Stress On Eyewitnesses Essay

1050 words - 4 pages

Deffenbacher, Bornstein, Penrod, and McGorty (2004) conducted a meta-analytic review intending to determine the effects of high levels of stress on memory of eyewitnesses. It was argued that much of the confusion in determining the effect of stress on memory was because many studies do not actually push participants to a high enough stress level. This review excluded any studies that did not elevate participant's stress level to elicit a defensive response or activation mode of attention control. This defensive response as defined by Deffenbacher et al is characterized by a pronounced change in physiological measures of stress. These measures include increased heart rate, blood pressure and muscle tone (2004). Two meta-analysis were conducted in this review. One attempted to determine whether stress impacted the ability of an individual’s facial recognition. Moderator variables were also examined that might impact the results of these studies. The second analysis examined the accuracy of eyewitness recall of details and the impact of stress. Additionally, the effect of other variables which may have influenced detail recall were also examined.
The conclusion of the first analysis was that stress did in fact have a negative effect on eyewitness identification accuracy (Deffenbacher et al., 2004). This is the outcome that was expected, however numerous other variables were discovered to have an impact on whether eyewitness memory was found to be impacted by stress. These variables were; lineup type, research paradigm, presence or absences of a staged crime, and witness age.
Lineup type, meaning either a target present (TP) or target absent (TA) was found to moderate the effect of stress on memory. Target present lineups had a moderate effect size on accuracy of face identification. Individual's who were in a low stress group had better facial identification than those in the high stress group in terms of correct hit rate (0.59 verses 0.39). However for the target absent lineup group there was no difference between the high and low stress participants in their ability to correctly reject the line up. It was hypothesized by Deffenbacher et al. that stress did not degrade the visual representations in memory enough to affect an individuals ability to decide that a face was not in the lineup. Additionally, high stress elevated false alarm rates in TP lineups. This supports the hypothesis that stress degrades memory and reduces a witness reliability when exposed to stress during the witnessing of an event.
The method in which the research was collected also has an impact on the ability to correctly identify a face. The two methods examined were the “standard face recognition task” and “eyewitness identification paradigm” (Deffenbacher et al., 2004). The eyewitness identification paradigm It was found that the former was impacted by high and low stress conditions. Stress did not have a statistically significant impact on the standard face...

Find Another Essay On Stress on Eyewitnesses

The Unreliability of the Eyewitness Essay

2207 words - 9 pages the conclusion that eyewitness testimonies are unreliable. The effects of stress and anxiety, reconstructive memory, weapon focus, and leading questions are all factors that cause an eyewitness’s account of a particular situation to become faulty (Mcleod). When in a stressful situation, it is often easy to see aspects of the situation at hand to be more dramatized than they really are. It is not that eyewitnesses mean to embellish while on the

Psychological research shows that eyewitness testimony is not always accurate, therefore it should not be used in the criminal justice system. Dis

1018 words - 5 pages eyewitness does not perceive the accused as thoroughly. For this reason, it can be seen that eyewitnesses may not always be accurate and consequently, do not hold a relevant place within the criminal justice system STRESS IMPACT There are two prominent issues when discussing stress impact. One is the presence of a weapon or violence and the impact this has on the victim’s ability to focus on facial versus the weapon or violence. The second is the

Accuracy of Eyewitness Testimony

2054 words - 8 pages “Wrongfully convicted at age 25, Calvin Johnson received a life sentence for the rape of a Georgia woman after four different women identified him. Exonerated in 1999, he walked out of prison a 41-year old man. The true rapist has never been found, (The Justice Project).” Eyewitness testimony is highly relied on by judges, but it can not always be trusted. Approximately 48% of wrong convictions are because of mistaken identity by eyewitnesses

Intelectual disability

1203 words - 5 pages researchers concluded that having information about a child’s cognitive ability might influence how they are evaluated, just not how trustworthy they are. One solution that may effect how the intellectually disabled are interviewed for a case is using the cognitive interview technique. Brown and Geiselman (1990) looked at the effect of the cognitive interview on intellectually disabled eyewitnesses. The cognitive interview was developed to help

Forensic Paper

758 words - 4 pages crime is being committed, any witness would be under extreme stress and anxiety, causing the brain not to be able to take in as much information about our surroundings. Also since we are humans, our natural instinct is to protect our self. If a weapon, such as a gun or knife, is present, a witness is more likely to focus on it than on the one holding it. It can also just depend on the person. Women are more likely to remember more about another woman


