Special Education Critique And Limitations Cited By Researchers

1568 words - 6 pages

Critique and Limitations Cited by Researchers
The studies reviewed were qualitative in nature, therefore they are considered subjective. Berry (2008) made a statement regarding author bias noting the inherent weakness of qualitative analysis. The author sought to counter this weakness by quantifying test units through the use of computer software programs.
Both Cook et al. (2007) and Gojkovic (2007) suggest future validation of the rating scale should involve observation of student-teacher interactions. They also suggest rewording the prompts in order to yield greater variance in the teacher ratings. Further research opportunities are also used to determine the reasons for teacher ratings of indifference toward included students as they are higher than those of students without disabilities. Additionally, further research could be conducted differently, including monitoring teachers’ attitudes toward all students throughout the school year, or examining the impact of specific events on teacher attitude.
In reviewing many studies several authors noted their research was limited due to location and small sample size. Cook et al. (2007) noted limitations including the location of the participants is very specific (e.g.,northeast Ohio) and test-re-test reliability is modest, therefore, caution should be taken when interpreting the results. Gojkovic (2007) also discussed the issue with small sample size. It was noted in the study that only a small number of subjects were used, and it was not an accurate sample of all teachers in Serbia. Daane et al. (2008) noted that a major limitation to their study was the low rate of participation from teachers. Researchers handed out a questionnaire to teachers and asked them to complete it, in their own time, and return it. Due to the lack of time given to complete the questionnaire, the majority of teachers did not return it back to the researchers. Burke and Sutherland (2004) also noted small sample size as being an issue. Their study only included 30 pre-service and 30 in-service teachers from a small borough of New York. While DeSimone and Parmar (2006) noted small sample size as a limitation, it was also noted that the small sample size made it difficult to randomize participants. It also made it difficult to obtain equal representation from the whole geographic region.
The most important limitation noted by Cook et al. was the evidence regarding validity is based on sociometric ratings conducted many years ago (30-35 years) in non-inclusive classrooms. In order to increase the rating scale’s reliability, authors suggest increasing the number of prompts and supervising the administration of rating scales.
Gojkovic (2007) stated that since his study was not longitudinal in nature, it was impossible to see if teacher attitudes changed over time. If the same teachers were observed and interviewed again in a few years, more information about the teachers, such as willingness to...

Find Another Essay On Special Education Critique and Limitations Cited by Researchers

Extensive Literature Review. A experimental study done by my class group, we've included each step and all the variables of our study. Includes limitations and a full analysis. 2 page works cited

3176 words - 13 pages attract potential buyers or consumers (King, p. 55).An article by R.J.R. Blair, titled “Facial Expressions”, goes into detail about emotional expressions serving as a communicatory function. However, Blair takes on a different approach than other researchers by stressing that the observer of the emotional expression also plays a large role in the purpose of emotional expressions, in the face and eyes (Blair).It is also said that

Assessment in Early Childhood and Special Education

896 words - 4 pages ). Portfolio is used throughout the article as a key form of assessment for special education students in the classroom. When following the correct guidelines and when making a progress-monitoring portfolio (PMP) on a student, it can help assessing the student’s progress. This is done through gathering the correct amount of data on the student throughout the school year, through curriculum, and any information on the student’s individual growth and

Collaboration in Special Education and English Language Learners Programs

1576 words - 6 pages During the 2012- 2013 academic school year, in the North shore school district , 2660 students with disabilities were served by Special Education services, and 5.4% of the student population were classified as English Language Learners in the State of Washington (Washington State Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction). Understanding the basic foundation and history of special education and English language development programs, can

Q1. What are the strengths and limitations of contemporary crime fiction as a vehicle for radical social and political critique?

