Standardized Testing A Failure In Education

1334 words - 5 pages

Standardized testing scores proficiencies in most generally accepted curricular areas. The margin of error is too great to call this method effective. “High test scores are generally related to things other than the actual quality of education students are receiving” (Kohn 7). “Only recently have test scores been published in the news-paper and used as the primary criteria for judging children, teachers, and schools.”(2) Standardized testing is a great travesty imposed upon the American Public School system.
Politicians claim that Accountability is needed. Dylan Wiliam wrote that “The logic of accountability is deceptively simple”(110) He goes on to say that “students attending higher quality schools will (by definition) have higher achievement than those attending lower quality schools, so that the differences in quality of schools will result in systematic differences in achievement between schools”(110). Yes indeed accountability is needed. It is needed for those who pay for education (tax payers) and the people who are educated (the students). The institutions that regulate education should be held accountable for the policies they enact as well as the government that approved those actions. “Of the total variance in mathematics achievement of 15-year-olds in the United States in 2004 only 8% was attributable to the actual quality of the education provided by the school, the results in science are similar” (111). This is an indictment of the American school system, it points out that standardized testing is in fact inaccurate and unnecessary.
These facts also relate to the poor quality to which standardized testing has fallen and directly to the poor quality of education received in our public school systems. These tests are measuring students' abilities to take tests and memorize short-term knowledge in order to regurgitate the same information shortly thereafter, and in no way supports the deeper knowledge or understanding of the curriculum that is needed for the basis of analytical thought.
While differences of scores on these tests should represent the quality of the education at the schools, “whether such inferences are valid depend wholly on the extent to which the tests used adequately represent the construct of interest (what schools are designed to develop in their students) (110). These tests don’t necessarily represent what the school curriculum is designed to teach.
Standardized testing is an inaccurate term because we lack a national standard. Diane Ravitch maintains that “In the absence of national standards, we have evolved a haphazard, accidental, dis-connected national curriculum based on mass-market text-books and standardized multiple-choice tests” (767). How can we even call these tests standardized as when there is no national standard?
Teachers who as Kohn described it have a “dislike/hate relationship with testing” are “forced to care about the scores” of testing through coercion and “public shaming” (19,20)....

Find Another Essay On Standardized Testing a Failure in Education

Standardized Testing has not been a proven helper to students

1296 words - 6 pages Standardized Testing is not a proven helper to students. Standardized Testing, such as the SAT and ACT, is for measuring a student’s knowledge. Unfortunately, standardized tests do not fulfill their purpose. According to Winter 2007 peerReview, “ACT tests seek to predict how current high school students will perform in courses commonly taken by new college students,”(24). These trials are simply beneficial to devise one for a more important

Standardized Testing Is an Unreliable Measure in Schools

1820 words - 8 pages Behind Act (NCLB) mandated annual testing in all 50 states. The use of these tests has begun to not only affect the form of education but the level of knowledge students are taking away from their educational experience. Although standardized testing is used throughout the country, it is an unreliable measure of education and is dramatically changing the curricula causing a creativity crisis. Standardized testing is an unreliable measure of

The Pros and Cons of Standardized Testing in the US

1508 words - 6 pages student who has had any type of education knows what standardized tests are and what a pain they can be. Our students are given standardized tests starting in elementary school, all the way through high school, and even into college. Standardized testing has been a recurring debate among scholars, teachers, and students alike. There are many reasons to approve of, and put to practice, standardized testing, but there are also many reasons why testing

Rejection of Standardized Testing in Grades K-2

696 words - 3 pages of time for that later. Standardized tests have their uses for older children, but only as an audit function, not as a measure of knowledge and skills of individual children (Carlsson-Paige, 2008). We know that children develop at individual rates causing inaccuracy in the testing data. And, people outside the education profession often misuse test data for their own purposes. School districts use test scores to justify budget requests, judge

Pitfalls of Standardized Testing. This essay explains how standardized tests should not be the only way that schools should look at how students improve in their acedemics

616 words - 2 pages , since they are without academic value. Students who like to make designs with their answers on the tests bring down the rating of the school. In turn the school receives less funding and the teachers are seen as incompetent. Teachers spend valuable class time preparing the students for standardized tests, then the students do not try and the entire semester was a waste of valuable education time.Finally high stake standardized tests should be

Standardized Tests: Do They Really Work for Raising the Rank of the US in World Education?

