This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Struggle Between Belief And Disbelief In Brothers Karamazov

1176 words - 5 pages

Brothers Karamazov, written by the accomplished Russian novelist - Fyodor Dostoevsky, is an ambiguous and somewhat contradictory novel when it comes to the issue of belief and disbelief in God. The ambiguity seems to represent Dostoevsky’s constant spiritual struggle with the issue of faith. This struggle is best reflected in the enlightening interactions between the two Karamazov brothers, Ivan and Alyosha throughout the novel, each appears to embody a different side on the spectrum of religious belief in Dostoevsky’s mind. They are Dostoevsky’s ultimate depiction of the conflict of faith and reason in light of the suffering in the world.
The novel revolves around the three Karamazov brothers – Dimitri, Ivan and Alyosha – ‘s emotionally spiritual conflict between reason and faith. Dostoevsky portrayed this best through Book V, chapter 3 to 5 – in which an intellectual conversation between Ivan and Alyosha takes place. Their dinner conversation opens up a whole new paradigm of spirituality. Ivan, in order to explain his point of view on the matter, brings up the suffering of innocent children in particular and the human race in general. It is beyond his grasp how a living God could let mankind suffer for no particular reason. Furthermore, Ivan cannot seem to comprehend why the innocent and harmless children have to live their lives in suffering. He says in Book V chapter 4 – Rebellion: “Listen: if everyone must suffer, in order to buy eternal harmony with their suffering, pray tell me what have children got to do with it? It’s quite incomprehensible why they should have to suffer, and why they should buy harmony with their suffering. “ His poignant speech is so eloquently articulated that it makes us question whether this is actually Dostoevsky’s view on God and the injustice in the world, especially when we consider the fact that the death of his three-year-old son Alyosha in May 1878 unfortunately intervened his writing of the novel.
Ivan is a heartfelt rationalist whose disbelief in God does not necessarily mirror atheism. Ivan never questions the existence of God, he only feels strongly that if, indeed, there was a God, he would not be all-loving and all-benevolent, given the all the injustice and pain people, especially children in this world have to endure. Therefore, it seems like Ivan never loses faith in the existence of God, but rather he has lost faith in a perfect God – this is the basis of his disbelief. To him, nothing can ever justify the suffering of children, too young to even have sinned. Ivan appears to reflect Dostoevsky’s thoughts and reason when all things go against his faith.
Dostoevsky wrote in the novel this which will always be one of my favorite sayings: “The awful thing is that beauty is mysterious as well as terrible. God and the devil are fighting there and the battlefield is the heart of man.” Brothers Karamazov is without any doubt the heart of Dostoevsky where the eternal battle is fought between faith and...

Find Another Essay On Struggle between Belief and Disbelief in Brothers Karamazov

Concept of Free Will in The Brothers Karamazov

2583 words - 10 pages theory by Father Paissy, his reply is “Yes, it was my contention. There is no virtue if there is no immortality” (pg. 70). Yet throughout the novel, he is one of the more moral characters in the novel despite his moniker as a Karamazov. If he so chose, he could go on the same kind of binges that his father and his brother go on. His disbelief in immortality and ultimately morality could allow him to waste ridiculous amounts of money on booze and women

The Brothers Karamazov chapter 4 Analysis and response

1280 words - 5 pages Chapter four of The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoyevsky raises some serious issues about religion and society in general. The conversation between Ivan and Aloysha provides the rationale behind the belief that one would be more reasonable and compassionate by not believing in god. Also, the morals of society come into question as the two brothers question society's norms. While this story takes place during a time very much different from

The Struggle Between Freedom and Slavery in Huckleberry Finn

396 words - 2 pages not immediately apparent. The novel contains ideas and observations that Twain felt were significant to the culture and the people he was writing to. The primary theme of the book (most appropriate considering the time period in which it was written) is the struggle between freedom and slavery.Huckleberry Finn experiences this struggle as the adults around him attempt to "sivilize" him and force him to conform to their ideas of appropriate behavior

Struggle Between Excellence and Mediocrity in The Fountainhead

1553 words - 6 pages Struggle Between Excellence and Mediocrity in The Fountainhead         Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead is a story of the struggle between men of greatness and men of mediocrity. An individualist to the core, Rand defines a man of greatness as one who is independent and uncompromising, one who derives his self-respect from his accomplishments and integrity rather than the approval of others. Rand defines a man of mediocrity, by contrast, as

