Sterelisation Of Young Women With Mental Disabilities

1762 words - 8 pages

Sterilisations of some young women with mental disabilities have been always involved legal debate and seen to be ethical issues. Recently in Australia, the Federal Disability Commissioner has been alarmed on the increasing numbers of disabled women and girls who are being sterilised. The Commissioner urges all the states and territories about the extent of the practice, where some parents approach medical practitioners about the possibility of sterilisation procedure of their disabled children without the authority of courts and tribunals (ABS News, 2012). This paper discusses the role of the court, parents and other stakeholders and explores some ethical issues in the purpose of the sterilisation of mentally handicap minors’ women. Knowing that sterilisation is irreparable, court orders emphasizes that parents or legal guardians who usually permit to medical procedures, not even the doctors but only the courts (Guardian and Administration Act, 1990). Moreover, it is proposed that sterilisation of mentally disabled women should not be allowed unless there is obvious reasons such pregnancy might place the life of patient in imminent danger and the sterilisation procedure must be the last option for the best interest of the child (Goldman & Quint, 1991).
According to Blackwood (1991) sterilisation on disabled young women was an unusual practice based on the reason that was in their best welfare, they would not have to concern about menstruation, pregnancy, and the possibility of having disabled children in the future. Sterilisations among intellectually disabled women have started in the United States of America from 1920s to 1970s under the eugenics theory (Silver, 2003). During this era treatment and recognition of mentally disabled young women’s rights was different from the rest of the population (Goldhar, 1991). In 1927, Justice Holmes once said that three generations of imbeciles are enough (Buck v Bell, 274 US 200). However, in 1994 the philosophy in Australia under the Declaration on the Rights of Disabled Person stated that every disabled person should benefit the same rights as those normal citizens, whatever the origin, nature and seriousness of their disabilities (Council, 1994).
In 2003, Andrew and Barrett claims that numbers of medical misconduct have dramatically risen in Australia compared to other country because of current changes in the regulation of consent. According to Petersen (1992) consent is an important principle of any legal system that the highest respect is compensated to the moral standards of physical and personal integrity. The right to consent is originated in the ethical principle of autonomy (Petersen, 1992). New York Justice Cardozo believed that every human being with sounds of mind has a right to decide what shall be done on his own body and a doctor who conducts an operation without a client’s consent commits an assault, for which he is accountable in damages (Schloendorff v Society of New York...

Find Another Essay On Sterelisation of Young Women with Mental Disabilities

Abilities Of People With Disabilities Essay

652 words - 3 pages Abilities of People With Disabilities Chris Moore      Assumption: A person with mental retardation cannot be trained to perform a job as well as an employee without a disability.      Fact: Over two thirds of Pizza Hut employees have mental retardation. The average turnover rate (the rate at which workers quit) of these employees is a modest twenty percent compared to a one hundred and fifty

Inequality Young People with Disabilities Experience in Leisure Activities

2318 words - 10 pages image and cyber bullying can impact leisure participation, along with sociology, which gives an insight into gendered leisure and social class. This essay will explore inequality and will be achieved by critically examining 5 young people with disabilities on a trip to The Melbourne Cup. By applying psychology and sociology disciplines to the hypothetical study can help explain the continued inequality young people with physical disabilities

Inclusion of Children with Disabilities

3145 words - 13 pages Inclusion of Children with Disabilities Along with many other topics of special education, the topic of inclusion has been surrounded by uncertainty and controversy for as long as the concept has been around. This controversy may stem from the fact that inclusion is expensive and experts disagree about how much time disabled students should spend in regular classrooms (Cambanis, 2001). Although this topic is controversial, it cannot be

Education of Children with Learning Disabilities

1986 words - 8 pages the law. The immediate problem in providing an integrated setting for preschoolers is that most public schools do not offer programs for 3- and 4-year-olds. Therefore, preschoolers with disabilities are generally placed in segregated classrooms. Some investigators report that integrated classrooms are effective. Others think that more research is needed to evaluate the quality of services for young children with disabilities in integrated settings

Human Rights of People with Intellectual Disabilities

863 words - 3 pages /resources/online/apdrj/apdrj204/adolescent.pdf Stanley, S. (2003). The human rights of persons with intellectual disabilities: different but equal. Oxford University Press, USA. Orville, E. (2011). Challenges to the human rights of people with intellectual disabilities. Jessica Kingsley Publishers Stratford, B. (1991) Human rights and equal opportunities for people with mental handicap, with particular reference to Down syndrome. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education United Nations Human Rights. Available at

