Stalin's Success Over Trotsky Essay

2209 words - 9 pages

After the Bolshevik Revolution of November 1917 took place, Lenin ruled the newly communist USSR until his death. “Joseph Vissarionovich Dzhugashivili,” commonly referred to as Stalin, was the one man he warned his country not to put in power. The man who appeared most qualified for the position, was rather Lev Davidovich Bronstein, or Leon Trotsky, the leader of the USSR’s military, an important member in the Communist party, and a close friend to Lenin (Rempel). Despite Trotsky’s superior position, Stalin became the new communist leader. To answer the question: “What were the factors that lead to Stalin, rather than Trotsky, rising to power in the post-Lenin USSR?”, several in-depth biographies, including: The Life and Death of Lenin by Robert Payne, Trotsky the eternal revolutionary by Dmitri Volkogonov, as well as several books on the USSR: The rise and fall of the Soviet Union and The USSR under Stalin by Stewart Ross; will be searched for any information pertaining to Stalin’s overtaking.
With The Communist Manifesto, published in 1848, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, a pair of German philosophers, established the foundation upon which the principles of the Russian revolution of November 1917 were based. Promoted by Lenin, the chairman of the communist party in Russia, as well as Trotsky, another prominent leader who was in charge of the Red Army, the values of a classless society, equality for all, equal distribution of resources, and a place for everyone became the basis of a revolution that transformed Russia into the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the USSR (Stoff 16).
Under Lenin, who became the new leader, the country was able to recover from the economic disaster it faced as a result of poor leadership and post WWI conditions. Lenin instituted his New Economic Policy, or NEP in 1921, and allowed some capitalist aspects of business back into the market, in an attempt to promote business, after they had been removed due to conflict with communist values (Rappaport 165). Private business and competition were again allowed. It was considered a minor setback, in order to allow for future total socialism (Stoff 17). Lenin also created the first form of secret police in the USSR, the Cheka, in 1917, who eventually evolved into the KGB. Despite his control, Lenin promoted a degree of artistic expression, legalized abortions, and encouraged women to enter the workplace. Eventually, however, the USSR increased oppression, limiting allowed expression, and censoring anything it didn’t agree with (17). The oppression only grew worse as Lenin ceased to be their leader.
On May 26, 1922 Lenin had a stroke. This took a great toll on his health and in 1924, he died, leaving it leaderless and in a state of disarray. The natural successor to the position he held was a close friend and long-time ally of Lenin, Leon Trotsky: leader of the Red Army, and another character high in the ranks of...

Find Another Essay On Stalin's Success over Trotsky

Why did Stalin rather than Trotsky emerge as the leader of the USSR after Lenin's death?

1732 words - 7 pages not seeing eye to eye), described him as 'that wonderful Georgian'. However Stalin's use of his given role shows considerable skill and cunning he managed to use it to not only place his supporters into positions of power likely to help him but also let him dismiss supporters of Trotsky. This power he held over the key members of the party meant that many saw him as a useful ally who could help them achieve power themselves.Luck played a large

Stalin Essay

1216 words - 5 pages ). Lenin the wrote letters and speeches to try and destroy Stalin's chances of taking over (Bolsheviks 4). Then on January 21, 1924 Lenin passed away and Stalin did exactly what Lenin feared; fill his shoes(Bolsheviks 4). Stalin then lied to Trotsky about the funeral date so Trotsky wouldn't show up(Bolsheviks 4). This weakened Trotsky chances of taking over and bettered them for Stalin (Bolsheviks 4). To get rid of Trotsky's war power, Stalin allied

Trotsky and Stalin

1372 words - 5 pages Trotsky and Stalin I think that without Trotsky's contribution to the revolution it wouldn't of been a success I think this because Trotsky was put in charge of organising the revolution by Lenin and this might show that Lenin believed that Trotsky could do great things and this also means Lenin must of trust Trotsky as he picked him very carefully. I also think as this was a vital job Lenin must of thought that Trotsky

Rise of Stalin To Power

702 words - 3 pages played with. The testament Lenin had left behind after his passing plainly favored Trotsky as future leader over Stalin, praising Trotsky's "outstanding ability, " and "potential," whilst doubting Stalin's ability to use the authority that he possesses correctly. However, Lenin also discussed the strengths and weaknesses of Bukharin and Pyatakov, making it unclear who he really wanted to take control of the USSR.The politburo, created by the Bolshevik

Assess how Trotsky lost the leadership challenge in 1924/5.

816 words - 3 pages and establish a dictatorship.When Lenin had died many people had expected Trotsky to take over as he was closer to Lenin than anyone in the party was. But Trotsky had a few things against him which would eventually cost him his life in 1939.One of the first things was that Trotsky was always on the fringes of the Bolshevik party when decisions were made, which had nothing to do with intelligence or simply making friends. But he was also brilliant

Why did Stalin take power and not Trotsky? The power struggle between the Bolshevik after Lenin's death.

