Special Education Vs Inclusive Education Essay

1579 words - 6 pages

Research suggests that the integration and inclusion of students with special educational needs can be beneficial to not only the student, but also to the parents, teachers and peers of the student (Stainback, Stainback & Jackson, 1992). It is also suggested that integration and inclusion is also beneficial to students in areas of learning other than academic, including that of emotional and social development.

Wagner is in support of inclusive education, but believes that “Placement in regular education alone does not ensure success.” (Wagner, 1996). It is important to understand the individual needs of children included in mainstream education, as well as their strengths and weaknesses (Harrison, 1998). Wagner also advises the use of teacher aids, saying that “At least partial support of an aide or teacher is usually necessary for optimal academic and social progress.” (Wagner, 1999). Wagner designed an ‘Inclusion Model’, as seen in the following diagram:


Powell says that it is important to understand how children with ASD learn, before their inclusion into the mainstream. He states,

“Autistic learning is of a disconnected kind and therefore pupils with autism need to be shown what connections are as well as what the specific connections are within the particular learning experience with which they are engaged.” (Powell, 2000)

He explains that using visual cues will help students with autism make these specific connections. Clearly, in order to put Powell’s suggestions in use in a mainstream school, the provision of resources and sufficient training would be necessary. Powell also states that

“There is a need to address the fundamental issue of how the thinking of these children can be made more effective, also accepting that teachers need to address this issue at the level at which children are able to operate.” (Powell, 2000)

Powell, therefore, believes in using differentiated instruction and assessment, and various teaching methods tailored to the needs of individual students.

Special Education in Singapore
Currently, Singapore does not have government legislation on special education needs, nor an “equivalent legislation to the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or the U.K.’s Disability Discrimination Act (DDA).” (Parker, 2001). The closest legislation in Singapore is Chapter 177A of the statutes of Singapore, the Mental Capacity Act, which was last revised in March 2010.

Education in Singapore is separated into two broad categories – mainstream education and Special Education (SPED) schools. Since the 1990s, providing for students with SEN has increased in importance within the Ministry of Education. Quah (cited in Lim, 2000) mentioned that there were eleven special schools. This number had increased to sixteen by the year 2000, as described by Levan Lim. (Lim, 2000). Currently, there are twenty SPED schools in Singapore that focus on the needs of students with various types of impairments, or different...

Find Another Essay On Special Education vs Inclusive Education

Special Education Essay

1219 words - 5 pages The goal of special education is to provide all students with and equal education. (Edwards, "Special Education") In 1997 Congress revised the Individuals with Disabilities Act to ensure that all students with a disability are given equal access to education. (Edwards, "Special Education") School districts must provide all children with disabilities a "free education" that meets their individual needs. (Edwards, "Special Education") "Special

Special Education Essay

2264 words - 9 pages nondiscrimination and equality. The most significant landmark desegregation case that catalyzed special education reform in the United States was Brown vs. Board of Education of Topeka, 347 U.S. 483 (1954). In the summer of 1950, Oliver Brown and other African-American parents attempted to enroll their children in a “white elementary school” in Kansas. However, the parents were informed that their children must enroll in an African-American school. The

Special Education

6506 words - 26 pages Special Education Special Education Special�education�is intended for students who are exceptional-significantly different from the average. The difference may be either desirable or undesirable. Just how different from average and in what ways a student must be different to merit special�education�are perpetual controversies. Furthermore, a difference alone does not entitle a student to special�education�under current law: the

Special Education

2023 words - 8 pages ) examined the perceptions of parents toward inclusion of students with Down’s syndrome and students with autism. The study specifically looked at the parent’s satisfaction and perceived advantages of their child’s educational program. This study also examined the parental desire for changes in their child’s current educational placement. Employment Another issue that continues to be difficult for students in Special Education as they transition to

Special education

774 words - 4 pages First, I will talk with you about my educational goals; The major I have chosen may seem difficult, I know that it will require time and energy, but I am ready for the challenge. Before I chose Special Education I was supposed to major in TESOL (Teaching of English to Speakers of Other Languages) but I changed my mind after an incident that happened couple of months ago. I was about to attend a zombie crawl parade in Denver that should start

