Stem Cell Research Is Illegal, Immoral And Unnecessary

2593 words - 10 pages

Stem Cell Research is Illegal, Immoral and Unnecessary

 
President Bush's limited federal funding of research relying on the destruction of human embryos violates federal statutory law. Christians have grieved for many years over the assault on unborn human life set loose upon our nation by the Supreme Court's Roe v. Wade decision. Even that decision, however, did not affect all areas of law where lawmakers seek to protect developing human life. Because they are not covered by the Court's theory of reproductive privacy, human embryos outside the womb may be fully protected by law - and at least nine states have acted to protect these embryos from lethal experiments. In some states, destructive experimentation on human embryos is a felony.

Most Christians have grave concerns on this critically important issue of embryonic stem cell research. In our view, conducting research that relies on deliberate destruction of human embryos for their stem cells is illegal, immoral and unnecessary.

It is illegal because it violates an appropriations rider (the Dickey amendment) passed every year since 1995 by Congress. That provision forbids funding "research in which" human embryos (whether initially created for research purposes or not) are harmed or destroyed outside the womb.(1) National Institutes of Health guidelines approved by the Clinton Administration nonetheless give researchers detailed instructions on how to obtain human embryos for destructive cell harvesting, if they wish to qualify for federal grants in "human pluripotent stem cell research."(2) Clearly, obtaining and destroying embryos is an integral part of this project, even if the specific act of destroying embryos does not directly receive federal funds. By implementing these guidelines, the federal government would encourage researchers to conduct destructive embryo experiments that are punishable as felonies in some states.(3)

This proposal is immoral because it violates a central tenet of all civilized codes on human experimentation beginning with the Nuremberg Code: It approves doing deadly harm to a member of the human species solely for the sake of potential benefit to others. The embryos to be destroyed by researchers in this campaign are at the same stage of development as embryos in the womb who have been protected as human subjects in federally funded research since 1975.(4) President Clinton's National Bioethics Advisory Commission (NBAC) and its 1994 predecessor, the NIH Human Embryo Research Panel, conceded that the early human embryo is a form of developing human life that deserves our respect(5). Treating human life as mere research material is no way to show respect.

Finally, this proposal is unnecessary because adult stem cells and other alternatives are already achieving some of the goals for which embryonic stem cells have been proposed, and new clinical uses are constantly being discovered.(6)

Human life deserves full respect and protection at...

Find Another Essay On Stem Cell Research is Illegal, Immoral and Unnecessary

Stem Cell Research and Breast Cancer

1481 words - 6 pages United States today. Swift action must be taken to eradicate breast cancer in America and throughout the world now. Many promising options exist in the fight against breast cancer, yet none has the potential to have a greater effect then stem cell research.      Today, the exact cause of breast cancer is still somewhat of a mystery. Therefore, prevention options are very limited. Women with a family history of breast

A Scientific Explanation of Stem Cells and Stem Cell Research

562 words - 2 pages ; Takahashi et al. 2007). These cells, term as induced pluripotent stem cells (iPS), were tested and expanded; showing similarity in population doubling rates, expression of pluripotency genes, and high level of differentiation capacity in vitro and in vivo. This discovery had shocked the stem cell research community and attracts more interest to explore its potential. Though there is limitation in technical and safety, iPS stand great potentials in disease model, drug development and therapeutic application.

Stem Cell Research

1065 words - 4 pages embryos. Some also argue that stem cell research can lead to knowledge on how to clone humans. They believe that it is immoral, illegal, and unnecessary research. The medical controversy on the stem cell research is the debate on research involving the usage of an embryo and the destruction of an embryo. It chiefly concentrates on embryonic stem cells because not all stem cell research requires the destruction of embryos. The destruction of

Stem Cell Research

3391 words - 14 pages Joseph F. Naumann of Kansas City made a public affair out of declaring Catholic views on stem cell research. The two held a Pro-Life convention in Orlando, Florida, where they stood up and proclaimed, "stem cell research does not present a conflict between science and ethics, rather science and religion," the U.S. bishops compared the use of human embryos in stem cell research as a "gravely immoral" and unnecessary destruction of life. The two

Stem Cell Research

1289 words - 5 pages further development. Many people believe that stem cell research is immoral and unethical, others claim that it is important and necessary, because it can lead to cures against cancer and diabetes. I personally, agree with the latter group. I believe, that stem cell research has to be encouraged and funded appropriately.To understand the debate over stem cell research, it is important to understand the science behind it. The term ?stem cell

Stem Cell Research

1494 words - 6 pages what people use to shape ethics? Ethics is defined as a set of moral principles. Many arguments against stem cell research turn to ethics, morality, and God. Emotion runs rampant in those three arguments so the fact belief that someone's ethics cannot be based on compassion and the want to help other is inherently wrong.In the argument that it is illegal to research embryos if it destroys the embryo is flawed in that in 2001 President Bush

Stem Cell Research.

