This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Stuart Hall And Cultural Identity English Essay

1149 words - 5 pages

Hall and Cultural Identity
The true definition of identity for the black diaspora has been a subject of debate for a long time. Most people believe that cultural identity is the feeling of belonging to a group and that it is based on a group’s sameness and synergy. However, Stuart Hall, author of “Cultural Identity and Diaspora” provides an alternative to this belief. In his study, Hall says that identity is not a stagnant thing and that it is a property that should be molded by individuals as they progress through life. Several authors within the black diaspora provide basis for his claims. Specifically, Frantz Fanon (“The Fact of Blackness”) and Jamaica Kincaid’s (“On Seeing England”) experiences coincide and clash with Hall’s ideas while giving a clearer definition of identity. Hall’s redefinition of cultural identity as a constantly evolving idea is exemplified through Fanon and Kincaid because both authors reestablish what makes them who they are in the diaspora.
In “Cultural Identity and Diaspora”, Hall argues that the more commonly known definition of cultural identity is that individuals within a diaspora are connected by a single oneness. In this definition, the affected individuals have one “shared history” that they must “discover, excavate, [and] bring to light.” This identity is not one that accommodates change due its “stable, unchanging” nature. According to Hall, this is a problematic issue for black people. The attempt to create a monolithic Afro-Caribbean/Afro-American culture is wrong due to all the cultural doctoring one would have to do to achieve that oneness. Despite Hall’s disagreements, he acknowledges that one benefit of a “shared culture” is that it allows people afflicted with the negatives of the diaspora to overcome their problems and have a better understanding of who they are.
Hall’s second definition of cultural identity partially juxtaposes and improves upon the first by giving people in the diaspora a chance to be themselves. Hall argues that cultural identity should be a metamorphic experience that is “far from being eternally fixed”. An identity is a “matter of becoming as well as being”. They have to originate from somewhere, have stories, and similar to the people who wield them, they undergo a “constant transformation”. Identity is mostly affected by “the continuous ‘play’ of history, culture, and power” When talking about the black diaspora specifically, colonized people have been oppressed throughout history and their need for freedom has affected many identities as time goes on.
Frantz Fanon, another chronicler of the black experience, has his own understanding of identity that may coincide and conflict with Hall’s ideas. Fanon’s text describes his experiences as black man and how his encounters with the white race made him feel inferior. He eventually overcomes this through resistance and boosting his self-confidence. In “Cultural Identity and Diaspora”, Hall explains that oppressors have the “power to...

Find Another Essay On Stuart Hall and Cultural Identity - English - Essay

Cultural Identity Interview and Analysis

1035 words - 4 pages , my mother never made me feel I was different. I always raised as being black.I believe common individuality and thoughts may be clear indicators of a shared cultural identity but in essence, it is determined by difference. Such as, if we feel we fit into a group, if a group classifies itself as a group, by noticing and highlighting differences with other groups and cultures or if their culture defines itself in relation, or conflict to other

Cultural Identity and the Language of Food

4270 words - 17 pages Cultural Identity and the Language of Food Food is integral to cultural identity and is as much a part of culture as religion and language. Indeed, some cultures elevate food to a level nearing, if not exceeding, the status of their religion. Because I love to cook, to combine flavors in a way that results in something unexpected and wonderful, this paper will discuss various words related to food. Not actual food words, but words

Cultural Identity and Cinematic Representation – A Summary

716 words - 3 pages her alone. In many English speaking countries like America, people will enjoy the party for the whole night, and usually no body will leave before 10 o'clock.David Hu had just started working for the foreign owned company. He was sitting at his workstation but had not been given any assignment that he should be doing at this moment. He was relaxing and waiting and then thought he would take the opportunity to have a look around. He poked his head

Utilitarianism and Morality in John Stuart Mill´s Essay

1190 words - 5 pages . Despite the lack of understanding, John Stuart Mill confidently believes that truths can still have meaning even if society struggles to understand its principles. Mill does an outstanding job at depicting morality and for that the entire essay is a masterpiece. His claims throughout the essay could not be any closer to the truth. Morals are an often talked about matter, but what is morality? Not everyone is instilled with the same morals

An Evasive Identity: Racial, Cultural, and Ethnic Differences in America

1736 words - 7 pages who dare to be different. These are Americans who do not conform to these norms. In essence, this shows that Americans have a divided identity described in terms of racial, class and cultural differences. Black people are victimized for wearing corn rows to work, Americans of Spanish descent fail to qualify for jury duty simply because they can speak Spanish. These are the scenarios witnessed by most Americans. Accepting and deriving pride in

