This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Standing Out For The Common Good

1224 words - 5 pages

C.S. Lewis’s, “Democratic Education,” is story that exemplifies our democratic government and how it is to be preserved through education. He gives an account of a school system where all children had equality. The equality was not that of “they were getting taught and treated the same”, but equality of the inner being. Every child should feel the same about where they are intellectually and no person should feel more or less educated and smart than the other. The account gives propositions of what society would be like in different situations depending on the other interpretations of democratic education and what prompts the positivity or negativity of having democratic education.
This analysis will explore why there is strong hint that there are negative connotations about a democratic education system when the text seems to be for this particular idea. C.S. Lewis has a distinctive style of sarcasm that is found within the piece and he uses this style to make the reader realize why the idea represented is one of stupidity. He explains what would have to happen in school systems, the sources of equality, how this type of equality and democracy do not relate, how the examples given are actually not examples of democracy, and what would happen if democratic education system (despite everthing) would, in the end, hinder the boy rather than help him.
Lewis begins by stating, “Until we have realized that the two things [democracy and education] do not necessarily go together we cannot think clearly about education.” Here he is bluntly stating his point of view before we even get into the argument. He then, spends the next three to four paragraphs of the text giving examples of how people may think democracy and education are related and what it would be like. In the second paragraph Lewis states, “For example, and education which gave the able and diligent boys no advantage over the stupid and idle ones, would be in one sense democratic.” In making the smarter of the boys not a superior over the boys that are less smart is making all the children equal. This is what he means by “[this] would be in one sense domocratic.” Later on in the third paragraph Lewis says, “To be consistent we must go further. We must also abolish all compulsory subjects; and we must make the curriculum so wide that ‘every boy will get a chance at something’. Even the boy......can be praised and petted for something. Then no boy and no boy’s parents, need feel inferior.” This is a way of making the student feel better about himself. He is, in a sense, pretending to be completely dedicated to persuading the audience how and why democratic education is good thing.
Based on prior knowledge, if a child (depending on what stage he/she is in cognitive thinking) doesn’t have a sense of success or anything to be proud of he automatically thinks we will amount to nothing and therefore, in the future, will actually amount to nothing because we base what...

Find Another Essay On Standing Out for the Common Good

Socialism for the Common Man Essay

2429 words - 10 pages hands, till the acid had eaten their fingers off” (104). As stated by fellow socialist and friend, Jack London referred to The Jungle as “…the Uncle Tom’s Cabin of wage slavery…. what Uncle Tom’s Cabin did for black slaves, The Jungle has a large chance to do for the wage-slaves of today…” (Rideout 173). It was a common sight to see packinghouse workers get injured on the job and then find out the company does not cover that injury because of

Analysis of Against the Odds and Against the Common Good

2119 words - 8 pages , instructing the readers to what is right and wrong, but not giving us a reason why. This shows especially at the end of the essay when she says that state legislators who have the best interest of the people would recognize that getting rid of lotteries is for “the common good”. In short, Jimenez makes some good points in her argument, but she only makes 'the point' and doesn’t elaborate on it or back it up with substantial evidence. Readers

For the Greater Good

1084 words - 4 pages A wise and frugal government, which shall leave men free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned - this is the sum of good government. Thomas Jefferson In the past, the intent of most House and Senate bills fell pretty much into one of four categories. They addressed routine funding for critical services, they echoed the will of the people, they fixed

For The Greater Good

700 words - 3 pages begets violence. This point can be understood through Gandhi quote: “an eye for an eye will only make the whole world blind”. In other terms if we as a country solve problems through capital punishment it will create a cycle of violence that will cause much greater good than harm. If violence is allowed to be a legal form of punishment within the government then rates of violence will spread throughout the country and violence will become more

Why The Common Core: Benefits for Students

1801 words - 8 pages Zabrial Crocker English Composition II Instructor Giffin Why The Common Core: Benefits for Students February 9, 2014 The Common Core Standards of Mississippi is an excellent way to educate Students in today’s society. This new way of education is believed to be the best method of teaching our young people the skills they will need to know to be successful as they enter into college or the workforce. The Common Core

