This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Standardized Testing: The Real Threat To American Schools By Alfie Kohn

1569 words - 7 pages

Standardized testing requires student to answer same or similar questions with given answer choices that are often in multiple choice or true or false form. Dating back from 2200 B.C standardized testing is recorded being used in China ,where people applying for government jobs had to take an examination ,testing their knowledge on confucian philosophy and poetry.During the mid-1800s in Industrial Revolution ,soon after child labor laws were enacted taking children out of farms and factories and putting them into schools the use of standardized test was introduced to America in Boston. Standardized testing was being used to compare schools and teaching quality; Boston’s program was soon ...view middle of the document...

Therefore the whole idea of standardized testing is not about measuring the level of thinking of students, but is merely a sorting device of which students are better test takers. (Kohn, Alfie. “The Real Threat to American Schools”.Tikkun. Mar/ Apr 2001: 25t. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 02Apr. 2014.)
The trust many of America's population places in standardized test scores is both astonishing and disturbing, mostly because standardized test scores are inaccurate in testing ,well, everything. The purpose of standardized test scores were original a way to to decide where to place a student or what kind of help was needed ,but now standardized test scores have twisted into a faulty way of judging students, teachers and schools. Test scores are often now being published in news and used as a basis for flunking students, denying diplomas and deciding where school funding should be spent. Tests that carry large amounts of weight on students lives do not properly measure a student knowledge because of stress and anxiety. If a student is so worried about the outcome of a test they might ‘choke’ also known as panicking and forgetting everything. This is a common occurrence among students who are given test that have the power to impact their lives or with students whose parents who believe that one test has that kind of power. In 2002 the Sacramento Bee published an article claiming “ test related jitters, especially among young students, are so common that the Stanford-A exam comes with instructions on what to do with a test booklet in case a student vomits on it”(ProCon.org. "Standardized Tests ProCon.org." ProCon.org. 1 Nov. 2013. Web. 16 Apr. 2014.).From caring too much to simply not caring at all, at the other end of the spectrum students do not care about the outcome of the test and or simply guess. These students tend to already be labeled as ‘below average’ or viewed as failures so on test they see no point in trying to improve.
The multiple choice and true or false format is another reason that standardized test do not properly measure the intelligence of a student. Multiple choice and true or false questions do not allow students to form their own answers or explain solutions ,therefore the test cannot provide an accurate sense of the student’s understanding. These forms of test either overestimate students or underestimate them. Often students that test well usually cannot explain how they got the answer they did or why it is right. Meanwhile, standardized tests are unfair to the students who are brilliant thinkers,but do not test well. Wrong answers do not always mean an absence of understanding , just like correct answers do not alway indicate understanding.
Though multiple choice and true or false format present many problems it is easier to agree on a correct answer of a basic criteria multiple choice question than a on deeper level of thinking, essay question ,therefore making the tests easier and faster to grade.This belief that...

Find Another Essay On Standardized Testing: The Real Threat to American Schools by Alfie Kohn

Botnets: The Real Threat Essay

4126 words - 17 pages one of the most severe threats to the Internet. Continued improvements and diversification of malware are [6] making the task of securing networks against attacks and intrusions ever more difficult. Bot technology is rapidly developing, [7] often supported and backed, by the open-source movement. The botmasters test their malicious code against popular antivirus products to ensure these are untraceable before releasing them into the real world

The Controversy of Standardized Testing Essay

1519 words - 6 pages in many different settings. This means that they are based on educational objectives common to such diverse schools, and rarely will these common objectives coincide with the specific objectives of the individual classroom teacher or project director” (Goodwin and Driscoll 60). Testing experts claim that standardized tests actually interfere with learning and student achievement by educators that use them. “Critics…state that these tests

The Shortcomings of Standardized Testing

1916 words - 8 pages Since the U.S. Congress passed the No Child Left Behind program, standardized testing has become the norm for American schools. Under this system, each child attending a school is required to take a standardized test at specific grade points to assess their level of comprehension. Parents, scholars and all stakeholders involved take part in constant discussions over its effectiveness in evaluating students’ comprehension, teachers’ competency

The Debate Over Standardized Testing

1307 words - 5 pages fields of law and medicine. To further prove his point, Walberg says, “The American Board of Internal Medicine, ... uses multiple-choice, standardized tests to asses a physician’s judgement before he can be certified in an advanced medical specialty” (Par. 16). Standardized Testing is clearly a controversial topic with many arguments which can be made for and against standardized tests. Harris, Harris, and Smith’s articles explain some of