2591 words - 11 pages Crime Fiction is a genre that is never stagnate, rather it is always adapting and regenerating itself. By remoulding the structures of its stories and crimes to reflect the cultural and social values in society to appropriately fit the political or moral message it is trying to send. The genre can be used to raise questions about identity and morality. The social and political critique I will focus on in this essay is the questions Crime Fiction

Special Education: Examining the Pros and Cons of Inclusion in Education

1105 words - 4 pages If one looks at the word “Inclusion”, its definition states that the word means being a part of something or the feeling of being part of a whole. By looking at this term, one gets a sense about what inclusion education is all about (Karten p. 2). Inclusion education is the mainstreaming of Special Education students into a regular classroom (Harchik). A school that involves inclusive education makes a commitment to educate each and every

Cultural Influences on the Treatment and Implementation of Special Education in Non-Like Regions

2778 words - 12 pages Norwegian culture values individual participation and believes that individuals with disabilities should not have to give up that opportunity to participate. Special Education and Cultural Influences in the United States The current treatment of Special Education in the United States is heavily influenced by the policy implementations that dictate how Special Education must be conducted. One of the major policies in place is the Individuals

Satire and Critique in Dead Soul by Nikolai Vasilievich Gogol

1259 words - 6 pages Gogol’s greatest work, Dead Souls is both an exemplar of intellectual Russian critique and side-splitting comedy gold, making it a satire worth crowning its author as one of the greatest writers of his time. Through the protagonist, Pavel Invanovitch Tchitchikov, and his encounters with the many different Russian nobles, women, and serfs that appear throughout the novel, Gogol depicts the flaws and faults of post-Napoleonic Feudalism and Russian

Critique of Quantitative Research: Colorectal Education and Health Awareness in African Americans

779 words - 4 pages informed, consenting, and knowledgeable of the right to withdraw. A moral line was encountered when churches demanded only immediate intervention programs. The researchers ethically complied and though skewing the data, made a responsible decision to protect anyone from harm by providing immediate intervention programs when requested. Not all terms or concepts were well defined. For example, the terms quasi-experimental study, fatalism, the 12-multi

This is a research paper about Obesity and how Physical Education could help solve the epidemic in America. Works Cited included a little under 5 pages in length

1478 words - 6 pages step towards a healthier America needs to be education, if children are taught early how to live a healthy life, chances are they will.Obesity in America is becoming a major problem. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in 2000, 400,000 deaths occurred due to poor diet, and physical inactivity. That's only 35,000 less than caused by tobacco related deaths, which is the leading cause of death in America (Reuters 2004). With


2340 words - 9 pages As government makes a shift to Universal Secondary with priority to students with disabilities, policy makes including educational institutions, in the cabinet and at parliamentary level should focus on some of the following suggestions to make the policy a success.They should account for the training of secondary education teachers in Special education especially in areas such as Deaf education, Sign Language, visual and mental impairment. This

The usefulness and Limitations of the corporate annual report, illustrating your answer by reference to one company's most recent 'Annual Report' and 'Annual Review' Documents

1463 words - 6 pages how accurately it has been audited and the date of the published financial data.Possible limitations on corporate annual reports could be that as the report is extremely long and highly technical and it can be seen that this information is too much to provide and can be a information over-load and whether the information that is contained within this report is really relevant to show. As reported by Nicole Garrison on her article 'Annual Reports

Similar Essays

Special Education Research Critique Essay

585 words - 2 pages selected from a group of 88 young boys who have intellectual, social, and emotional deficits. These boys were enrolled in a special education facility in New Zealand. The students who started before May 2000 and after March 2001, which was 49 students, were not included because of the likelihood of them leaving before the study was completed. This left a remaining 39 students. These students were given the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) test. A total

Minorities And Special Education Essay

2097 words - 8 pages identification in special education. Some of the legal cases discussed include Larry P. v Riles, Diana v. State Board of Education, and Guadalupe v. Tempe Elementary School, which all significantly impacted special education today. Additionally, the Individual with Disabilities Education Act has enforced that minority groups must receive an equal education in the least restrictive environment possible. It is our duty as teachers and citizens to abide by

Critique Of Education: Sociology And Formal Education

1442 words - 6 pages Critical pedagogy is a term used to describe the techniques, strategies, and approaches for teaching and learning. Unfortunately, most kids are not getting the “critical” part of this education. Education has been designed to promote, protect, and perpetuate the status quo. It is designed to keep things the same. Education has a basic goal or function to maintain society as it is right now. It is a society by and for the capitalist class

Special Education In The Us And Denmark

1328 words - 5 pages ). The United States government has passed laws to include students in general education by mainstreaming them into public schools. These countries are compared and contrasted for their individual instructional attributes and educational qualifications of the countries special education inclusive program for people with disabilities. The general structure and procedure of placing a child in a special education program in Denmark consists of several