The Struggle between Good and Evil; in Macbeth

1014 words - 4 pages are suggesting good and evil as being one. The witches’ line reflects on human nature as there are fair and foul parts to everyone. Shakespeare wanted to get this message across as the main character, Macbeth, is a prime example of the struggle between good and bad within one person. This opening scene is set in a battle field. The scary thunder and lightening is an example of pathetic fallacy; the weather reflects the aggressive atmosphere and

Struggle in The River Between

929 words - 4 pages Struggle in The River Between   In the book "The River Between" we find traditional values of the tribe challenged by tribal members who had converted to Christianity. The novel focuses on the struggle between two conflicting interests: First there was the interest to convert Africans to Christianity, and the second was the tribe trying to keep their traditional values in the midst of Christianity. The most contrasting characters in

Exploring the Relationship Between Faith and Belief

983 words - 4 pages crisis of belief, and explain how Marsh’s notion of a “theology of negotiation” (33) fits with Lonergan’s definition and allows him to argue that film can help us raise theological questions. I will explore the relationship between faith and belief. At first glance, most of us will have the same thought that there is no difference between faith and belief. However, if we carefully examine them in detail, we will recognize their differences

The importance of reason and emotion in distinguishing between belief and knowledge

1433 words - 6 pages Belief comes from every emotion of a person in order for him to sense what is right and wrong inside his thoughts. On the other hand, knowledge is based upon reason that people had tried to discover to answer mysteries found in universe. One can argue that they both exist inside our minds and also have some similarities and differentiations. Focusing at emotion and reason will be the best way to distinguish between belief and knowledge.With the

Discuss the importance of reason and emotion in distinguishing between belief and knowledge

1396 words - 6 pages Sometimes we hear reasoned arguments that oppose a view to which we are emotionally committed; sometimes we hear a passionate plea for a view we have good reasons to reject.Distinguishing between belief and knowledge is not easy. Perhaps defining these concepts in terms of reason and emotion helps, but every person has their own view of what belief constitutes. Believing is not based on something we can see; it is not based on statistics or

The Importance of Reason and Emotion in Distinguishing between Belief and Knowledge

1472 words - 6 pages conditions for the knowledgeable belief to be true are that the person must believe and must also have good grounds for believing. Knowledge itself is acquired through many different ways, such as through the senses (empically), reasoning (rationally) and also largely from experiences.A few months ago large disputes arose between the Guatemalans and Albanians people resulting with demonstrations around Guatemala protesting in regard to a new

TOK ESSAY: Discuss the importance of reason and emotion in distinguishing between belief and knowledge

1131 words - 5 pages As a Hong Kong Student, who is holding a British national (overseas) passport, now living in China, and receiving an international education, I have been been absorbing different perspectives of belief and knowledge. As an example, I can see a "truth" here in China is different from the one which is stated by the Japanese. And due to the multi-culture environment and the various aspects gained by an IB student, I notice how emotions and reasons

Similar Essays

Common Themes In Crime And Punishment And The Brothers Karamazov

2411 words - 10 pages Russian author and philosopher, Fyodor Dostoevsky, was best known for his literary contributions between 1866 and 1880. Of his substantial work, Crime and Punishment, The Idiot, The Devils, and The Brothers Karamazov are the novels he remains most recognized for. In each of these novels, Dostoevsky examines and interprets several social, physical, mental, and emotional situations and conditions, which he believed to, influenced the nature of

Theodicy And Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov

2618 words - 10 pages Theodicy and Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov The problem of reconciling an omnipotent, perfectly just, perfectly benevolent god with a world full of evil and suffering has plagued believers since the beginning of religious thought. Atheists often site this paradox in order to demonstrate that such a god cannot exist and, therefore, that theism is an invalid position. Theodicy is a branch of philosophy that seeks to defend religion by

Children In Crime And Punishment, The Idiot, Devils, The Brothers Karamazov

2189 words - 9 pages Theme of Children in Crime and Punishment, The Idiot, Devils, The Brothers Karamazov       As an adult, Dostoevsky became fascinated with children, but was extremely affected by the suffering they were often forced to endure. As a result, the theme of children became "one of the most important in his portrayal of society" and he became obsessed with the theme of "children on the road to destruction"(p.572, Grossman). The charming children

Portrayal Of Man In Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov

1216 words - 5 pages Portrayal of Man in The Brothers Karamazov           Debauchery, dueling, infidelity, orgies, and even monastery life are all used to help Fyodor Dostoevesky define his characters in The Brothers Karamazov. At the beginning of the novel, the reader becomes filled with contempt for a few members of the Karamazov family, yet filled with admiration for others. The legitimate members of the Karamasov family each represent a separate aspect of