Legal Rights of Students with Disabilities

2964 words - 12 pages A. Summarize the six key components of the original 1975 IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act). B. Summarize the key components of the following IDEA reauthorizations: PL 99-457 (1986), PL 101-476, PL 105-17(1997), IDEA 2004: PL 108-446C. Summarize, in sequential order, the mandated IDEA guidelines and processes for referring a student with a suspected disability for evaluation for special education services. Public Law (PL) 94

Reflection Paper: History of People with Disabilities in Northwest Ohio

1659 words - 7 pages Conference, Brisbane, October 18-20, 1996.Fontaine, C.R., (1994) "Roundtable Discussion: Women With Disabilities - A Challenge To Feminist Theology," Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion. 10(2), 1994, pp. 99-134.Funk, R., (1987) "Disability Rights: From Castle to Class in the Context of Civil Rights," in Gartner, A. and Joe, T., eds., Images of the Disabled, Disabling Images. New York: Praegar.Higgins, P., (1992), Making Disability: Exploring the

My Philosophy of Education and Those with Disabilities

1480 words - 6 pages There are 50 million people in the United States who have some kind of disability. People with disabilities are discriminated against in the United States. It is not a discrimination that is talked about like race, or gender. This discrimination usually takes the form of avoidance. People to do understand, or know how to act around a person with a disability, so they ignore the person. This is not right because people should not be defined by a

The Evaluation And Labeling Of Children With Disabilities

1706 words - 7 pages The information given me by various professionals who have repeatedly evaluated my daughter is the biggest issue that I face in my life. In order for me to resolve my issue I need to explore whether my issue lies with the professionals and the process of evaluation, or with me not wanting to accept that my child is disabled.My six and a half year old daughter, Malia, began to show signs of delayed development at age eighteen months. Her speech

Living With the Stigma of Mental Illness

1367 words - 5 pages Life with a serious mental disorder such as schizophrenia and others, usually never falls within the boundaries of what could be considered ‘easy.’ Long treatment regiments, intense medications and sometimes debilitating symptoms are just a few headlines in the laundry list of hardships that befall those diagnosed with a serious mental disorder. Even with all this, they then must face society and its uncanny ability to stigmatize and isolate

Young and Wild Women of The Twenties

896 words - 4 pages experiment with new values and behavior as well as new fashions. Today, you will be reading about the most significant changes and qualities in women during the 1920’s. Over the course of the rebellious and luxurious atmosphere of the twenties, women began asserting their independence, and demanding the same values and freedoms that men received. The lives of the young and wild women of the twenties began with a new attitude and a completely

Similar Essays

The Stigma Of Mental Disabilities Essay

860 words - 4 pages nondisabled and disable people has affected and isolated people with disabilities. Some stereotypes have been developed about the disability community. People whose fits in this category are viewed as people whom depend on others for survival, which in many cases that is the case. However, this model does not apply to all people who are disabled. All they want is to take part of society as a normal individual. The disability-movement has fought for

Legal Disabilities Of Women Essay

629 words - 3 pages views of women from this time. When compared and contrasted, Legal Disabilities of Women, and A Letter to The Liberator exemplify the feelings and emotions portrayed by the devoted women involved with the movement. The parallelism of the two documents concerning women's rights, and the involvement of women is abolitionism is easily recognized and can be examined to a further extent..Sarah M. Grimke can be noted as a radical from this particular

Teaching British Sign Language To Improve The Lives Of Children With Mental Disabilities

1380 words - 6 pages children between the ages of 3-36 months (Jones 20). Even at such a young age, British Sign Language was discovered to help the children with their vocabulary and ability to express emotion (Kanade 2). British Sign Language was shown to help children with mental disabilities learn to read. Also, teaching British Sign Language to children with mental disabilities gives them a better opportunity to adapt better to changes in their life (Kanade 4). All

Employment Of People With Disabilities Essay

1978 words - 8 pages with disabilities were more likely than other workers to be employed in large firms. Although wages among all workers with disabilities, as a group, declined in comparison to those of other workers, the wages of ADA-covered workers with disabilities did not experience such a decline. Part-time employment increased for workers with disabilities, primarily due to an increase in voluntary part-time employment, especially among workers with mental