2398 words - 10 pages moving from the bottom of the list to the top. Fig.1.This cartoon shows how a student attempts to expand their knowledge but the teacher will only teach what might be on the test. Teachers are so concerned with standardized tests that they limit the students’ education (Story 2006). In the figure above the teacher doesn’t answer the student’s question because she doesn’t think it will be on the test, but what if the exam had a

Public Education and Standarized Testing in the US

1607 words - 7 pages how they are today. Standardized test have such an immense historical background. Everything has a history and sometimes the history of things can be overwhelmingly. Standardized test began in 2200 B.C. in China. (The History of Standardized Testing in Education – xtimeline.com). Many people may not be aware of this, but standardized test has been on this earth even before the NCBL Act. In this era the Chinese used these examinations for the

The Role of Testing and Assessment in Early Childhood Education

2264 words - 9 pages and without the the pressures of knowing they are being tested. I believe that while standardized testing is not the best in early childhood education, there should be routine assessments to gauge and monitor the progress of students in order to make changes to the curriculum if necessary. The purpose of curriculum is to outline goals for the teacher to teach and for the students to learn. As a teacher I think that it is important to check in

Animal Testing and In Vitro Testing as a Replacement

1032 words - 5 pages , many of these tests are inconclusive and require further examination. In 1959, to combat some of the controversial animal testing practices, William Russell and Rex Burch proposed a set of three principles aimed at revising safety testing. The principles known as “The Three Rs”, comprised of replacement, reduction, and refinement. Replacement regards replacing live animals with non-living ones, and in vitro and in silico assays. However

Alternatives to Outcome Assessment Testing in Higher Education

2137 words - 9 pages assessment. Outcomes assessments are usually employed within the field of higher education to find whether students have achieved success within their program of study. Those using outcomes assessments have attempted to measure the success of a student/s using data such as percentage of student graduation in an allotted time-frame, standardized tests and knowledge tests in specific disciplines (Thornton, 2008). Because there are so many

A Successful Failure in Apollo 13 Project

1005 words - 5 pages . Another issue was related to the high pressure from the helium tank. From the video, it is observed that during the launch of this mission was successful; hence we can say that the planning and quality planning was also successful. The crew had to go through rigorous testing in order to be certain that all quality methods (i.e. in-process and appraisal methods) were followed when preparing for this mission critical project. As a result the

Similar Essays

Vocational Education Vs. Standardized Testing Essay

1519 words - 6 pages Plenty of schools focus on the scores that come from standardized testing. Though standardized testing is not going to help a student get to where they need to be in order to gain their career. In fact, standardized tests are mainly being used to measure a teacher’s ability to teach (Manalo 1). Why are schools basing their curriculum on standardized test scores rather than teaching vocational education courses that will help students later on in

How Standardized Testing Effect The Education In The United States

584 words - 3 pages creativity or enhancing their knowledge. Prior to the educational reform movement of the 1970s and 1980s, standardized tests were primarily employed as measures of student achievement that could be reported to parents, and as a means of noting state and district trends. Educators paid little attention to these tests, which had little impact on curriculum. In the continuing quest for better schools and high achieving students, testing has become a

High Stakes Testing, The Standardized Classroom, And The Marginalization Of Multicultural Education

1864 words - 7 pages “The world’s greatest problems do not result from people being unable to read and write. They result from people in the world-from different cultures, races, religions, and nations-being unable to get along and to work together to solve the world’s problems.” These statements by James A. Banks have made a profound impact on my view towards multicultural education and the nation’s current trend of standardization and high-stakes testing

Is Standardized Testing A Good Idea? The Lack Of Equality In Today's School Systems Often Decide A Student's Future. Is A Standardized Test The Measure Of A Student?

1219 words - 5 pages and Berliner 3)In 1983, after the article A Nation at Risk was released by the National Commission onEducation states began taking another look at standardized testing for high schoolstudents. The article stated that the United States was losing it's intellectual standing inthe world due to an insufficient education at the high school level. The study suggestedthat high school students were only learning enough to get through school and