This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Open Adoption Records Do Not Decrease Adoption Rates Or Increase Abortion Rates

1796 words - 7 pages

Why are adoption records sealed? What would happen if adoption records were opened? In the last 160 years, adoptions in the United States transitioned from informal placements to sealed-record contracts. When Massachusetts enacted the first adoption law in 1851 there was no legal precedent and as adoption law developed, states began sealing adoption birth records. Later in the 1960s and 70s, birth control pills, legalized abortion, and single parent families reduced unplanned pregnancies, increased single parent households, and made illegitimate an obsolete label. As baby-boom adoptees matured, they called for open birth records and were met lawmaker and social worker fears of lower adoption rates, higher abortion rates, and loss of anonymity. Despite these fears and reservations, research shows that open records may not cause privacy loss, decrease adoptions, or increase abortions.
Although the codes and laws of ancient civilizations include adoption, the Massachusetts Adoption of Children Act of 1851 is held as the first modern adoption law. Joan Hollinger (1993) in her book Adoption Law and Practice asserts that American adoption law was unprecedented and "purely a creature of the statutes which have been enacted in this country since the mid-nineteenth century.” Early adoption law “was usually employed to provide male heirs to childless couples, to maintain family lines and estates” “and any benefits to the adoptee were secondary.“ (Hollinger 1993) Nor was there precedent in English common law which did not mention adoption and only in 1926 did England enact its first adoption law. (Sokoloff 1993) English custom accommodated orphan and indigent children by giving them to craftsmen as apprentices or families as indentured labor. Even after 1851, America continued English custom by sending children to frontier families to exchange labor for food, shelter and clothing as in the orphan trains of 1854. (Sokoloff 1993) In the meantime, the Massachusetts law not only strove to codify and provide judicial oversight, it also broke with custom and required that the wellbeing of the child be considered.
In the 22 years after Massachusetts enacted its law, “…16 additional states passed acts which provided for judicial supervision over adoption, and by 1929 all states had enacted some form of adoption legislation. Virtually all statutes emphasized the best interests of the child as the basis for adoption.” (Sokoloff 1993) In a Golden Gate University Law Review article, Jason Kuhns (1994) says Minnesota introduced secrecy with the passing of the “nation’s first sealed records law closing adoption files from inspection by adult adoptees, their birth parents, and the general public.”
Other sealed-record-laws were few until 1938 when “the Child Welfare League of America began promoting secrecy in adoption as official policy. By the end of the 1940's, most states had followed suit.” (Kuhns 1994) All these laws sealed original birth...

Find Another Essay On Open Adoption Records Do Not Decrease Adoption Rates or Increase Abortion Rates

International Adoption and Open Adoption Essay

1466 words - 6 pages enforcement of guidelines for adoption. Such guidelines will not only ensure children will continue to be provided with safe homes and families, they will also guarantee that the child and/or birth parents rights will not be violated. At the same time, providing perspective parents, with the opportunity to adopt a child in a protected manner. Works Cited Appell, Annette R. "The Open Adoption Option." Childrens Rights litigation 13.1 (2010): 8-12

Increase in Obesity Rates Essay

2156 words - 9 pages their small decisions could immensely help or impact them fallaciously. There are many organizations/campaigns that are against obesity and are trying to decrease the rates in the United States. One of them is Michelle Obama’s Let’s Move! program. Another is Wisconsin’s congressman, Ron Kind whose goal is targeted for mostly fitness. He has a program called Fitness Integrated with Teaching (FIT) Kids Act, which has smaller programs that are targeted

Open Adoption vs. Closed Adoption Why closed adoption is better

1280 words - 5 pages that an open ended adoption is unhealthy for the child, adoptive parents, and biological parents. By the child having no contact with their biological parents the adoptive parents do not feel threatened or overprotective by knowing their child could be in a harmful situation with their biological parents. Another vital factor of a closed adoption is the fact of having uncomplicated celebrations ( i.e. Christmas, Birthdays, Thanksgiving, Easter

Adoption over Abortion

1210 words - 5 pages the mother, then they insert scissors in the neck, cut it open and suck the brain out. *The baby jerks and then drops.3. Saline abortion- A needle is inserted through the abdomen to remove amniotic fluid. A strong salt solution is then injected, which poisons the fetus and badly burns the lungs and skin. The child is usually delivered within 24 hours. *This method is not used any more, since it can cause serious, even fatal risks to the

