are being trained to be this way by their own parents. Taking a look at children who were spanked, as adults they report having more anger. This in turn, increases the likelihood that they will spank their own children and puts them at risk for marital conflict or abuse. (Guidance for Effective Discipline, online) Is spanking your child really worth it? Many parents will say “this is the only way

Discipline

1393 words - 6 pages " (McBroom). In addition to that, there has not been adequate proof that children who are spanked suffer from depression, alcoholism or violent behavior, regardless of the authors claim that” Others have linked excessive spanking to increased risk of depression, alcoholism and violent behavior” (“Child Abuse in Plain View”). Perhaps there is no evidence because parents, who physically discipline their children, do so as an act of love. It is the

Striking a Child with an Open Hand on the Buttocks

2559 words - 11 pages Spanking is a form of discipline that parents may or may not agree with. Parents usually do not admit that they spank their children. Is it because they know that it is a bad act of discipline? Parents who do admit to spanking of their child say it is to show the child who is boss in the house. As for others, spanking is wrong because these parents think there can be a future problems from the effect of spanking. Spanking children can lead to

The Controversy Behind Child Spanking

1642 words - 7 pages Straus because he is an often-quoted representative of the antispanking movement. Rosemond believes that Straus? research does not prove spanking is problematic (Rosemond 21). Straus? research conclusions are based mostly upon adults who, as teenagers, were spanked (Rosemond 21). Straus also fails to distinguish between beating and spanking (Rosemond 22), which does not allow a distinction between child abuse and child discipline. Rosemond believes

Spanking and its effects

1494 words - 6 pages only on the negative effects which is somewhat expected already by the public reading it. Research also focuses on the resulting to alcohol or substance abuse, depression problems and other anti-social behavior from childhood to adult.While there is an large quantity of literature that already provides sufficient proof about the negative effects of spanking to a child, specialists seem to be shying away from a psychological topic involved in

Spare the Bottom

823 words - 4 pages How many times have you witnessed children spanked by their parents for misbehaving or for throwing a tantrum at the store? It is a very common act of physical punishment used by many parents. The painful act of discipline towards children goes back from generations and seen as an effective way of correcting bad behavior. Defined by the Oxford English Dictionary, spanking is, “The action of beating or slapping with the open hand by way of

Why spanking your child should not be illegal

1031 words - 5 pages Has your child ever gotten so outta hand that you are not sure what to do? Have you tried reaching out for help and finding that there is NONE, not even the government? Well I think if all else fails that you should be able to discipline your children with a spanking and not having a huge consequence from the government who was not there by the way, as long as you are not putting your child in the hospital. As the Bible says “Spare the road

Corporal Punishment- Is It Necesssary?

1230 words - 5 pages while, the parent usually repeats the spanking whenever the child misbehaves. Corporal punishment may then be used more frequently as the child misbehaves. Often this can lead to harsher spankings and gradually become more abusive. According to the Institute for the Prevention of Child Abuse, "85% of all cases of Physical abuse result from some form of over discipline through the use of Corporal Punishment." ("Spanking Fact or Fiction"). Another

Why Spanking Children Is Wrong

1462 words - 6 pages Why Spanking Children is Wrong Parents have been spanking their children for hundreds of years, but recently this practice has come into question. The concern is not regarding the effectiveness of spanking but the correctness of spanking. Parents should not be allowed to strike their children. Child abuse is defined as any unnecessary or intentional physical or emotional or sexual mistreatment of children. Spanking is not the only method of

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast Discipline Or Abuse

863 words - 3 pages distinguished from physical abuse.Distinguishing physical punishment from physical abuse can be determined by the presence or absence of physical injury. (e.g. National Clearinghouse on Child Abuse and Neglect Information, 2000) It can be argued that the intent can determine abuse from normative discipline, that parents who discipline their children intend not to harm them, but to learn a lesson and teach them. (Gil, 1970; Kadushin & Martin, 1981

Juvenile Who Commit Homicide Or Parricide And The Presence Of Child Abuse

1840 words - 8 pages killed both the mother and father Pamela and Kermode Jordan. During the trial it had come out that Jacob had endure years of emotional, physical and sexual abuse at the hands of Kermode Jordan, the stepfather. The abuse was supported by Jacob’s older brother Charles who gave a summary of the life within the house. Charles stated ,"He would wait until we got home, oftentimes sneaking up behind me or Jacob and throwing us into the bathroom… he

Spanking And Physical Punishment Essay

1237 words - 5 pages spanking can be justified. Parents have to understand that they will have to discipline their children for many ages. A spanking needs to be part of that discipline. People must appreciate that as long as the child is spanked in the right method, it is certainly not child abuse but it is only discipline. If a parent is self-controlled and systematic, spanking is not violence or abuse. In reality, spanking can reduce child abuses, like screaming in

To Spanke, Or Not To Spank

1782 words - 8 pages every psychologically damaging or traumatic and this is where my positive reinforcement was found. I am providing all this background information on me to give you an idea of how spanking did not affect a human being in a negative way, even though there are millions of studies trying to prove it as abuse and not discipline. I will not dismiss the fact that spanking does hold the potential to affect some children differently; a child who is raised