1306 words - 5 pages opposing Stalin's rule. This led to Trotsky being exiled out of Russia. Even though he had been exiled Trotsky still wrote books on how bad Stalin was for Russia which led to him being killed by one of Stalin's agents in 1939. For it was the fact that Trotsky believed in Permanent Revolution that was the source of his down coming.From then on Stalin had total rule over Russia because nobody thought he would go to the extremes he would. This was also

Trotsky's Contribution to the Success of the Bolsheviks Up to 1922

734 words - 3 pages Trotsky's Contribution to the Success of the Bolsheviks Up to 1922 1.a) Trotsky’s contribution to the success of the Bolsheviks up to 1922 was mainly through the military; Trotsky was a close friend of Lenin which helped Trotsky get the place at the head of the Military Revolution committee of the Petrograd soviet. Under Trotsky’s leadership, the military revolutionary committee was actually planning to seize power of

Stalin How He Kept Power in Russia

2468 words - 10 pages Stalin's Russia STRUGGLE FOR POWER AFTER LENIN DIED IN 1924 [Stalin Takes Power] 1.Secretary - as General Secretary of Com. Party installed supporters in important positions. 2.Trotsky unpopular - brilliant but big-headed/ Missed Lenin's funeral (Stalin told him wrong date)/ Ideas of world revolution worried some Russians - too soon. 3.Played off 2 sides of Politburo against each other: First Stalin allied with Zinoviev and Kamenev [Leftists

Account for Stalin’s rise to power in the period 1922 to 1929

1740 words - 7 pages History 2084: Russia in War and Revolution, 1894-1953Account for Stalin's rise to power in the period 1922 to 1929INTRODUCTIONStalin's ascent to the leadership of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) was neither easy nor inevitable. Following the incapacitation and subsequent death of Vladimir Lenin, there were many legitimate claimants to this leadership: Grigory Zinoviev, Lev Kamenev, Nikolai Bukharin and, particularly, Leon Trotsky

To what extent was Stalin anything more than a brutal dictator?

1116 words - 4 pages a product of what came before him he played a large part in what followed him. This is not to rule out that he had to take into consideration party views and structure or economic and political circumstance. There is much evidence to say that Stalin's policies were carried out over zealously by the grass roots of the party and that the politburo was not completely under his control e.g. the Riyutin case. It was Stalin who reacted to circumstance

The legacy of Stalin

2494 words - 10 pages world's most infamous dictators? How did the son of a Georgian shoemaker succeed with his 'communist manifesto', or rather his personal manifesto? To understand 'Stalinism' fully, one needs to understand a bit about Stalin's background and the events, which dominated his rule.Born on the 21st December 1879, Stalin- or man of steel- became Joseph's adopted name in 1913, taking precedence over his other alias, 'Koba'. He was educated in Georgia, his

Similar Essays

Trotsky's Role As A Revolutionary Between 1917 1940. Discuss Trotsky's Role As A Revolutionary In The Period 1917 1940

2246 words - 9 pages sees him delaying the signing of the treaty due to his prediction of a Revolution in Germany.In March 1918 Lenin appointed Trotsky Commissar For War, Lenin had declared that no other member of the party was capable of saving the revolution as civil war was at stake Lenin believed that Trotsky was more than capable of leading the Red Army to victory over the White Army. Lenin proved to be right.In 1918 War Communism had come into place, many of the

Why Stalin Was Able To Win The Power Struggle With Trotsky

2213 words - 9 pages history arose, Leon Trotsky, and Joseph Stalin. As the power struggle continued, the mutual antagonism grew, resulting in a life or death struggle. Eventually, Stalin was able to seize power and exile Trotsky. The reason for Stalin's success over Trotsky can be seen in their respective methodologies. Initially, the two were both long-time Marxists, in great positions of power, and both had worked closely alongside Lenin. However, where

Why Did Trotsky Not Become The New Leader Of The Bolshevik Party After Lenin's Death?

3990 words - 16 pages stop Trotsky, a new and ambitious member of the party, from becoming the leader over the older members who had been dedicated to the cause for longer. Stalin was actually using Zinoviev and Kamenev to defeat Trotsky. Trotsky describes Stalin as "The most eminent mediocrity in our party." John Reed, who recorded the October revolution in his book, "Ten Days That Shook the World", described Stalin as a "grey blur, looming up now and then dimly and

To What Extent Were The Mistakes Of Stalin's Opponents The Main Reason Why He Became Leader?

983 words - 4 pages Stalin's strength.Ideological splits within the party were used very effectively by Stalin to rid himself of his enemies. It was his enemies' mistake not to realize this as much as it was Stalin's own success and ability. Those on the left failed to band together in time against Stalin. On the other hand Zinoviev and Kamonev committed political suicide joining with Trotsky, as he was so unpopular in the party. With the left out of the way Stalin