Abortion vs. Adoption

876 words - 4 pages Are you pro-life or pro-choice? Do you believe that terminating pregnancy early is a good choice, or is it better to put up the baby for adoption? Should not every child be giving the opportunity to live and succeed? When is abortion a good thing and why? In America it always seems we are choosing the “easy wrong” vs. the “hard right.” How often do we think of the unborn child's life, and what it would take to give it an opportunity to live

Technology Adoption by Organizations - Successful or Not

2333 words - 10 pages al. 1984). On the other hand, Woodward (1965) found that adopting a particular kind of technology (e.g. unit, mass or process production) led to changes in organizational structure (e.g. functional vs. line-staff structure). While understanding these predictors and consequences is illuminating in itself, they do not shed light on the differences between more and less successful adoption processes. Research on technology adoption processes is rare

Open or Closed Adoption: What is Your Choice?

1782 words - 7 pages medical or otherwise should be disclosed in the initial adoption paperwork leaving no need to open the closed records at a later date. As parents we are given some authority to shape and mold our children. If we equip them with the full armor of God they can withstand the knowledge of not knowing their biological parents. My husband and I were foster parents for ten years. It was very rewarding to be able to take children from an unsafe environment

It's Time for Open Adoption

1115 words - 4 pages well as the child, from ruthless feelings toward them by the public. During the conception years of adoption, many people were not aware of how adoptions worked or why they were taking place, so they automatically assumed the worst of the situation and the people involved in it (Roszia). However, over the years, the society's comprehension of adoptions in general has changed from oblivious to increasingly aware about how the process works

The Advantages of Closed Adoption Over Open Adoption

1226 words - 5 pages “I want to be like my adoptive mother, but my birth mother says I’m like her. I don’t know what to do or who I am. My whole life is messed up. It’s not my fault. It can’t be fixed,” said a girl adopted into an open adoption (Byrd). An open adoption is a process in which the birth parents and the adoptive parents know each other and are involved in the adopted child’s life. A closed adoption is when there is no contact at all and no identifying

Open Adoption Benefits Every Party Involved

1435 words - 6 pages The definition of adoption "is a social, emotional, and legal progress though which children who will not be raised by their birth parents become full, permanent and legal members of another family" ("Ethical"). Adoption is a common way to gain a child when normal means do not or cannot work. "The past decade has seen the rise of a broad and loose coalition of activists out to change the way adoptions work in America" (Matcher). The increase is

Why Open Adoption Is Better For You

1903 words - 8 pages “We should not be asking who this child belongs to, but who belongs to this child.” (Gritter; image) Open Adoption is a form of adoption that lets birth parents stay in contact with the adoptive family in varying forms: from just sending mail and/or photos, to face-to-face visits between birth and adoptive families. The adoptive parents hold all the rights as the birth parents. Even though parents are giving the child up does not mean they do

Similar Essays

Immigrants Do Not Increase Crime Rates

2246 words - 9 pages article asked foreign-born individuals whether they have increased the rates of crime. The question was asked to several upset immigrants in an interview, all who believed that they were victims of discrimination. The difference between the first three articles from the last two is that they do not contain bias. This article’s results are different because the writer proceeded to defend both sides by discussing how family, peer or stress influence

Adoption Records Essay

1640 words - 7 pages for me my birthmother did not close the records so if I feel I am ever ready to meet my birthmother I may.Statistically, ever since the 1967 abortion act and abortion became legal; Adoption rates dropped overnight, giving birthmothers who want a choice other than giving the baby away. "If enough women are scared about what is happening, more and more will choose abortion over adoption. The open-records movement is so young we don't have proof yet

Adoption, Not Abortion Essay

940 words - 4 pages high enough to surpass other western world countries’ rates. Thus, Roe vs. Wade should be overturned because fetuses do experience pain, abortion side effects can a woman psychologically and physically, and the number in abortion performed annual remains high. If abortion remains legal in the U.S. then it should just be strictly for cases dealing with rape, incest, or even disabled child difficulties, but even then abortion should not be the

Open Adoption Essay

915 words - 4 pages Open Domestic adoption Benefits vs. Risks “However [Parenthood] comes to you, it’s a miracle” (Morton). The definition to “Open adoption is an adoption in which the child is aware that he or she was adopted and one in which he or she may or may not have contact with the Birth parents” (Sember). Although Open adoption has its benefits and risks, open adoption does significant things for children in their lives, open adoption should be the first