568 words - 2 pages There is much controversy surrounding stem cell research. Stem cells are cells that are not greatly different and thus may be used to produce daughter cells of other types. Stem cell research is the study of using cells from aborted fetuses to create skeletal, neurological, or cardio tissue through certain techniques that stimulate cell growth. This tissue can then be transplanted into a patient who is in need of it by replacing the damaged

Stem Cell Research - 1337 words

1337 words - 5 pages obtaining embryonic stem cells by extraction, which does not destroy the embryo or involve cloning. Some scientists believe that because embryos are capable of developing and growing, they are human beings and should have the same rights as we do (George 200). Nevertheless, embryos are only "part" of the human species and are not really humans at all, only small masses of cells. Embryonic stem cell research is believed to be unnecessary, the benefits

Embryonic Stem Cell Research

1979 words - 8 pages For many people embryonic stem cell research is immoral and should be done away with since it disrespects the purity of life, it has seen ample disapproval by traditionalists to not be freely backed, and feel it is pointless due to other options being available. However there are many that believe embryonic stem cell research can end the suffering of young child, parents and people alike. People alike feel as stem cell research are immorally

Stem Cell Research - 995 words

995 words - 4 pages Stem cell research is an ethical controversy because of the way the cells are collected. The most controversial method is the use of embryonic stem cells. Embryonic stem cells are derived from embryos that develop from eggs that have been in vitro fertizilized (usually at a clinic) and then donated for research purposes. They are usually 4-5 days old when used. (Stemcells.nih.gov).The embryonic stem cells can be used to test new drugs, cell

Stem Cell Research

1296 words - 5 pages Stem Cell Research What is a Stem Cell? Stems cells are immature cells found in embryos that can develop into any kind of specialized cells. They can form virtually any cell of the human body. These types of stem cells are known as pluripotent cells. Multipotent cells are stem cells that are more mature; they can be found in adults and children. Multipotent cells are not as flexible as pluripotent cells, as they have already developed

Similar Essays

Embryonic Stem Cell Research: Good Ends Do Not Justify Immoral Means

2566 words - 10 pages advisory board of the Nebraska Coalition for Ethical Research, is opposed to embryonic stem cell research because he believes that it is immoral and should be banned as it is a violation of the life, dignity, and rights of human beings (Eckman, 3). Dr. Eckman’s further states that: “Failure to protect embryonic and fetal human life, the most vulnerable of human beings, erodes the moral fiber of our society. An assault against any innocent human

Cloning And Stem Cell Research Essay

1974 words - 8 pages does not concern many people. When people begin discussing cloning and stem cell research heads turn because it is such a controversial issue. Is it morally right to destroy a life so that maybe someday others could live? According to an article in People Weekly the theory is that embryonic stem cells could replace any damaged or diseased tissue, curing diseases like Alzheimer?s, Parkinson?s, and diabetes. Sounds like a winning plan to the

Is Stem Cell Research The Answer?

1356 words - 5 pages potential to be one of the greatest things that has ever happened to mankind or the worst. With every good product comes a controversial side. One issue that contains a good and bad side is stem cell research. Stem cell research could be one of the biggest breakthroughs in medical history. Although it could be the cure to a vast number of diseases, there are certain moral and ethical issues that come into play.With most public issues, there are two

Conflict Between Stem Cell Research And Ethics

1382 words - 6 pages Stem cells are a large focus of study in today's biomedical world. They are also a large focus in the world of ethics, politics and religion.Embryonic stem cell research is one of the most important breakthroughs in biomedicine. The discovery of these cells has created a huge potential for improving and prolonging our lives. This study has opened a debate to some of the most severe and difficult questions about the value of life itself and the