Special Education

1600 words - 6 pages cannot be accommodated in a special education programs designed solely for children with hearing disabilities or with visual disabilities. individuals with Deaf-blindness may have different degrees of the vision and hearing loss. Characteristics of Deaf-Blindness There are several characteristics that may affect students who are deaf-blind which includes: difficulty communication with others, difficulty developing concepts, difficulty

Inclusive Education in UAE

2868 words - 12 pages Introduction A significant step towards achieving inclusive education in the UAE was possible after passing the Federal law 29/2006. The articles 12, 13, 14 related to this law ensure that the special need student’s right to education is met and article 15 appointed a committee to oversee the implementation of the law (Gaad, 2011). The private education system came in to meet the demands of the diverse expatriate population needs that come

Special Education Students: Inclusion vs Reality

1778 words - 7 pages Shocking and demeaning words such as idiot, moron, and retard were once used as actual labels for disabled children in special education. “Prior to 1975, schools were not mandated to educate students with disabilities . . . . [Those with disabilities] were deemed to be uneducable and were barred from entering schools” (“Exceptional Students”). Federal and state laws, as well as mandates, now require schools to educate all

Inclusive Education in Mainstream Classrooms

2380 words - 10 pages inclusive education. The integration of students with special abilities into mainstream schools in Australia echoes the global advancement of human rights legislation over past decades such as; the Standard Rules on the Equalisation of Opportunities for Persons with Disabilities 1994 (United Nations, 1994), and the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2006 (United Nations, 2006), which both advocate the rights of people with

Teaching Strategies for Inclusive Education

1205 words - 5 pages Policies and legislation have set the standard for an inclusive education system that values all students, regardless of difference. As a preservice teacher about to enter into the teaching profession it will be my responsibility to cultivate optimum teaching and learning experiences that will support all students’ social, emotional and academic development. Whilst this task does seem daunting and challenging, it is also exciting to be one of

Special Education Becoming Less Special?

1247 words - 5 pages special education students is the main reason behind these disruptions. Some of these pupils spend up to 80 percent of their day in a standard classroom setting. Inclusion of disabled students into a customary classroom has become a growing trend in many public schools throughout America in the past few decades. Because of this, mainstreaming is affecting the students, their peers, and their educators. (“Special Education”). Vast majorities of

Similar Essays

Inclusive Education Essay

1469 words - 6 pages intensive programme for the promotion of inclusive education, with a substantial reduction in the number of pupils with special needs attending special schools and a corresponding increase in the number of pupils attending mainstream schools[…]” (European Agency for development in Special Needs Educations : Development of Inclusion : Malta, Mar 26, 2010) This fact was proven later on in the document stating that : “It is estimated that only 0.36

Inclusive Education Essay

3477 words - 14 pages . It is thus the responsibility of an inclusive school to embrace the diversity and special needs of all its learners, (Flem, Moen & Gudmundsdottir, 2004) identify and minimise the barriers to learning (Department of Education, 2001) and create a tolerant and respectful atmosphere in which people are valued and stigmatisation is minimised (Carrington & Robinson, 2004). All children thus need to be given the support they need so they can achieve

Regular Vs. Special Education Classes Essay

1588 words - 6 pages I posed this question prior to my research; do special education students receive the same attention and level of education as students in regular education? Through investigation and observation, I explored the differences between regular education classrooms and special education classrooms to see if there were in fact inequalities between the two. Prior to doing research, I assumed that all education was alike, and that regardless of

Special Education Essay

861 words - 4 pages being disruptive or playing too rough subsequentially, this can challenge the classroom management skills of even the most experienced teacher. According to the U.S. Department of Education 75% of student with disabilities are boys. (Truth in labeling, 2007) This is a disproportional number of boys vs. girls in special education with a higher than average number being African American males. In general, boys are more active and tend to move