The Good Old Days! To help bring out the message

1043 words - 4 pages The Good Old Days! To help bring out the message in a poem, the author will use many literary devises. Often the author will write about real life situations or maybe they will write about fantasies. A poem is a fascinating style of writing. It can tell a story or just get a message across. There are different kinds of poetry, and the level of understanding differs greatly depending on the poem and poet. In the case of Gwendolyn Brooks, her

Standing Up for One's Beliefs in The Book Theif by Markus Zusak

1075 words - 5 pages When standing up for what we believe in, sometimes, our voices are not heard and we are unable to make the difference we had hoped. In The Book Thief, Liesel and Hans both disagree with what Adolf Hitler is doing to the Jews. They have discussed in the privacy of their home what it is they feel is wrong and how they do not completely follow the Fuhrer and his ideas. The girl and her father never dare to talk about what they believe to those

Smoking: Good For The Economy?

1105 words - 4 pages Smoking, when one hears it they automatically thing death, but imagine being in a world where smoking was actually good for the economy. What would the person's expression be like? Smoking is one of the most harmful killers in the United States, but can it be good for the economy? Well as matter of fact, it may be unbelievable to some, but smoking is actually very good for the economy. Many studies have shown different types of facts of how

How Challenging Is the Common Core Standards for Students

739 words - 3 pages The purpose of this study was to determine how challenging the common core standard really is for our students by using lexiles to determine its complexity. They added the intra- lexiles which is the mean sentence length (msl) and the mean log word frequency (mlwf) to determine exactly how difficult it may be. Lexiles is a readability formula that was designed electronically to calculate a student’s MSL and MLWF. Using this formula they was able

James Joyce's Araby - Araby as Epiphany for the Common Man

2076 words - 8 pages James Joyce's Dubliners - Araby as Epiphany for the Common Man Joseph Campbell was one of many theorists who have seen basic common denominators in the myths of the world's great religions, Christianity among them, and have demonstrated how elements of myth have found their way into "non-religious" stories. Action heroes, in this respect, are not unlike saints. Biblical stories are, quite simply, the mythos of the Catholic religion, with

The Cry Out for Help in Lord of the Flies

904 words - 4 pages Is adolescence really about fitting in or not standing out? Do you have any responsibility to those students who do not fit in? Do you hear that? Hush, and listen closely. Do you hear it now? The cries for help of the kids who don’t fit in with the crowd. The cries aren’t always loud. Sometimes they don’t make a sound. Stop and listen to them. Take responsibility for those kids and stand up for those kids who won’t stand up for themselves. In

Similar Essays

Common Core Not For The Common Good

1371 words - 5 pages the Common Core, due to “President Barack Obama’s Race to the Top initiative, which awarded more than $4 billion in federal grants to states that demonstrated a commitment to education reform and innovation. “ ( Golod). Now many states are fighting to get out of Common Core. The majority of the funding for Common Core has come from The Gates Foundation and companies such as Microsoft. Even with funding from the government and Obama’s Race To The

Fighting For The Common Good Essay

1436 words - 6 pages of nonviolent civil disobedience and is held as the inspiration for civil rights leaders and non-violent activists around the world. Both philosophers sought to instruct others on how to live a virtuous life and help contribute towards the common good of all people. However, Aquinas and Gandhi hold different views on how their shared goal is to be met. When comparing the two philosophies, one finds that Thomas Aquinas’s philosophy of natural law

Mill's Utilitarianism, Sacrifice The Innocent For The Common Good?

1209 words - 5 pages . Unfortunately for the decision maker, the information necessaryto make either of these calculations is unavailable.There is no way to determine which people will be killed and weighwhether their deaths would be good for society. Utilitarianism requiresthat one compare the good that the people would do for society with theharm they would do society if they were not killed. For example, if ayoung Adolf Hitler were in the building, it might do more

Stretch It Out For Good Health

2306 words - 10 pages Stretch It Out “The definition of stretching is the straightening or extending of one’s body or a part of the body to its full length, typically so as to tighten one’s muscles or in order to reach something” (dictionary.com). That is just the generic definition that one will find when they google “definition of stretching”. Various stretches target different muscles and other areas of the body. People stretch for different reasons, but