The Flaws of Standardized Testing

1736 words - 7 pages have become a dreaded rite of passage for every student. The earliest record of standardized testing originates from China. It was created to test knowledge of Confucian poetry and philosophy for men applying for government jobs. In 1905 a man by the name of Alfred Binet created his own, “standardized test of intelligence.” Binet’s standardized test was later used to develop the modern day I.Q. test. At the beginning of World War one is when

The Problems With Standardized Testing 

1889 words - 8 pages objectivity and consequently of equal opportunity. However, "the only goal of standardized tests is the scoring, which is done by machine" (Facts on Standardized Tests and Assessment Alternatives). It is made clear that the purpose of testing is to provide information to be used in conjunction with, not in place of, teacher judgment, then educators might view standardized tests as a beneficial addition, rather than an intrusion, to their classroom

The Cons of Standardized Testing

1399 words - 6 pages Throughout high school and college we will go through a vast amount of testing but why? Testing is used to show a person’s amount of knowledge on a particular subject. Usually it’s for one specific subject and not a majority of them, standardized tests administered in schools today include all testable subjects as in English, Math, Science, Writing, and Reading. However, before we can all take the next step and begin our college careers

The Problems With Standardized Testing

1839 words - 7 pages will require students to take tests in order to gather information about their academic achievement. Although educators and administrators claim that the mandatory ability testing programs being initiated in America’s public schools will hold students and teachers accountable for academic achievement, these programs are really causing more problems than they are solving. Mandated standardized testing is also known as “high-stakes testing

Excessive Testing in American Schools

2518 words - 10 pages Excessive Testing in American Schools General testing in today's school systems has a negative effect upon the actual learning of the students. Standardized testing narrows school curriculum, labels children as failures at a young age, and uses money that could possibly be used in a more productive manner. While standardized tests are problematic at all ages and levels of schooling, they are especially questionable in primary grades

The Schools and Testing

1590 words - 7 pages that. The students do not necessarily become test wise after taking these tests. Standardized testing does not only affect the students but the teachers as well. Many educators are leaving the art of teaching, because they feel schools do not teach anymore and schools rely on test scores rather than education ( alfie kohn 2). The teachers are thinking of resigning from their posts, because they see the Students stressed, anxiety ridden

Standardized Testing: The SAT and the ACT

1322 words - 5 pages Ivy Leagues Schools follow the lead of Harvard and use the SAT for scholarship selection. In 1948 the Education Testing Service (ETS) was created to encourage schools to implement the SAT. By 1957 the number of students taking the test yearly passes half a million. In 1959, decades after SAT formation, emerged the ACT. As the years progress more and more schools sign up to use the SAT or the ACT as their entrance exam. As the 21st century

Similar Essays

Standardized Testing Is An Unreliable Measure In Schools

1820 words - 8 pages , leaving no room for creativity. The constant practice and "drill and kill" tactics used by educators is causing strict order without expression developing a creativity crisis. As stated in a letter written by 120 American children authors sent to President Obama, "We are alarmed at the negative impact of excessive school testing mandates...many schools devote their library budgets to test prep materials, depriving students of access to real literature

Pitfalls Of Standardized Testing. This Essay Explains How Standardized Tests Should Not Be The Only Way That Schools Should Look At How Students Improve In Their Acedemics

616 words - 2 pages . Standardized test scores may be rising but this comes at the expense of other important school curriculum. For the sake of accountability, politicians have imposed high stakes on standardized tests, ignoring the warnings of testing experts. Evidence of the pitfalls of standardized tests was presented by Bob Chase in AChallenging The Almighty Test.@ Standardized tests take up valuable classroom time, have no academic value, and are biased ways to determine

The Standardized Testing Debate Essay

1703 words - 7 pages Standardized testing is one of the most hotly debated topics in education. Experts in education have different views on the topic. Standardized testing refers to a testing method whereby students are subjected to the same assessment procedures set by examiners that intend to examine and score them as part of a wider student’s body. Standardized tests are of two kinds, the aptitude tests and the achievement tests. The aptitude test examines the

The Dreaded Standardized Testing Essay

897 words - 4 pages should looked at their growth in the course over a year instead of a single test performance. (About) The pros of standardized testing are holding the teachers and the schools accountable for what the student’s learn for the test. The tests are not narrowing what they do in the classroom; rather they are focusing it on important basic skills all student need to accomplish, the testing had a positive impact, and improving students achievements