Visual and cultural art essay

1300 words - 6 pages For my visual and cultural arts essay I visited the James E Lewis museum at Morgan State University. For my essay I have selected key pieces of art that I believe express the African experience in terms of their social, ethnographical and theological beliefs. This paper will also attempt to draw a comparison to key themes features in the African Creation myths, which will further elucidate the meanings hidden in these various works of art. It is

American Identity --- talking about the ways American people can find their own national identity - English - essay

466 words - 2 pages , eliminating discrimination, assisting people in need and providing education are three ways indicated in this essay for American people to find their national identity. I predict that Americans will have a common narrative again in the near future if all three suggestions are accepted by the American Pentagon.

The pressure of being accepted and liked by others can change a person’s personality and identity (Three Day Road) - York Mills, English 4U - Assignment/ essay outline

873 words - 4 pages the pressure of being accepted makes some people change their identity and become completely different from who they used to be. NOW...let’s get to the business of getting that message across. #1 – a SOLID THESIS, which is a statement that will be proven by YOUR ESSAY. The pressure of being accepted and liked by others can change a person’s personality and identity. #2 – An organizing statement – the basic elements of your topic sentences. In the

The Cultural Construction Of Gender And Representation Of Identity In Soaps And Music Videos

2060 words - 9 pages Soaps but more importantly music videos can be said to interrogate the cultural construction of gender and representations of identity. The video suggests a set of images to the viewer and usually these are a blurring of gender and identity. Music videos predicate on the representation of female gender experience. The two interrelated sign systems- access signs and discovery signs- will be discussed. Music clips that will be focused on are

Race and the Census: Effect on the Social Context of Cultural and Social Identity

2049 words - 8 pages The focus of this research study is to explore the construct of race in the census survey and the effect that it has on the social context of both cultural and social identity. These changes are based on the evolving landscape of the population as it pertains to the characteristics of its people. The Census was first administered in the 1790 and would take place every ten years . Its main purpose was to better respond to the needs of its

Fairytales and their lasting cultural impressions - ACA English - Honors English Weekly Writing

481 words - 2 pages House 1 Alayna House Mrs. Hill Pre-AP English 20 February 2017 Fairytale Weekly Writing What do you think of when you hear the word “mermaid”? Today, we characterize mermaids as gorgeous, happy, and energetic creatures, because of the movie The Little Mermaid that a majority of people have seen or heard about. The Little Mermaid is a well-known fairytale, which is a children’s story about magical and imaginary beings and lands. Being a

Similar Essays

My Cultural Identity Is About Things That Make Me. My Controlling Metaphor Is My Hair. Early College Academy English 2 Essay

486 words - 2 pages manageable. With thick, curly hair it is not always wise to trust packages labeled “for thick hair” or “natural hair approved”. I learned this the hard way with the Michel Mercier brush. Previously mentioned above, tangled ponytails are special because they represent the intermingling of cultures related to my cultural identity; by tying two popped ponytails and forming a new ponytail cultures have been joined. For example bringing my music, and dance

Stuart Hall Encoding And Decoding

3068 words - 12 pages Stuart Hall Four intellectuals established Cultural Studies, namely, Richard Hoggart, Raymond Williams, E.P. Thompson, and Stuart Hall. Hall (b. 1932) has had the lion's share of publicity. Scholars working in this tradition often take their cue from his articles. Hall tells us that he grew up in Jamaica, the "blackest son" (in his words) of a middle-class, conservative family; from an early age, Hall says, he rejected his father's attempt

Music And Cultural Identity Essay

1465 words - 6 pages can function the same way in a culture; it can reflect many of the culture’s values and ideologies. Music can have many effects on culture and the people’s idea of who they think they are within that culture. Music can serve in a way that promotes cultural identity and pride, yet it could also play a role in the separation of social and economical identities in within cultures. Music played a very important role in the lives of people is

Cultural And Unified Coherent Identity Essay

1544 words - 7 pages Learning journey is widely shaped by an individual’s sense of identity. However to understand how this identity shapes the learning journey, it is paramount to examine the various structures and themes associated with the term ‘identity’ such as gender, cultural and social. For these themes are constantly changing consequently affecting personal identity within the learning journey. This essay will mainly focus on the theme of cultural identity