613 words - 3 pages evidence, but eyewitnesses are often unreliable... People may lie, or, they may not see things as clearly as they believe, especially if an event occurs quickly or at a time of high stress” (Circumstantial versus Direct Evidence). Expert witnesses are considered direct evidence because they have direct involvement with evidence and have the proper knowledge to explain the importance to the jury. Direct evidence is important because the facts prove who

The Unreliability of Eyewitness Testimony in Children

2963 words - 12 pages Memory is not reliable; memory can be altered and adjusted. Memory is stored in the brain just like files stored in a cabinet, you store it, save it and then later on retrieve and sometimes even alter and return it. In doing so that changes the original data that was first stored. Over time memory fades and becomes distorted, trauma and other events in life can cause the way we store memory to become faulty. So when focusing on eyewitnesses

Judges and jurists have great faith in the accuracy of eyewitness testimony. Psychologists, however, would have us believe eyewitnesses have little to offer the Criminal Justice System. Discuss

2488 words - 10 pages believe that most judges place too much value or emphasis on eyewitness evidence (Brigham, 1981). If judges are unaware of the fallibility of eyewitness evidence, then they may not be highly motivated to give instructions which stress caution in evaluating eyewitness evidence.Judges knowledgeDespite the invaluable role that judges can play in identifying inaccurate witness testimonies, only two studies have examined judges' knowledge of the factors

The Kennedy Assassination

1332 words - 5 pages became aware of a possible conspiracy. Could the Warren Report have been wrong? One of the many eyewitnesses that the commission leaned on heavily could not even pick Oswald out of a group of suspects. This was ironic because it was the same witness who supposedly saw Oswald actually shoot President Kennedy. Another piece of evidence that contradicted the Warren Report was a paraffin test taken of Oswald's right cheek. This test was used to tell

The Attacks at Hang Tuah High School in Indonesia

739 words - 3 pages came the police office on the D+4, he brought some people as his supporter team, i.e. his father, his father’s friend (a former province policeman head), his brother and his gf. Sidoarjo policeman head denied that Anggara’s family interfere the integration process. He said Angga was alone in the integration room, while the others were waiting in a separate room. But according few eyewitnesses, all of them were in the integration room. Not only

Credability of Eyewitness Testimony

1222 words - 5 pages EWT as language; leading questions and post-event information may even distort reconstruction, further leading to memory to use and confabulation. Loftus and Palmer found that changing the wording of one critical question ("About how fast were the cars going when they (hit/smashed/collided/ bumped/contacted-the five conditions) each other?") posed to eyewitnesses of a car accident had a significant effect on the

Similar Essays

Veracity To Patients Essay

1531 words - 7 pages inaccurate testimony of the witnesses based on their perceptions and stereotyping. Some witnesses may not consciously do so, but such biases should be recognized and those people should be eliminated from testifying in criminal proceedings. When courts select juries, they have a procedure to ensure that any jurors that may possess bias are eliminated from the trial. It has been suggested that the same be done for eyewitnesses. Although some

To What Extent Is An Eyewitness Testimony Credible And Therefore Be Used In Court?

2105 words - 8 pages together than retrieving a video recording.” (Arkowitz & Lilienfeld 2009) Psychologist are now discussing if theres a difference in the impact of stress on a citizen eyewitness then on a law enforcement officer, who make up a majority of eyewitnesses. Police are required to undergo training in how to react in a stressful situation, whereas an everyday citizen doesn't have any training, and often go into panic mode when they witness a criminal

Veracity To Patients Essay

1417 words - 6 pages accounts, it is our aim to suggest future research designs and programs that may aid in limiting inaccurate eyewitness testimony.   Psychological Components to Eyewitness Fallibility: Erroneous Eyewitness Testimony Introduction Eyewitness accounts have aided the criminal justice system in locking up offenders in criminal proceedings for decades, yet there are also several documented cases in which the testimony of eyewitnesses actually

Eyewitness Identification And Reliable Testimony Essay

2839 words - 11 pages . Retrieval is recalling stored information about an event with the purpose of making an identification of a person in that event (Samaha, 2011). There are many factors that can contribute to faulty eyewitness testimony, including own-race bias, focus on a weapon, stress, length of exposure to the stranger, eyewitness confidence, and events that occur after the incident, such as suggestive police procedures (Vallas, 2011). “Own-race bias, also