St. Anselm's Ontological Argument Essay

561 words - 2 pages

An ontological argument is an argument for the conclusion that God exists based on premises derived from rationale; an argument founded on reasoned, a priori premises. The first ontological argument was proposed by St. Anselm of Canterbury in the 11th. Century A.D. Anselm claims to derive the existence of God from the concept of "something than which nothing greater can be conceived." (Anselm 78) He reasoned that, if such a being fails to exist, then a greater being can be conceived. But, nothing can be greater than the greatest thing imaginable, which means that a being which no greater can be conceived (i.e. God) must exist.A formal statement of Anselm's argument would look like this:1.) God is "something than which nothing greater can be conceived"2.) God exists in the understanding (your mind), where you conceive of Him as the most perfect being possible.3.) It is possible to conceive God existing in both the understanding and in reality.4.) If God exists just in the understanding we could also conceive of him as really existing; but then this would be greater.5.) Things that exist in reality are greater than those that exist only in the mind. God cannot, then, exist just in the understanding since we would then be able to conceive of something greater. It is impossible to conceive of a being greater than the greatest conceivable being.Therefore:6.) God must exist in both the understanding and in reality.Premise (1) of this argument is Anselm's conception of God. Premise (2) is a simple logical truth; anything can be conceived of in the understanding. Premises (3) and (4) combine the ideas of God and his existence in reality. Anselm continues...

Find Another Essay On St. Anselm's Ontological Argument

The Major Features of the Ontological Argument for the Existence of God

1562 words - 6 pages The Major Features of the Ontological Argument for the Existence of God The ontological argument for the existence of God was originally set out in eleventh century by St. Anselm in his Proslogian. Anselm was a Benedictine monk, Archbishop of Canterbury, and one of the great medieval theologians. It has received a lot of both support and criticism from leaning philosophers. The argument is appeals to those who already

Anselm’s Philosophy Essay

1552 words - 6 pages Chapter 3) The nonexistence of all other beings is possible, but when it comes to the nonexistence of the most perfect thinkable being, it is not possible. The argument for God=s existence is very similar to the argument that it is impossible for one to believe that God does not exist. After reading Anselm's ontological argument, I had a difficult time debating whether I believed his theories justified God's existence. Basically, I came to

The Ontological Argument

1442 words - 6 pages The Ontological Argument   The Ontological Argument, put forth by Saint Anselm in his Proslogium, attempts to prove the existence of God simply by the fact that we have a particular concept of God - that God is "that than which nothing greater can be conceived." Saint Anselm presents a convincing argument that many people view as the work of a genius. It is also quite often considered a failure because, in William L. Rowe's words

The Ontological Argument

3667 words - 15 pages says in his heart "There is no God"', this is the first line of Psalm 14 and St Anselm goes on to talk about the foolish man. He goes on to discuss the Ontological Argument more (though he didn't the argument this, we have over time). St Anselm says the foolish man is very foolish to arrive at such a conclusion as there is no because no intelligent man cannot conclude this because you are contradicting yourself.1) THE FOOLISH MAN MUST KNOW WHAT

St. Anselm

1976 words - 8 pages " then we would prove the existence of that island (Anselm 2). According to Gaunilo, if you used Anselm's argument then you could prove the existence of anything you wanted. Gaunilo concluded that the ontological argument was therefore unsound (Anselm 2).Anselm tried to respond to Gaunilo's criticism but never addressed it directly. He states that the island example fails but never really says why (Saint 4-5).Despite the criticisms of Gaunilo

Descartes: Ontology or Cosmology?

1539 words - 6 pages ; (Palmer 120). The similarities between Anselm's argument and those of Descartes are striking, which is why Descartes' argument is one written in the ontological vein.The cosmological argument, which was penned by Saint Thomas Aquinas, was the philosopher's attempt to reconcile the worlds of science and religion—a way to blend the philosophical with the theological. The reason that his five arguments, presented in his work titled Summa

Aquinas versus Anselm

1137 words - 5 pages certain way because that is how one pictured him is not really a supportable belief. If God is a supreme being who which is also infinite and infallible mere mortal thought shouldn't be able to that simply prove his existence That I would argue is the main point illustrates not only a major flaw in the ontological argument in Proslogian, but in a sense at least presents evidence against it's claim. I tend to think Anselm's closing argument would

Comparing Theories of God's Existence

959 words - 4 pages Comparing Theories of God's Existence Many different philosophers have their own theory on God's existence. They have their own thoughts of how they believe God is a cause. Such philosophers are Anslem, Spinoza, and Leibniz. . Anslem is a philosopher who used the ontological way of thinking to explain God's existence. The ontological thought process shows the existence and being of a thing. Anselm's argument is that God is

Anselm's Existence of God Refuted

1564 words - 6 pages Anselm's Existence of God Refuted Anselm's Existence of God Refuted If the only proofs for the existence of God were Aquinas’s five ways and Anselm’s ontological argument, in my opinion, Anselm provides the best reasoning. I am not saying that Anselm’s argument is good, or even valid, but just that given the set of proofs by Aquinas and Anselm, Anselm’s is better. Anselm argues, in effect, that the existence of God is built into the

Does God exist?

994 words - 4 pages greater than God to be ruling the world, and therefore he must exist. St Anselm's argument is that by definition, God is the greatest conceivable being; if he only existed in the mind he would not be the greatest being; therefore, God must exist in reality. Contradicting to Stephen Hawking's argument and the cosmological argument, theists agree that the big bang theory could be true, but ask why it happened in the first place and what set it in

The existance of God

1588 words - 6 pages Being has become the source of much doubt and controversy. What was once certain and surely unquestionable has become the most questioned. The faithful, believing people have become unsure. Often called the father of modern philosophy - the father of modern thought, Rene Descartes chose to take up the proof of the existence of God in his Meditations on First Philosophy. Descartes proves the existence of God using an ontological argument, one aimed

Similar Essays

Analyze And Discuss St. Anselm’s Ontological Argument

1235 words - 5 pages Many theologies take/ give the existence of God a lot of importance due to their beliefs, and faith. However, some philosophers and theologians thought it is important that to demonstrate the existence of God to those who says that there is no God. The St. Anselm’s ontological Argument is a priori argument for the Existence of God. Anselm’s Ontological Argument had been known as the first Ontological Argument which had been proposed in 1078 by

Anselms Ontological Argument And The Philosophers

1838 words - 7 pages Anselm's Ontological Argument and the Philosophers      Saint Anselm of Aosta, Bec, and Canterbury, perhaps during a moment of enlightenment or starvation-induced hallucination, succeeded in formulating an argument for God's existence which has been debated for almost a thousand years. It shows no sign of going away soon. It is an argument based solely on reason, distinguishing it from other arguments for the

"The Ontological Argument": Explain The Traditional Forms Of The Ontological Argument Put Forward By Anselm And Descartes

1584 words - 6 pages a) Explain the traditional forms of the ontological argument put forward by Anselm and Descartes. (33 marks)The ontological argument is a deductive a priori argument that attempts to prove God's existence from logical reasoning. The first and best known ontological argument was proposed by St Anselm (Archbishop of Canterbury) in his writings 'Proslogion', however since then variations have been developed by other philosophers such as Rene

Exploring The Ontological Argument Essay

2212 words - 9 pages those arguments, ontological arguments still provide a phenomenal vehicle for ontological discussion through St. Anselm’s original ideas and argument, objections raised, and revisions of previous arguments. The ontological argument still intrigues philosophers despite potential objections and flaws found in it. St. Anselm: The First Ontological Argument St. Anselm came up with the first and most well-known ontological argument (Oppy, 2012, para. 2